What's wrong with this menu?
Old Horseshoe Restaurant & Tavern
65 South Main Street
Johnstown, OH 43031
Uber
MORE PHOTOS
more menus
Main Menu
Beer
Main Menu
Appetizers
Chicken Tenders
$8.00
Hand Breaded all White Meat Chicken Strips Choice of Mild, Hot, BBQ, Thai Chili Sauce.
Chicken Wings
$8.00
Served with Celery Sticks Choice of Mild, Hot, BBQ, Thai Chili Sauce.
Potato Skins
$7.00
Cheddar, Bacon, Scallions, Sour Cream.
Hummus
$6.00
Served with Pita, Assorted Veggies.
Cajun Spiced Calamari
$9.00
Served with Thai Chili Sauce Or Cocktail Sauce.
Ooey Gooey Fries
$6.00
Sour Cream Sriracha, Red Peppers, Cheddar, Jalapeños, Basil, Parmesan, Sesame Seeds.
Meatball Sliders
$7.00
Three House-made Meatballs, Provolone, Banana Peppers.
Salads
Soup & Side Salad
$6.00
Ask your server about today's soup offering.
Caesar Salad
Hearts of Romaine, Garlic Croutons, Grated Parmesan, House Made Caesar Dressing. Dressing Options: Balsamic Vinaigrette, Bleu Cheese, Caesar, Italian, Ranch, 1000 Island.
- Chicken Breast
- $2.00
- Salmon
- $4.00
- Shrimp
- $4.00
- Flash-Fried Calamari
- $3.00
Traditional Iceberg Wedge Salad
$7.00
Iceberg Lettuce, Walnuts, Bacon, Bleu Cheese, Tomato. Dressing Options: Balsamic Vinaigrette, Bleu Cheese, Caesar, Italian, Ranch, 1000 Island.
- Chicken Breast
- $2.00
- Salmon
- $4.00
- Shrimp
- $4.00
- Flash-Fried Calamari
- $3.00
Tuscan Kale Salad
$6.00
Kale, Fennel, Red Radish, Lemon, Red Onions, Parmesan, Italian Dressing. Dressing Options: Balsamic Vinaigrette, Bleu Cheese, Caesar, Italian, Ranch, 1000 Island.
- Chicken Breast
- $2.00
- Salmon
- $4.00
- Shrimp
- $4.00
- Flash-Fried Calamari
- $3.00
Spinach Salad
$6.00
Spinach, Strawberries, Candied Pecans, Fresh Mozzarella, Red Onion. Dressing Options: Balsamic, Vinaigrette, Bleu Cheese, Caesar, Italian, Ranch, 1000 Island.
- Chicken Breast
- $2.00
- Salmon
- $4.00
- Shrimp
- $4.00
- Flash-Fried Calamari
- $3.00
Soups
Soup & Side Salad
$6.00
Ask your server about today's soup offering.
Soup of the Day
$4.00
Ask your server about today's offering.
Sandwiches & Wraps
Build-Your-Own
$9.00
Build your own Burger, Chicken Sandwich or Wrap! Choose: Hand Pattied Beef, Grilled Chicken or Chicken Tenders. Choose up to five toppings: Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Sauteed Mushrooms, Caramelized Onion, Roasted Red Peppers, Pineapple, Banana Peppers, Bacon, Ham, Swiss, Havarti, Cheddar. Bread: Brioche Bun, Marble Rye, Texas Toast, Wrap. Sauce: Mild, Hot, Bbq, Thai Chili Sauce, Balsamic Glaze
Reuben
$8.00
Corned Beef, Sauerkraut, Thousand Island, Swiss, Marble Rye. Sandwiches are served with house fries and a dill pickle.
Blackened Chicken Sandwich
$8.00
Blackened Chicken, Bacon, Pepper Jack, Bayou Mayo, Grilled Onions. Sandwiches are served with house fries and a dill pickle.
Braised Short Rib & Grilled Cheese Sandwich
$9.00
Ale Braised Beef Short Rib, Havarti, Onions, Bistro Sauce, Texas Toast. Sandwiches are served with house fries and a dill pickle.
Spicy Black Bean Burger
$8.00
Choice Of: Bacon, Bleu Cheese, Cheddar, Swiss, Mushrooms, Sautéed Onions. Sandwiches are served with house fries and a dill pickle.
Entrees
Served with a house salad and choice of two sides.
Blue Crab Mac & Cheese
$14.00
Mac & Cheese, Garlic, Green Onions, White Wine, Basil, Heavy Cream.
Grilled Local New York Strip
$21.00
12 oz. Center Cut Strip Loin, Served With A1® Steak Sauce.
Chicken Parmesan
$13.00
Parmesan Crusted Chicken, Linguini, Marinara.
Spaghetti & Meatballs
$12.00
Housemade Meatballs, Tomato Basil Sauce.
Fish n' Chips
$13.00
Beer-battered cod.
The Old Horseshoe Meatloaf
$13.00
Texas Toast, Meatloaf, Gravy.
Sirloin Petit Filet
$15.00
Char-Grilled 8 Oz. Steak, House Sauce.
