What's wrong with this menu?
Mill Creek Tavern
275 Bayville Ave
Bayville, NY 11709
Uber
MORE PHOTOS
more menus
Dinner Menu
Menu
Dessert Menu
Wine - Beer - Cocktails
To Go Trays
Dinner Menu
Gluten free pasta available upon request. Most Items can be made gluten free. Just ask your server
Starters
French Onion Soup
$11.95Lobster Bisque
$11.95Kung Pao Cauliflower
$13.95
crispy cauliflower, Kung Pao sauce, scallions
vegan
Burrata Mozzarella
$16.95
creamy mozzarella, balsamic reduction, basil-infused olive oil, grape tomatoes
vegetarian
Spicy Ahi Tuna
$17.95
mango salsa, spicy mayo, crispy chips
Classic Chicken Wings
$16.95
hot sauce, bleu cheese dressing, celery
Crispy Chili Pop Shrimp
$17.95
baby shrimp, sweet Thai chili sauce
Pretzel Baked Brie
$10.95
brown sugar, fig jam
vegetarian
Three Cheese Spinach Fondue
$14.95
tri-color tortilla chips
vegetarian
gluten-free
Tuscan Calamari
$17.95
fried calamari, marinara, lemon, horseradish aioli
Prime Angus Burger Sliders
$14.95
bacon, cheddar, potato buns
Iron Skillet Meatball Parmesan
$12.95
homemade meatballs, melted mozzarella, pomodoro
Buffalo Chicken Spring Rolls
$13.95
Vermont cheddar, bleu cheese, scallions, hot sauce
Baked Littleneck Clams Oreganata
$13.95
roasted garlic, white wine, olive oil, parmesan bread crumbs
Potato & Cheese Pierogies
$11.95
bacon brown butter, chive sour cream (no bacon)
vegetarian
Salads
Salad Additions: (grilled or blackened) Chicken $8.95, Salmon $11.95, Jumbo Shrimp $12.95, Tuna $12.95, Skirt Steak $13.95
Tavern Market Salad
$13.95
baby greens, garden vegetables, choice of dressing
vegan
gluten-free
Caesar Salad
$13.95
crisp romaine, Caesar dressing, parmesan, croutons
vegetarian
Iceberg Wedge
$14.95
Applewood smoked bacon, red onion, chopped tomatoes, bleu cheese dressing
gluten-free
Country Salad
$14.95
baby field greens, dried cranberries, candied walnuts, Maytag bleu cheese, balsamic vinaigrette
vegetarian
gluten-free
Harvest Salad
$15.95
baby arugula, crispy onions, beets, toasted almonds, goat cheese, maple stone mustard vinaigrette
Handhelds
All served w/ choice of French fries or sweet potato fries or substitute a House or Caesar Salad +$2.95. (Gluten free bun or lettuce wrap +$1.95)
Grilled 10oz Prime Angus Burger
$18.95
exclusive blend
Plant Based Beyond Burger
$19.95
Burger Toppings: ($1.50 ea) American, cheddar, Swiss, bleu cheese, mozzarella, bacon, mushrooms, sautéed onions
vegan
Buttermilk Fried Chicken Sandwich
$17.95
lettuce, tomato, special sauce
Grilled Chicken Club
$17.95
Applewood smoked bacon, cheddar, lettuce, tomato, mayo
Steak Sandwich
$25.95
filet mignon, toasted garlic roll, mushrooms, sautéed onions, melted mozzarella, horseradish mayo
Baja Fish Tacos
$16.95
(grilled or blackened) shaved cabbage, mango salsa, queso fresco, cilantro lime crema
gluten-free
Grilled Shrimp BLT Wrap
$19.95
grilled shrimp, Applewood bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo
Noodles
Add Side Market, Country or Caesar Salad $7.95
MCT Homemade Macaroni & Cheese
$18.95
cheddar cheese, American cheese, fresh cream
