What's wrong with this menu?
The Sayville Inn
199 Middle Rd
Sayville, NY 11782
Uber
MORE PHOTOS
more menus
Main Menu
Drink Menu
Catering Menu
Main Menu
Weekly Specials
Seasonal Items That Would Appear on Our Chalk Boards Weekly
Watermelon Feta Salad
$15.00
Mixed greens, red onion, tomato with lemon vinaigrette dressing
Buffalo Calamari
$15.00
Fried calamari tossed in our signature buffalo sauce with side of blue cheese dressing & celery
Lobster Roll
$35.00
House made lobster salad on a butter toasted top split bun with shoestring french fries
Surf & Turf Tacos
$28.00
1 Steak taco, mixed Greens, coleslaw, sriracha mayo on top 1 Lobster salad taco, mixed greens, coleslaw, house made lobster salad with a side of corn salad
Creamy Penne Pasta
$18.00
Spinach, bacon, cherry tomatoes, grilled chicken and garlic ciabatta
Starters
John Scott's Wings
$15.00
Choice of Buffalo, Honey BBQ or Old Bay, celery, bleu cheese
Boneless Wings
$12.00
Choice of Buffalo, Honey BBQ or Old Bay, celery, bleu cheese
Eggplant Towers
$14.00
Lightly fried eggplant, fresh mozzarella, tomato, basil pesto
Mozzarella Sticks
$10.00
Beer-battered, marinara
Bowl of Chili
$9.00
Served in a crock, topped with melted cheddar jack cheese
Pretzel Bites
$9.00
Cheese dipping sauce
Chicken Tenders
$12.00
Original w/ BBQ or Buffalo w/ bleu cheese
Feta-Spiked Hummus
$14.00
Olives, cucumbers, grilled pita
Firecracker Calamari
$15.00
Chipotle Thai chili glaze
Macaroni & Cheese
$11.00
Signature house blend
Buffalo Popcorn Shrimp
$15.00
Crumbled bleu, bleu cheese dressing, celery
Sayville Nachos
$13.00
Melted cheddar jack, chili, jalapenos, sour cream & salsa
Avocado Toast
$12.00
Ciabatta, feta, pico de gallo
French Fries
$7.00
Shoestring or waffle, Sayville Sauce
Disco Fries
$12.00
Shoestring, brown gravy, melted mozzarella
Margherita Cauliflower Crust Pizza
$14.00
Mozzarella, diced tomatoes, basil, balsamic glaze
Coconut Shrimp
$18.00
Lightly fried, coconut battered, Thai chili marmalade
Chips & Guacamole
$12.00
Fresh made guacamole with corn tortilla chips
Soups
$8
New England Clam Chowder
$9.00Manhattan Clam Chowder
$9.00Long Island Half N' Half
$9.00French Onion Soup
$9.00
Homemade croutons, melted mozzarella
Sayville Tacos
Two tortillas w/ side of corn salad
Baja Fish Tacos
$18.00
The House Specialty! Coconut beer batter, pico de gallo, chipotle slaw & tequila lime aioli
Steak Tacos
$20.00
Grilled sirloin, mixed greens, chipotle slaw, frizzled onions & Sriracha mayo
Buffalo Chicken Tacos
$16.00
Lettuce, tomato, red onion & bleu cheese dressing
Beer Braised Short Rib Tacos
$20.00
Mixed greens, chipotle slaw, red onion & Sayville Sauce
Grilled Salmon Tacos
$19.00
Chipotle slaw, mango black bean salsa & tequila lime aioli
Dirt Candy Tacos
$15.00
Vegetables medley, feta, red onions & Sayville Sauce
Grilled Shrimp Tacos
$18.00
Chipotle slaw, field greens, pico de gallo & tequila lime aioli
Salads
House Salad
$9.00
Mixed greens, tomatoes, red onion & House Vinaigrette
Iceberg Wedge
$13.00
Smoked bacon, tomato, crumbled bleu cheese & House Vinaigrette
All Kale Caesar
Chili croutons, parmesan, creamy Caesar dressing
- $11.00
- With Cajun or Grilled Chicken $17.00
- With Cajun or Grilled Shrimp $19.00
- With Grilled Steak* $22.00
Grilled Salmon Salad*
$20.00
Kale, red onion, tomato, parmesan & lemon vinaigrette
Chicken & Field Greens
$18.00
Walnuts, craisins, crumbled bleu, tomato, red onion & House Vinaigrette
