What's wrong with this menu?
The Nutty Irishman
60 E Main St
Bay Shore, NY 11706
Uber
MORE PHOTOS
Main Menu
Appetizers
Nutty Platter
$14.95
Mozzarella sticks, crispy zucchini, boneless buffalo tenders, jalapeno poppers
Fried Mac and Cheese
$8.95
Homemade mac and cheese chipotle ranch dipping sauce
Chicken Tenders
$7.95
Crispy white meat strips served with a side of honey mustard or our famous irish whiskey bbq sauce or tossed in buffalo, teriyaki, our famous irish whiskey bbq sauce or nutty 911
Wings
Your choice of hot, medium, mild, teriyaki, our famous irish whiskey bbq or nutty 911
- Small (8 Wings) $8.95
- Medium (12 Wings) $12.95
- Large (16 Wings) $16.95
Nachos
$8.95
Piled high homemade tortilla chips topped with guinness stout chili, house blend of cheeses, scallions, jalapeños, olives, tomatoes, and sour cream
The Irishman Nachos
$8.95
Waffle fries topped with melted mozzarella, bacon pieces, and scallions
Mozzarella Sticks
$7.95
Beer battered mozzarella served with spicy marinara
Bavarian Pretzel
$7.95
Oversized bavarian pretzel served with beer cheese or spicy mustard
Spinach Dip
$7.95
Spinach, artichoke hearts blended parmigiano and romano cheese topped with melted mozzarella served with warm tortilla chips
Chicken Quesadilla
$9.95
Grilled chicken bacon, cheddar, cajun ranch drizzle
Nutty Quesadilla
$10.95
Blackened chicken, roasted peppers, caramelized onions, monterey jack cheese served with black beans and sour cream on the side
Sliders
Bottle Caps
$7.95
Three sirloin mini burgers, topped with american cheese, pickles, and special sauce
Pulled Pork
$7.95
Three mini slow roasted pork sandwiches, our famous irish whiskey bbq sauce served with a side of cole slaw
Nutty Bbq Chicken
$7.95
Three mini grilled chicken sandwiches with cheddar, bacon, jalapeño, and our famous irish whiskey bbq
Sandwiches
Served with shoe string fries & a side of cole slaw
Nutty Grilled Chicken
$7.95
American cheese on texas toast
- Add Bacon
- $1.00
- Add Tomato
- $1.00
Steak Tidbits
$11.95
Marinated grilled steak and melted mozzarella on garlic bread
Grilled Chicken
$8.95
Grilled chicken, cole slaw, spicy mayo and jack cheese on a baguette
Salads
Add chicken $4, add steak** $5
Garden Salad
$6.95
Mixed greens, tomato, red onion, cucumber
House Salad
$7.95
Mixed greens, cranberries, candied walnuts, crumbled blue cheese, honey balsamic vinaigrette
South of the Border
$8.95
Mixed greens, black beans, monterey jack cheese, tomatoes, onions, roasted corn, crispy tortilla strips, southwestern ranch
Burgers
Served with shoe string fries & a side of cole slaw
Classic*
$9.95
Lettuce, tomato, red onion
Buffalo Blue*
$10.95
Crumbled blue cheese, buffalo sauce, crispy bacon
Big Texan*
$10.95
Bacon, cheddar, onion rings, our famous irish whiskey bbq sauce
Make Your Own
$9.95
Choose your first two at no extra charge, add $0.50 For each additional item: crispy bacon, sautéed onions, frizzled onions, mushrooms, jalapeños, onion rings, roasted red peppers, american cheese, monterey jack cheese, cheddar cheese, mozzarella cheese, blue cheese crumble, guinness stout chili, fried egg
