What's wrong with this menu?
Costello's Pizzeria & Wings
U.S. 9
Smithville, NJ 08205
Uber
MORE PHOTOS
Main Menu
Open all Year! Mon-sun 11am-10pm
Appetizers & Sides
Bagetta Bruschetta
$6.69
Toasted Italian bread with chopped tomatoes, onions, & fresh basil bruschetta
- Add Melted Provolone Cheese
- $1.49
Jalapeño Poppers
Filled with Philadelphia Cream Cheese and served with a side of raspberry vinaigrette
- (6) $7.29
- (12) $13.49
- (24) $23.99
Buffalo Chicken Dip
$9.29
Served with tortilla chips
Chicken Fingers (5) & French Fries
$7.99
Served with your choice of honey mustard or BBQ dipping sauce
Shrimp in a Basket with French Fries
$7.99
Served with a side of cocktail sauce
Onion Rings
$4.69
Served with a side of ranch dressing
Mozzarella Sticks
Served with a side of homemade marinara sauce
- (6) $6.29
- (12) $12.49
- (24) $23.99
Fried Calamari
$9.29
Served with a lemon wedge & marinara sauce
Spinach and Artichoke Dip
$8.29
Served with tortilla chips
Mussels
(Red, White or Fra Diablo) Farm raised mussels served in your choice of homemade sauce
- (20) $8.99
Broccoli Cheddar Bites
Broccoli florets & cheddar cheese battered, fried, & served with a side of ranch
- (6) $4.79
- (12) $8.99
- (24) $15.99
Fresh Mozzarella & Tomato
$9.29
Slices of tomato & fresh mozzarella cheese with balsamic drizzle
Fries
Add Ons: Cheese $0.99 each (Mozzarella, American, Provolone, Swiss, Cheddar Cheese Sauce), Bacon $1.39, Jalapeño Peppers $0.99, Buffalo Wing Sauce $0.94, Red Sauce $0.59, Old Bay Seasoning $0.59
French Fries
$3.99Curly Fries
$4.19Waffle Fries
$4.79Sweet Potato Fries
$5.49Funnel Cake Fries
$5.49Legendary Buffalo-Style Chicken
Our Famous Mild Buffalo, Hot, Atomic, BBQ, or Honey BBQ. Add Ons: Celery $0.59 each, 1X Bleu Cheese $0.69, 2X Bleu Cheese $0.99, 3X Bleu Cheese $1.59, 4X Bleu Cheese $1.99, 1 Pint Bleu Cheese $3.99, 1X Sauce $0.69, 2X Sauce $0.99, ½ Pint Sauce $1.99, 1 Pint Sauce $3.99
Buffalo Wings
Chicken wings fried crispy & tossed in your choice of sauce
- 6 Pc w/ 1 Bleu Cheese $6.49
- 12 Pc w/ 1 Bleu Cheese $9.49
- 24 Pc w/ 2 Bleu Cheese $17.49
- 48 Pc w/ 4 Bleu Cheese $34.99
- 100 Pc w/ 2 Pints of Bleu Cheese $69.99
Buffalo Tails
Boneless chicken breast lightly floured, fried crispy, & tossed in your choice of sauce
- 6 Pc w/ 1 Bleu Cheese $7.49
- 12 Pc w/ 1 Bleu Cheese $13.99
- 24 Pc w/ 2 Bleu Cheese $24.99
- 48 Pc w/ 4 Bleu Cheese $47.99
- 100 Pc w/ 2 Pints of Bleu Cheese $84.99
Buffalo Ears
Breaded chicken fingers fried crispy & tossed in your choice of sauce
- 6 Pc w/ 1 Bleu Cheese $7.49
- 12 Pc w/ 1 Bleu Cheese $13.99
- 24 Pc w/ 2 Bleu Cheese $24.99
- 48 Pc w/ 4 Bleu Cheese $47.99
- 100 Pc w/ 2 Pints of Bleu Cheese $84.99
Salads
All salads are served with garlic knots & side of your choice of dressing. Creamy Italian, French, Russian, Ranch, Bleu Cheese, Honey Mustard, Creamy Balsamic, Oil & Vinegar, Caesar, Raspberry Vinaigrette. Add Ons: Grilled Chicken $3.99, Blackened Chicken $3.99, 3 Buffalo Tails $3.99, Breaded Chicken Cutlet $3.99, Crispy Chicken $3.99, 4 Grilled Shrimp $3.99, 4 Chilled Shrimp $3.99, Tuna Salad $2.99, Chicken Salad $2.99, Egg $1, Avocado $2
Garden Salad
$5.99
A bed of mixed greens topped with garden fresh tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, & green peppers
Caesar Salad
$6.79
Crisp romaine lettuce with homemade croutons, imported romano cheese, & side of creamy Caesar dressing
