What's wrong with this menu?
Coyle's
75 Howells Rd
Bay Shore, NY 11706
Uber
MORE PHOTOS
Main Menu
Ice Cream
Chocolate
Choc Brownie Nut Fudge
Choc Fudgee Wudgee
Chocolate Monster Mash
Vanilla Chocolate Chip
Crazy Vanilla
Chocolate Oreo
White Pistachio/Nuts
French Vanilla
Oreo Cookie
Coffee
Cherry Garcia
Pistachio Walnut
Banana
Banana Oreo
Chocolate Banana
Heath Bar Crunch
Strawberry Cheesecake
Raspberry Choc Chip
Rum Raisin
Maple Walnut
Mint Oreo Cookie
Bailys Irish Cream
Choc Raspberry Truffle
Sugar Free Coffee
Vanilla Cake Batter
Banana Peanut Butter
Chocolate Choc Chip
Chocolate Turtle Pecan
Chocolate Rocky Road
Vanilla
Cherry Vanilla
Choc Peanut Butter Fudge
Vanilla Peanut Butter Fudge
Vanilla Butterscotch
Vanilla Cookie Dough
Mocha Chip
Mississippi Mud
Vanilla Fudge
Pistachio Cherry
Chocolate Marshmallow
Banana Nut Fudge
Butter Pecan
Strawberry
Black Raspberry
Peaches N Cream
Orange Sherbet
Pralines N Cream
Mint Chocolate Chip
Moms Apple Pie
Kahlua Liqueur
Coconut Cream
Sugar Free Vanilla
Chocolate Cake Batter
Assorted Sorbet Flavors
Toppings
Toppings
wet walnuts, black cherries, red cherries, hershey syrup, hot fudge, hot caramel, strawberries, pineapple, dry peanuts, m and ms, reeses pieces, marshmallow, choc sprinkles, rainbow sprinkles, crunch, butterscotch, choc syrup, banana, gummy bears, gummy worms, sno caps, sweedish fish, sour fish, malted milk balls
Sundaes
all sundaes include your choice of ice cream, one toppings, whip cream, sprinkles or crunch and a cherry
Sundaes
- Super 5 Flavors $8.95
- Large 3 Flavors $6.50
- Medium 3 Flavors $5.50
- Small 2 Flavors $4.75
Banana Boat
$6.75
choose any three flavors of ice cream, add any three toppings, all placed on a whole sliced banana topped with lots of whip cream, sprinkles and a cherry
Waffle Bowl Sundae
$6.95
your choice of waffle bowl (nut, sprinkle or crunch)filled with any three flavors of ice cream and any two toppings, topped with lots of whip cream, sprinkles and a cherry
Waffle Cone Sundae
$4.95
your choice of waffle cone (nut, crunch, or sprinkles)filled with ant two flavors of ice cream and any one topping, topped with lots of whip cream, sprinkles and a cherry
Hot Fudge Brownie Sundae
$5.95
your choice of any three flavors of ice cream placed on a warm choc chip fudged brownie topped with lots of whip cream, sprinkles and a cherry
Hot Fudge Brownie Sundae
$5.95
your choice of any three flavors of ice cream placed on a warm choc chip fudged browie topped with lots whip cream, sprinkles and a cherry
Sticky Finger Sundae
$5.95
your choice of any three flavors of ice cream, filled with hot fudge, peanut butter sauce, reeses pieces and crunch, topped with lots of whip cream, sprinkles and a cherry
Afternoon Delight
$4.95
medium cup of yogurt, topped strawberries, sliced banana and whip cream
Blackout of 65
$5.95
fudgee widgee, rocky road and brownie nut fudge crunch and black cherries, topped with lots of whip cream and a cherry
Austin's Avelanche
$5.95
vanilla peanut butter fudge, cookie dough and oreo ice topped with lots of whip cream, sprinkles and a cherry
Buccaneer Blast
$5.95
vanilla, chocolate and Strawberry ice creams filled with pineapples strawberries, black cherries and chocolate sauce, topped with lots of whip cream, sprinkles and a cherry
Bayberry Breeze
$4.95
vanilla and orange sherbet blended with seltzer and syrup, topped off with a large scoop of vanilla ice cream
1950's Ice Cream Soda
$4.25
your choice of any flavor ice cream, vanilla or chocolate soda, blended with our own special cream and seltzer
Chocolate Monkey
$4.95
banana ice cream blended with our own special cream and chocolate sauce
Brown Cow
$4.25
root beer and Choc syrup blended with our own special cream and seltzer then floated with two scoops of premium hard vanilla ice cream
Ice Cream Shake
$4.95
choose any of our 48 flavors of ice cream blended with our own special cream creating your very own special shake
Shake Float
$5.50
choose any of our 48 flavors of ice cream blended with our own special cream, then floated with 2 scoops of ice cream
Yogurt Shake
$5.50
premium Colombo yogurt blended with own special cream
Sponge Bob Special
$3.25
soft serve ice cream filled with any one topping, whip cream, sprinkles and a cherry
Fresh Homemade Waffles
your choice of two flavors of ice cream and any two topping covered in whip cream, your choice of any three flavors and three toppings covered in whip cream
- Large $8.95
- Small $6.95
Small Waffle
$2.95
plain with maple syrup
Large Waffle
$4.95
plain with maple syrup
Smoothies/Cappaccino
$4.50
made with fresh fruit and fruit juices blended with ice cream creating smooth refreshing drink,
Brooklyn Egg Creams
- Large $2.50
- Small $1.75
Italian Ices
- Quart $5.95
- Pint $3.95
- Large $1.95
- Small $1.50
Specialty Ice Cream Cakes
20 flavor banana split cake, bailys Irish cream, Mississippi mud, brownie nut fudge and others
25 Flavor Party Platter
$24.95
choose your favorite 25 flavors-we place on a decorative platter, then drizzle with raspberry and Belgian chocolate sauce