Begin your custom creation with our homemade dough and fresh mozzarella. Choose from our red sauce, or white sauce. Choose your toppings from our list below. Half toppings will be charged at full price
Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Mushrooms, Garlic, Fresh Basil, Green Peppers, Pineapple, Jalapeños, Onions, Black Olives, Fresh Oregano, Pepperoncini, and Sliced Tomatoes
Canadian Bacon, Ham, Smoked Bacon, Sliced Meatballs, Ground Beef, Banana Peppers, Green Olives, Grilled Chicken, Double Mozzarella Cheese, Crumbled Feta Cheese, Cheddar Cheese, Anchovies, Veggie Mix, and Artichoke Hearts
No Substitutions, Please
pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, black olives, and green peppers
tomatoes, onions, green peppers, mushrooms, veggie mix, and garlic
pepperoni, sausage, sliced meatballs, bacon, and ham
white sauce, pepperoni, onions, tomatoes, ham, and black olives
BBQ Chicken Pizza
chicken, pineapple, onions, cilantro, jalapeños, and BBQ sauce
Ground beef, cheddar cheese, and onions. Then topped with shredded lettuce and diced tomatoes
served with side salad and garlic bread
Layers of pasta with a mix of cheeses, savory homemade meat sauce, and marinara sauce
Breaded chicken breast baked with mozzarella and marinara sauce, and served over spaghetti
Breaded eggplant baked with mozzarella and marinara sauce, and served over spaghetti
With your choice of Meatballs, Meat Sauce (Bolognese), Italian Sausage, or Mushrooms
Three pasta shells filled with Ricotta cheese and baked in fresh marinara sauce
Subs and Sandwiches
served with your choice of Homemade Potato Salad or Chips
Breaded chicken breast, marinara sauce and mozzarella
Homemade meatballs and marinara sauce covered with mozzarella on a fresh hoagie roll
Breaded eggplant, marinara sauce and mozzarella
(served on sliced Whole Wheat bread) Swiss, mozzarella, veggie mix, onions, and mushrooms
Home Made Desserts
Dessert of The Week
Please ask your server
Key Lime Pie
A classic local dessert with a touch of South American flavor
Beer & Wine
Sam Adams / Michelob Ultra / Land Shark / Coors Light / Miller Light / Killians Red / Budweiser / Bud Light / Yuengling
Upper Crust Pizza was originally founded in Marathon in 1980. Throughout the years Upper Crust Pizza has consistently provided outstanding food quality combined with excellent customer service, which has been recognized through multiple awards and commendations.
In October 2006 we moved to our new location at 37th street. The relocation process took over two years from concept to completion but it was worth the effort. Our new location is pleasant, welcoming, spacious, and most important, in full compliance with all the codes and regulations applicable to a food service establishment.
We are not associated to any franchise or chain of restaurants. This is an independent, family-owned and operated business and this is our only location in the Florida Keys.
We are not a fast food restaurant either. We make the main ingredients of our dishes daily from scratch, on the premises, and we carefully prepare all our menu items to order. These practices contribute to the consistent quality and freshness of our products.
The ambiance, the unsurpassed cleanliness, the attention to detail, the personal attention of the owners, and the quality of the food are conducive to a fine dining experience.