- Add Crab Meat
- $2.99
- Add Fried Calamari
- $2.99
Antipasto Salad
$8.99
Mixed greens, Genoa salami, capicola, pepperoni, provolone cheese, Italian olives, & fire roasted red peppers sprinkled with sharp provolone shavings
Chef's Salad
$8.99
Mixed greens, turkey slices, ham, American & provolone cheese, with tomatoes, cucumbers, & red onions
Buffalo Chicken Salad
$8.99
Three mild buffalo tails served over mixed greens with sharp provolone cheese & black olives
Crispy Chicken Salad
$8.29
Warm crispy chicken tenders with mandarin oranges, tomatoes, cucumbers, & black olives over mixed greens
Tuna Bruschetta Salad
$8.49
A bed of mixed greens topped with a scoop of tuna salad, a scoop of fresh tomato bruschetta, & slices of fresh mozzarella cheese
Blacken Chicken Bruschetta Salad
$8.99
A bed of mixed greens topped with grilled blackened chicken, a scoop of fresh tomato bruschetta, & slices of fresh mozzarella cheese
Spring Mix Salad
$8.79
Spring mix lettuce, sliced tomatoes, red onions, feta cheese, walnuts, & dried cranberries. Try with our raspberry vinaigrette dressing!
Cobb Salad
$8.99
Mixed greens with grilled chicken, bacon, hard-boiled egg, cucumbers, and tomatoes
Smithville Salad
$10.99
Chilled shrimp & crab meat over mixed greens with avocado, tomatoes, and old bay seasoning
Cold Subs & Wraps
Served on your choice of an Atlantic City 10" sub roll, flour or wheat tortilla. Add Ons: Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Sweet or Hot Peppers, Oil, Vinegar, Mayo, Seasonings. No additional charge. Cheese: Mozzarella, American, Provolone, Swiss $0.99 each
Regular Italian
$6.49
Capicola, Genoa salami, ham, & provolone cheese
Turkey
$6.49Ham
$5.49Genoa Salami
$5.49Tuna
$6.49Roast Beef
$6.49Capicola, Salami & Cheese
$6.49The Galloway Clubs
Served dry on your choice toast (White, Wheat, Or Rye)
Club I
$6.99
Roast beef, coleslaw, & Russian dressing with lettuce, tomato, & bacon
Club II
$6.99
Thinly sliced turkey breast with lettuce, tomato, & bacon
Club III
$7.99
Thinly chopped beef steak & melted American cheese with lettuce, tomato, & bacon
Club IV
$6.99
Our homemade tuna salad with lettuce, tomato, & bacon
Club V
$5.99
Bacon, lettuce, & tomato
Signature Subs & Wraps
Served on your choice of an Atlantic City 10" sub roll, flour or wheat tortilla. Add Ons: 1X Sauce $0.69, 2X Sauce $0.99, 1X Bleu Cheese $0.69, 2X Bleu Cheese $0.99, 3X Bleu Cheese $1.59
The Costello
$7.59
Genoa salami, prosciutto ham, fire roasted red peppers, provolone & extra virgin olive oil
The Guido
$8.29
Italian meats & cheeses, roasted red peppers, prosciutto ham, and imported sharp provolone cheese
The Godfather
$8.29
Chicken cutlet, breaded and golden brown, with spinach & melted sharp provolone cheese
- Add Roasted Peppers
- $0.99
The Fatty
$7.59
Grilled chicken steak mixed with our famous mild buffalo sauce & bleu cheese
- Add American Cheese
- $0.99
BBQ Chicken Sub
$7.59
Grilled chicken tossed in BBQ sauce, topped with crispy bacon & melted provolone cheese on a 10" Atlantic City sub roll
Grilled Chicken & Roasted Pepper Sub
$7.59
Grilled chicken breast, spinach, roasted red peppers, & melted provolone cheese
Turkey Reuben
$7.59
Sliced turkey breast, Russian dressing, coleslaw, & melted Swiss cheese served on rye toast
Honey Turkey Sandwich
$7.29
Sliced turkey breast, bacon, lettuce, tomato, honey mustard, & provolone cheese. Try as a wrap!
