What's wrong with this menu?
Old City Public House
200 Portion Rd.
Lake Ronkonkoma, NY 11779
Uber
MORE PHOTOS
more menus
Dinner Menu
Express Home Party Menu
Kids Menu
Dinner Menu
Appetizers
Chicken Fingers
$7.00
chicken fingers served with honey mustard dressing
Mozzarella Cheese Sticks
$7.00
five mozzarella sticks served with marinara sauce
Potato Skins
$7.00
smothered in melted cheeses and bacon served with sour cream
- Make It Mexi-skins for an Additional
- $2.00
Old City Fries
$7.00
fries topped with melted american cheese served with brown gravy on the side for dipping
Beef Nachos
$9.00
seasoned beef, melted cheese, topped with shredded lettuce, tomatoes and black olives served with salsa and sour cream
Beer-Battered Onion Rings
$8.00
a generous portion of golden-fried onions served with horseradish dressing
The Big Pretzel
$10.00
served with cheese sauce and mustard
Coconut Shrimp (6)
$10.00
served with mandarin orange dipping sauce
Chicken Wings
$12.00
10 wings, bbq, mild, hot, super hot or Jimmy's house sauce
Chicken Quesadilla
$11.00
savory chicken, a blend of cheeses and bacon served with sour cream and salsa
Signature Premium Dip Sandwiches
Featuring our slow roasted beef served on our special bakery roll served with a side of "Au Jus", fries and pickle. Substitute fries for onion rings $2.69. Add a cup of soup or house salad for an additional $2.69
Popular New York Style Reuben
$14.00
corned beef, sauerkraut and melted swiss cheese with mustard and thousand island dressing served closed or open-faced
Chicken Fingers BLT Hero
$13.00
diced chicken fingers with bacon, lettuce, tomato and american cheese on a hero, served with mayonnaise on the side
Garlic Roast Beef Melt
$14.00
Boar's Head roast beef topped with brown gravy and melted mozzarella cheese on a toasted garlic roll
Turkey Club Wrap
$12.00
turkey, crisp bacon with lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise
BBQ Chicken with Bacon and Cheese
$12.00
boneless bbq chicken breast topped with melted swiss cheese and crispy bacon on a kaiser roll
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
$12.00
three breaded chicken tenders in hot sauce and served with blue cheese dressing, lettuce and tomato
Chicken Caesar Wrap
$12.00
grilled chicken tossed with parmesan and romano cheese, romaine lettuce, tomato and creamy caesar dressing
Good Old City Turkey Club
$13.00
turkey layered with lettuce, tomato and bacon on toasted white bread
Open Faced Turkey Melt
$13.00
roasted turkey in brown gravy topped with melted american served with a side of cranberry sauce
Corned Beef Hero
$13.00
corned beef with melted swiss cheese served with a side of cole slaw
Burgers
All burgers served on a bakery fresh roll with lettuce, tomato, pickle and fries. Substitute fries for onion rings $2.69. Add a cup of soup or house salad for an additional $2.69
Cheeseburger*
$13.00
choice of american, swiss or mozzarella
American Cheese and Bacon Burger*
$14.00American Cheese and Fried Onion Burger*
$14.00BBQ, American Cheese and Bacon
$14.00Mushroom and Mozzarella Cheese Burger*
$14.00Hamburger*
$12.00Veggieburger
$12.00Swiss and Sauteed Onion Burger*
$14.00Mushroom, Onion and Pepper Burger*
$14.00Patty Melt*
$14.00
beef patty, fried onions and swiss cheese on grilled rye
Create-A-Burger*
$16.00
choice of 3 toppings served with 3 onion rings
Entrees
All entrées served with your choice of a cup of soup or caesar salad or house salad and your choice of fries, baked potato or rice
Steak
Served with caesar salad or house salad and your choice of fries or baked potato or rice
14oz. Shell Steak*
$19.00
topped with homemade fried onions
14oz. Marinated Shell Steak*
$19.00
topped with homemade fried onions
14oz. Marinated Steak and Shrimp*
$25.00
marinated steak and golden-fried shrimp
18oz. Porter House*
$29.00
plain, marinated or teriyaki topped with fried onions
Seafood
Add a cup of soup or house salad for an additional $2.69
Fish and Chips Dinner
$14.00
