What's wrong with this menu?
Sugar Island Cupcakes & Bakery
5575 A1A South
Saint Augustine, FL 32080
Uber
MORE PHOTOS
Main Menu
Cupcakes
Classic Chocolate
Chocolate Cake w/ Chocolate butter cream frosting
Reese's Peanut Butter Cup
Chocolate Cake w/ Peanut butter cream frosting (topped with Reese's cup)
Bacon
Vanilla Maple Cake w/ Maple butter cream frosting (topped w/ Maple Bacon)
Pretty N Pink
Strawberry Cake w/ Pink Vanilla butter cream frosting
Red Velvet
Chocolate Cake w/ cream cheese frosting
Wedding Bliss
White Cake w/ White butter cream frosting
Coconut Dream
Vanilla Cake w/ Coconut butter cream frosting
Margaritaville
Lemon Cake w/ Lime butter cream frosting topped with lime and an umbrella
S'mores
Graham Cracker & Chocolate Cake stuffed with Marshmallow w/ vanilla butter cream frosting
Sand Dollar
Vanilla cake stuffed with chocolate fudge topped Chocolate fudge frosting with white sprinkles
Strawberry Cheesecake
Graham Cracker Strawberry Cake w/ butter cream Frosting
Oreo Cookie
Chocolate Cake w/ Cookies & Cream Butter frosting (topped with an oreo)
Yolo's
Chocolate Cake filled w/ Butter cream frosting topped with fudge
Orange Creamsicle
Orange Vanilla Cake w/ Orange / vanilla butter cream frosting
Confetti
(Confetti) Vanilla Cake w/ (Confetti) butter cream frosting
Brownie Eyed Girl
Brownie Cupcake w/ Chocolate peanut butter creme frosting
Hawaiian Pineapple
Chocolate Cake w/ Pineapple Butter Cream Frosting
Key Lime Pie
Keylime Vanilla Cake with Graham Cracker w/ Key Lime Butter cream Frosting
Cinnamon Streusel
Cinnamon Streusel Cake w/ Streusel butter cream frosting
Chocolate Salted Caramel
Chocolate Cake stuffed w/ Salted Caramel butter cream topped with pretzels, chocolate chips, and caramel
Lemon Kiss
Vanilla Cake w/ Lemon butter cream frosting
Marble Swirl
Chocolate & Vanilla Marble Cake w/ Chocolate & Vanilla butter cream frosting
Pina Colada
Vanilla coconut cake with coconut butter cream frosting w/ pineapple and cherry on top
Blue Crush
Vanilla Cake baked with blueberries w/ butter cream frosting topped with blueberry
German Chocolate
Chocolate Cake w/ Chocolate Fudge & Butter Pecan Frosting
Carrot
Carrot Cake w/ Cream cheese frosting
Holy Cannoli
Vanilla Almond Cake w/ Ricotta & chocolate chip Cream cheese Frosting
Chocolate Lava
Chocolate Cake w/ Chocolate Ganache filling and Chocolate Fudge frosting
Pumpkin Spice
Pumpkin Cake w/ Pumpkin Butter Cream frosting
Peanut Butter Banana
Banana Cake w/ Chocolate & Peanut butter cream frosting
Cake Jar (Great Gift)
$5.00
Jar stuffed with your favorite cupcake flavor!
Ice Cream Cone Cupcake
$3.25
Vanilla cake w/ Vanilla butter cream frosting w/ sprinkles
Sugar Free Vanilla
Vanilla Cake w/ Vanilla Sugar free frosting
Sugar Free Chocolate
Chocolate Cake w/ Chocolate Sugar free frosting
Hummingbird
Vanilla Cake w/ Fresh crushed pineapple, bananas, cinnamon, and walnuts
Cookies N' Cream
Vanilla cake baked with chocolate chips topped with vanilla Buttercream and a cookie and cookie crumbles
Cookie Dough
Vanilla cake baked with cookie dough topped with vanilla
Boston Cream
Vanilla cake stuffed with vanilla custard topped with chocolate ganache
The Dutchess
Caramel cake topped with caramel butter cream topped with caramel
Calypso
Vanilla stuffed with peanut butter topped with chocolate
Island Latte
Chocolate cake topped with a coffee chocolate butter cream (latte and cappuccino)
Cherry Bomb
Chocolate Stuffed wit cherries topped with vanilla butter cream with a cherry on top
Bakery Treats
Brownies
- $3.00
- Original $2.50
- Doz. $24.99
Brownies Frosted
- $3.50
- Frosted $2.95
- Doz. $29.99
Marshmallow Treats
$2.00
Original
Marshmallows Treats
$2.50
Frosted
Churros
$2.95
Cinnamon & Sugar Pastry sticks / Chocolate dipped
Oatmeal Peanut Butter Bar
$2.50Peanut Butter Balls
$1.50
Peanut butter rolled in chocolate
Peanut Butter Pinwheels
- $1.95
- Doz. $19.99
Chocolate Covered Pretzel Rods
$2.50
Honey baked pretzels dipped in Milk Chocolate (variety of toppings)
Chocolate Chip Cookie
