What's wrong with this menu?
The Good Batch
936 Fulton St.
Brooklyn, NY 11238
Uber
MORE PHOTOS
Main Menu
Add Handwritten Card $5
Cookies
Signature Cookie Sampler
$24.00
Enjoy a sampler box of our Signature Cookies. Each cookie type is sealed in a 2-pack to preserve freshness and prevent flavor mingling. The bundle includes 6 varieties for a total of one dozen cookies. (2) Brown Butter Salty Cookie, (2) Oat Chocolate Chunk Cookie, (2) Ginger Molasses Cookie, (2) Chunky Peanut Butter Cookie (vegan), (2) Chocolate Fudge Cookie, (2) Cookie of the Month
Stroopwafel
$24.00
Anna's stroopwafel recipe is what founded The Good Batch, back in 2010. Chewy caramel-filled waffle cookie with a house blend of spices. Each waffle is hand-pressed, sliced open and filled with a buttery caramel. At room temperature, the cookie is chewy and incredibly addictive, and when placed over a cup of your favorite steaming beverage, the caramel melts making the waffle gooey and even more delicious. We recommend trying it both ways! Order includes one dozen cookies. Ingredients: enriched wheat flour (niacin, reduced iron, thiamine mononitrate, riboflavin, folic acid), butter, brown sugar, sugar, corn syrup, wheat glucose, heavy cream, eggs, vanilla extract, spices, salt, cream of tartar
Goodwich Ice Cream Sandwich
$20.00
An aromatic and wonderfully textured fresh ginger and molasses cookie. Our dough is loaded with cold-pressed ginger juice and rolled in sugar before baking, resulting in a soft, incredibly flavorful cookie. Pairs perfectly with a hot cup of tea. This cookie was the inspiration behind our collaboration with Haagen-Dazs for the Ginger Molasses Cookie Ice Cream, as part of their Artisan Collection. Order includes one dozen cookies. Ingredients: enriched wheat flour (niacin, reduced iron, thiamine mononitrate, riboflavin, folic acid) brown sugar, sugar, butter, molasses, eggs, vanilla extract, fresh ginger, ground ginger, cinnamon, allspice, cloves, evaporated cane juice, salt
"Anna's Favorites" Sweet Bundle
$60.00
This bundle includes 6 Bars, 12 Signature Cookies, 6 Gourmet Sandwich Cookies.Product Details, (3) Gooey Everything Bar, (3) Gluten-Free Brooklyn Brownie, (6) Brown Butter Salty Cookie, (6) Oat Chocolate Chunk, (3) Flourless Chocolate Pecan Sandwich Cookie, (3) The Good Batch Macaroon Sandwich Cookie
Chunky Peanut Butter Cookie
$20.00
We developed this cookie to satisfy our vegan customers and our own love of all things peanut butter. This cookie is loaded with natural peanut butter and chopped roasted peanuts, and topped with the perfect dash of sea salt. We use applesauce to keep the cookie soft and moist, which results in a perfect texture. Order includes one dozen cookies. Ingredients: enriched wheat flour (niacin, reduced iron, thiamine mononitrate, riboflavin, folic acid), applesauce, peanuts, oats, canola oil, evaporated cane juice, brown sugar, vanilla, baking powder, salt
vegan
Brown Butter Salty Cookie
$20.00
Incredibly addictive shortbread cookie made with brown butter, unrefined cane sugar and topped with sea salt. Ideal as an afternoon snack with your favorite tea or as a post-dinner dessert. Order includes one dozen cookies. Ingredients: enriched wheat flour (niacin, reduced iron, thiamine mononitrate, riboflavin, folic acid), turbinado sugar (evaporated cane juice), sugar, butter, egg, vanilla, baking powder, salt
Chocolate Lovers Gift Box
$50.00
Curated with our favorite cocoa treats, this bundle is guaranteed to delight all chocolate lovers on your list. This gift set includes 21 generously sized treats. Each set of cookies is individually sealed to prolong freshness and prevent flavor mingling. Product Details: (6) Brownies, (6) Oat Chocolate Chunk Cookies, (6) Chocolate Fudge Cookies, (3) Flourless Chocolate Pecan Sandwich Cookies (Gluten Free)
