X
What's wrong with this menu?

Successfully reported!
Powered by Tripadvisor

Brotherhood of Thieves

Call Menu Info
23 Broad St.
Nantucket, US-MA 02554
Uber
MORE PHOTOS
more menus
Main Menu
Drinks
Dessert
Happy Hour
Specials

Main Menu

Raw Bar

Oysters*

from nantucket
  • (each) $4.00

Shrimp Cocktail

giants
  • (each) $4.50

Soups + Appetizers

Clam Chowder

new england style
  • Cup $10.00
  • Bowl $12.00

French Onion Soup

$12.00
in a crock with melted cheese and house croutons

Boom Boom Shrimp

$20.00
crispy fried, sweet sriracha sauce, sesame seeds

Buffalo Caribbean Chicken Tenders

$18.00
mango-buffalo sauce, pineapple salsa, blue cheese dressing

Cheesesteak Egg Rolls

$18.00
american and provolone cheeses, caramelized onions, chinese mustard

Thai Chicken Lettuce Wraps

$18.00
roasted chicken, basil, carrots, cabbage, cilantro, peanuts, sesame-ginger vinaigrette

Tuna Wontons*

$20.00
diced bluefin, avocado, pickled ginger, seaweed salad and soy dressing, on togarashi spiced wontons

Nachos

$18.00
chicken tinga, jack cheese, guacamolio, black bean salsa, lime crema, pickled onions

Bistro Mussels

$18.00
garlic miso butter, parsley, white wine, grilled focaccia

Curly Fries

$9.00
classic or parmesan-truffle

Burgers*

on seeded brioche, with curly fries or greens

Brotherhood

$20.00
house tri-blend, l,t,o, cheese
  • Bacon
  • $2.00

Reverend Foster

$22.00
american cheese, caramelized onions, lettuce, special sauce

BBQ

$22.00
cheddar, bacon, bbq sauce, onion strings

Cisco

$22.00
blue cheese, caramelized onions, bacon, lettuce, balsamic

Veggie

$18.00
quinoa, sweet potato, black beans, mushrooms, pickled onion, avocado, cilantro crema

Sandwiches

with curly fries or greens

Grilled Chicken Caprese

$20.00
fresh mozzarella, arugula, pesto aioli, tomato jam, on toasted ciabatta

Fried Chicken

$20.00
buttermilk or nashville hot, sour pickles, lemon aioli, seeded brioche

Blackened Swordfish

$24.00
pickled veggies, arugula, cilantro, piri-piri sauce, sriracha aioli, seeded brioche

Lobster Rolls

with fries and cole slaw, on griddled brioche

Traditional

$38.00
celery, chive, lemon, mayo

Brown Butter

$38.00
warmed in brown butter

Entrées

Spicy Rigatoni

$28.00
panko-breaded chicken in a calabrian chili vodka cream sauce with pecorino romano

Chicken Picatta

$26.00
pan-fried chicken over fresh bucatini, with capers, parsley, lemon, pecorino, garlic wine sauce

Grilled Salmon*

$36.00
with roasted carrots, english peas, parsnip purée, lemon beurre blanc

Sole Meunière

$32.00
pan-fried, with lemon caper butter, mashed potatoes, sautéed green beans

Fish + Chips

$28.00
beer battered or lightly fried cod, with curly fries and cole slaw

Herb-Roasted Chicken

$26.00
half chicken with roasted garlic gravy, baby carrots, whipped mash

Steak Frites*

$38.00
grilled brandt farms ny strip, chimichurri, garlic aioli, parmesan-truffle curly fries

Braised Short Ribs

$38.00
red wine gravy, smoked gouda orzo mac, roasted broccoli, gremolata

Salads

add chicken $8, shrimp $14, salmon* $16, ny strip* $20, lobster $24

Poke Bowl*

$28.00
diced bluefin or salmon, rice, mango, cucumber, cabbage, cilantro, avocado, carrots, pineapple-ginger dressing

Maple Bourbon Glazed Salmon Wedge*

$28.00
little gem lettuce, blue cheese, cherry tomatoes, bacon, blue cheese dressing

Chicken Caesar

$24.00
regular or buffalo crispy chicken tenders, romaine, pecorino, house croutons

Almond Crusted Goat Cheese

$18.00
brûléed goat cheese tart, sun-dried cranberries, radish, candied pecans, little gem lettuce, cranberry vinaigrette

Chicken Cobb

$24.00
grilled chicken, romaine, arugula, avocado, corn, tomatoes, egg, bacon, blue cheese, champagne vinaigrette

Side Caesar or Fancy Simple House

$12.00

Desserts

Cranberry Bread Pudding

$12.00
soaked in cinnamon custard, served warm with vanilla ice cream

Death by Chocolate

$14.00
ooey gooey layered cake

Carrot Cake

$12.00
cream cheese frosting, pecans, caramel sauce, gluten free

Brohood Chocolate Chip Cookie Sundae

$14.00
in a cast iron skillet, with vanilla ice cream, whipped cream, chocolate sauce

Crème Brûlée

$12.00
custard topped with caramelized sugar

Lunch Selections

available Monday through Friday until 3:00 pm

Chicken Caesar Wrap

$18.00
crispy chicken tenders, regular or buffalo, romaine, pecorino, pickled red onions, creamy lemon dressing

Short Rib Melt

$21.00
braised short rib, pepadews, pimento cheese, on griddled bread

Salmon Super Crunch*

$24.00
grilled salmon, cabbage, chopped greens, quinoa, green apples, carrots, almonds, avocado, mint, orange-sesame vinaigrette

Pretzel Crusted Cod

$24.00
german potato salad, mustard aioli
*Consuming raw or uncooked meat, seafood or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness. Before placing your order, please inform your server if a person in your party has a food allergy
Tripadvisor logo
disclaimer: pricing and availability subject to change.
Terms of Service | Privacy Policy

Browse Nearby

General Info

23 Broad St.
Nantucket, US-MA 02554
774-325-5812
https://www.brotherhoodnantucket.com/
Map of Brotherhood of Thieves
Cuisine
Burgers
Sandwiches
Meals
Lunch
Dinner
Late Night

Hours

Monday:
11:30am - 9:00pm
Tuesday:
11:30am - 9:00pm
Wednesday:
11:30am - 10:00pm
Thursday:
11:30am - 10:00pm
Friday:
11:30am - 10:00pm
Saturday:
11:30am - 10:00pm
Sunday:
11:30am - 9:00pm

About Us

The name of this legendary local hangout - The Brotherhood of Thieves - is a nod to the title of an 1844 pamphlet written on Nantucket by Stephen S. Foster, in which Foster vigorously attacked those who continued to support the institution of slavery, even as the tide of abolition rose. Diversity and strong opinion have always found a tolerant home on this island. During the Revolutionary War, the Patriots, Tories, and Quaker pacifists coexisted here and unsuccessfully pleaded for neutrality. A unique spirit grew in Nantucket’s host environment committed to nurturing uncompromising independence, strength of character, and the fostering of a potent distillation of the early American genius. Exemplary of that is Benjamin Franklin, the son of Nantucketer Abiah Folger. That spirit provided fertile ground for women’s rights for Lucretia Mott, first president of the American Equal Rights Association, and Maria Mitchell, an American astronomer and a pioneer for women in science. Today, here on Nantucket, rugged individualism, personal liberty, and the fostering of eccentricity not only exist, but happily, continue to thrive – especially at the Brotherhood of Thieves!

See Us On

Foursquare Yelp