What's wrong with this menu?
Sibby's Cupcakery
716 S Railroad Ave
San Mateo, CA 94401
Uber
MORE PHOTOS
more menus
Signature Designs
Classic Themes
Custom Themes
Wedding Tastings
Signature Designs
Signature Designs
Each Signature Flavor has a unique decoration and color scheme. Always darling and flavor-inspired, our Signature Designs are appropriate for any occasion. If ordering online, our gluten-free versions are listed together after the traditional flavors. Pricing: Mini $33/dozen, Regular $48/dozen, Jumbo $12/each
Butter Cup*
Carrot Cinnamon
Choco Choco*
Chocolate Coconut Cream*
Chocolate & Cream*
Coconut Snowball
Confetti Surprise
Dulce de Leche*
Grandma's Chocolate Tea Cake
Latte Love*
Lemon Drop
MMM Good Mocha*
Old-Fashioned Birthday Cake*
Red Velvet
Salted Caramel
Snickerdoodle
Super Chewy Chocolate
Trio of Sizes - Mini, Regular, Jumbo
*May be ordered gluten-free
Classic Themes
At Sibby's Cupcakery, we offer classic decoration themes for popular occasions including birthdays, baby showers, bridal showers, graduations and traditional holidays. Classic Themes are available at no extra charge and include at least 4 unique decorations. Pricing: Mini $33/dozen, Regular $48/dozen, Jumbo $12/each
St. Patrick's Day
Baby Boy
Bridal
Birthday
Graduation
Baby Girl
4th of July
Festive
Stripes, Polka Dots, Sprinkles and Bows in your color scheme
Halloween
Thanksgiving
Be Mine
Holiday
Custom Themes
We love to create unique designs to complement your special occasion! There is a minimum design fee of $6/dozen for custom themes, which typically include 4 decorations per order. The design fee for more complex requests including multiple designs on a cupcake or a different decoration per cupcake is $12/dozen. We also offer edible custom-printed fondant discs with your graphic or logo for $12/dozen (2 dozen minimum). You are always welcome to do part of your order with custom designs and part with our Signature or Classic decorations which are perfect for any occasion and are no extra charge
Hawaiian Beach
Train
Sports
Giants
Roses
Princess
Stanford
Milkshakes
UC Berkeley
Drinks
Baptism
Safari
Pirates
Under the Sea
Custom-Printed Fondant Discs
I Love My Dog
Back to School
Doctor
49ers
Burgers & Sweets
Monsters
Delivery & Display
Our delivery fee varies based on distance from the bakery. Specific delivery prices are available on our website.
We can provide quotes for delivery outside this range. As an alternative, you are welcome to pick up the cupcakes from our bakery in downtown San Mateo (we have custom inserts that hold each cupcake in place). We also have a selection of tiered cake stands that are available for rent or purchase with an order. We can create a beautiful display for your cupcakes for $100 plus the cost of the stand rental. Please see our wedding gallery at http://sibbyscupcakery.com for photos
Pricing
They are about 4 1/2″ in diameter. Some couples like to use the Jumbo cupcake for the "cake" cutting ceremony. There is no additional cost for customizing colors. An additional design fee may apply for particularly intricate decorations and monograms or custom fondant decorations, however most couples tend to keep things relatively simple
Cupcake
The prices on our website apply for weddings. Minis are about half the size of a regular size cupcake.
- For Regular Size (per dozen) $48.00
- For Mini Size (per dozen) $33.00
Jumbo Cupcakes
We also sell Jumbo cupcakes individually.
- (each) $12.00
Browse Nearby
General Info
Payment Types
All Major Cards
Cuisine
Dessert
Hours
Monday:
Closed
Tuesday:
8:00am - 5:30pm
Wednesday:
8:00am - 5:30pm
Thursday:
8:00am - 5:30pm
Friday:
8:00am - 5:30pm
Saturday:
8:00am - 5:00pm
Sunday:
8:00am - 2:00pm
About Us
Sibby’s Cupcakery - called “the cupcake center of the universe” by the San Francisco Bay Guardian - has been featured in numerous local and national publications, including San Francisco Modern Bride, Daily Candy and Lucky Magazine, which named it one of the best places for baked goods in Northern California.