What's wrong with this menu?
Sea Critters Cafe at Harbor Lights
506 Hill St
Green Lake, WI 54941
Uber
MORE PHOTOS
Main Menu
Appetizers
Crab Cake
$8.99
Lightly grilled traditional Blue Crab cake served with key lime aioli
Smoked Fish Dip
$7.99
A savory blend of smoked salmon and cream cheese served with crackers
Chicken Quesadilla
$8.29
Grilled chicken breast, green peppers, onions, jack and cheddar cheeses and roasted chilies served with salsa fresca
U-Peel Shrimp
Served hot or cold with Old Bay Seasoning & cocktail sauce
gluten-free
- 1/2 lb $8.99
- 1 lb $15.99
Hot Wings
$8.99
Fall-off-the-bone tender pork shanks served Buffalo or BBQ style
Cheese Curds
$8.99
Beer battered and served with our own sauce for dipping
Crunchy Fried Shrimp
$8.99
Rolled in our signature Crunchy Almond Crust and served with spicy cocktail sauce
Calamari
$7.99
Marinated for tenderness, tossed with our signature breading mixture, fried and served with sweet chili sauce
Onion Rings
$6.99
Lightly breaded, deep-fried and served with our chipotle ranch sauce for dipping
Spinach Artichoke Dip
$8.99
Artichoke hearts, spinach & five cheeses served hot with grilled pita wedges
Soups
Tomato Basil Crab Bisque
Our signature tomato basil bisque topped with a mound of chilled Blue Crab just before serving
- Cup $3.99
- Bowl $5.99
Soup of the Day
Ask your server
- Cup $3.99
- Bowl $5.49
Steaks/Ribs/Chicken
Each Entree below includes two sides and our Warm Bread with Caribbean Butter. With any Entree you can add: Crab Cake $7.99, Crunchy Almond Shrimp $5.99, Fried Large Sea Scallops $7.99. Add a cup of soup of the day for only $2.99
Filet Mignon
The most tender, leanest steak cut from the tenderloin
- 9 oz $26.99
- 12 oz $34.99
Ribeye
Richly marbled for melt-in-your-mouth flavor
- 14 oz $24.99
- 18 oz $30.99
Baby Back Ribs
Danish baby back ribs slow cooked and basted with a sweet and tangy barbecue sauce
- 1/2 Rack $14.99
- Full Rack $25.99
Top Sirloin
$21.99
A hearty cut of steak with the most "beefy" flavor
T-Bone
$26.99
The best of both worlds.. juicy NY strip paired with tender Filet Mignon
Chicken Fresca
$14.99
Two chargrilled chicken breasts topped with our own olive oil lemon herb sauce
Seafood Specialties
Each Entree below includes two sides and our Warm Bread with Caribbean Butter. All Pasta & Rice Dishes include Salad Bar and Warm Bread with Caribbean Butter. Add a cup of soup of the day for only $2.99
Today's Fresh Catch
Your choice from today's selection of fresh fish prepared as you like: Blackened (Gluten Free), Grilled (Gluten Free), Jerked (Gluten Free), Fried, Crunchy Almond Crusted. Mediterranean Sauce: tomatoes, garlic, capers, fresh spinach, kalamata olives and white wine. Add: Key Lime Butter Sauce (Gluten Free) $1.29, Parmesan Garlic Cream Sauce (Gluten Free) $1.29, Mediterranean Sauce (Gluten Free) $1.29, Crab Cake $7.99, Crunchy Almond Shrimp $5.99, Fried Large Sea Scallops $7.99. Add a cup of soup of the day for only $2.99
- Market Price
Fish & Chips
$14.99
Beer battered cod filets, deep fried and served with tartar sauce and malt vinegar
- Crab Cake
- $7.99
- Crunchy Almond Shrimp
- $5.99
- Fried Large Sea Scallops
- $7.99
- Cup of Soup of the Day
- $2.99
Crab Cakes
$18.99
Our traditional Blue Crab cakes grilled golden brown with key lime aioli
- Crab Cake
- $7.99
- Crunchy Almond Shrimp
- $5.99
- Fried Large Sea Scallops
- $7.99
- Cup of Soup of the Day
- $2.99
Crunchy Fried Shrimp
$17.99
Crunchy Almond Crusted, fried golden brown and served with our spicy cocktail sauce
- Crab Cake
- $7.99
- Crunchy Almond Shrimp
- $5.99
- Fried Large Sea Scallops
- $7.99
- Cup of Soup of the Day
- $2.99
Sea Scallops
$19.99
Fresh jumbo sea scallops lightly breaded, fried golden brown and served with our tartar sauce. Also available grilled or blackened
- Crab Cake