vegetarian
Classic Linguine Clam Sauce
$28.95
whole littleneck & fresh chopped clams, red or white
Linguine & Meatballs
$22.95
homemade meatballs, pomodoro, parmesan
Linguine Seafood
$33.95
jumbo shrimp, calamari, clams, mussels, white wine - garlic -olive oil or fra diavolo
Rigatoni & Blackened Skirt Steak
$28.95
gorgonzola, spinach, porcini mushroom-sage cream sauce
Three Cheese Ravioli
$24.95
melted mozzarella, basil pomodoro or vodka sauce
vegetarian
Rigatoni Ala Vodka
$23.95
pomodoro, fresh cream, vodka, parmesan, crushed red pepper
vegetarian
Zucchini Linguine
$19.95
roasted tomato-white wine-garlic broth
vegan
gluten-free
- Add Baby Shrimp
- $9.95
Angel Hair & Chicken
$25.95
spinach, diced tomatoes, basil, fresh mozzarella, roasted garlic white wine
English Pea Ravioli
$26.95
mushrooms, spinach, grape tomatoes, shallots, white wine, olive oil, fresh herbs
vegan
Tavern Mussels
$17.95
Fra Diavolo
spicy pomodoro
gluten-free
Au Vin Blanc
white wine, fresh herb, lemon, garlic, olive oil
gluten-free
Provençale
tomatoes, garlic, onions, white wine, butter
gluten-free
Casino
shallots, garlic, red peppers, bacon, white wine
gluten-free
Prime Steaks & Chops
Add Side Market, Country or Caesar Salad $7.95. Served with choice of side. Add extra side $4.95. Au poivre, Bordelaise, Truffle Butter, Gorgonzola Butter
10oz Filet Mignon
$53.95Marinated Skirt Steak
$38.9516oz New York Strip
$46.95Double-Cut Pork Chop
$33.95Mains
Add Side Market, Country or Caesar Salad $7.95. Served with choice of side. Add extra side $4.95
Chicken Schnitzel
$27.95
mushroom gravy
Chicken Parmesan
$27.95Chicken Française
$27.95Julio's Southern Fried Chicken
$26.95MCT Meatloaf
$24.95
brown gravy
Hickory Smoked BBQ Baby Back Ribs
gluten-free
- Half Rack $21.95
- Full Rack $32.95
Sesame Crusted Tuna
$31.95
soy ginger, wasabi
gluten-free
Stone Mustard Grilled Salmon
$33.95Lemon Sole Française
$27.95Jumbo Shrimp Scampi
$32.95Jumbo Shrimp Française
$32.95Grilled Jumbo Shrimp
$32.95
gluten-free
Pan Seared Sea Scallops
$39.95
gluten-free
House Specialties
Add Side Market, Country or Caesar Salad $7.95
Country Chicken Pot Pie
$26.95
roasted chicken breast, carrots, peas, potatoes, fresh sage béchamel sauce, puff pastry crust
Sautéed Chicken
$27.95
diced Roma tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, basil, lemon scampi olive oil, parmesan roasted potatoes
Murray's Organic Roasted Half Chicken
$26.95
sautéed spinach, mashed potatoes, natural chicken jus
gluten-free
Seafood Sampler
$41.95
pan seared salmon, scallops & shrimp, grape tomato caper beurre-Blanc, Spring pea risotto
Lemon Sole Oreganata
$31.95
jumbo shrimp, mussels, tomatoes, sautéed spinach, roasted garlic-lemon olive oil, angel hair
Pan Seared Sea Scallops
$39.95
shrimp risotto, shaved grana, lobster cream
Eggplant Parmigiana & Ricotta Cheese Ravioli
$24.95
vodka sauce
Double Pork Chop
$34.95
pancetta, broccoli rabe, cherry peppers, roasted potatoes, pan jus
Sauerbraten Short Ribs
$32.95
mustard herb späetzle, braised red cabbage
Shepherd's Pie
$24.95
