Deposit required on orders for cakes over 8". Fillings: Custard, Lemon, Strawberry, Blueberry, Rasberry, Chocolate; Fresh Fruit: Strawberries, Bananas, or Brown Derby (Strawberries, Bananas & Peaches); Cannoli Filling: Price is same as Fresh Fruit. Napoleon Cake: 1/4 Sheet $44.05, 1/2 Sheet $80.00, Full Sheet $176.10. Writing & Decorating 1/4 Sheet $3.70, 1/2 Sheet $7.20, Full Sheet $14.40 Drawings (only on 10 inch cakes or larger) $32.65. Cancelled Orders must have 24 hours notice
7" Cake
6-8 Serves
Butter Cream$26.80
Whipped Cream or Fudge$28.40
Fresh Fruit$9.70
Liqueur$9.70
Fondant$8.15
8" Cake
8-12 Serves
Butter Cream$38.45
Whipped Cream or Fudge$40.90
Fresh Fruit$10.45
Liqueur$10.45
Fondant$10.45
10" Cake
12-18 Serves
Butter Cream$60.55
Whipped Cream or Fudge$67.15
Fresh Fruit$15.25
Liqueur$15.25
Fondant$19.25
12" Cake
18-30 Serves
Butter Cream$86.90
Whipped Cream or Fudge$96.20
Fresh Fruit$21.00
Liqueur$22.75
Fondant$22.35
1/2 Sheet Cake
30-40 Serves
Butter Cream$98.20
Whipped Cream or Fudge$107.90
Fresh Fruit$21.35
Liqueur$26.95
Fondant$26.15
Full Sheet Cake
60-80 Serves
Butter Cream$193.80
Whipped Cream or Fudge$215.90
Fresh Fruit$40.80
Liqueur$56.70
Fondant$48.95
1/2 Bible
30-40 Serves
Butter Cream$107.80
Whipped Cream or Fudge$118.40
Fresh Fruit$21.35
Liqueur$26.95
Fondant$22.50
Full Bible
60-80 Serves
Butter Cream$213.50
Whipped Cream or Fudge$235.00
Fresh Fruit$40.80
Liqueur$37.50
Fondant$49.35
Ice Cream Cakes
7" Ice Cream Cake
$27.35
6-8 Serves
8" Ice Cream Cake
$36.60
8-12 Serves
10" Ice Cream Cake
$60.65
12-18 Serves
12" Ice Cream Cake
$86.15
18-30 Serves
1/2 Sheet Ice Cream Cake
$98.90
30-40 Serves
Full Sheet Ice Cream Cake
$195.10
60-80 Serves
Pastries, Cakes & Pies
Apple Blossom Cake
$26.50
Bavarian Cream Ring
$21.50
Blueberry Nut Ring
$21.50
Brown Derby Cake
Half$16.70
Full$33.50
Brownies
$1.25
Cannolis
Plain$3.85
Chocolate$4.50
Carrot Cake
$45.00
Cheese Cake
Plain$18.50
Cherry$21.50
Fresh Strawberry$25.00
Chocolate Mousse Cake
$25.00
Coconut Custard Pie
$26.00
Cupcake
$1.60
Éclairs
$3.35
Fruits of the Forest Pie
$28.75
Fruit Pies
$26.00
Apple, Blueberry, Cherry, Pumpkin (in season)
Fudge Mice
$3.00
German Chocolate Cake
$28.00
Key Lime Pie
$30.00
Layer Cakes
$25.00
Lemon Meringue Pie
$29.00
Napoleon
$3.90
Pecan Pie
$29.00
Pineapple Upside-Down Cake
$20.50
Rasberry Crumb Cake
$20.50
Rum Balls
$3.00
Seven Layer Cakes
$20.50
Sacher Torte
$28.00
Tropical Fruit Pies
$36.50
Whipped Cream Pies
$28.00
Chocolate, Coconut, Banana, Strawberry
Writing on Cake
$2.15
24 hours notice
Pies by the Slice
Snickers or Reese's
$5.75
Cookie Platters
3 Pound Platter
$38.50
Breads and Rolls
Babka
$17.05
Bagels
(each)$1.50
Continental Rolls
(each)$1.05
(per dozen)$12.10
Croissants
Plain$3.65
Almond Filled$5.35
Fruit Stollen
$23.00
Garlic Bread
$5.50
Hard Rolls
(each)$1.05
(per dozen)$12.10
Irish Soda Bread
$8.50
Italian Bread
$3.55
Pumpernickel
1 1/2 Lbs$7.70
