What's wrong with this menu?
Plus 1 Pizza
26 Olive St
Caldwell, OH 43724
Uber
MORE PHOTOS
Main Menu
Create Your Own Pizza
Pizza Sizes: Small: 10" - 6 Slices (Feeds 1-2), Medium: 12" - 8 Slices (Feeds 2-3), Large: 14" - 8 Slices (Feeds 3-4), X-Large: 15" - 12 Slices (Feeds 4-5).
Crust
Original Classic Crust
An original, classic medium-thick crust, light and airy with a home-baked flavor.
Thin Crust
Crispy thin crust that bakes to a golden brown with a extra crispy texture. Our thin crust lets full flavor form the cheese and toppings hit your taste buds.
Deep Dish
Thicker crust with a pleasing crunch on the outside, soft and tender on the inside.
Gluten Free
Gluten Free Medium size only. Gluten free items are prepared in a common kitchen with the risk of gluten exposure. Therefore, We Do Not recommend this pizza for customers with celiac disease. Gluten free crust is not made in house and is a prepared product.
Sauce
Family Recipe Signature Pizza Sauce
Our original family recipe. Our signature naturally sweet red tomato sauce that's made fresh daily in a Plus One Pizza tradition.
Neapolitan Pizza Sauce
Red tomato sauce packed with more garlic and oregano for customers that like a little more garlic.
Fresh Garlic Sauce
Minced-from-the-clove garlic with extra virgin olive oil for just the right flavor. Made for true garlic lovers.
Garlic Herb Sauce
Butter garlic sauce with blend of Italian seasoning and herbs.
Tuscan Pizza Sauce
A savory combination of our signature red sauce and buttery garlic sauce.
Barbecue Sauce
Sweet Ray's barbecue sauce.
Ranch Sauce
Creamy ranch sauce.
Alfredo Sauce
Cream, butter, parmesan cheese & chopped garlic.
Pesto Sauce
Pesto-Basil sauce with fresh basil, olive oil, garlic, parmesan cheese and pine nuts.
Toppings
We have a passion for pizza. We are constantly searching for ingredients of the highest quality to create one-of-a-kind flavor combinations that keep folks coming back for more.
Meats & More
Pepperoni - Old World Pepperoni - Spicy Pepperoni - Bacon - Sausage - Ground Beef - Ham - Chicken - Italian Sausage - Salami – Anchovies – Meatball – Steak.
Veggies & Cheeses
Roma Tomatoes - Mushrooms - Black Olives - Green Olives - Banana Peppers – Green Peppers - Red Onions - Jalapeños - Garlic - Onions - Pineapple - Extra Provolone - Extra Cheese - Premium toppings at extra Cheese cost more that regular toppings. Not all topping are available at all stores.
Topping Drizzles
Roasted Garlic – Garlic Herb – Ranch Drizzle – BBQ Drizzle – Buffalo Drizzle - Pesto Basil Drizzle.
Crust Toppers
Garlic Herb Topper, Butter Cheese Topper, Ranch Topper.
Cheese
Premium Blend of Mozzarella & Provolone Cheese Mozzarella, Provolone, Chaddar, Remono.
The Classics
The Tot-Za Pizza
Seasoned Tater Tot Pizza! Your choice of our fresh home made crust, starts with our ranch sauce, with over half pound of Provolone and Mozzarella cheese, crispy round seasoned tater tots, smoky bacon and fresh cut green onions with drizzles of nacho cheese. This pizza rocks!. A delightful flavor explosion for your taste-buds. Try one today!.
Veggie Delight Pizza
Our Secret Family Recipe Pizza Sauce, Fresh Crunchy Broccoli Florets baked with Provolone and Mozzarella, Freshly Sliced Zucchini, Sweet Corn, Fresh Sliced Roma tomatoes and Fresh Spinach topped with our Famous Basil Pesto!.
The Voodoo Pizza - (Aka the Dumpster Pizza)
Our original pizza sauce, mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, sausage, ham, ground beef, bacon and banana peppers. Drizzled with Honey BBQ and Ranch Sauce. Then topped off with cheddar cheese. Sounds crazy but tastes so good.