Oat Chocolate Chunk Cookie
$20.00
An irresistible oat cookie loaded with Belgian milk and dark chocolate chunks, and topped with sea salt. This is the ideal cookie for a lover of the sweet and salty combination. Each cookie is a hearty morsel. They are great as an afternoon snack (or second breakfast!), and make a lovely alternative to the classic chocolate chip cookie. Order includes one dozen cookies. Ingredients: enriched wheat flour (niacin, reduced iron, thiamine mononitrate, riboflavin, folic acid), oat, sugar, butter, dark chocolate (unsweetened chocolate, sugar, cocoa fat, soy lecithin, natural vanilla flavor), milk chocolate (sugar, cocoa fat, dry whole milk, unsweetened chocolate, soy lecithin, natural vanilla flavor, salt), egg, baking powder, salt, espresso powder, cocoa powder
Brooklyn Brownie
$20.00
This brownie is everything. The chocolate flavor is intensely rich, yet balanced with the perfect level of sweetness. The texture is both chewy AND cakey, and we've studded it with chunks of dark Belgian chocolate to up ante even more. It's also deceitfully gluten-free, so all sweet tooths can enjoy! Each bar is individually sealed to preserve freshness. One order contains 6 bars. Ingredients: butter, canola oil, unsweetened bakers chocolate, sugar, eggs, vanilla extract, espresso, rice flour, xantham gum, salt, baking powder, chocolate chunks (unsweetened chocolate, sugar, cocoa fat, soy lecithin, natural vanilla flavor) Please Note: The Brooklyn Brownie does not contain any wheat products. Please note that we are NOT a certified gluten-free kitchen, and although we take precautions to keep and bake our wheat-free products separate, there is still flour in the facility. We advise those with a severe wheat allergy or celiac to keep this in mind
gluten-free
Gooey Everything Bar
$24.00
Hands down one of our best sellers at the bakery. This bar is a heavy hitter and should be taken seriously. We tasked ourselves with developing a fun layered bar that embodied The Good Batch, and we managed to fit seven distinct flavors and textures in, resulting in perhaps our most sensational creation. Each bar is approximately 3″ x 3″, which can easily be divided into satisfying bite-sized pieces to share…or enjoyed as a whole. Sharing is optional, afterall! A Brown Butter Salty shortbread is topped with caramel, chocolate chips, toasted coconut, toffee bits, toasted almonds, flaky sea salt. Each bar is individually sealed to preserve freshness. One order contains 6 bars. Ingredients: enriched wheat flour (niacin, reduced iron, thiamine mononitrate, riboflavin, folic acid), turbinado sugar (evaporated cane juice), sugar, butter, cream, almonds, milk, milk chocolate (milk chocolate contains: sugar, milk ingredients, cocoa butter, unsweetened chocolate, lactose, soy lecithin, artificial flavour), glucose, coocnut, egg, vanilla, baking powder, salt
Gourmet Sandwich Cookie Sampler
$38.00
Coconut Macaroon Ingredients: Unsweetened shredded coconut, almond flour, butter, milk chocolate (sugar, cocoa fat, dry whole milk, unsweetened chocolate, soy lecithin, natural vanilla flavor, salt), sugar, egg white, cream, vanilla, salt. Flourless Chocolate Pecan Ingredients: Cocoa powder, milk chocolate (sugar, cocoa fat, dry whole milk, unsweetened chocolate, soy lecithin, natural vanilla flavor, salt), sugar, cream, toasted pecan, cornstarch, egg white, vanilla, salt. Product Details: Each cookie is approximately 3" in diameter. All sandwiches cookies listed here do not contain any wheat products. Please note that we are not a certified Gluten-Free kitchen, and although we take precautions to keep and bake our wheat-free products separate, there is still flour in the facility. We advise those with a severe wheat allergy or celiac to keep this in mind
gluten-free
Cookie Subscription
We bundle cookies by the dozen, so you can select how many dozen you'd like sent each month. The flavors will change every month, featuring our core flavors as well as seasonal specials. When ordering, please specify if recipient has any allergies. We will accommodate nut and chocolate allergies, however please note that at this time we only have a limited assortment for gluten allergies. Product Details: Cookies are sent by the dozen. Select how many Dozen per Month you'd like sent. Shipping will be calculated at checkout. You can cancel your subscription at any time
- (month) $20.00
The Good Batch Coconut Macaroon Sandwich Cookie
$38.00
This bundle includes one dozen cookies. Ingredients: Cocoa powder, milk chocolate (sugar, cocoa fat, dry whole milk, unsweetened chocolate, soy lecithin, natural vanilla flavor, salt), sugar, cream, toasted pecan, cornstarch, egg white, vanilla, salt. Product Details: Each cookie is approximately 3" in diameter. Does not contain any wheat products. Please note that we are not a certified Gluten-Free kitchen, and although we take precautions to keep and bake our wheat-free products separate, there is still flour in the facility. We advise those with a severe wheat allergy or celiac to keep this in mind
gluten-free
Cookie Monster Box
$120.00
A collection of our favorite cookies, wonderfully bundled up for you. Makes the perfect gift for a large group of cookie lovers. Order includes 12 stroopwafels and 72 cookies. Stroopwafel (1 dozen), Oat Chocolate Chunk (1 dozen), Brown Butter Salty (1 dozen), Chocolate Fudge (1 dozen), Chunky Peanut Butter (1 dozen), Ginger Molasses (1 dozen), Cookie of the Month (1 dozen)
Ginger Molasses Cookie
$20.00
Perfectly textured, perfectly spiced. An aromatic and wonderfully textured fresh ginger and molasses cookie. Our dough is loaded with cold-pressed ginger juice and rolled in sugar before baking, resulting in a soft, incredibly flavorful cookie. Pairs perfectly with a hot cup of tea. This cookie was the inspiration behind our collaboration with Haagen-Dazs for the Ginger Molasses Cookie Ice Cream, as part of their Artisan Collection. Order includes one dozen cookies. Ingredients: enriched wheat flour (niacin, reduced iron, thiamine mononitrate, riboflavin, folic acid) brown sugar, sugar, butter, molasses, eggs, vanilla extract, fresh ginger, ground ginger, cinnamon, allspice, cloves, evaporated cane juice, salt
Flourless Chocolate Pecan Sandwich Cookie
$38.00
Two rich, flourless chocolate cookies sandwich a hearty dollop of a chewy milk chocolate pecan caramel. The best way to describe this creation is a cross between a dark, decadent chocolate cookie and a chewy caramel candy bar. It's the absolute best of both confectionary worlds. Each cookie is approximately 3″ in diameter and weighs 2.5 ounces resulting in a very satisfying portion. This sandwich cookie pairs great with a strong cup of coffee or a tall glass of milk. This bundle includes one dozen cookies. Ingredients: Cocoa powder, milk chocolate (sugar, cocoa fat, dry whole milk, unsweetened chocolate, soy lecithin, natural vanilla flavor, salt), sugar, cream, toasted pecan, cornstarch, egg white, vanilla, salt
gluten-free
Cakes
Cakes Are Available for in-store Pickup Only
Build Your Own Birthday Layer Cake
- 6" cake (3 layers, serves 4-8) $32.00
- 9" cake (4 layers, serves 10-16) $45.00
- 12" cake (4 layers, serves 18-40) $75.00
Peanut Butter Pretzel Layer Cake
Peanut Butter + Pretzels + Ganache. This cake is perfect for people who love decadence, a little bit of salt with their sweet, and a very special dessert. Our chocolate devil's food cake is slathered with a creamy peanut butter buttercream and coated with a smooth and rich bittersweet ganache. We encase the cake in a pretzel and sea salt crumble. It's absolutely divine
- 6" cake (3 layers, serves 4-8) $37.00
- 9" cake (4 layers, serves 10-16) $55.00
- 12" cake (4 layers, serves 18-40) $100.00
Brown Butter Salty Layer Cake
This cake is the perfect balance of rich, salty and sweet. Our white velvet cake is layered with house made caramel and brown butter buttercream and then topped with a crunchy crumble made from our Brown Butter Salty cookies
- 6" cake (3 layers, serves 4-8) $37.00
- 9" cake (4 layers, serves 10-16) $55.00
- 12" cake (4 layers, serves 18-40) $100.00
Cookies, Cookies and Cream Layer Cake
Chocolate Cake + Cookie Crumb Buttercream + Chocolate Chip Cookie Crumbs. This cake has a little bit of everything…we take our rich chocolate devil's food cake and layer it with vanilla buttercream laced with our chocolate cookie crumbs, then finish the entire cake with a chocolate ganache drip and crumbs of our freshly baked chocolate chip cookies
- 6" cake (3 layers, serves 4-8) $37.00
- 9" cake (4 layers, serves 10-16) $55.00
- 12" cake (4 layers, serves 18-40) $100.00
Summer Special – Strawberry Lemon Lime Layer Cake
Vanilla + Strawberries + Lemon Lime. This cake is all the thing summer is made of – layers of fluffy white velvet cake soaked in a fresh lemon lime syrup and filled with strawberry buttercream. The whole thing is topped with fresh strawberries and candied lemon and lime zest. Nice and sweet with just the right about of citrus-y zing!
- 6" cake (3 layers, serves 4-8) $37.00
- 9" cake (4 layers, serves 10-16) $55.00
- 12" cake (4 layers, serves 18-40) $100.00
Chocolate Caramel Layer Cake
One of our best-sellers. Each layer of the fluffy chocolate devil's food cake is coated with caramel sauce before being stacked with our creamy salted caramel buttercream. The fully frosted cake is topped with a rich dripping layer of dark chocolate ganache, which is both dramatically beautiful and delicious. The top is finished with a ring of chocolate sprinkles. This is truly a crowd pleaser!
- 6" cake (3 layers, serves 4-8) $37.00
- 9" cake (4 layers, serves 10-16) $55.00
- 12" cake (4 layers, serves 18-40) $100.00
Merch
Baker Baggu
$20.00
The perfect everyday bag for the everyday baker. We spent a lot of time crafting this product because we wanted it to be extremely high quality and thoughtfully designed, just like our baked goods. BAGGU makes beautifully functional bags and accessories, and The Good Batch founder Anna Gordon happens to be a humungous fan of the brand. With various snaps and handles, the bag can be worn across the body (great for biking and traveling), off the shoulder, or by the short handle, looking like the chic baker that you are. Product Details: Text colors: White / Metallic Gold, Dimensions: 16″ high, 10″ wide, 5.5″ deep, Matte silver hardware, durable taped seams, and a round inner pocket, 16oz recycled cotton canvas "DUCK" bag by Baggu, Bag message: "flour, butter, sugar, love, oats, chocolate, brooklyn, vanilla, salt", Made in the U.S.A
The Good Batch Mug
$9.00