Seared Steak Salad*
$22.00
Sirloin, portobello, tomato, red onion, crumbled bleu & House Vinaigrette
Chicken Milanese
$19.00
Fried cutlet, field greens, tomato, red onion, parmesan & lemon vinaigrette
Chopped Salad
$19.00
Chopped iceberg, tomato, red onion, cucumber, fresh mozzarella, bacon, grilled chicken, house vinaigrette
Tavern Classics
Buttermilk Fried Chicken Sandwich
$19.00
American, bacon, lettuce, tomato, Sayville Sauce
Hot Coffee Burger*
$17.00
Melted mozzarella, jalapenos & Sayville Sauce
Black & Blue Burger*
$17.00
Melted bleu cheese, frizzled onions & steak sauce
Teddy Roosevelt Burger*
$17.00
Melted swiss, sauteed mushrooms, parmesan
BBQ Bacon Burger*
$18.00
Melted cheddar, frizzled onions, BBQ sauce
Middle Road Burger*
$20.00
Short rib, melted mozzarella, caramelized onions, Au Jus, toasted garlic english muffin
Tuscan Burger*
$18.00
Tomato, fresh mozzarella, red onion, basil, balsamic glaze
California Chicken Wrap
$18.00
Grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato, red onion, avacado, bacon, firecracker sauce
Turkey Burger
$16.00
Feta, guacamole, field greens
Portobello Burger
$16.00
Roasted mushroom and red pepper, fresh melted mozzarella & tequila lime aioli
Flatbread Sandwiches
Our own pizza dough, grilled & wrapped, with waffle fries
Short Rib French Dip
$20.00
Horseradish sour cream, frizzled onions, Au Jus
Shrimp Po' Boy
$19.00
Popcorn shrimp, lettuce, tomato Sayville Sauce
Cajun Chicken
$18.00
Lettuce, tomato, red onion, Ranch dressing
Veggie
$16.00
Black bean, lettuce, tomato, red onion, roasted red pepper & portobello, cauliflower, Sayville Sauce
Entrees
BBQ Ribs
$26.00
Homemade BBQ, shoestring french fries
Coconut Shrimp
$25.00
Coconut beer-battered, shoestring, corn salad, Thai chili marmalade
Cajun Steak Frites
$29.00
Cajun gravy, shoestring fries & Sayville Sauce
Lemon Parmesan Chicken
$24.00
Parmesan dusted, with mashed potatoes & vegetables of the day
Fish & Chips
$23.00
Coconut beer-battered, waffle fries, key lime tartar sauce
Grilled Cajun Salmon
$29.00
Tarragon butter sauce, garlic mashed potatoes, vegetable of the day
Pasta of the Day
Served With garlic ciabatta
- Priced Accordingly
Homemade Desserts
Tollhouse Cookie Pie
$11.00
Homemade chocolate chip pie, topped with Vanilla ice cream, hot fudge
Brownie Chip Sundae
$10.00
Homemade chocolate chip brownie topped with Vanilla ice cream & hot fudge
Rice Krispy Treat Pie
$11.00
Rice Krispy treat crust, layered with chocolate peanut butter fudge & Cookies and Cream ice cream
Riverbottom Pie
$11.00
Coffee ice cream, Oreo cookie crust
Mint Chip Pie
$11.00
Rice Krispy treat crust, hot fudge, whipped cream
Peanut Butter Pie
$9.00
Housemade, whipped cream
Root Beer Float
$7.00
Vanilla ice cream, whipped cream
Kids Sundae
$6.00
Chocolate, Vanilla, Cookies & Cream or Mint Chip topped with whipped cream and hot fudge
Kids Menu
Kids under 10. Served with juice or soft drink
Grilled Chicken & Vegetables
$9.00Burger & Fries
$8.00Cheeseburger & Fries
$9.00English Muffin Pizza
$8.00Chicken Fingers & Fries
$8.00Penne Marinara or Butter
$8.00Grilled Cheese & Fries
$8.00
*This menu item can be cooked to your liking. Consuming raw or uncooked meat, fish, shellfish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of food-bourne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions
Summer Cocktails
Seasonal Cocktails available through Labor Day!
