If you finish, we made a mistake! Corned Beef & Pastrami
The Rudy Reuben
$15.99
corned beef, pastrami, & cole slaw
Reuben Strudel
$15.99
corned beef and pastrami, melted Swiss and sauerkraut, baked in a pastry dough
Reuben Twins
$15.99
potato pancakes, served Reuben style
Reuben Dogs
$12.99
2 Sabrett hotdogs, topped Reuben style
The Open Faced Reuben
$19.99
This is the traditional way to serve a Reuben. Layers of corned beef, pastrami, turkey or any combination topped with a mound of sauerkraut and melted Swiss
The Mighty Reuben Burger*
$17.99
This should get us on TV! Yes fries come with it! and we dare you to finish the whole thing
Reuben Fries
$14.99
Topped with chopped corned beef, pastrami, sauerkraut & melted Swiss
Super Sized Sandwiches
Bread: New York Rye, Onion Pocket or whole wheat. Cheese: Swiss, Cheddar, American, Provolone or “Eddie” Muenster - $0.99; Any sandwich grilled - $1; Extra Lean - $1; Melt your cheese -- $2
Hot Corned Beef
We cook our own everyday!
$14.99
Add cole slaw and Russian Dressing$16.99
Hot Corned Beef and Pastrami Combo
$15.99
Hot Pastrami
A little spicy and always moist
$14.99
Add cole slaw and Russian dressing$16.99
Brisket of Beef
$15.99
Roasted Turkey
$14.99
Add cole slaw & Russian dressing$16.99
Turkey & Hot Pastrami
$16.99
Turkey, Bacon & Cheddar
$15.99
Roast Beef
Cooked in house and yes, it’s rare!
$14.99
Add cole slaw and Russian dressing$16.99
Tongue
$19.99
Center cut or tip. We can warm it if you like
Ham & Swiss
$11.99
Kosher Salami
$12.99
Chopped Liver
The flavor is in the schmaltz (chicken fat)
$12.99
Add a scoop to any sandwich$2.99
Solid White Albacore Tuna Fish
$11.99
The best tuna money can buy… Albacore tuna fish, mayo, celery and that’s it
Chicken Salad
$11.99
It’s so good because it’s so simple! Celery, kosher salt, pepper & mayo
Egg Salad
Eggs, mayo & salt
$8.99
With bacon$10.99
Shrimp Salad
$12.99
lightly seasoned
Mile High Club Sandwiches
All clubs served with potato salad, cole slaw, or pasta salad. Sub fries $2. (Membership does have its privileges.). Upgrade to first class, add a layer of cheese $0.99
B.L.T.
$14.99
The classic done the 58 way! It’s a triple decker and it’s all about the bacon
All American
$14.99
Turkey, ham, lettuce, tomato, lots of bacon and mayo
The Turk
$14.99
All turkey, lettuce, tomato, lots of bacon and mayo
Chicken Salad B.L.T.
$14.99
Chicken salad, bacon, lettuce, tomato
Main
The USS Sailor
$17.99
Your choice of Corned Beef, Pastrami, or both on rye bread topped with a split Knockwurst and Swiss. Anchors away!
Twin Spin
Two onion rolls filled with any meat or salad with potato salad, cole slaw, or pasta salad. *Onion rolls only
Two can dine for$21.99
Add cheese$1.00
Add Lettuce & Tomato$1.00
Classic American Grilled Cheese
Grilled American Cheese$5.99
With Bacon$6.99
With Bacon & Tomato$7.50
With Ham$6.99
With Taylor Pork Roll$6.99
Served with chips or sub fries$2.00
Triple D
$19.99
This is a Triple Decker served on rye only with a layer of roast beef, turkey, cole slaw, Russian dressing and corned beef
Big Stosh Super Nosh
Nova or salty lox, whitefish piece, kippered salmon piece, garnish and two bagels with plain or scallion cream cheese
For 2 or more only(per person)$19.99
58 Deli Meat Platters
$21.99
Corned Beef, Pastrami, Turkey or Roast Beef. Served with potato salad, cole slaw or pasta salad, with rye bread. Mix & match any meats or salads (3 choices)
Sabrett Hot Dogs and Knockwurst
Deli Dogs
2 hot dogs covered with chopped corned beef & pastrami. Served with cole slaw, pasta salad or potato salad
$12.99
Sub fries$2.00
Hot Dog
$3.75
Our all beef natural casing. Dogs are longer then our buns! Top it With: Sabrett Red Onion Sauce, mustard, onion, chili, relish, cole slaw or kraut
2 Knockwurst
$12.99
(specials) served grilled or boiled with baked beans or crinkle cut fries, rye bread and butter
The “Dumbrowski”
$12.99
2 hot dogs, crinkle cut fries, and a Dr. Brown’s soda
Muenster Size Portions
Add bread to the bottom for a buck!