beer battered golden-fried fish served with cole slaw, fries and tarter sauce
Baked Salmon
$19.00
salmon baked in a lemon-wine sauce served with rice and broccoli
Shrimp Basket
$15.00
golden fried shrimp served with fries and coleslaw Seafood
Chicken
Add a cup of soup or house salad for an additional $2.69
Monterey Chicken
$16.00
two grilled chicken breasts smothered with BBQ sauce, bacon, monterey jack and cheddar cheeses, sautéed onions and peppers, served with broccoli and rice
Marinated Chicken
$15.00
two grilled chicken breasts marinated in creamy italian dressing, served with broccoli and rice
BBQ Chicken
$14.00
two grilled chicken breasts topped with tasty BBQ sauce, served with broccoli and rice
Buffalo Chicken Fingers Platter
$13.00
our signature chicken fingers tossed in hot sauce, served with fries and blue cheese dressing
Chicken Fingers Platter
$13.00
our signature chicken fingers served with fries and honey mustard
Old City Southern Fried Chicken Dinner
$14.00
served with fries and cole slaw
Pastas
Add a cup of soup or house salad for an additional $2.69. Add: Grilled Chicken $4; Sliced Marinated Steak* $5; Shrimp* $6
Penne Florentine Old City Style
$12.00
penne pasta tossed with spinach, tomatoes and alfredo sauce, sprinkled with parmesan and romano cheese
Tortellini Pomodoro
$12.00
cheese tortellini tossed with alfredo and marinara sauce with a touch of garlic and parmesan
Sizzling Fajitas
Add a cup of soup or house salad for an additional $2.69. Served over a bed of grilled peppers and onions with shredded cheeses, lettuce, salsa and sour cream. Served with warm flour tortillas and rice. Add guacamole $1.50
Vegetable Fajitas
$14.00Chicken Fajitas
$15.00Steak Fajitas*
$16.00Shrimp Fajitas*
$17.002-Way Combo
$17.00
choose 2: chicken, steak* or shrimp*
3-Way Combo
$19.00
with chicken, steak* and shrimp*
Slow Cooked Baby Back Ribs
Full Rack Of Baby Back Ribs
$28.00Half Rack Of Baby Back Ribs
$16.00Half Rack Of Baby Back Ribs
$21.00
with a BBQ Chicken Breast
South of the Border
3 Way Fajitas
$21.00
grilled strips of seasoned steak and juicy chicken with broiled cajun-spiced shrimp served sizzling hot over peppers and onions, served with flour tortillas, salsa, sour cream and shredded cheeses
Burrito Supremo
$16.00
a flour tortilla filled with seasoned beef, black beans, lettuce and cheese, topped with mixed cheeses and tomatoes served with rice, black beans, salsa and sour cream
Mexican Pizza
$12.00
baked flour tortilla topped with seasoned roast beef, melted cheeses, tomato, black olives, jalapeños served with salsa and sour cream
Old City Signature Premium French Dip Sandwiches
Featuring our slow roasted beef served on our special bakery roll served with a side of "Au Jus", fries and pickle. Add a cup of soup or house salad for an additional $5
French Dip Sandwich
$14.00
with American Cheese
French Dip Sandwich
$16.00
with Mushrooms and Mozzarella Cheese
French Dip Sandwich
$16.00
with American Cheese and Fried Onions
French Dip Sandwich
$16.00
with Swiss Cheese and Sautéed Onions
French Dip Sandwich
$16.00
with Mushrooms, Peppers and Onions
Old City Favorites
Add a cup of soup or house salad for an additional $5
Vegetarian Quesadilla
$9.00
with melted cheese, sautéed mushrooms and roasted red peppers, served with salsa and sour cream
Chicken Parmigiana Hero
$12.00
served with fries
Old City Chicken Cutlet Salad
$15.00
a combo of iceberg and romaine lettuce topped with sliced breaded chicken cutlet, roasted red peppers, swiss and mozzarella cheeses, served with balsamic vinaigrette
Veggie Burger
$12.00
served with lettuce tomato and fries
- Any Topping Add (Each)
- $1.50
Sides Orders
French Onion Soup
$7.00Soup Of The Day
$5.00Fries
$5.00Guacamole
$3.00House Salad
$5.00Caesar Salad
$5.00Rice & Beans w/ Salsa
$6.00Chips and Salsa
$5.00
*Menu Items can be cooked to order. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of food-borne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions