Hot Fudge, Hot Caramel, Mixed Nuts, Peanuts, Whipped Cream, Wafer Cookie, Amarena Cherry
Sm - 1 Flavor$5.50
Med - 1-2 Flavors$6.75
Lg - 1-4 Flavors$8.50
The Screamin' Mimi
$9.50
Warm homemade Brownie, 1 or 2 ice cream flavors, homemade hot fudge or caramel sauce, nuts or sprinkles
The Sebastopol Mimi
$9.50
Warm Apple Bread, 1 or 2 ice cream flavors (We suggest Vanilla), homemade caramel sauce, nuts or sprinkles
Banana Split
$9.50
3 Scoops + 3 Toppings, hot fudge, caramel, marshmallow, strawberry. Includes whipped cream, amarena cherry, nuts and sprinkles!
Wafflecone Sundae
$8.00
1 or 2 ice cream flavors, choice of homemade hot fudge or caramel, nuts or sprinkles
Sammies
$7
Salted Toffee-Vanilla
Salted Toffee Oatmeal Cookie w/ Vanilla Ice Cream
gluten-free
Party Cake
Snickerdoodle dipped in chocolate and sprinkles with vanilla ice cream
Bad Boy Roy
chocolate espresso chocolate chips and nuts Vanilla Ice cream
Chocolate Chip-Mint
chocolate chip cookie with Creme de menthe ice cream
Strawberry Shortcake
Snickerdoodle with Strawberry Ice Cream
Chocolate Chip-Vanilla
chocolate chip cookie with vanilla ice cream
Shakes & Floats
Milkshake
Choose Any Flavor (non - "Mud")
Reg$8.25
Lg$9.75
Mudslide
Mimi's (or any) "Mud" + Hot Fudge
Reg$9.25
Lg$10.75
Espresso Shake
Vanilla shake with Espresso
Reg$9.25
Lg$10.75
Mocha Shake
Espresso Shake with Hot Fudge
Reg$9.25
Lg$10.75
Float
Any Flavor in Root Beer or Italian Soda
16 oz$6.75
Fruit Shake
Sorbet and Fruit Juice
Reg$8.25
Lg$9.75
Affogato
$6.25
Ice Cream "Drowned" in Espresso
Pints
Available Prepacked Pints $12
Mimi's Mud
Gluten Free Mud
English Toffee
Coffee Caramel Swirl
Double Espresso Chip
Ground Down; coffee ice cream w/flecks of ground coffee
Creme de Menthe
Peppermint Stick
Peppermint and Cookies
Minty Mud
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
Cookie Break
Galaxy
Vanilla Swiss Almond
Birthday Cake
Caramel Swirl
Vanilla
Local Strawberry
Cherry Chip Fudge
Vanilla
with date bits
Lemon Sorbet
Raspberry Sorbet
Mango Sorbet
Coconut Sorbet
Bollywood Sorbet
Cranberry Orange
ginger, lime, turmeric, golden beet
Chocolate Sorbet
sorbet
Vegan Mimi's Mud
Coconut milk
Vegan Mint Chip
Vegan Chocolate Mint Chip
Bulliet Bourbon
Olive Oil
Chai
Coconut Chocolate Almond
Chocolate Chocolate Almond
Deep Dark Secret
Praline Pecan
Bourbon Pecan
Maple Walnut
runnig low
Butter Pecan
Pear Zinfandel
Pear
Pumpkin Spice Latte
Running low!
Birthday Cake
Jalapeno Lime Sorbet
Only one left! Running low!
Espresso & Drinks
Latte
Sgl$3.95
Dbl$4.25
Cappuccino
Sgl$3.50
Dbl$3.75
Mocha
Sgl$4.00
Dbl$4.50
Espresso
Sgl$2.75
Dbl$3.00
Americano
Dbl$3.00
Hot Cocoa
Sgl$4.00
Dbl$4.75
Tea
Sgl$2.00
Italian Sodas
16 oz $5.25
Rootbeer Syrup
Blackberry Syrup
Cherry Syrup
Lavender Syrup
Lemon Syrup
Lime Syrup
Vanilla Syrup
Peach Syrup
Raspberry Syrup
Strawberry Syrup
Passionfruit Syrup
Watermelon Syrup
The price of our ice cream
We sell ice cream by the weight, not by the scoop. Why? Because it allows you to mix as many flavors in any size cup, it allows you to get exactly what you want and you pay for what it weights, not what looks about right. We have sold ice cream per ounce since we opened in 1995 and we believe it's the best way to sell ice cream for both the customer and the business.
Ice cream and Sorbet
Priced by the weight, minus the inedible containers. However, due to Covid, we have stardardized our sizes and we check the weight to ensure it's the amount you have paid. You can still mix as many flavors as you like in any size cup.
(small / 5 oz)$5.25
(Regular /7 oz)$7.25
(Large /10 oz)$9.25
Walk-Up Menu
Our Walk-up menu is specifically for the flavors listed on this page only. We cannot scoop any of the flavors listed on the other menus. We only make these items when you arrive to avoid melting and thinning, this limits what items you can pre-order. Prices vary per size/ item.
1 Scoop Sundae
1 Scoop of any flavor of ice cream, your choice of Hot fudge or Caramel ,whipped cream, nuts or sprinkles and a cherry.
$5.50
2 Scoop Sundae
2 Scoops of any flavors of ice cream, your choice of Hot fudge or Caramel ,whipped cream, nuts or sprinkles and a cherry.
$6.75
4 Scoop Sundae
Four scoops, with up to four different flavors, your choice! Hot fudge, or caramel, whipped cream, a cherry, and nuts or sprinkles!
$8.50
Screamin' Mimi
Our house made warm brownie sundae with 2 scoops of ice cream, hot fudge or caramel, whipped cream, nuts or sprinkles, and a cherry.
$9.50
The Sebastopol Mimi
Warm apple bread with 2 scoops of ice cream, our homemade caramel or hot fudge sauce and fresh made whipped cream, with a cherry and nuts or sprinkles!
$9.50
Banana Split
3 Scoops of ice cream with up to three sauces, Hot Fudge, Caramel, Strawberry, Pineapple, Marshmallow, or Peanut butter! With whipped cream a cherry and nuts or sprinkles!
$9.50
Milkshakes
Any flavor ice cream available, excluding any mud flavor, blended into a milkshake. Whipped Cream optional. Malt powder available.
(Regular /16 oz)$8.25
(Large /20 oz)$9.75
(Malted)$0.50
(Whipped cream)$1.50
Mudslide
A milkshake using Mimi's Mud ( or any Mud flavor) a shot of hot fudge and topped with our fresh, house made whipped cream and hot fudge drizzle.
(Regular /16 oz)$9.25
(Large/20 oz)$10.75
Espresso Shake
An Espresso shake using fresh brewed Illy Cafe and our vanilla ice cream!
(Regular/16 oz)$9.25
(Large/ 20 oz)$10.75
Mocha Shake
An Espresso shake using fresh brewed Illy Cafe and our vanilla ice cream, also blended with our house made hot fudge and of course topped with our delicious whipped cream
(regular /16 oz)$9.25
(large/20 oz)$10.75
Fruit shake
A dairy free shake made with your choice of sorbet and fruit juice.
(Regular)$8.25
(Large)$9.75
Ice cream Float
Traditional Root Beer (we use Sprecher's) or any of our Italian Syrup flavors and your choice of ice cream
(16 oz)$6.75
Italian soda
Choose from a large variety of Italian syrup flavors. Made with or without cream, your choice.
$5.25
Affogato
Your choice of 1 ice cream flavor with a fresh brewed double shot of Illy Cafe espresso poured over, topped with whipped cream and a wafer cookie! (Both optional)
$6.25
Sammies
Our ice cream sandwiched between two delicious cookies. Pick them up at our express window or order them at our front order area. Available in a variety of flavors combinations
(Regular)$7.00
(Gluten Free)$7.00
Today's flavors
Mimi's Mud
Our most popular flavor for a good reason. Espresso, chocolate chips, crushed cookies and our homemade fudge
Galaxy
Our Chocolate Chip
Cookie Break
Our version of Cookies and Cream, but even better
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
We make our own eggless Chocolate Chip cookie Dough and put it in our vanilla ice cream
Strawberry
Made with local strawberries
Vanilla
Made with pure Madagascar vanilla
Deep Dark Secret
Our dark chocolate ice cream
Creme de Menthe
Our version on the classic mint chocolate chip
Caramel Cone Explosion
Vanilla ice cream with chocolate covered cone pieces and caramel swirl
Honey Crunch
Vanilla ice cream with honeycomb pieces
Butter Brittle
Birthday Cake
Vanilla ice cream with rainbow sprinkles and chunks of choclate sponge cake
Inspired to find ice cream reminiscent of her childhood, Maraline Olson began making her own homemade ice cream and opened Screamin' Mimi's on October 28 1995. Maraline makes ice cream fresh every day, choosing from over 300 recipes.