Farmer's Market
$15.00
Crop Cucumber Vodka, Fresh Squeezed Watermelon Juice, Fresh Lemon Juice, Simple Syrup, Club Soda
Strawberry Blonde
$15.00
Jalapeno-Infused Tequila, Strawberry Puree, Fresh Lime Juice, Fresh Lemon Juice, Splash of Club Soda
That's Coconuts
$15.00
1800 Coconut Tequila, Fresh Lime Juice, Simple Syrup, Fresh Mint, Topped with Club Soda
Kentucky Buck
$16.00
Bulleit Bourbon, Strawberry Puree, Fresh Lemon Juice, Aromatic Bitters, Topped with Ginger Beer
East End Empress
$15.00
Empress Gin, St Germain Elderflower Liqueur, Fresh Lemon Juice, Simple Syrup, Club Soda
Summer in Sayville
$15.00
St Germain Elderflower Liqueur, Fresh Mint, Lime, La Marca Prosecco
The Painkiller
$15.00
Pusser's Rum, Blend of Coco Lopez, Pineapple Juice, Orange Juice, Topped with Nutmeg
Orange Crush
$15.00
Stoli Orange Vodka, Triple Sec, Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice, Splash of Club Soda
Wine
Vicolo Pinot Grigio
- $10.00
- $36.00
Rex Goliath Chardonnay
$9.00Kendall Jackson Chardonnay
- $12.00
- $44.00
Fetzer Riesling
- $10.00
- $36.00
Hahn Cabernet
- $10.00
- $36.00
Cartlidge & Browne Cabernet
- $12.00
- $44.00
Rodney Strong Merlot
- $14.00
- $52.00
Alamos Malbec
- $10.00
- $36.00
Mark West Pinot Noir
- $10.00
- $36.00
Cecchi Chianti
- $11.00
- $40.00
Juliette Rose
- $11.00
- $40.00
Liberty Creek White Zinfandel
$9.00La Marca Prosecco
$11.00Draft Beer
Blue Point Toasted
$7.00Grennport Otherside IPA
$7.00Sam Adams Summer Ale
$7.00Montauk Wave Chaser IPA
$7.00Stella Artois
$8.00Guinness
$8.00Kona Big Wave
$8.00Great South Bay Blood Orange
$7.00Bottle Beer
Amstel Light
$7.00Angry Orchard
$7.00Blue Moon
$7.00Brooklyn Lager
$7.00Bud Light
$6.00Budweiser
$6.00Coors Light
$6.00Corona
$7.00Corona Light
$7.00Corona Zero N/A
$7.00Heineken
$7.00Heineken Light
$7.00Heineken Zero
$7.00High Noon Peach
$9.00Goose Island IPA
$7.00Guinness Zero N/A
$8.00Landshark
$7.00Michelob Ultra
$7.00Miller Lite
$6.00Montauk Juicy IPA
$8.00Montauk Summer Ale
$7.00Montauk Watermelon
$7.00Nutrl Watermelon
$9.00O'Doul's
$7.00Peroni
$7.00Surfside Iced Tea
$9.00Surfside 1/2 & 1/2
$9.00Super Bowl
Please order no later than Saturday, February 8th. Accepting orders day of while supplies last. Any orders placed day of cannot be guaranteed. All orders must be picked up on the hour and half hour ONLY.
AFC Package
$135.00
½ Tray Wings, ½ Tray Buffalo Chicken Meatballs, ½ Tray Cheeseburger Sliders
NFC Package
$160.00
½ Tray Wings, Pick 2: ½ Tray Lemon Parm Chicken, ½ Tray Penne alla Vodka or ½ Tray Sausage and Peppers
Championship Package
$250.00
½ Tray Wings, ½ Tray Cheeseburger Sliders, ½ Tray Lemon Parm Chicken, ½ Tray Penne alla Vodka, ½ Tray Sausage and Peppers
1⁄2 Tray Wings
$55.00
Buffalo, Old Bay, or Honey BBQ
½ Tray Boneless Wings
$50.00
Buffalo, Old Bay, or Honey BBQ
½ Tray Buffalo Chicken Meatballs
$50.00½ Tray Chicken Tenders
$55.00
Plain, Buffalo, Old Bay or Honey BBQ
½ Tray Mozzarella Sticks
$60.00
Original or Buffalo Style
½ Tray Popcorn Shrimp
$55.00
Plain, Buffalo, or Firecracker
½ Tray Calamari
$60.00
Plain or Firecracker
½ Tray Cheeseburger Sliders
9 pieces
- Regular $45.00
- With Bacon $50.00
½ Tray Buttermilk Fried Chicken Sliders
$50.00
9 pieces
½ Tray Coconut Shrimp
$65.00Food Choices
Wings*
$55.00
Buffalo, Plain, or Old Bay, Honey BBQ (GF N/A),
Boneless Wings
$50.00
Buffalo, Honey BBQ, Plain, or Old Bay
Chicken Meatballs
$50.00
Buffalo or Marinara
Meatballs