ground beef, carrots, peas, fresh herb jus, mashed potato crust
Starters
French Onion Soup
- $9.95
Lobster Bisque
- $9.95
Kung Pao Cauliflower
$12.95
crispy cauliflower, Kung Pao sauce, scallions
vegetarian
Burrata Mozzarella
creamy mozzarella, balsamic reduction, basil-infused olive oil, grape tomatoes
vegetarian
- $15.95
Spicy Ahi Tuna
mango salsa, spicy mayo, crispy wonton
- $16.95
Classic Chicken Wings
hot sauce, bleu cheese dressing, celery
- $13.95
Crispy Chili Pop Shrimp
baby shrimp, sweet Thai chili sauce
- $16.95
Pretzel Baked Brie
brown sugar, fig jam
vegetarian
- $9.95
Three Cheese Spinach Fondue
tri-color tortilla chips
vegetarian
gluten-free
- $13.95
Tuscan Calamari
fried calamari, marinara, lemon, horseradish aioli
- $16.95
Prime Angus Burger Sliders
bacon, cheddar, potato buns
- $12.95
Iron Skillet Meatball Parmesan
$12.95
homemade meatballs, melted mozzarella, pomodoro
Buffalo Chicken Spring Rolls
Vermont cheddar, bleu cheese, scallions, hot sauce
- $12.95
Baked Littleneck Clams Oreganata
roasted garlic, white wine, olive oil, parmesan bread crumbs
- $12.95
Potato & Cheese Pierogies
bacon brown butter, chive sour cream (no bacon)
vegetarian
- $11.95
Tavern Mussels
$17.95
Fra Diavlo
spicy pomodoro
gluten-free
AU Vin Blanc
white wine, fresh herb, lemon, garlic, olive oil
gluten-free
Provençale
tomatoes, garlic, onions, white wine, butter
gluten-free
Casino
shallots, garlic, red peppers, bacon, white wine
gluten-free
Prime Steaks & Chops
(Grilled or Blackened). Served with choice of side, Add Side Market or Caesar Salad $5.95
10oz Filet Mignon
$48.95Marinated Skirt Steak
$37.9516oz New York Strip
$46.95Double-Cut Pork Chop
$32.95Salads
Tavern Market Salad
baby greens, garden vegetables, choice of dressing
vegan
gluten-free
- $12.95
Caesar Salad
crisp romaine, Caesar dressing, parmesan, croutons
vegetarian
- $12.95
Iceberg Wedge
Applewood smoked bacon, red onion, chopped tomatoes, bleu cheese dressing
gluten-free
- $13.95
Country Salad
baby field greens, dried cranberries, candied walnuts, Maytag bleu cheese, balsamic vinaigrette
vegetarian
gluten-free
- $13.95
Chopped Cobb Salad
grilled chicken, tomatoes, red onions, bacon, cucumber, Maytag bleu, cheddar, sliced egg, avocado, mixed greens, bleu cheese dressing
gluten-free
- $22.95
Salad Additions
grilled or blackened
Chicken
$7.95Salmon
$10.95Jumbo Shrimp
$11.95Tuna
- $11.95
Skirt Steak
- $13.95
Handhelds
All served w/ choice of French fries or sweet potato fries or substitute a House or Caesar Salad +$2.95. Gluten free bun or lettuce wrap +$1.95
Grilled 10oz Prime Angus Burger
Exclusive blend. Burger Toppings: American, cheddar, Swiss, bleu cheese, mozzarella, bacon, mushrooms, sautéed onions
- $17.95
- Burger Toppings (Ea)
- $1.50
Plant Based beyond Burger
Burger Toppings: American, cheddar, Swiss, bleu cheese, mozzarella, bacon, mushrooms, sautéed onions
- $18.95
- Burger Toppings (Ea)
- $1.50
Buttermilk Fried Chicken Sandwich
lettuce, tomato, pickles, special sauce
- $16.95
Grilled Chicken Club
Applewood smoked bacon, cheddar, lettuce, tomato, mayo
- $16.95
