Colossals with garlic butter, parmesan and bread crumbs
Colossal Lump Crab Cocktail
$27.00
Cocktail or remoulade sauce
Classic Shellfish Bisque
$15.00
Carpaccio*
$22.50
Prime beef tenderloin, capers, parmesan, arugula
Seafood Platter*
Create your own selection of colossal shrimp, jumbo crabmeat, oysters, crispy lobster tail and shellfish bisque. Stone crabs available in season | A.Q.
Stone Crabs
October 15 – May 1 | A.Q.
Usda Prime-Only Steaks*
Aged 28 days and prepared "Pittsburgh-style" with a charred exterior. Accompaniments: Oscar $18, Garlic Shrimp $12, Crispy Lobster Tail A.Q., Bearnaise $4
Petite New York Strip
$53.00
10 oz.
Bone-In Filet
$105.00
16 oz.
Petite Filet
$60.00
8 oz. barrel cut
Chopped Steak of Prime, Aged Beef
$36.00
Topped with sautéed onions
Center Cut Filet
$78.00
12 oz. barrel cut
Bone-In Ribeye
$86.00
22 oz.
New York Strip
$73.00
16 oz.
Delmonico
$61.00
12 oz. cajun style or broiled
Director's Cuts
Porterhouse
$145.00
(for two) 40 oz.
Tomahawk Ribeye
$150.00
40 oz.
Wagyu Manhattan
$74.00
10 oz. BMS 8+ (Mishima Ranch USA)
Entrees
Lamb Chops*
$61.00
Two 10 oz.
Double Rib Veal Chop*
$62.00
16 oz.
Garlic Chicken
$33.00
White wine, garlic, fresh herbs
Redfish Amandine*
$41.00
Jumbo crab, toasted almonds, brown butter
Crab Cakes
$54.00
1/2 lb. Colossal lump "no filler," mustard sauce
Sea Bass*
Pan roasted with garlic | A.Q.
Scottish Salmon*
$41.00
Topped with sautéed portobello mushrooms
Shrimp Alfredo
$45.00
Garlic shrimp, fettuccine
Live Maine Lobster - 3 to 13 Lbs.
+ Add lump crabmeat stuffing per lobster lb. | A.Q.
Salads $15
Slightly smaller size available
Chopped Italian Salad
Onions, tomatoes, peppers, hearts of palm, anchovies, almonds, olive oil, parmesan and bleu cheese | Add Colossal Crab +27.00
Wedge Salad
Bacon, chives, tomatoes, blue cheese dressing
Classic Caesar
Crisp romaine, croutons, parmesan
Arugula & Apple
Endive, blue cheese, radicchio, candied walnuts, raisins, champagne vinaigrette
Sides $13
Slightly smaller size available
Spinach
Creamed or Garlic
Sautéed Mushrooms
Onions
Rings, Sautéed, Straws
Charred Brussels Sprouts
Southwest Creamed Corn
Broccolini
Grilled Asparagus
Hash Browns / Lyonnaise
Steak Cut French Fries
Cheese Mashed Potatoes
Fettuccine Alfredo
Loaded Baked Potato - 1 Lb.
*Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodbourne illness
Martinis $15
Martini Hour 4:00-6:00 - $10
Dirty "Coldest in Town"
Chopin Potato vodka, green olive brine, blue cheese salt rim, olives stuffed with blue cheese
This wildly popular steakhouse with swift, professional service, a classy supper club ambiance and extensive wine list has topped “best of” lists for close to 20 years. The focus at New York Prime is its top-quality, USDA prime-only beef, colossal seafood platters and classic sides. And for a sight you have to see to believe… when Big Red (aka the largest lobster in the tank) gets wheeled around in a Radio Flyer wagon for guests to ogle and order. Visit our menu story to see why New York Prime is a different kind of steakhouse. Live entertainment nightly. Seasonal courtyard dining.