For over 20 years, Gib's Bagels has been serving up authentic, delicious New York style bagels right here in northern Colorado. We've been voted “best bagel” in Fort Collins for so many years it’s hard to keep track!. Our expertise in the preparation of authentic New York Style bagels is what makes a Gib’s bagel so delicious. Our bagels take 24 hours to prepare because of the several steps the dough must go through. If even one step is missed or fumbled, you will wind up with a bagel that can’t be served.