- $0.99
- Doz. $10.99
Sugar Cookie
- $0.99
- Doz. $10.99
Peanut Butter Cookie
- $0.99
- Doz. $10.99
Cookie Sandwich
Chocolate / Peanut butter / Sugar
- $3.50
- Doz. $35.99
Cake Pops
$2.50
Cake balls dipped in Chocolate & Vanilla w/ chocolate drizzle
Large Cannoli
$2.75Mini Cannoli
$1.75Truffles
$1.50
Chocolate rolled in either coconut or crushed almonds
Peanut Butter and Chocolate Fudge
$3.50Candy Apples
Apple rolled in chocolate or caramel
- $4.50
- Choc. $4.95
Bundt Cakes
"Mini" bundt cakes (available in the same flavors below) $5 each
Classic Vanilla
$19.95Classic Chocolate
$19.95Red Velvet
$19.95Carrot
$19.95Lemon Kiss
$19.95Maple Bacon
$19.95Wedding Bliss
$19.95Marble Swirl
$19.95Pretty N Pink
$19.95Coconut
$19.95Blue Crush
$19.95German Chocolate
$19.95Confetti
$19.95Cinnamon Streusel
$19.95Pumpkin
$19.95Round Cakes
6' Round (Serves 8-12)
$35.00
Fondant or Specialty Design additional
8' Round (Serves 12-20)
$45.00
Fondant or Specialty Design additional
10' Round (Serves 19-27)
$55.00
Fondant or Specialty Design additional
Sheet Cakes
1/4 Sheet Cake
$65.00
Fondant or Specialty Design additional
1/2 Sheet Cake
$85.00
Fondant & Specialty Design additional
Full Sheet Cake
$150.00
Fondant & Specialty Design additional
Theme Cakes
Jumbo Cupcake Cake
$35.00
Fondant or Specialty Design additional
Football Cake
$35.00
Basic Design with Buttercream frosting (names / teams can be added)
Heart Cake
$35.00
Basic Design w/ buttercream frosting / fondant additional
Cross-Religious
$35.00
Basic Design w/ butter cream frosting (variety of colors)
Chocolate Chip
Round 11"x 11" Chocolate Chip
$25.00
Delicious & Moist and made with real chocolate chips. (Serves 16)Basic Design with Butter cream frosting. Message or Name added included
Speciality Cakes
Tea Cakes
$2.95
Variety Flavors / Frostings
Rolled Cakes
$5.95
Chocolate cake w/ marshmallow butter cream filling topped with Chocolate Ganache
Bar Cakes
$9.95
Choose Cake Flavor / Fillings / Frosting
Sand Castle Cake
$32.00
Choose Cake Flavor & Ganache Flavor
Rainbow Cakes
$55.00
5 Layer 6" round Butter Cream frosted
Pinata Cake
$45.00
Choose Cake Flavor & Frosting & candy choice
Doll Cake
$45.00
Choose a cake flavor & frosting
Types of Cake
Layered Cakes
Layer cakes include 3 layers of cake & 2 layers of filling which results in a cake 4" tall. Layer cakes are based on either a 2x2x4" slice or a 1.5x2x4" slice. Square cakes are available and provide slightly more servings than rounds. Squares are prices slightly higher than rounds
- 6' Round (Serves 8-12) $35.00
- 8' Round (Serves 12-20) $45.00
- 10' Round (Serves 19-27) $55.00
Tiered Cakes
Tiered cakes are a combination of layered cakes and made with buttercream & cream cheese frosting
- 8"+ 6" (Serves 20-32) $90.00
- 10"+6" (Serves 27-39) $105.00
- 10"+8" (Serves 31-47) $115.00
- 10"+8"+6" (Serves 44-64) $160.00
Sheet Cakes
Sheet cakes includes 2 layers of cake and 1 layer of fillings which results in a cake approx. 3" tall. Sheet cake servings are based on either a 3x2x3" slice or a 2x2x3" slice
- 1/4 Sheet Cake (Serves 19-29) $65.00
- 1/2 Sheet Cake (Serves 72-108) $130.00
Cookie Cakes
$25.00
(11" X 11"), Includes butter cream frosting with message
Frosting
Vanilla Butter Cream
Chocolate
Peanut Butter
Lemon Butter Cream
Cream Cheese
Additional charges
Fillings
Vanilla Buttercream
Peanut Butter Butter Cream
Lemon Buttercream
Strawberry Jam
Additional charges
Chocolate Buttercream
Cream Cheese
Additional charges
Raspberry Jam
Additional charges
Cookies N' Cream
Breakfast
We serve breakfast!
Scones
$1.75
Blueberry, Maple Oatmeal, Cranberry, Pumpkin, and Banana Walnut
Muffins
$1.75
Blueberry, Maple Oatmeal, Cranberry, Pumpkin, and Banana Walnut
Cheddar Biscuits
$1.75Donuts
$1.75
Vanilla, Chocolate, Powdered
Eclairs
$1.75
Vanilla
Turnover- Apple or Cherry
$1.95Cinnamon Streusel Coffee Cake
$2.50Pies
We sell our pies in a variety of delicious flavors
Pecan
Oreo
Reese's Peanut Butter
Coconut Dream
Chocolate
Strawberry Swirl Cheesecake
Additional charges