What's wrong with this menu?
Shelsky's Smoked Fish
251 Smith St
Brooklyn, NY 11231
Uber
MORE PHOTOS
Main Menu
Beverages
Ashlawn Farm French-Pressed Coffee
- Starting at $2.00
Dr. Brown's Soda's
$1.00Martinelli's Sparkling Apple Cider
$2.99Manhattan Special Espresso Soda
$2.00Fizzy Lizzy Sparkling Fruit Juice
$2.00Salads
Cucumber Salad
- (per lb.) $5.95
Egg Salad
- (per lb.) $8.98
Pickled Herring Salad
- (per lb.) $15.98
Baked Salmon Salad
- (per lb.) $17.98
Citrus Roasted Beet Salad
- (per lb.) $8.98
Fancy Tuna Salad
- (per lb.) $14.98
Smoked Whitefish Salad
- (per lb.) $17.98
Guss' Pickles
Sour Pickle
Two half or full sour pickles, or purchase a quart
- Starting at $1.00
Sauerkraut
- (per quart) $8.00
Sour Tomatoes
- (per sour tomato) $1.00
Breads
Orwasher's Ultimate Whole Wheat
$8.00
Made with local flours and grains
Orwasher's Raisin Pumpernickel
- One Lb. $3.75
Giant Onion Pocket
$0.75Kossar's Bialys
Please contact the restaurant for availability
- Starting at $1.00
Braided Bagel Challah
$8.00Orwasher's Rye
$3.50
One lb. of either seeded or plain rye
Sesame Pane Rustico
$3.50Kossar's Bagels
Please contact the restaurant for availability
- Starting at $1.00
Kossar's Pletzle
$6.00Cold Smoked and Cured Fish
Eastern Gaspe Nova
- (per 1/4 lb.) $8.99
Irish Double Cured Organic Salmon
- (per 1/4 lb.) $10.49
Mild Scottish Salmon
- (per 1/4 lb.) $8.99
David Burke Pastrami Salmon
- (per 1/4 lb.) $8.99
House-Cured Gravlax
- (per 1/4 lb.) $11.99
Cold Smoked Tuna
- (per 1/4 lb.) $13.99
Western Wild Salmon
- (per 1/4 lb.) $10.49
House-Cured Clementine and Ginger Salmon
- (per 1/4 lb.) $11.99
Saltier Scottish Salmon
- (per 1/4 lb.) $10.49
Belly Lox
- (per 1/4 lb.) $8.49
Sable (Black Cod)
- (per 1/4 lb.) $14.99
Mexican Achiote Cured
- (per 1/4 lb.) $11.99
Hot Smoked Fish
Blue Fish
- (per 1/4 lb.) $5.49
Lean Kippered Salmon
- (per 1/4 lb.) $8.99
White Fish
- (per lb.) $18.85
Kippers
- (per lb.) $11.50
Fatty Kippered Salmon
- (per 1/4 lb.) $10.49
Fancy Lake Sturgeon
- (per 1/4 lb.) $16.49
Bering Cisco
- (per lb.) $23.75
Herring, Pickled Etc.
