What's wrong with this menu?
New Bethel Ordinary
8838 Southeastern Avenue
Indianapolis, US-IN 46239
Uber
MORE PHOTOS
more menus
Main Menu
Drink Menu
Main Menu
Appetizers
Breadsticks
Nacho Cheese, Pizza Sauce, Garlic Butter
- Half $3.99
- Full $5.99
Potato Skins
$10.99
Cheese, Bacon, Ranch, Sour Cream
Chicken Strips
$8.99
Hand Breaded or Grilled, Choice of Sauce
Quesadilla
$7.99
Traditional, BBQ, Buffalo Pico, Jalapeno, Lettuce, Salsa
- Pulled Pork or Grilled Chicken - Add
- $3.00
- Brisket or Chipotle Beef - Add
- $4.00
Fried Ravioli
$10.99
Marinara
Cheesy Garlic Bread
Garlic Toast, Mozzarella, Pizza Sauce
- Half $4.99
- Full $6.99
Loaded Fries
$10.99
Cheese, Bacon, Ranch, Sour Cream
Fried Cauliflower
$6.99
Ranch
Beer Battered Onion Rings
Petal Dipping Sauce
- Half $5.99
- Full $7.99
New Bethel Nachos
$9.99
Tortilla Chips, White Queso, BBQ Sauce, Pico, Guacamole, Sour Cream
- Pulled Pork or Grilled Chicken - Add
- $3.00
- Brisket or Chipotle Beef - Add
- $4.00
Tenderloin Strips
$8.99
Hand-Breaded or Grilled, Horseradish Sauce, Ranch
Breaded Mushrooms
$6.99
Ranch
Mozzarella Sticks
$6.99
Marinara
Wings
Sauces: Mild | Buffalo | Hot | BBQ | Golden BBQ | Teriyaki | Firecracker | Mango Habanero. Rubs: Jamaican Jerk | Bonfire | #9 Lemon Pepper | BBQ | Cajun | Garlic. Signature Sauces: Bourbon Cola | Chipotle | Garlic Parmesan | Ghost Pepper | Jamaican Jerk BBQ | Maple Sriracha $1 Upcharge. Side of Sauce or Dressing: Small $0.50 | Large $1. Extra Celery $0.50
Traditional Bone in Wings
$10.99
10 Wings Served With Ranch or Blue Cheese And Celery
Boneless Wings
10 Wings Served With Ranch or Blue Cheese And Celery
- 1/2 Lb. $7.49
- Full Lb. $13.99
Soups & Salads
Dressings: Ranch | Bleu Cheese | French | Italian | Oil & Vinegar | 1000 Island | Honey Mustard | Balsamic Vinaigrette
Side Salad
$4.99
House or Caesar
Chicken Salad
$10.99
Hand Breaded or Grilled, Cheddar, Bacon, Tomato, Croutons
Chef Salad
$10.99
Ham, Turkey, Egg, Bacon, Cheddar, Tomato, Croutons
Wedge Salad
$7.99
Iceberg Wedge, Bacon, Bleu Cheese Crumbles, Red Onion, Tomato, Bleu Cheese Dressing
Chicken Caesar Salad
$10.99
Grilled Chicken, Parmesan, Croutons
Ham & Bean Soup
- Cup $2.50
- Bowl $4.99
Chili
- Cup $2.50
- Bowl $4.99
Pizza
The Signature Item of the Ordinary. Our Pizzas Are Made To Order Using Only the Freshest, Top Quality Meats, Veggies, And Cheese. Piled High And Baked In Our Traditional Brick Deck Pizza Ovens. Toppings - Veggies (For 10-inch $1 | For 12-inch $1.25 | For 16-inch $1.50): Mushroom | Black Olive | Green Pepper | Onion | Banana Pepper | Jalapeno | Tomato | Pineapple. Meats (For 10-inch $1.75 | For 12-inch $2 | For 16-inch $2.25): Pepperoni | Sausage | Ham | Bacon | Italian Sausage | Grilled Chicken | Ground Beef | Crumbled Sausage. Extra Cheese: For 10-inch $1.50 | For 12-inch $2 | For 16-inch $2.50. Gluten Free Crust (10- and 12-inch) acid $2. Take & Bake: Any Of Our Famous Pizzas Can Be Prepared For You To Take Home And Bake Yourself
Deluxe
Pepperoni, Sausage, Ham, Mushroom, Black Olives, Green Pepper, Onion
- 10 Inch $16.99
- 12 Inch $19.99
- 16 Inch $25.99
BBQ Chicken
Grilled Chicken, Red Onion, BBQ Sauce
- 10 Inch $14.99
- 12 Inch $16.99
- 16 Inch $20.99
Meat Lovers
Pepperoni, Sausage, Ham, Italian Sausage, Bacon
- 10 Inch $16.99
- 12 Inch $19.99
- 16 Inch $25.99
Cheese Pizza
Build Your Own
- 10 Inch $12.99
- 12 Inch $13.99
- 16 Inch $17.99
Hawaiian
Ham, Pineapple, BBQ Sauce
- 10 Inch $14.99
- 12 Inch $16.99
- 16 Inch $20.99
Burgers
Fresh, 1/2 Pound, 100% Angus Beef. Toppings: Lettuce | Tomato | Pickle | Onion | Mayo. Served On a Brioche Bun With Choice Of Side Item. Substitute Onion Rings or House or Caesar Salad For $2
Texas BBQ Burger
$10.99
Cheddar, Bacon, BBQ Sauce, Onion Ring
Bacon Bleu Burger
$10.99
Bacon, Bleu Cheese Crumbles
Patty Melt
$10.99
Marble Rye, Sautéed Onions, Swiss, 1000 Island
Shroom Burger
$10.99
Sautéed Mushrooms, Swiss
Build Your Own Burger
$8.99
Cheeses: American | Swiss | Cheddar | Pepper Jack. Toppings: Banana Pepper | Jalapeno | Grilled Onions | Grilled Mushrooms | Pico. Premium Toppings: Bacon | Bleu Cheese Crumbles | Onion Ring | Guacamole