Steak Sandwich
toasted garlic roll, mushrooms, sautéed onions, melted mozzarella, horseradish mayo
- $23.95
Baja Fish Tacos
(grilled or blackened) shaved cabbage, mango salsa, queso fresco, cilantro lime crema
gluten-free
- $16.95
Grilled Shrimp BLT Wrap
grilled shrimp, Applewood bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo
- $18.95
Organic BBQ Tempeh Tacos
$16.95
avocado, pico de gallo, lettuce, corn tortilla
vegan
Noodles
Add side Market or Caesar salad +$5.95
MCT Homemade Macaroni & Cheese
Cheddar cheese, American cheese, fresh cream
vegetarian
- $17.95
Classic Linguine Clam Sauce
whole littleneck & fresh chopped clams, red or white
- $22.95
Linguini & Meatballs
homemade meatballs, pomodoro, parmesan
- $19.95
Linguine Seafood
jumbo shrimp, calamari, clams, mussels, white wine - garlic -olive oil or fra diavolo
- $29.95
Rigatoni & Blackened Skirt Steak
gorgonzola, spinach, porcini mushroom-sage cream sauce
- $28.95
Three Cheese Ravioli
melted mozzarella, basil pomodoro
vegetarian
- $22.95
Rigatoni Ala Vodka
pomodoro, fresh cream, vodka, parmesan, crushed red pepper
vegetarian
- $20.95
Zucchini Linguine
roasted tomato-white wine-garlic broth
vegan
gluten-free
- $18.95
- Add Baby Shrimp
- $9.95
Angel Hair & Chicken
spinach, diced tomatoes, basil, fresh mozzarella, roasted garlic white wine
- $22.95
English Pea Ravioli
$24.95
mushrooms, spinach, grape tomatoes, shallots, white wine, olive oil, fresh herbs
vegan
Mains
Add Side Market or Caesar Salad $5.95. Served with choice of side, add extra side $4.95
Chicken Schnitzel
mushroom gravy
- $25.95
Grilled or Blackened Chicken
$24.95
gluten-free
Chicken Parmesan
- $24.95
Chicken Française
- $25.95
Julio's Southern Fried Chicken
- $24.95
MCT Meatloaf
brown gravy
- $23.95
Hickory Smoked BBQ Baby Back Ribs
gluten-free
- Half Rack $18.95
- Full Rack $29.95
Eggplant Parmesan
basil pomodoro
vegetarian
- $17.95
Sesame Crusted Tuna
soy ginger, wasabi
gluten-free
- $29.95
Stone Mustard Grilled Salmon
- $27.95
Lemon Sole Française
- $26.95
Jumbo Shrimp Scampi
- $29.95
Jumbo Shrimp Française
- $29.95
Grilled Jumbo Shrimp
gluten-free
- $29.95
Pan Seared Sea Scallops
gluten-free
- $33.95
House Specialties
Add side Market or Caesar salad $5.95
Country Chicken Pot Pie
roasted chicken breast, carrots, peas, potatoes, fresh sage béchamel sauce, puff pastry crust
- $24.95
Sautéed Chicken
diced Roma tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, basil, toasted pine nuts, lemon scampi olive oil, parmesan roasted potatoes
- $26.95
Chicken Granny Smith Apples
roasted sweet potatoes, candied walnuts, Hudson Valley cider riesling sauce
- $26.95
Murray's Organic Roasted Half Chicken
$26.95
sautéed spinach, mashed potatoes, natural chicken jus
gluten-free
Lemon Sole Oreganata
jumbo shrimp, mussels, tomatoes, sautéed spinach, roasted garlic-lemon olive oil, angel hair
- $29.95
Pan Seared Sea Scallops
shrimp risotto, shaved grana, lobster cream
- $35.95
Eggplant Parmigiana & Ricotta Cheese Ravioli
vodka sauce
- $19.95
Double Pork Chop
$33.95
pancetta, broccoli rabe, cherry peppers, roasted potatoes, pan jus