Enjoy your coffee with style. Our teal ceramic diner mug makes for a beautiful sip. We use these mugs at the bakery, and now you can enjoy them at home! Dishwasher safe. Product Details: Text colors: White / Metallic Gold, Dimensions: 16″ high, 10″ wide, 5.5″ deep, Matte silver hardware, durable taped seams, and a round inner pocket, 16oz recycled cotton canvas "DUCK" bag by Baggu, Bag message: "flour, butter, sugar, love, oats, chocolate, brooklyn, vanilla, salt", Made in the U.S.A
Granola & Nuts
Sweet & Spicy Sriracha Nuts
$16.00
Joyfully spicy, perfectly sweet and highly addictive. Our Sweet & Spicy nuts make the perfect gourmet snack. Pumpkin seeds, cashews, walnuts and almonds are baked with a brown sugar blend of cinnamon, cayanne pepper and sriracha hot sauce. The nuts are contained in a 32 oz. glass Ball jar, which can be reused for anything your heart desires. Order includes 12 ounces of nuts contained in a single jar. Ingredients: almonds, pumpkin seeds, walnuts, cashews, sugar, brown sugar, egg whites, sriracha (chili, sugar, salt, garlic, distilled vinegar, potassium sorbate, sodium bisulfite, xanthan gum), cinnamon, cayenne, salt
The Good Batch Granola
$14.00
The perfect amount of sweet and crunchy. We adore our granola. It's the perfect amount of sweet, thanks to a touch of honey and Vermont maple syrup, and the oat, toasted almonds and pumpkin seeds contribute a wonderful crunchy texture. We serve it with our Ronnybrook yogurt parfaits at the bakery, but we also love sprinkling it over ice cream, muffins, and straight into our mouths. Order includes 16 ounces of granola contained in a single jar. Ingredients: almonds, pumpkin seeds, oats, honey, maple syrup, light brown sugar, cinnamon, vanilla extract, salt
Ice Cream Sandwiches
Ice cream sandwiches are available for in-store pickup only
Goodwich Ice Cream Sandwich
The Goodwich is our original ice cream cookie sandwich. Made with our sea salt-sprinkled Oat Chocolate Chunk cookies, Blue Marble's creamy vanilla ice cream, and a thick drizzle of dark chocolate fudge. Crunchy, creamy, salty, sweet, this ice cream sandwich is the perfectly composed dessert. Each sandwich is approximately 6 ounces with a 4.5″ diameter
- Half dozen $42.00
- Good batch dozen - 14 for the price of 12 $84.00
Mini Birthday Cake Ice Cream Sandwich
These mini ice cream sandwiches are the perfect birthday celebration dessert. Ideal for kids, adults, grandparents, and everyone in between, each sandwich is a sweet little size that can be gobbled up in just a few bites. Rainbow confetti sugar cookies sandwich Blue Marble vanilla ice cream coated in rainbow sprinkles and a generous piping of our chocolate buttercream. Each sandwich is approximately 4 ounces with a 3″ diameter
- Half dozen $30.00
- Good batch dozen - 14 for the price of 12 $60.00
The Crispy Ice Cream Sandwich
House made caramel folded into rice crispy treat cookies and Blue Marble's creamy vanilla ice cream. Rich, creamy and crispy…a nod to your favorite childhood treat stepped up a few notches. Each sandwich is approximately 6 ounces with a 4.5″ diameter
- Half dozen $42.00
- Good batch dozen - 14 for the price of 12 $84.00
Mint Brownie Magic Ice Cream Sandwich
Gluten-free, gooey brownie cookies layered with dark chocolate, dark chocolate chips and creamy Blue Marble mint ice cream. Each sandwich is approximately 6 ounces with a 4.5″ diameter
- Half dozen $42.00
- Good batch dozen - 14 for the price of 12 $84.00
Ice Cream Sandwich Sampler
Can't decide on one flavor? Get them all! The Ice Cream Sandwich Cookie Sampler features a Good Batch dozen (14) of our delectable ice cream sandwiches. (4) Goodwich, (4) Crispy, (3) Mint Brownie Magic, (3) Birthday Cake. Each sandwich is approximately 6 ounces with a 4.5″ diameter
- Good batch dozen - 14 for the price of 12 $84.00