Sides
Shoe String Fries
$4.95Sweet Potato Fries
$6.95Onion Rings
$6.95Tater Tots
$7.95Waffle Fries
$7.95Beverages
we proudly serve coca-cola products
Coca-Cola
$3.00Diet Coke
$3.00Sprite
$3.00Minute Maid Lemonade
$3.00Nestea
$3.00Sweetened Iced Tea
$3.00Orange Juice
$3.00Cranberry Juice
$3.00Poland Spring Bottled Water
$3.00Coastal Vines - Sonoma California
By the glass
Chardonnay
$7.00Merlot
$7.00Cabernet
$7.00Zinfandel
$7.00Pinot Grigio
$7.00Bottled Beer
Budweiser
- Domestic $4.75
- Import $6.00
Bud Light
- Domestic $4.75
- Import $6.00
Coors Light
- Domestic $4.75
- Import $6.00
Miller Lite
- Domestic $4.75
- Import $6.00
Michelob Ultra
- Domestic $4.75
- Import $6.00
Heineken
- Domestic $4.75
- Import $6.00
Heineken Light
- Domestic $4.75
- Import $6.00
Amstel Light
- Domestic $4.75
- Import $6.00
Corona
- Domestic $4.75
- Import $6.00
Corona Light
- Domestic $4.75
- Import $6.00
Ommission - Gluten Free
- Domestic $4.75
- Import $6.00
O'douls - Non-Alcoholic
- Domestic $4.75
- Import $6.00
Draught Beers
We proudly support our local breweries
Seasonal & Rotated Craft Beer
Ask your server
Long Ireland
Brewing Blue Point Company
Moustache, Brewing 09
Port Jeff Brewing Company
Brooklyn Brewery
Barrier Brewing
Specialty Shots
Pickle Back
$5.50
A shot of jameson irish whiskey & a shot of pickle juice
Chocolate Covered Pretzel
$5.00
Whipped cream vodka & frangelico
Fuzzy Ball
$5.00
Fire ball whisky, peach schnapps & orange juice
Nutty Irishman
$5.00
Bailey's irish cream & frangelico
Hand Grenade
$14.00
Stoli orange, jagermeister, & energy drink
Cinnamon Toast Crunch
$5.00
Fireball whisky & rumchata crème rum
Whiskey
Jameson 12 Yr Reserve
- Drink $8.50
- Rocks $11.00
- Neat $11.75
Teeling's Small Batch
- Drink $6.00
- Rocks $8.50
- Neat $9.25
The Irishman Founder's Reserve
- Drink $6.00
- Rocks $8.50
- Neat $9.25
Bourbon
Basil Hayden
- Drink $7.00
- Rocks $9.50
- Neat $10.25
Booker's
- Drink $7.00
- Rocks $9.50
- Neat $10.25
Jim Beam Devil's Cut
- Drink $6.00
- Rocks $8.50
- Neat $9.25
Scotch
Laohroaig 10 Yr Old
- Drink $8.50
- Rocks $11.00
- Neat $11.75
Mcclelland's Highland Single Malt
- Drink $7.00
- Rocks $9.50
- Neat $10.25
The Glenlivet 15yr Old French Oak
- Drink $9.00
- Rocks $11.50
- Neat $12.25
Aberlour 12yr
- Drink $7.00
- Rocks $9.50
- Neat $10.25
Auchentoshen American Oak
- Drink $6.00
- Rocks $8.50
- Neat $9.25
*This menu item can be cooked to your linking. Consuming raw or uncooked meat, fish, shellfish, or fresh shell eggs can increase your risk of food-bourne illness, especially if you have certain health conditions
Browse Nearby
General Info
Payment Types
All Major Cards
Cuisine
Bar
Meals
Lunch
Dinner
Late Night
Hours
Monday:
12:00pm - 3:59am
Tuesday:
12:00pm - 3:59am
Wednesday:
12:00pm - 3:59am
Thursday:
12:00pm - 3:59am
Friday:
12:00pm - 3:59am
Saturday:
12:00pm - 3:59am
Sunday:
12:00pm - 3:59am