The Hail Caesar Wrap
$7.29
Grilled chicken breast, romaine lettuce, imported romano cheese, & creamy Caesar dressing served in a flour tortilla wrap
The Big Biff
$8.59
Philly steak, bacon, pepperoni, seasoned curly fries, & melted mozzarella cheese
Stockton Bomb
$8.59
Boneless buffalo tails, mozzarella sticks, French fries, & bleu cheese dressing
Buffalo Ranchero
$7.59
Crispy chicken tossed in mild buffalo sauce with lettuce, tomato, ranch dressing, & side of French fries. Try as a wrap!
Ranchero Wrap
$7.59
Crispy chicken, lettuce, tomato, American cheese & ranch dressing served in a flour tortilla wrap
Spring Mix Wrap
$7.59
Grilled chicken breast, spring mix lettuce, tomato & raspberry vinaigrette severed in a flour tortilla wrap
Buffalo Chicken Quesadilla
$7.59
Grilled chicken steak, our famous buffalo wing sauce & melted American cheese served with a side of bleu cheese
Tuna Melt
$7.59
Our homemade tuna salad, sliced tomato, with your choice of melted cheese & toast. Served with a side of French fries
Blue Devil
$7.29
Chicken steak, bacon, French fries, mild sauce, mozzarella & bleu cheese dressing
Hot Subs & Wraps
Served on your choice of an Atlantic City 10" sub roll, flour or wheat tortilla. Add Ons: Extra Cheese $0.99, Mushrooms $0.79, Green Peppers $0.79, Bacon $1.49, 1X Sauce $0.69, 2X Sauce $0.99
Cheesesteak
$6.99Chicken Cheesesteak
$6.99Pizza Steak
$7.29
Thinly chopped steak with our homemade red sauce & melted mozzarella cheese
Chicken Cordon Bleu
$7.29
Breaded chicken cutlet, ham, mushrooms, honey mustard, & melted Swiss cheese
Veggie Sub
$6.49
Sautéed broccoli florets, mushrooms, spinach, tomatoes, green peppers, & onions
- Add Your Choice of Cheese
- $0.99
- Add Grilled Chicken
- $2.99
Sausage, Peppers & Onions
$6.49Meatball Parmigiana
$6.49
Our homemade meatballs with red sauce & melted mozzarella cheese
Sausage Parmigiana
$6.49
Italian sausage with our homemade red sauce & melted mozzarella cheese
Chicken Parmigiana
$6.99
Breaded chicken cutlet with our homemade red sauce & melted mozzarella cheese
Eggplant Parmigiana
$6.49
Sliced breaded eggplant with our homemade red sauce & melted mozzarella cheese
Pasta
All entrees are served with soup or salad, your choice of pasta, & side of garlic knots. Capellini, Fettuccine, Linguini, Penne, Substitute Pasta with Sautéed Broccoli. Add Ons: Garlic Bread $3.99, Mozzarella Cheese $0.99, 3 Meatballs $3.99, Sausage $3.99
Basic Pasta
$10.99
Our homemade marinara, alfredo, vodka, or rosa sauce served over your choice of pasta
Pasta Meatball
$11.49
Our homemade meatballs & red sauce served over your choice of pasta
Eggplant Parmigiana
$10.99
Breaded eggplant with our homemade red sauce & melted mozzarella cheese served over your choice of pasta
Sicilian Baked Ziti
$10.99
Penne pasta baked with our homemade red sauce & mozzarella cheese
Pasta with Meat Sauce
$11.99
Our homemade meat sauce served over your choice of pasta
Pasta with Chicken & Broccoli
$14.49
Sautéed chicken and broccoli in our garlic & oil sauce with your choice of pasta
Pasta Alfredo with Chicken & Broccoli
$14.99
Your choice of pasta with grilled chicken & broccoli in an Alfredo sauce
Pasta Primavera
$13.99
Broccoli, carrots, green and red peppers in our garlic & oil sauce with your choice of pasta
- Add Sautéed Chicken
- $3.99
Ravioli
$11.99
(8) Cheese filled ravioli in our homemade red sauce
Pasta Mussels
$14.99
