16 flavors of deliciousness for your favorite indulgence
Black Pepper Pistachio Pint
$13.75
We use only pistachios in this ice cream. Most "pistachio" ice cream is at least 50% almond flavoring. Not ours, it's all California Pistachio with pieces of roasted pistachios and a hint of black pepper that really makes the flavor pop! Food Allergen Summary: egg, nuts, milk
Brown Sugar Banana Pint
$13.75
Fresh banana ice cream made with our homemade dark brown sugar. Try this with our Nutella cream sauce!! Food Allergen Summary: egg, milk
Cup O' Joe Spinelli (Espresso) Pint
$13.75
Named after Rori's dad, this is a rich espresso ice cream with just a hint of smoky smooth bittersweet chocolate. Food Allergen Summary: egg, milk
Fresh Mint Patty Pint
$13.75
Never has mint tasted so fresh! We cold steep the mint for 2 days in the cream so it tastes just like it's been picked from the garden. We make our own mint patties dipped in Belgian dark chocolate. Food Allergen Summary: egg, milk
Honey Almond Crunch Pint
$13.75
We make house made honey almond brittle and break it up into our honey ice cream both made with Santa Barbara's San Marcos Farms honey. Food Allergen Summary: egg, milk, nuts
Lemon Curd Pint
$13.75
This is a bright, creamy, refreshing ice cream that's not too sweet. Tiny flecks of lemon zest and a touch of butter really give it the taste and feel of real lemon curd. Food Allergen Summary: egg, milk
Ice Cream Sandwiches
The Big Easy
$10.50
Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookies with Vanilla Bean ice cream
Monkey in the Middle
$10.50
Snickerdoodle cookie with Banana Brown Sugar ice cream and a schmear of Nutella
At Papa John's many things guide us toward excellence, but nothing is as important as our commitment to quality. We pride ourselves in providing a menu that's prepared with only the finest ingredients. From fresh vegetables to our never frozen, hand-tossed original dough and superior-quality tomato sauce, we strive to exceed your expectations. We even take special care to ensure all of our pizzas are made with zero trans fat. Combine our total commitment to quality with our superior ingredients, and the result is pure pizza excellence.