Sauerbraten Short Ribs
mustard herb späetzle, braised red cabbage
- $31.95
Shepherd's Pie
$24.95
ground beef, carrots, peas, fresh herb jus, mashed potato crust
Roasted Cauliflower Steak
$19.95
chimichurri sauce, sautéed vegetables, roasted potatoes
vegan
gluten-free
Main
Campfire S'mores
Hershey's Chocolate Bars, Marshmallows, Graham Crackers
- Two People $9.50
- Four People $16.50
MCT Brownie Sundae
Homemade brownie, vanilla bean ice cream, M&Ms, Hershey's chocolate syrup
- $9.50
New York Cheesecake
Fresh whipped cream, raspberry coulis
- $9.00
Oreo Mousse Pie
Dark chocolate mousse, Oreo crumbs, fresh whipped cream
- $9.50
Tami's Key Lime Pie
$8.50
Key lime custard, graham cracker crust, whipped cream, lime zest
Raspberry Sorbet
Häagen-Dazs raspberry sorbet
- $7.00
Warm Apple Crisp
Granny Smith apples, cinnamon, nutmeg, rolled oat crumb topping, vanilla bean ice cream
- $9.50
White
Riesling, Chateau Ste. Michelle, Washington
- Glass $13.00
- Bottle $42.00
Pinot Grigio, Lagaria, Italy
- Glass $11.00
- Bottle $39.00
Sauvignon Blanc, Smoking Loon, California
- Glass $12.00
- Bottle $40.00
Sauvignon Blanc, Kim Crawford, Marlborough, New Zealand
- Glass $15.00
- Bottle $45.00
Chardonnay, Avalon, California
- Glass $11.00
- Bottle $38.00
Chardonnay, Sea Sun by Caymus, California
- Glass $16.00
- Bottle $52.00
Rosé
Sparkling Rosé, Le Grand Courtage, France
- 187ml $13.00
Rosé, La Vieille Ferme, France
- Glass $11.00
- Bottle $37.00
Red
Pinot Noir, Angeline, California
- Glass $13.00
- Bottle $42.00
Pinot Noir, Educated Guess, Sonoma Coast
- Glass $14.00
- Bottle $48.00
Merlot, Maison Nicolas, France
- Glass $11.00
- Bottle $39.00
Cabernet Sauvignon, Leese-Fitch, California
- Glass $13.00
- Bottle $41.00
Cabernet Sauvignon, Bonanza by Caymus, California
- Glass $16.00
- Bottle $56.00
Malbec, Tinto Negro "Uco Valley", Mendoza, Argentina
- Glass $13.00
- Bottle $43.00
Chianti Classico DOCG Carpineto, Tuscany, Italy
- Glass $14.00
- Bottle $47.00
Bottles & Cans
Budweiser
$7.00Bud Lite
$7.00Coors Lite
$7.00Michelob Ultra
$7.00Miller Lite
$7.00Pabst Blue Ribbon
$6.50O'Douls
$7.00Corona
$8.00Guinness
$9.00Amstel Light
$8.00Blue Moon
$8.00Peroni Pale Lager
$8.00Heineken
$8.00Heineken Lite
$8.00Heineken 0.0
$8.001911 Heritage Rose Cider
$8.50Founder's All Day IPA
$8.00White Claw Hard Seltzer
$8.00
assorted flavors
Specialty Drinks
$15
French Pear Martini
Absolut Pear Vodka, St.Germain Liqueur
Cucumber Cooler
Nue Cucumber Vodka, rosemary-ginger syrup, lemonade
Moscow Mule
Grey Goose, ginger beer, lime juice
Blueberry Mojito
Stoli Blueberry Vodka, fresh muddled blueberries, mint, simple syrup
Spicy Pineapple Thyme Margarita
Spicy Patron Tequila, lime juice, pineapple juice, sour mix, fresh thyme, spicy salted rim
Bee's Knees
Uncle Val's Botanical Gin, honey syrup, lemon
Sunset Sangria
Sauvignon Blanc, white peach liqueur, mango, raspberry
Jungle Juice
Captain Morgan Spiced Rum, Malibu Coconut Rum, pineapple juice, orange juice, splash of cranberry, Bacardi 151 floater
Choice of Appetizer