Supreme Pizza
Our original pizza sauce, pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, ham, green peppers and black olives.
The Pepperoni Feast Pizza
Loaded with our famous "Old World Pepperoni", traditional pepperoni, Spicy Dried cured Pepperoni and your choice of one extra topping and our original pizza sauce.
"Home-On-The-Ranch" Potato Pizza
Our ranch sauce, a blend of mozzarella and provolone cheese, Italian sausage, onions, bacon, and roasted potatoes.
Meat Lovers Feast
All Meat Pizza with our original pizza sauce, pepperoni, Italian sausage, ham, bacon, and ground beef.
Deluxe Pizza
Our original pizza sauce, pepperoni, Italian sausage, mushrooms, onions, green peppers and banana peppers.
The Aloha Hawaiian Pizza
Our original pizza sauce, Extra cheese, extra ham, bacon, and pineapple.
The Flying White Buffalo
Ranch style white sauce, marinated "Spicy Hot" grilled white chicken, fresh sliced onions topped with a blend of three cheeses.
Veggie Supreme Pizza
Our original pizza sauce, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, banana peppers, and black & green olives.
Florentine Pizza
Blend of mozzarella and provolone cheese, our tuscan sauce, feta cheese, mushrooms, spinach, roma tomatoes and black olives.
South Roma Pizza
A blend of mozzarella and provolone cheese, our tuscan sauce, pepperoni, sausage, ground beef and smoked ham.
Greek Veggie Pizza
Fresh garlic sauce, extra virgin olive oil and chopped garlic, feta cheese, artichokes, spinach, and green olives (or black olives), baked on top our blend of mozzarella and provolone cheese.
East Coast Delight
Fresh garlic and parmesan alfredo sauce, with grilled white chicken, ham, onions, and mozzarella & provolone cheese.
Garden Gourmet Pizza
Fresh garlic sauce, extra virgin olive oil and chopped garlic, feta cheese, artichokes, spinach, and green olives (or black olives), baked on top our blend of mozzarella and provolone cheese.
Ace of Harts Pizza
Our fresh garlic sauce with extra virgin olive oil, chopped garlic, artichokes, tomatoes, ricotta cheese dollops and blend of mozzarella cheese and provolone cheese.
The New Yorker
Fresh garlic sauce with virgin olive oil and chopped garlic, extra cheese, blend of extra mozzarella & provolone cheeses, fresh sliced tomato and topped with ricotta cheese dollops with a swirl of our pesto-basil drizzle.
Singing Veggie Revival
Fresh baby spinach, sliced roma tomatoes, in harmony with our fresh garlic sauce which makes the veggies stand up and sing, we added some delicious cermini mushrooms to sing soprano. Mozzarella and Provolone are part of the choir.
Beckon Desire
Our Pesto-Basil sauce, fresh spinach, blend of mozzarella and provolone cheese followed by artichoke heart, sun-dried tomato and ricotta cheese dollops, some say it's just infatuation but we know better.
Pesto - Potato Pizza
Basil Pesto Sauce with roasted potatoes, artichokes, fresh roma tomatoes, onions mozzarella and provolone cheese.
Cheesy Potato-Head Pizza
Creamy alfredo sauce, roasted potatoes, bacon, green peppers, onions, topped with a fresh shredded cheddar cheese and our aged cheddar cheese sauce. Oh how cheesy!.
The "Green Bird"
The "Green Bird" Starts with our pesto-basil sauce, fresh baby spinach, grilled chicken, layered with mozzarella & provolone cheese, ricotta cheese dollops and sun-dried tomatoes (or substitute with fresh roma tomatoes).
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Creamy ranch sauce, grilled chicken, smoked bacon, fresh sliced onions and roma tomatoes.
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Grilled chicken, smoked bacon, fresh sliced onions and authentic BBQ sauce.
Starters and Bread Items
Dipping Sauce Choices: Our pizza sauce, barbecue, garlic butter, blue cheese, ranch.
Cheesy Bread
Fresh flat bread made from our home-made pizza dough brushed with our garlic butter sauce, piled high with cheese and baked in our oven until hot and bubbly. You can add bacon for even more flavor. Served with your choice of dipping sauce. Sizes: Small, Medium, Large.