Herring
- (per filet) $3.25
Matjes Herring
$5.50Pickled Lox
- (per 1/4 lb.) $8.49
Roll Mops
$3.25
One roll mop
Kippered Herring
$1.50Specialty Sandwiches
Member of the Tribe Sandwich
$8.50
Gaspe nova with scallion or plain cream cheese and served on a bagel or bialy. Please call restaurant for availability
Peter Shelsky Sandwich
$11.50
Gaspe nova, sable, pickled herring with cream sauce and onion, and scallion cream cheese all served on a bagel or bialy. Please call restaurant for availability
Brooklyn Transplant Sandwich
$10.50
Fatty kippered salmon, apple horseradish, cream cheese and pickled herring salad served on pumpernickel or rye bread. Please call restaurant for availability
Dr. Goldstein Special Sandwich
$9.50
Duck fat laced chopped liver and apple horseradish sauce served between two schmaltz fried potato latkes. Please call restaurant for availability
Sweet and Smokey Blintz Sandwich
$6.60
Lean kippered salmon, apples, red onions and horseradish creme fraiche rolled in a crepe. Please call restaurant for availability
Brooklyn Native Sandwich
$10.50
Gaspe nova, smoked whitefish salad, pickled herring and sour pickle served on a bagel or bialy. Please call restaurant for availability
Shelsky's Pastrami Sandwich
$10.50
Pastrami salmon, mustard herring and Riesling braised sauerkraut, served on pumpernickel or rye. Please call restaurant for availability
The Tribute Sandwich
$12.50
Horseradish cream cheese, smoked whitefish salad and wasabi tobiko. Please call restaurant for availability
Sweets and Homemade Baked Goods
Mama Ilene's Coconut Macaroons
$0.75Lingonberry and Toasted Spiced Pumpkin Seed Rugelach
- (per lb.) $14.50
Chocolate and Cinnamon Babka
- (per lb.) $9.50
Chocolate Covered Vanilla Marshmallow Twists
- (per lb.) $8.50
Rugelach
- (per lb.) $14.50
Clementine and Ginger Rugelach
- (per lb.) $14.50
Chocolate Covered Jelly Rings
- (per lb.) $8.50
Halvah Bars
$2.50Jarred Items
Sarabeth's Peach Apricot Preserves
$9.99Sarabeth's Strawberry and Raspberry Preserves
$9.99Manischewitz Sweet Gefilte Fish
$9.99BF Salt Packed Capers
$4.99Brooklyn Brine Whiskey Sour Pickles
$10.00Brooklyn Brine Lavender Pickled Asparagus
$10.00Linda Caperberries
$3.79Wild Hibiscus Flowers in Syrup
$10.00Portuguese Spicy Sardines in Olive Oil
$3.75Ortiz Yellow Fin Tuna Jars
$12.00Think Pink Canned Salmon
$3.75Reniero Estate Extra Virgin Olive Oil
$13.79Sarabeth's Blood Orange Marmalade
$9.99Manischewitz Premium Gold Gefilte Fish
$9.99Manischewitz Jarred Borscht with Diced Beets
$3.99BF Capers in Brine
$3.99Brooklyn Brine Damn Spicy Pickles
$10.00Brooklyn Brine Fennel Beets
$10.00Honeycup Honey Mustard
$6.49Portuguese Sardines in Olive Oil
$3.75Portuguese Sardines in Tomato Sauce
$3.75Red Head Canned Salmon
$6.25Unio Extra Virgin Olive Oil
$16.99Boxed and Bagged Items
Tam Tam Original Crackers
$4.99Carrs Cracked Pepper Crackers
$4.50Macy's Cheese Sticks
$4.00David's Kosher Salt
$1.99Mashuga Nuts Double Chocolate Walnuts
- 2.5 Oz. $4.99
Streitz Matzo Meal
$3.99Carrs Sesame Water Crackers
$4.50Plain Bremner Wafers
$3.75Diamond Crystal Kosher Salt
$4.99Mashuga Nuts Sweet and Salty Pecans
- Starting at $4.49
Manischewitz Wide Egg Noodles
$3.49Streitz Matzo
$3.99Browse Nearby
General Info
Cuisine
Seafood
Meals
Breakfast
Lunch
Hours
Monday:
Closed
Tuesday:
8:00am - 6:00pm
Wednesday:
8:00am - 6:00pm
Thursday:
8:00am - 6:00pm
Friday:
8:00am - 7:00pm
Saturday:
8:00am - 7:00pm
Sunday:
8:00am - 4:00pm
About Us
From great restaurants to excellent cheese shops and other specialty food shops, Brooklyn is a foodie paradise. What has been missing though, is the Smoked Fish and Appetizing shop of old. Speaking to people around the brownstone Brooklyn, it became clear that like us, they were hankering for appetizing, but sick of having to schlep to Manhattan to get it. So, we are so excited to bring Shelsky