Lobster Bisque
Soup of the Day
Pretzel Stick
cheddar ale sauce
Potato & Cheese Pierogies
bacon brown butter, chive sour cream
Iceberg Wedge
bacon, red onion, tomatoes, bleu cheese
Choice of Entrée
Chicken Schnitzel
mushroom gravy
Sauerbraten Short Ribs
Grilled Salmon
mustard sauce
Pork Chop
apple sauce
Choice of Side
Add extra side $4.95
Mustard Herb Spaetzle
Braised Red Cabbage
Mashed Potatoes
French Fries
Roasted Potatoes
Sautéed Mixed Veggies
Sautéed Spinach
Backyard BBQ Wednesday
$28.95. Choice of Side: Mac & Cheese, French Fries, Coleslaw, Sweet Potato Fries, Sautéed Broccoli. Choose two:
¼ Rack of Baby Back Ribs
¼ BBQ Chicken
BBQ Popcorn Shrimp
BBQ Chicken Wings
Appetizers
Crispy Calamari "Tuscan Style"
hot cherry peppers, marinara, garlic aioli
- Half $80.00
- Full $155.00
Chili Pop Shrimp
baby shrimp, sweet chili sauce
- Half $80.00
- Full $155.00
Three Cheese Spinach & Artichoke Fondue
tri-color tortilla chips
- Half $40.00
- Full $75.00
Classic Chicken Wings
hot sauce, bleu cheese dressing, celery
- Half $60.00
- Full $115.00
Buffalo Chicken Spring Rolls
Vermont cheddar, bleu cheese, scallions, hot sauce
- Half $60.00
- Full $115.00
Cheeseburger Sliders
cheddar cheese, applewood smoked bacon, potato rolls
- Half $55.00
- Full $105.00
Parmesan Artichoke Risotto Cakes
pomodoro
- Half $50.00
- Full $95.00
Brie Stuffed Pretzel
brown sugar, fig jam (cut into 4 pcs)
- Half $50.00
- Full $95.00
Pigs In a Blanket
ketchup & mustard
- Half $40.00
- Full $75.00
Chicken Fingers
honey mustard
- Half $40.00
- Full $75.00
Potato & Cheese Pierogies
bacon brown butter, chives, sour cream
- Half $40.00
- Full $75.00
Baked Little Neck Clams Oreganata
roasted garlic, white wine, olive oil, parmesan bread crumbs
- Half $60.00
- Full $115.00
Chilled Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail
- Half $70.00
- Full $135.00
Pasta
Rigatoni Seafood
jumbo shrimp, calamari, white wine, garlic & olive oil, fra diavolo or red or white
- Half $90.00
- Full $175.00
"Classic" Linguine w/ Clam Sauce
whole littleneck & fresh chopped clams (red or white)
- Half $85.00
- Full $165.00
Zucchini Linguine
roasted tomato-garlic white wine broth with baby shrimp
- Half $65.00
- Full $115.00
- With Baby Shrimp - Half $85.00
- With Baby Shrimp - Full $165.00
Rigatoni & Blackened Skirt Steak
grilled portobello mushrooms, gorgonzola, porcini mushroom-sage cream sauce
- Half $90.00
- Full $175.00
Homemade Macaroni & Cheese
cheddar cheese, American cheese, fresh cream, baked-buttered bread crumbs
- Half $60.00
- Full $115.00
Rigatoni & Chicken
spinach, fresh mozzarella, sun-dried tomatoes, basil, lemon-garlic olive oil
- Half $70.00
- Full $135.00
Penne a la Vodka
crushed red pepper, tomatoes, cream
- Half $60.00
- Full $115.00
Rigatoni Pomodoro
fresh mozzarella
- Half $60.00
- Full $115.00
Puttanesca
filetto di pomodoro, roasted garlic, black olives, capers
- Half $60.00
- Full $115.00
Bolognese
classic meat sauce
- Half $70.00
- Full $135.00
Pink Carbonara
onions, smoked bacon, cream, pomodoro
- Half $60.00
- Full $110.00
Chicken
