What's wrong with this menu?
Papa John's
240 1St St
Niagara Falls, NY 14303
Uber
MORE PHOTOS
Menu
Papa's Picks
Create Your Own Original Crust Pizza
. Choose a sauce base: Original Sauce Base, BBQ Sauce Base, Choose a bake : Normal Bake, Well Done Bake. Choose a cut: Normal Cut (Slices), Square Cut. Would you like whole toppings?: 3 Cheese Blend, Parmesan Romano Cheese Blend, Mozzarella Cheese, Extra 3 Cheese Blend, Extra Parmesan Romano Cheese Blend. Would you like toppings on the left half?: 3 Cheese Blend (Left Half), Parmesan Romano Cheese Blend (Left Half), Mozzarella Cheese (Left Half), Extra 3 Cheese Blend (Left Half), Extra Parmesan Romano Cheese Blend (Left Half). Would you like toppings on the right half?: 3 Cheese Blend (Right Half), Parmesan Romano Cheese Blend (Right Half), Mozzarella Cheese (Right Half), Extra 3 Cheese Blend (Right Half), Extra Parmesan Romano Cheese Blend (Right Half). Would you like to add seasonings?: Crushed Red Pepper, Special Seasoning, Parmesan.
- Extra Large 16" $19.00
- Small 10" $12.00
- Small Gluten Friendly 10" $12.00
- Buffalo Dipping Sauce
- $1.00
- BBQ Dipping Sauce
- $1.00
Create Your Own 14" Large Thin Crust Pizza
$16.00
. Choose a sauce base: Original Sauce Base, BBQ Sauce Base, Ranch Sauce Base. Choose a bake : Normal Bake, Well Done Bake. Choose a cut: Normal Cut (Slices), Square Cut.
- 3 Cheese Blend
- $2.00
- Parmesan Romano Cheese Blend
- $2.00
- Mozzarella Cheese
- $2.00
- Extra 3 Cheese Blend
- $2.00
- Extra Parmesan Romano Cheese Blend
- $2.00
Papa's Signature Specialties
Meatball Pepperoni Pizza
Savory meatballs and premium pepperoni make for a tasty combination, especially when we add a three-cheese blend, and real mozzarella, then sprinkle it all with classic Italian seasoning for an extra dash of flavor. Choose a sauce base: Original Sauce Base, Choose a bake : Normal Bake, Choose a cut: Normal Cut (Slices),
- X-Large Original 16" $25.99
- Large Thin 14" $22.99
- Small Original 10" $14.99
- Small Gluten Friendly 10" $14.99
- Buffalo Dipping Sauce
- $1.00
- BBQ Dipping Sauce
- $1.00
- Pizza Dipping Sauce
- $1.00
- Ranch Dipping Sauce
- $1.00
- Special Garlic Dipping Sauce
- $1.00
Philly Cheesesteak Pizza
Our new Philly sauce, steak from the Original Cheesesteak Company, combined with fresh-cut onions and green peppers. Topped with real Asiago, Fontina, Provolone, and mozzarella cheese. Choose a sauce base: Original Sauce Base, Choose a bake : Normal Bake, Choose a cut: Normal Cut (Slices),
- X-Large Original 16" $25.99
- Large Thin 14" $22.99
- Small Original 10" $14.99
- Small Gluten Friendly 10" $14.99
- Buffalo Dipping Sauce
- $1.00
- BBQ Dipping Sauce
- $1.00
- Pizza Dipping Sauce
- $1.00
- Ranch Dipping Sauce
- $1.00
- Special Garlic Dipping Sauce
- $1.00
Papa's Meatless Specialties
Tuscan 6-Cheese Pizza
Mozzarella, parmesan, romano, asiago, provolone, fontina cheeses & a special blend of Italian herb seasoning. Choose a sauce base: Original Sauce Base, Choose a bake : Normal Bake, Choose a cut: Normal Cut (Slices),
vegetarian
- X-Large Original 16" $25.99
- Large Thin 14" $22.99
- Small Original 10" $14.99
- Small Gluten Friendly 10" $14.99
- Buffalo Dipping Sauce
- $1.00
- BBQ Dipping Sauce
- $1.00
- Pizza Dipping Sauce
- $1.00
- Ranch Dipping Sauce
- $1.00
- Special Garlic Dipping Sauce
- $1.00
Garden Fresh Pizza
Tomatoes, fresh baby portabella mushrooms, green peppers, onions, black olives & mozzarella cheese. Choose a sauce base: Original Sauce Base, Choose a bake : Normal Bake, Choose a cut: Normal Cut (Slices),
vegetarian
- X-Large Original 16" $25.99
- Large Thin 14" $22.99
- Small Original 10" $14.99
- Small Gluten Friendly 10" $14.99
- Buffalo Dipping Sauce
- $1.00
- BBQ Dipping Sauce
- $1.00
- Pizza Dipping Sauce
- $1.00
- Ranch Dipping Sauce
- $1.00
- Special Garlic Dipping Sauce
- $1.00
Sides
Spicy Buffalo Wings
Bone-in wings are oven baked and tossed in tangy Buffalo sauce.
- 20 Pieces $21.99
- 10 Pieces $12.99
- Buffalo Dipping Sauce
- $1.00
- BBQ Dipping Sauce
- $1.00
- Pizza Dipping Sauce
- $1.00
- Ranch Dipping Sauce
- $1.00
- Special Garlic Dipping Sauce
- $1.00
BBQ Wings
Bone-in wings are oven baked and covered in a bold BBQ sauce.
- 20 Pieces $21.99
- 10 Pieces $12.99
- Buffalo Dipping Sauce
- $1.00
- BBQ Dipping Sauce
- $1.00
- Pizza Dipping Sauce
- $1.00
- Ranch Dipping Sauce
- $1.00
- Special Garlic Dipping Sauce
- $1.00
indicates a spicy dish