The Open Faced Reuben
$19.99
This is the traditional way to serve a Reuben. Layers of corned beef, pastrami, turkey or any combination topped with a mound of sauerkraut and melted Swiss
Philly Style Open Faced
$19.99
Layers of corned beef, pastrami, turkey or any combination covered with creamy cole slaw and homemade Russian dressing
Open Faced Tuna
$12.99
Grilled rye, tuna, and melted cheese (Jeff’s Tip: Go with the Muenster cheese)
Diner Dishes
Benny’s Beef Brisket Platter
$19.99
Brisket topped with brown gravy, two potato pancakes, rye bread and butter
Stuffed Cabbage Rolls
$19.99
Served with mashed potatoes, rye bread and butter
Oscar’s Garbage Bowl
$17.99
Hot roast beef, turkey or beef brisket served with grilled onions topped with a mound of crinkle cut fries and smothered in brown gravy. (It’s a Jersey thing. Must we analyze everything?)
Char-Grilled Burgers
We don’t do anything small… Served with lettuce, tomato, onion, crinkle cut fries & pickle
Cheeseburger Deluxe*
Served with lettuce, tomato & onion
$12.99
With bacon$14.99
The 58 Pastrami Burger*
$15.99
Full 1lb. pastrami burger topped with melted Swiss
Classic Patty Melt*
$12.99
Grilled rye, American cheese & grilled onions
The Mighty Reuben Burger*
$17.99
Look at it…What more do you need to know?? Yes, fries come with it! and we dare you to finish the whole thing
Chicken Shack
Served with lettuce, tomato, onion, crinkle cut fries and a pickle
Grilled Chicken Breast
$12.99
Grilled Chicken Breast B.L.T.
$14.99
Basket of Chicken Tenders & fries
$10.99
Smoked Fish From New York
All platters include tomato, onion, cucumber, olives, bagel and your choice of plain or scallion cream cheese
Nova Platter
$15.99
Salty lox Platter
$15.99
Whitefish (Piece) Platter
$16.99
Whitefish Salad Platter
$14.99
Kippered Salmon Piece
$17.99
Smoked Fish Sandwiches
served on a bagel. Bagel with Cream Cheese. $2.99; Bagel with Scallion Cream Cheese. $3.25
Nova
$12.99
Salty Lox
$12.99
Whitefish Salad
$10.99
The Kid’s Corner
All kid’s meals are served with milk or a fountain drink, chips or applesauce, and a black & white cookie
Grilled Cheese
$6.99
Hot Dog
$6.99
Chicken Tenders
$6.99
Small Turkey or Pastrami Sandwich
$6.99
Sides
Potato Salad
$2.99
Cole Slaw
$2.99
Pasta Salad
$2.99
Barrel Cured Kraut
$1.99
Pickled Tomatoes
$1.99
Baked Beans
$3.99
Potato Pancakes
$7.99
Let’s Get Fried
Basket of Crinkle Cut Frie
$3.99
Jersey Gravy Fries
$6.99
Cheese Fries
$6.99
Bacon Cheese Fries
$9.99
Chili Cheese Fries
$9.99
Disco Fries
$9.99
Brown gravy & melted provolone
Reuben Fries
$14.99
Topped with chopped corned beef, pastrami, sauerkraut & melted Swiss
Jumbo Onion Rings
$5.99
Desserts
7 Layer Cake
Lemon Coconut Cake
5th Avenue Pie
Carrot Tower Cake
Chocolate Tower Cake
Lemon Meringue Pie
Rugulah
Black and White Cookies
Rice Pudding every Friday
Cheesecake
Plain Cheesecake
Strawberry Cheesecake
Marble Cheesecake
Chocolate Cheesecake
Chocolate Truffle Cheesecake
Cherry Cheesecake
Blueberry Cheesecake
Sides
Deli Sides
Potato Salad
$2.99
Cole Slaw
$2.99
Pasta Salad
$2.99
Barrel Cured Kraut
$1.99
Pickled Tomatoes
$1.99
Baked Beans
$3.99
Potato Pancakes
$7.99
Let’s Get Fried
Basket of Crinkle Cut Fries
$3.99
Jersey Gravy Fries
$6.99
Cheese Fries
$6.99
Bacon Cheese Fries
$9.99
Chili Cheese Fries
$9.99
Disco Fries
$9.99
Brown gravy & melted provolone
Reuben Fries
$14.99
Topped with chopped corned beef, pastrami, sauerkraut & melted Swiss
Jumbo Onion Rings
$5.99
*Contains (or may contain) raw or under cooked ingredients
Livingston, New Jersey…. if there was ever a Mayberry, this was it. Born in 1958, most of my memories growing up revolved around food from as far back as I can remember…. Sunday mornings with Dad at Tabatchnicks picking up deli and my father poking me in the arm urging me to watch the old man behind the fish counter hand slice the nova so thin you could see through it….I also remember sitting next to the bread slicer in eager anticipation so that when they sliced a rye bread, one of the counter men would give me the heel to nibble on, as a kid, what could be better?