Sautéed Chicken
diced Roma tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, basil, lemon scampi, olive oil, parmesan roasted potatoes
- Half $85.00
- Full $165.00
Chicken & Granny Smith Apples
grilled, sweet potatoes, candied walnuts, Hudson Valley cider riesling sauce
- Half $85.00
- Full $165.00
Chicken Schnitzel
chicken cutlets, mushroom gravy
- Half $85.00
- Full $165.00
Grilled or Blackened Chicken
honey mustard
- Half $85.00
- Full $165.00
Chicken choice of Francaise, Marsala, Piccata or Parmigiana
- Half $85.00
- Full $165.00
Seafood
Sole Oreganata
chopped tomatoes, spinach, roasted garlic-lemon olive oil
- Half $80.00
- Full $155.00
Jumbo Shrimp Francaise, Piccata, Oreganata or Parmigiana
- Half $95.00
- Full $185.00
Mustard Grilled Salmon
warm grilled vegetables, spinach, goat cheese, stone ground mustard glaze
- Half $90.00
- Full $175.00
Grilled or Blackened Salmon
- Half $90.00
- Full $175.00
Filet of Sole Choice of Francaise, Almondine or Piccata
- Half $80.00
- Full $155.00
Jumbo Shrimp choice of Francaise, Piccata Oreganata or Parmigiana
- Half $95.00
- Full $180.00
Meat
Grilled Marinated Sliced Skirt Steak
- Half $160.00
- Full $295.00
Grilled Filet Mignon Tips
au poivre
- Half $120.00
- Full $235.00
Classic Meatloaf
crispy onions, country gravy
- Half $75.00
- Full $135.00
Grandma's Meatballs
basil pomodoro
- Half $75.00
- Full $135.00
Sauerbraten Short Ribs
order must be placed 48 hours prior to pick-up
- Half $95.00
- Full $185.00
Salads
Add: Grilled or Blackened Chicken: Half - $15, Full - $30
Market Salad
field greens, garden vegetables, choice of dressing
- Half $60.00
- Full $115.00
Caesar Salad
shaved parmesan, rustic croutons
- Half $60.00
- Full $115.00
Baby Field Green Salad
dried cranberries, candied walnuts, maytag bleu cheese, balsamic vinaigrette
- Half $60.00
- Full $115.00
Chopped Cobb Salad
grilled chicken, tomatoes, red onions, bacon, maytag bleu cheese, cheddar, sliced egg, mixed greens, bleu cheese dressing
- Half $70.00
- Full $135.00
Browse Nearby
General Info
Payment Types
All Major Cards
Cuisine
American - Contemporary
American - Traditional
Bar
Dessert
Meals
Dinner
Hours
Monday:
Closed
Tuesday:
4:30pm - 9:00pm
Wednesday:
4:30pm - 9:00pm
Thursday:
4:30pm - 9:00pm
Friday:
4:30pm - 10:00pm
Saturday:
4:30pm - 10:00pm
Sunday:
4:00pm - 9:00pm
About Us
Mill Creek Tavern is a cozy and warm neighborhood restaurant with big city cuisine offerings. Mill Creek Tavern in Bayville New York offers a small dining room with exquisite menu selections for both intimate and family affairs.
Our menu is comprised of a unique blend of savory new concept dishes such as our Buffalo Chicken Spring Roll, Tuna Martini and Mozzarella Towers to our Comfort Classic Selections like Chicken Pot Pie, and Lemon Roasted “Natural” ½ chicken. Dig in and taste our Specialty dishes such as Rigatoni & Blackened Skirt Steak with Gorgonzola and Porcini Mushrooms, Pan Seared Sea Scallops with Lobster/Asparagus Risotto or Chicken Granny Smith Apples with candied walnuts and Hudson Valley Cider Riesling sauce.