ham, turkey, cheese, & choice of dressing
wal-nutty chicken, tuna, ham & egg salad
Sandwiches
Tblt
"triple decker" turkey, bacon, cheese, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise (no half sandwich)
Hot Pepper Turkey
turkey, hot pepper jack cheese, honey mustard dressing, lettuce & tomato on toasted bread
Sweet Virginia Ham
"our special family recipe" sweet relish, lettuce,
tomato & mayonnaise
Club Coyle
"triple decker ham, turkey, cheese, lettuce, tomato
& mary's homemade 1000 island dressing
(no half sandwich)
Grilled Chicken Breast
low fat & no guilt. a tender grilled chicken breast served with fat free honey mustard dressing, lettuce, tomato, & monterey jack cheese. (no half sandwich)
Other Great Ones
all sandwiches served with a choice of potato salad macaroni salad, cottage cheese, or potato chips & a pickle spear. bread choices: white, whole wheat, marble rye, sour dough, kaiser roll, or sub roll.
french dip, roast beef, blt -"believe it or not" 12 strips of bacon!, fancy albacore tuna, cheeses: monterey jack, hot pepper jack american or all four above served with lettuce, tomato, & mayonnaise.
chili dog, 1/4 lb hot dog, baked ham, breast of turkey, two above served with lettuce, tomato, and mary's homemade 1000 island dressing. wall-nutty chicken salad, ham salad, egg salad
Specialties Of The House
The Jolly Green Giant
ho ho ho! laugh your way out of this one. mint chocolate chip & chocolate chip ice cream covered with marshmallow topping & a side of chocolate topping, sprinkled with chocolate chips. choose from these toppings: hot fudge, caramel, cherry, marshmallow, chocolate, pineapple, & fresh strawberries.
The Hill
a huge hill of ice cream. four full pounds, plus whipped cream. two toppings & nuts included. plenty for 5 people!
The Suicide
or is it murder? vanilla ice cream covered with caramel & marshmallow toppings, chocolate chip ice cream covered with hot fudge, & penuche nut ice cream covered with caramel, garnished with cashews, almonds, & pecans. topped with whipped cream & a cherry.
Incredible Shakes
if the best ice cream in the world really "shakes" you up, you'll love mary's incredibly creamy, incredibly thick, incredibly yummy milk shakes, in all flavors. they...well, incredible!
The Mountain
a veritable ice cream "mountain". seven full pounds, plus whipped cream. four toppings & nuts included. plenty for 10 people
Ice Cream Flavors
Ol' Favorites - "all The Timers"
16% Butterfat Ice Cream Made On The Premise
Our ice cream is Old Fashioned and still made here on our premises, the same way, with the same quality ingredients that was used on our opening day, back in 1951!
We're a family and we care. Because we're a family, the name we chose was our Mother's..."Mary." We hope you will remember "Mary Coyle."
It is the goal of our website to remin d you of all the good things we have at Mary Coyle Ol' Fashion Ice Cream and to remind you to come and visit us more often!
When you visit Mary Coyle's, you'll be treated just like you're a member of the family, and served delicious ice cream, sandwiches, soups and salads. Wonderful atmosphere, fun people and great prices!