$50.00
Swedish or Marinara
Chicken Tenders
$55.00
Plain, Buffalo, Honey BBQ, or Old Bay
Mozzarella Sticks
$60.00
Plain or Buffalo
Popcorn Shrimp
$55.00
Plain, Buffalo, Firecracker
Calamari
$60.00
Plain, Firecracker
P.E.I. Mussels*
$60.00
Fra Diavolo, White, or Marinara
Cheeseburger Sliders
- 9 Pieces $50.00
- Add Bacon
- $5.00
Specialty Burger Sliders
$55.00
3 each Teddy, BBQ, Hot Coffee
Tuscan Chicken Sliders
- 9 Pieces $55.00
Buttermilk Chicken Sliders
- 9 Pieces $55.00
Crab Cake Sliders
- 9 Pieces $80.00
Lobster Roll Sliders
Available with 9 Pieces
- MP
Baja Fish Tacos
- 8 Pieces $60.00
Steak Tacos*
- 8 Pieces $60.00
Buffalo Chicken Tacos
- 8 Pieces $60.00
Short Rib Tacos*
- 8 Pieces $60.00
Grilled Salmon Tacos*
- 8 Pieces $60.00
Grilled Shrimp Tacos*
- 8 Pieces $60.00
Assorted Tacos
$60.00
choose any 2 styles, 4 of each
Coconut Shrimp
$65.00Shrimp Cocktail*
$80.00Feta Spiked Hummus*
$45.00
Pita, Vegetables
Macaroni and Cheese
$50.00Short Rib Macaroni and Cheese
$65.00Crab Cake Balls
$95.00Chili and Cheese*
$50.00Caprese Skewers*
$45.00Penne alla Vodka
- $55.00
- With Chicken or Shrimp $65.00
Fettuccine Alfredo
- $55.00
- With Chicken or Shrimp $65.00
Cajun Penne Pasta
- $55.00
- With Chicken or Shrimp $65.00
Pesto Penne Pasta
- $55.00
- With Chicken or Shrimp $65.00
Short Rib Penne Pasta
$70.00Pasta Bolognese
$65.00Lemon Parmesan Penne
- $55.00
- With Chicken or Shrimp $65.00
Pasta Primavera
$55.00Lasagna
$65.00Baked Ziti
$55.00
Meatless
Cheese Ravioli Caprese
$60.00Lobster & Crabmeat Ravioli
- MP
Lemon Parmesan Chicken
$65.00Tijuana Chicken*
$65.00
served over rice
Chicken Marsala
$65.00Chicken Francese
$65.00Chicken Parmesan
$65.00Chicken Parmesan Ala Vodka
$65.00Chicken Teriyaki
$65.00Chicken Stir Fry
$65.00Chicken Fajitas*
$65.00
tortillas, salsa, sour cream on side
Steak Stir Fry
$75.00Sliced Sirloin
$125.00Marinated Sliced Skirt Steak
$125.00Marinated Sliced Flank Steak
$125.00Sliced Pork Loin
$80.00Meatloaf and Gravy
$70.00Sausage and Peppers*
$60.00Garlic Lime Shrimp*
$65.00
served over rice
Shrimp Scampi*
$65.00
Over Spaghetti
Eggplant Parmesan
$55.00Eggplant Towers
$55.00
9 Towers
Seafood Paella*
$95.00
served over rice
Jambalaya*
$75.00
Chicken, Shrimp, Sausage, and rice
Grilled Cajun Salmon*
$80.00Broiled Flounder
$125.00
with Crabmeat Stuffing
House Salad*
- $30.00
- With Chicken or Shrimp (Plain or Cajun) $45.00
Kale Caesar Salad*
- Dressed $30.00
- With Chicken or Shrimp (Plain or Cajun) $45.00
Chicken and Field Greens*
$50.00
Craisin, Walnuts, Crumbled Bleu
Watermelon and Feta Salad*
$45.00
Seasonal
Chopped Salad*
$50.00
with Chicken
Corn Salad*
$25.00Coleslaw*
$25.00Fries
$30.00
Shoestring* or Waffle
Garlic Mashed, Roasted Potatoes, Sweet Potato Mashed
$35.00Grilled Vegetables*
$35.0016oz Signature Dressings*
$10.00
House or Lemon Vinaigrette
16oz Sauces*
$10.00
Buffalo, Honey BBQ (can not be made gluten free), Sayville, or Firecracker
16oz Brown Gravy
$10.00Homemade Ice Cream Pie
$85.00
Mint Chip, Rice Krispie, River Bottom, Tuxedo
*Item is or can be made gluten free. Please note, any gluten free item that requires deep frying is cooked in the same oil as non-gluten free items
Browse Nearby
General Info
Cuisine
American - Traditional
Burgers
Seafood
Meals
Dinner
Hours
Monday:
4:00pm - 9:00pm
Tuesday:
Closed
Wednesday:
4:00pm - 9:30pm
Thursday:
4:00pm - 10:00pm
Friday:
4:00pm - 10:00pm
Saturday:
4:00pm - 10:00pm
Sunday:
12:00pm - 9:00pm