- $7.99
- Crunchy Almond Shrimp
- $5.99
- Fried Large Sea Scallops
- $7.99
- Cup of Soup of the Day
- $2.99
Sea Critters Combo Platter
$23.99
Beer battered cod, crab cake, crunchy shrimp, scallops & onion rings served with a selection of our sauces for dipping
- Crab Cake
- $7.99
- Crunchy Almond Shrimp
- $5.99
- Fried Large Sea Scallops
- $7.99
- Cup of Soup of the Day
- $2.99
Lobster Pasta
$20.99
Tender chunks of slipper lobster tail, fresh spinach and tomatoes sauteed in olive oil, seafood bouillon & white wine, served over angel hair pasta dusted with parmesan
Jambalaya
$17.99
Spicy Andouille sausage, chicken breast & shrimp sauteed with olive oil, garlic, peppers & onions, finished with our own creole sauce, served over rice
gluten-free
Shrimp Penne Pesto
$19.99
Succulent shrimp sauteed with oven roasted tomatoes and tossed with rich basil pesto and penne pesto
Risotto Scallops Rockefeller
$20.99
Jumbo sea scallops sauteed with fresh spinach, garlic bacon, and Anisette, enveloped in a fennel, cream, parmesan risotto
gluten-free
Sides
Creamy Cole Slaw Thick-Cut Steak Fries
$1.99
gluten-free
Baked Potato
$1.99
gluten-free
Sauteed Vegetables
$1.99
gluten-free
Country-Style Potato Salad
$1.99
gluten-free
Rice Pilaf
$1.99
gluten-free
Salad Bar
$3.49Sweet Potato Fries
$2.99- As a side choice add
- $0.99
Desserts
Homemade Key Lime Pie
$4.99Funnel Cake Fries
$4.99Homemade Brownie a la Mode
$5.99Cheesecake
$5.99Other Favorites
All Favorites come with your Choice of Two Sides
Prime Rib of Beef Au Jus
Served every Saturday and Sunday
- Lighter Fare 10 oz $17.99
- Sea Critter Cut 14 oz $24.99
- Super Cut $30.99
1/2 Fried Chicken Dinner
$12.99Chicken and Ribs
$17.99
2 Pieces of Fried Chicken and 1/2 rack of Ribs
Coconut Shrimp
$16.99
With Sweet and Sour Sauce
Walleye Pike
$18.99
Served Pan Fried or Grilled
Baby Beef Liver
$14.99
2 Pieces of Liver Smothered in Onions
Grilled Salmon
$16.99
Served with our Savory Lemon Dill Sauce
Friday Night Fish Fry
Includes Salad Bar and Choice of Potato
3 Piece Beer Battered Cod
$11.996 oz Perch Plate
$17.993 Piece Haddock
$12.99Lighter Fare Menu
Includes Salad Bar
1/4 Fried Chicken Dinner
$10.99
With Steak Fries
Baby Beef Liver
$10.99
With bacon, onions and choice of potato
Center Cut Pork Chop
$13.99
With choice of Potato
6 oz Petit Filet
$18.99
With Choice of Potato
Spaghetti
$11.99
With Meat Sauce and Garlic Bread
Chicken Parmesan
$14.99
Grilled chicken with our own Marinara Sauce
Sea Critters Sandwich Board
Includes Steak Fries
1/2 Lb Angus Burger
With Lettuce and Tomato
- $7.99
- Add Swiss or Cheddar Cheese $8.99
Fish Sandwich
$8.99
Fried or Grilled Haddock with Tartar Sauce
Sea Critters Dip
$9.99
Shaved Prime Rib with Au Jus
Grilled Chicken Breast Sandwich
$8.99
On a Toasted Bun
6 oz Ribeye Steak Sandwich
$13.99Little Critter Menu
We love little kids.. they never question the bill! Little Critter Menu for Children 10 years old & younger ONLY!
Grilled Cheese
$3.99
"Better than Mom's". Served with French Fries
- Add bacon
- $0.99
- Add sliced tomato
- $0.35
"Old Salty's" Fried Shrimp (4)
$4.99
Served with French Fries
Kid's Burger
$4.99
Served with French Fries
- Add bacon
- $0.99
- Add cheese (Cheddar or Swiss)
- $0.99
Go Fish
$4.99
no "square fish" served here! Fried Fish Nuggets. Served with French Fries
Chicken Tenders
$4.99
Served with French Fries
Hot Dog - All Beef
$4.29
Served with French Fries
Pasta
$4.99
Your choice of Cheese Sauce or Marinara
Mama Mia Pizzeria
$4.99
5 inch Cheese Pizza Pie
Browse Nearby
General Info
About Us
Our new menu features a "Fresh Catch of the Day" along with many other Seafood Delights including our Lobster Pasta, Jambalaya, and our famous Sea Critters Crab Cakes. Our Prime Rib Au Jus is served every Saturday and Sunday along with our succulent Steaks which are served daily.