Ranch Cheese Sticks
Fresh flat bread made from our classic pizza dough piled high with provolone cheese and creamy ranch sauce, baked in our oven until hot and bubbly. Served with ranch dressing for dipping. Small, Medium, Large Sizes.
Home Made Bread Sticks
Made fresh each day and brushed with butter and garlic, served with dipping sauce. 4pc and 8pc orders.
Cheese Filled Bosco Sticks
Cheese filled breadsticks with dipping sauce. Just a little something as a throwback to when you were in grade school. 4pc and 8pc orders. Not made in house, these are sold as a convenience item and are not homemade.
Garlic Bread
Oven toasted with butter and chopped garlic.
Buffalo Wings
Chicken Wings: 8 Wings, 14 Wings, 28 Wings. Dipping Sauce Choices: Barbecue, garlic butter, mild, hot, blue cheese, ranch.
Bone In Wings Chicken Wings
Bigger, meatier and even tastier! Choose Hot & Spicy, Mild, Garlic, or BBQ Flavor.
Boneless Chicken Wings
Boneless- wings cooked to perfection!. Choose Hot & Spicy, Mild, Garlic, or BBQ Flavor.
Stromboli
Filled with our tasty Italian cheeses and stuffed with lots of fresh fillings, then brushed with buttery garlic sauce, sprinkled with Romano and Italian spices, and served with our Family Recipe pizza sauce for dipping.
Deluxe
$6.99
Ham, pepperoni, salami, Italian cheeses, banana peppers, onions, and mushrooms.
Godfather
$7.95
Ham, pepperoni, salami, Italian cheeses, banana peppers, sausage, green peppers and onions.
Regular
$6.49
Ham, salami, pepperoni & cheeses.
Pepperoni Stromboli
$6.49
Loaded with extra pepperoni and cheese.
Oven Toasted Sub Sandwiches
Italian Sub
Ham, salami, pepperoni, cheese, banana peppers, lettuce, tomato, and creamy Italian dressing served on an Italian bun.
Ham & Cheese Sub
Ham, cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise.
Pizza Sub
Pizza sauce, cheese, pepperoni, and your choice of two toppings.
Meatball Sub
Pizza sauce, cheese, onions, and meatballs served on an Italian roll.
The Bad Boy Sub
Steak patty topped with pepperoni ham, sausage, salami, onions, mushrooms, banana peppers, cheese, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise served on an italian roll.
Steak Hoagie Sub
Steak patty topped with green peppers, onions, mushrooms, banana peppers, cheese, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise, and steak sauce served on an italian roll.
Chicken Bacon Ranch Sub
Grilled chicken, crisp bacon, mozzarella cheese, lettuce, tomato, and ranch dressing served on an Italian roll.
Philly Steak
Chopped steak mixed with green peppers, onions, and mushrooms, cheese, and cheese sauce served on an toasted Italian roll. You may wish to add lettuce, tomato and mayo or steak sauce on request.
Buffalo Chicken Sub
Grilled chicken smothered in hot buffalo sauce, mozzarella cheese, lettuce, tomato, and ranch dressing served on an Italian roll.
Veggie Sub
Cheese, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, black and green olives, and banana peppers served on an Italian roll.
Browse Nearby
General Info
Payment Types
All Major Cards
Cuisine
Pizza
Hours
Monday:
3:00pm - 10:00pm
Tuesday:
3:00pm - 10:00pm
Wednesday:
3:00pm - 10:00pm
Thursday:
3:00pm - 10:00pm
Friday:
11:00am - 11:00pm
Saturday:
11:00am - 11:00pm
Sunday:
3:00pm - 10:00pm
About Us
We make fresh handcrafted pizza that people connect over. That’s our thing. We know we’re not negotiating world peace treaties, but we take our job seriously. We live by a set of core values each and every day. We want you to know that when you order from us you can count on us to take your pizza order seriously, that’s what we do. Our Mission Statement: To delight every customer one pizza at a time and to be the best pizzeria in the world by killing it on every detail of the customer experience.