What's wrong with this menu?
Shaffer City Oyster Bar & Grill
5 W 21st St
New York, NY 10010
Uber
MORE PHOTOS
Dinner Menu
Appetizers
Salmon Tartar With Pita Chips
$16.00
horseradish dill and mustard combined with fresh salmon keeps this a must have appetizer
Shaffers Country Club Shrimp Cocktail
$18.00
classic shrimp cocktail served with cocktail sauce and cilantro cream you gunna love it
Southwestern Lobster Cocktail
$22.00
black beans avocado jack cheese tomato and smoked red adobo vinaigrette crispy corn chips
Steamed Pei Mussels
$16.00
herbs white wine and butter make this a wonderfully simple bowl of love
Fried Oysters Over Creamed Spinach & Chipotle Aioli
$18.00
best darn cream spinach anywhere with six plump oysters a top and slightly spicy chipotle sauce
Crab Cakes Over Black Bean Salad
$14.00
jumbo lump crab and house made mayo make this crab cake as good as any maryland one
Mesclun Salad Truffled Mushroom Vinaigrette
$8.00
slow roasted mushroom vinaigrette and oven dried tomatoes make this a house favorite
Caesar Salad With Cured Spanish Anchovies
$8.00
its all about the fresh garlic and imported pecorino romano with pita wedges
Soup Du Jour
$8.00
it changes daily and most love the chefs way of messin with your palate
New England Clam Chowder
$8.00
this is not your typical thick floury white chowder ours is light and has a rich flavor of fresh clams
Entrees
Ny Strip Steak
$30.00
served au poivre accompanied by rich cream spinach and bacon horseradish mash
Grilled Salmon
$26.00
with basmati rice and an oven dried tomato caper herb broth
Diver Scallops
$28.00
from the pristine waters of new bedford, massachusetts over our signature mushroom risotto
Wild Striped Bass With Lobster Mashed Potatoes
$33.00
been here before you know what were talking about rookies step up and taste true perfection
Red Snapper
$28.00
warm potato nicoise salad... we put the potatoes where the greens were and it works
Cod
$26.00
herb crusted and pan seared served over moroccan cous cous
Double Cut Grilled Pork Chop
$25.00
a rosemary crusted grilled chop served with german spaetzle and apple compote
Pick Yo Fish
$26.00
any of our fresh seafood cooked the way you like with a heart healthy mixture of veggies
Browse Nearby
General Info
Cuisine
Seafood
Hours
Monday:
12:00pm - 11:00pm
Tuesday:
12:00pm - 11:00pm
Wednesday:
12:00pm - 11:00pm
Friday:
12:00pm - 11:00pm
Saturday:
12:00pm - 11:00pm
About Us
After almost 12 years as the seafood institution of the Flatiron District, Shaffer City is proud to say we have once again reinstituted our famed, original and creative seafood dishes. We have added a new craft beer menu and increased the raw bar happy hours to 6 days a week. The dining room is still serving your favorite shrimp and corn mashed potatoes. Fried oysters are still on the appetizer menu along with all your favorites from the past. Don’t miss out on New York’s most notable hidden pearl. Come on back and see why we’ve been receiving accolades for over a decade. You have just found your new favorite seafood - period.