Mussels cooked in your choice of homemade sauce (red, white, or fra diablo) & served over your choice of pasta
Crab Meat & Vodka Sauce
$17.99
Crab meat in our homemade vodka sauce served over your choice of pasta
Pollo
All entrees are served with soup or salad, your choice of pasta, & side of garlic knots. Capellini, Fettuccine, Linguini, Penne, Substitute Pasta with Sautéed Broccoli
Chicken Parmigiana
$14.99
Breaded chicken cutlet with our homemade red sauce & melted mozzarella cheese served over your choice of pasta
Chicken Piccante
$14.99
Sautéed chicken in white wine, capers, peppers, & lemon slices served over your choice of pasta
Chicken Marsala
$14.99
Sautéed chicken in our homemade Marsala sauce & mushrooms served over your choice of pasta
Chicken Rosa
$14.99
Sautéed chicken in our homemade Rosa sauce with spinach & red peppers served over your choice of pasta
Chicken Francese
$14.99
Battered chicken in white wine & lemon slices served over your choice of pasta
Chicken & Vodka Sauce
$14.99
Sautéed chicken in our homemade vodka sauce served over your choice of pasta
Gourmet Pizza
Add Ons: 1X Sauce $0.69, 2X Sauce $0.99, 1X Bleu Cheese $0.69, 2X Bleu Cheese $0.99, 3X Bleu Cheese $1.59
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Grilled chicken smothered in our famous wing sauce, topped with mozzarella & a side of bleu cheese dressing
- 10" $9.29
- 14" $15.99
- 16" $16.99
Fuggeddaboudit Pizza
Pronounced (fa-ged-a-bout-it). Our traditional pie topped with pepperoni, sausage, onions, mushrooms, green peppers, black olives & extra cheese
- 10" $9.29
- 14" $15.99
- 16" $16.99
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Grilled chicken smothered in a hickory smoked BBQ sauce, topped with mozzarella & bacon. Served with a side of ranch
- 10" $9.29
- 14" $15.99
- 16" $16.99
Philadelphia Cheesesteak Pizza
Thinly chopped beef steak with fried onions, provolone & American cheese
- 10" $9.99
- 14" $16.99
- 16" $17.99
Da Veggie
An oil & garlic pie covered with slices of tomato, broccoli florets, spinach, button mushrooms, ricotta & mozzarella
- 10" $9.29
- 14" $15.99
- 16" $16.99
Pizza Palermo
Fresh plum tomato marinara sauce, mozzarella, provolone, grilled chicken, spinach & garlic roasted red peppers
- 16" $16.99
Pizza Italiano
Fresh plum tomato marinara sauce, mozzarella, Italian sausage, garlic & roasted red peppers
- 16" $16.99
Pizza Carini
Fresh plum marinara sauce, mozzarella, tomatoes, garlic roasted red peppers, onion, olive oil & basil
- 16" $15.99
Classic Tomato Pie
Fresh marinara sauce, olive oil & oregano
- 16" $11.99
Chicken Bacon Ranch
White pie with chicken, bacon, and ranch dressing
- 16" $17.49
Stockton Bomb Pizza
Served with a side of bleu cheese
- 10" $9.99
- 16" $17.99
Margherita Pizza
Fresh plum tomato marinara sauce, sliced mozzarella cheese topped with basil
- 16" $15.99
Meat Lovers Pizza
Our traditional red pie topped with pepperoni, sausage, and bacon
- 16" $17.49
Pizza
Regular Toppings - Pepperoni, Sausage, Mushrooms, Onions, Green Peppers, Black Olives, Hot Peppers, Sweet Peppers, Broccoli, Spinach, Tomato, Ricotta, Pineapple, Ham, Extra Cheese or Anchovies. Premium Toppings - Grilled Chicken, Meatballs, Roasted Red Peppers, Bruschetta or Bacon
Cheese
- 10" $8.49
- 14" $11.49
- 16" $12.49
- Sicilian $14.49
Oil & Garlic (White)
- 10" $8.49
- 14" $11.49
- 16" $12.49
- Sicilian $14.49
Additional Regular Toppings (Each)