Mediterranean Pasta
$18.00
Sautéed Shrimp, Spaghetti, Tomatoes, Mushrooms, Black Olives, Garlic, Butter.
Grilled Herb Salmon
$15.00
Grilled Atlantic Salmon Filet, Choice of Citrus Herb Butter, Balsamic Glaze or Teriyaki Sauce.
Shrimp & Grits
$13.00
Andouille Sausage, Shrimp, Grits, Jalapeño Cheddar.
Pizza
$9.00
Choose up to 5 toppings: Sauce & Cheese: Garlic Oil or Tomato Sauce, Mozzarella Cheese. Meats: Pepperoni, Sausage, Bacon, Chicken, Ham. Vegetables: Mushrooms, Spinach, Red Onion, Roasted Red Peppers, Pineapple, Banana Peppers.
Bottled
Budweiser, St. Louis, MO, USA, 5.00%
$3.00
Anheuser-Busch
Bud Light, St. Louis, MO, USA, 4.20%
$3.00
Anheuser-Busch
Bud Light Platinum, St. Louis, MO, USA, 6.00%
$3.00
Anheuser-Busch
Coors Light, Golden, CO, USA, 4.20%
$3.00
MillerCoors
Corona, Mexico, 4.60%
$3.50
Grupo Modelo S.A. de C.V.
Guinness Draught, Ireland, 4.20%
$4.00
Guinness Ltd.
Heineken, Netherlands, 5.00%
$3.50
Heineken Nederland B.V.
Miller Lite, Milwaukee, WI, USA, 4.17%
$3.00
MillerCoors
Newcastle Brown Ale, UK (Scotland), 4.70%
$4.00
The Caledonian Brewery Company Limited
Yuengling Lager, Pottsville, PA, USA, 4.40%
$3.00
Yuengling Brewery
Yuengling Light, Pottsville, PA, USA, 3.20%
$3.00
Yuengling Brewery
Four C's American Pale Ale, Strongsville, OH, USA, 6.00%, 55
$4.50
The Brew Kettle Taproom & Smokehouse / Production Works
White Rajah American IPA, Strongsville, OH, USA, 6.00%, 70
$5.00
The Brew Kettle Taproom & Smokehouse / Production Works
Old Leghumper American Porter, Akron, OH, USA, 6.70%
$5.00
Thirsty Dog Brewing Company
Ellie's Brown Ale, Boulder, CO, USA, 5.50%
$4.50
Avery Brewing Company
Two Hearted Ale American IPA, Kalamazoo, MI, USA, 7.00%, 55
$5.00
Bell's Brewery Inc.
Founders Porter, Grand Rapids, MI, USA, 6.50%
$5.00
Founders Brewing Company
60 Minute IPA, Milton, DE, USA, 6.00%, 60
$5.00
Dogfish Head Brewery
Redds Apple Ale , Milwaukee, WI, USA, 5.00%
$3.75
MillerCoors
Chocolate Stout, Newport, OR, USA, 6.00%
$10.00
Rogue Ales
Dead Guy Ale, Newport, OR, USA, 6.50%
$5.00
Rogue Ales
Arrogant Bastard Ale , Escondido, CA, USA, 7.20%, 100+
$10.00
Stone Brewing Co.
Golden Monkey Tripel, Downington, PA, USA, 9.50%
$5.00
Victory Brewing Company
CBC Pale Ale, Columbus , OH, USA, 5.50%, 29
$4.00
Columbus Brewing Company
Urban Cowboy American Stout, Lancaster, OH, USA, 8.00%
$10.00
Rockmill Brewery
Bumble Berry Honey Blueberry Ale, North Olmsted , OH, USA, 5.30%
$5.75
Fat Heads Brewery & Saloon
Head Hunter IPA, North Olmsted, OH, USA, 7.50%, 87
$6.00
Fat Heads Brewery & Saloon
Draft
Bud Light, St. Louis, MO, USA, 4.20%
Anheuser-Busch
- 16 OZ $3.00
- 22 OZ $4.25
Fat Tire Amber Ale, Fort Collins, CO, USA, 5.20%
New Belgium Brewing
- 16 OZ $6.50
- 22 OZ $8.00
Razz Wheat, Athens, OH, USA, 5.50%
Jackie O's Pub & Brewery
- 16 OZ $6.50
- 22 OZ $8.00
Saison Noir Farmhouse Ale, Lancaster, OH, USA, 8.00%
Rockmill Brewery
- 16 OZ $8.00
- 22 OZ $10.00
Yuengling Lager, Pottsville, PA, USA, 4.40%
Yuengling Brewery
- 16 OZ $3.00
- 22 OZ $4.25
Barnraiser Pale Ale, Heath, OH, USA, 5.40%, 41
Homestead Beer Co.
- 16 OZ $6.00
- 22 OZ $7.50
White Weasel Wheat Ale, Zanesville, OH, USA, 4.50%
Weasel Boy Brewing Co.
- 16 OZ $7.00
- 22 OZ $8.50
French Ridge IPA, Millersburg, OH , USA, 7.50%, 70
Millersburg Brewing Co.
- 16 OZ $5.00
- 22 OZ $6.50