- Cheeses (Each)
- $0.99
- Toppings (Each)
- $0.99
- Premium Toppings (Each)
- $1.49
Tacos
All Served On Flour Tortilla
Spicy Chicken
$8.99
Hand Breaded or Grilled Chicken, Lettuce, Pico, Chipotle Sauce, Bonfire Rub
Bourbon Cola Brisket
$9.99
House Smoked Brisket, Shredded Pepper Jack Pickled Red Onion, Bourbon Cola Sauce
BBQ Pulled Pork
$8.99
House Smoked Pork, BBQ Rub, Cheese, Pico, BBQ Sauce
Boom Boom Shrimp
$9.99
Breaded Popcorn Shrimp, Lettuce, Pico, Boom Boom Sauce
Beef Tacodilla
$9.99
Shredded Beef, Cheese, Pico, Guacamole, Sour Cream, Grilled Tortilla
Sandwiches
Tenderloin
$9.99
Pork Loin, Hand Breaded or Grilled
Texas Toast BLT
$9.99
Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo, Texas Toast
Fish Sandwich
$9.99
Hand-Breaded Haddock
Chicken Sandwich
$10.99
Hand Breaded or Grilled
Beef Brisket Sandwich
$12.99
House-Smoked Brisket. Side of BBQ Sauce
Pulled Pork Sandwich
$11.99
House-Smoked Pork, Side of BBQ Sauce
Chicken Wrap
$10.99
Hand Breaded or Grilled, Pico, Lettuce, Cheese, Chipotle Sauce
Grilled Ham & Cheese
$9.99
Smoked Pit Ham. Choice of Cheese And Bread
Cuban Sandwich
$13.99
Ham, Pulled Pork, Mustard, Pickle, Hoagie Bun
Sides
Fries
$2.79Potato Salad
$2.79Cottage Cheese
$2.79Green Beans
$2.79Cole Slaw
$2.79Apple Sauce
$2.79Desserts
Bread Pudding
$4.99
Cinnamon Sauce
Brownie ala Mode
$5.99
Brownie, Vanilla Ice Cream, Whipped Cream, Chocolate Syrup
Craft Beers
Ace Perry Hard Cider - Sebastopol, CA - 5.0% ABV
Bare Hands Westy IPA - Granger Indiana - 7.0% ABV
Bare Hands Rotating - Granger, IN
Bell's Two Hearted American WA - Comstock, MI - 7.0% ABV
Bloomington Brewing Kirkwood Cream Ale - Bloomington, IN - 5.0% ABV
Breckenridge Nitro Vanilla Porter - Breckenridge, CO - 4.7% ABV
Daredevil Liftoff IPA - Anderson, IN - 7.2% ABV
Dogfish Head 60 Minute IPA - Milton, DE - 6.0% ABV
Elysian Space Dust IPA - Seattle, WA - 8.2% ABV
Founders Brewing Rotating - Grand Rapids, MI
Goose Island 312 Wheat - Chicago, IL - 4.2% ABV
Greenbush Star Chicken Shotgun IPA - Sawyer, MI - 6.8% ABV
Kentucky Bourbon Barrel Ale - Lexington, KY - 8.2% ABV
Kentucky Vanilla Barrel Ale - Lexington, KY - 5.5% ABV
Lagunitas IPA - Petaluma, Ca - 6.2% ABV
Natural Liberty American Pale Ale - Indianapolis, IN - 5.4% ABV
New Belgium Fat Tire - Fort Collins, CO - 5.3% ABV
New Holland Dragons Milk Porter - Holland, MI - 11.0% ABV
Sun King Cream Ale - Indianapolis, IN - 5.3% ABV
Sun King Osiris Pale Ale - Indianapolis, IN - 5.6% ABV
Sun King Wee Mac Scottish Ale - Indianapolis, IN - 5.3% ABV
Taxman Deduction Belgian Dubbel - Bargersville, IN - 8.0% ABV
Taxman Exemption Belgian Trippel - Bargersville, IN - 8.5% ABV
Three Floyd's Rotating - Munster, IN
Quaff On Six Foot Blonde - Nashville, IN - 4.0% ABV
450 North Brewing Rotating - Columbus, IN
Browse Nearby
General Info
Cuisine
American - Traditional
Pizza
Meals
Lunch
Dinner
Hours
Monday:
7:00am - 9:30pm
Tuesday:
7:00am - 9:30pm
Wednesday:
7:00am - 9:30pm
Thursday:
7:00am - 9:30pm
Friday:
7:00am - 10:30pm
Saturday:
7:00am - 10:30pm
Sunday:
7:00am - 9:30pm
About Us
Welcome to the New Bethel Ordinary. Located in the heart of downtown Wanamaker, the Ordinary has grown to become a popular dining destination for people from all over Central Indiana. The Ordinary has always strived to maintain a small-town appeal, serving great food and drinks in a casual family friendly atmosphere. The Ordinary is open at 7:00 a.m. daily to serve you a full cooked-to-order breakfast. We offer daily lunch and dinner specials, as well as cost-friendly Kid's and Seniors menu. Friday and Saturday nights we still feature our 12 ounce grilled prime rib dinner. The signature item of the Ordinary is our Pizza. Try a 10 or 16 inch pizza, each made to order, using only the freshest ingredients and baked in our traditional style brick ovens. The pizza is available daily at 10:00 a.m. for dine-in or carry-out. In a hurry - these same great pizzas are now available for take and bake.