- 10" $0.99
- 14" $1.99
- 16" $1.99
- Sicilian $2.99
Additional Premium Toppings (Each)
- 10" $1.99
- 14" $2.79
- 16" $2.99
- Sicilian $3.99
Calzone & Stromboli
Served with a side of our homemade red sauce. Add Ons: 1X Sauce $0.69, 2X Sauce $0.99, 1X Bleu Cheese $0.69, 2X Bleu Cheese $0.99, 3X Bleu Cheese $1.59
Regular Calzone
Fresh dough stuffed with mozzarella & ricotta, baked until golden brown. Served with a side of homemade red sauce
- Sm $7.99
- Lg $13.99
Steak Calzone
- Sm $8.99
- Lg $14.99
Chicken Calzone
- Sm $8.99
- Lg $14.99
Veggie Calzone
Spinach, onions, broccoli, mushrooms, tomato, green peppers, ricotta & mozzarella cheese
- Sm $8.99
- Lg $14.99
The Works
Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, & mozzarella cheese
- Sm $8.49
- Lg $14.99
Steak Stromboli
- Sm $8.99
- Lg $14.99
Chicken Stromboli
- Sm $8.99
- Lg $14.99
The "Fatty" Stromboli
Grilled chicken with our famous buffalo sauce & mozzarella cheese
- Sm $8.99
- Lg $14.99
Build Your Own Stromboli
Add any of our pizza toppings to create your own stromboli
- Sm $7.49
- Lg $13.49
- Additional Toppings (Sm)
- $0.99
- Additional Toppings (Lg)
- $1.99
- Additional Premium Toppings (Sm)
- $1.49
- Additional Premium Toppings (Lg)
- $2.49
Stockton Bomboli
Boneless buffalo tails, mozzarella sticks, French fries, & mozzarella cheese served with a side of bleu cheese dressing
- Sm $9.99
Burgers & Chicken Sandwiches
All burgers are 8oz. of lean ground beef, served on a Kaiser roll with a side of fries and cooked to your temperature choice
The Basic Burger
$7.49
Topped with lettuce, tomato, raw onion, & your choice of cheese (American, Swiss, mozzarella, or provolone)
Mushroom Swiss Burger
$7.99
Topped with fried onions, sautéed mushrooms, & melted Swiss cheese
Bleu Bacon Burger
$7.99
Topped with crispy bacon, bleu cheese dressing, & melted American cheese
Cheddar Bacon Burger
$7.99
Topped with bacon & melted cheddar cheese sauce
Pizza Burger
$7.99
Topped with homemade red sauce & melted mozzarella cheese
The Basic Chicken
$7.49
Grilled chicken breast with lettuce, tomato, onion, & your choice of cheese (American, Swiss, mozzarella, or provolone)
Grilled Chicken & Portobello Mushroom
$7.99
Grilled chicken breast with a sautéed Portobello mushroom, spinach, & melted provolone cheese
Bruschetta Chicken
$7.99
Grilled chicken breast topped with homemade tomato, basil and onion bruschetta & melted provolone cheese
Chicken Avocado
$8.99
Grilled chicken breast topped with avocado, bacon, tomato, & served with a side of ranch dressing
Kid's Menu
Mac & Cheese
$4.99
Kid's portion of penne pasta with our homemade cheese sauce
Pasta Meatball
$4.99
Penne pasta served with your choice of red or butter sauce, & (1) meatball
Ravioli
$4.99
(4) Cheese filled ravioli in our homemade red sauce
Hot Dog & French Fries
$3.99Chicken Fingers (3) and Fries
$5.99
Served with your choice of honey mustard or BBQ dipping sauce
Grilled Cheese
$4.99
Your choice of toast (white, wheat, or rye) with melted American cheese & side of French fries
- Add Tomato
- $0.49
- Add Bacon
- $1.49
- Add Ham
- $1.49
Browse Nearby
General Info
Payment Types
All Major Cards
Cuisine
Italian
Pizza
Sandwiches
Meals
Lunch
Dinner
Hours
Monday:
11:00am - 10:00pm
Tuesday:
11:00am - 10:00pm
Wednesday:
11:00am - 10:00pm
Thursday:
11:00am - 10:00pm
Friday:
11:00am - 10:00pm
Saturday:
11:00am - 10:00pm
Sunday:
11:00am - 10:00pm