Rye (Plain or Seeded)
$5.25
Sicilian
$3.55
Torpedo Rolls
(each)$1.05
(per dozen)$12.10
Yeast
(per pound)$4.00
White Bread
$4.70
Whole Wheat Bread
$6.05
Cookies, Danish & Cookies
Almond Horns
$4.50
Almond Tarts
$4.50
Rasberry-filled
Apple Turnovers
$2.95
Bear Cookie
$2.00
Black and Whites
$2.75
Butter Cookies
(per pound)$16.90
Chinese Chocolate Drop Cookie
$2.00
Chocolate Chip Cookie
$2.00
Coconut Macaroons
$2.00
Crumb Bun
$1.50
Danish
$3.00
Cherry, Cheese, Almond, Cinnamon
Donuts
$1.50
Jelly, Cake, Glazed, Bavarian Cream, French Cruller
Fruit Flips
$2.50
Blueberry, Cherry
Gingerbread Men
2/Pkg$3.00
Linzer Tart
$3.00
Muffins
$3.00
Blueberry, Bran, Corn, Lemon Poppyseed, Cranberry
Norwegian Cookies
One Pound$16.90
Pecan Ring
$13.95
Rasberry Sour Cream Pastry
$2.50
Rugula
(per pound)$16.90
Scone
$3.00
Smile Face Cookie
$2.00
Gourmet Cookies
(each)$0.80
3 For$2.15
Beverages
Coffee or Hot Tea
12 oz$1.55
16 oz$2.20
Cappuccino
12 oz$1.80
16 oz$3.00
Arizona Ice Tea
20 oz$2.85
Snapple
$2.85
Mott's Juice
$2.30
Milk
Pint$2.20
Quart$3.35
Half Gallon$4.40
Gallon$5.90
Chocolate Milk
Pint$2.20
Soda
20 oz$2.85
Gatorade
$3.15
Powerade
$3.15
Mash
$3.75
Calypso
$3.75
Joe's Ice Tea
$3.75
Pure Leaf Ice Tea
$3.75
Yoo-Hoo
$3.15
Water
$1.95
8 oz$1.25
Yellow Cottage Famous
Old Fashioned Root Beer
$2.85
Ginger Ale
$2.85
Orange
$2.85
Black Cherry
$2.85
Rasberry Lime Rickey
$2.85
Breakfast
Egg Sandwich
$3.00
Egg & Cheese
$3.75
Egg, Ham, Breakfast Potatoes & Cheese
$6.75
Egg & Sausage
$3.95
Egg, Sausage & Cheese
$5.25
Taylor Ham & Cheese
$6.00
Taylor Ham, Egg & Cheese
$6.75
Bacon, Egg & Cheese
$6.25
Bacon on a Roll
$4.50
Sausage & Cheese
$4.75
Breakfast Potatoes
$3.25
Muffins
$3.10
English Muffin
$1.55
Bagel
$1.50
Bagel with Butter
$2.55
Bagel with Cream Cheese
$3.25
Bagel with Veggie Cream Cheese
$3.85
Bagel with Cinnamon Walnut Cream Cheese
$3.90
Croissant
$3.75
Croissant with Butter
$3.95
Wedding Cake
Price Per Serving - $3.85. Choice of Cake: Vanilla or Chocolate. Choice of Filling: Raspberry, Pineapple, Lemon, Cherry, Strawberry, Bavarian Cream, Chocolate Pudding. Fresh Fruit Filling: Strawberries, Bananas or Brown Derby (combination of strawberries, bananas & peaches). Cannoli Filling: Same Price as Fresh Fruit. Choice of Icing: Buttercream, Chocolate Buttercream, Mocha Buttercream, Maple Buttercream
Holiday Hours
New Years Eve 8am-5pm
Temporarily closed January 1-21
About Us
Bakery & Deli has been in businessYellow Cottage has been part of the Sussex County community for over 30 years. Fresh baked breads, cakes, cookies, pies. Yellow Cottage has been part of the Sussex County community for over 30 years. Fresh baked breads, cakes, cookies, pies and pastries are always plentiful at our shop. Celebration cakes made to order for weddings, birthdays, anniversaries and corporate events. Our Deli sandwiches are generous! Add chips, a beverage and dessert-one stop to satisfy any size appetite.