With the onset of Corona Virus we have had to adjust our menu drastically. We are offering easy pick up of packed pints of ice cream in a variety of flavors. Text your pint order (707-800-2916) and allow 15-20 minutes before pick up. Make sure to use the area code and that you received your order confirmation. In addition to ordering pints, we do have cups of ice cream, milkshakes and sundaes available TO ORDER IN PERSON AT THE DOOR. We do not make these ahead to ensure quality
The Price of Our Handmade Ice Cream
We sell ice cream by the weight, not by the scoop. Why? Because it allows you to mix as many flavors in any size cup, it allows you to get exactly what you want and you pay for what it weights, not what looks about right. We have sold ice cream per ounce since we opened in 1995 and we believe it's the best way to sell ice cream for both the customer and the business
Ice Cream and Sorbet
All items are weight (minus the inedible container weight)
Prepacked Pints / 16 Ounces / 1-4 Servings
These items are specially packed for easy take out. We have a large quantity of the following flavors available. A pint is 16 ounces. It can serve 4 people, or one person who likes to keep it hidden in the freezer. These are already packaged and cannot be re-sized
Our most popular flavor, espresso ice cream, cookies, fudge and chocolate chips. Contains gluten
Gluten Free Mimi's Mud
Our most popular flavor, espresso ice cream, Gluten Free cookies, fudge and chocolate chips
Java Chocolate Almond
Coffee ice cream with chocolate covered almonds
Creme de Menthe
Mint ice cream with chocolate chips
Peppermint Stick Ice Cream
Peppermint stick ice cream made with real peppermint sticks
Midnight de Menthe
Mint chocolate chocolate chip
Our version of chocolate chip ice cream. Why the name galaxy? Because it has as many chips as stars in the sky
Chocolate cookies & graham cracker in vanilla ice cream
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
We' re pretty sure this will be the best you've ever had because we hand make the (egg less) cookie dough and it's delish!
Perfect, rich vanilla ice cream
Vanilla Swiss Almond
Vanilla ice cream with chocoalte covered almonds
Cherry Chip Fudge
We only use locally sourced strawberries, and you can taste the difference
Local Raspberry Ice cream
Made with fresh, local organic raspberries
Deep Dark Secret
our dark chocolate ice cream
Chocolate ice cream with cinnamon
Chocolate Raspberry Chip
Lemon Poppyseed Ice cream
Buttery ice cream with salted pecan pieces and halves
Buttery ice cream with sweet crunchy praline pecans
Caramel Bourbon Pecan
Pistachio Ice cream
Sorbet: All Vegan & Gluten, Dairy & Egg Free
these are dairy free, gluten free and vegan. Made with fruit, cane sugar and some are made with coconut milk
Creamy Chocolate Sorbet
Vegan Orange Cardamom Sorbet
Pineapple Basil Cream
Our Ice Cream sandwiches & Pies
Mimi's Mud Pie
Oreo Crust with Mimi's Mud ice Cream, fudge topping and whipped vanilla ice cream around the edges
Serves 6-10 People$30.00
Vanilla Swiss Almond / Chocolate Chocolate Almond Pie
One layer of each flavor in an oreo crust. We promise lots and lots of Chocolate covered almonds in it!!!
Peppermint Patty Pie
Oreo crust with a layer of Creme d' Menthe Ice cream between layers of Deep Dark Secret
Ice Cream Pie
Made to order (most flavors) with 5 days notice. Choice of Oreo or Graham Cracker crust, fudge topping or whipped vanilla ice cream topping. We can write on the pies, but space is limited. we have a edible chocolate wafer that says Happy Birthday, available for no extra charge Custom pies are limited to ONE flavor per pie
The "Basic" Pie
Sometimes there's nothing quite like Vanilla and Chocolate...and maybe a little Caramel and cookie crunch in between the layers! Far from real basic, but spot on delicious!
Peanut Butter Pie
Oreo crust with a layer of Peanut Butter Galaxy Ice cream between layers of Deep Dark Secret
Neapolitan Ice Cream Pie
Strawberry, Vanilla and Deep dark Secret all layered in one pie. Oreo or Graham cracker crsut available. Orders of flavors vary due to our production schedule
Salted Toffee Oatmeal Vanilla Sammies
An absolutely delicious salted toffee cookie with our vanilla ice cream. Gluten Free! Sold individually or four pack
Bad Boy Roi Sammie
A fudgey, chocolate, walnut and pecan cookie with vanilla ice cream.
Chocolate Chip Mint Sammie
Choocolate Chip cookie with Creme de menthe ice cream.
Snickerdoodle cookie with Strawberry Ice cream
Chocolate Chip Vanilla Sammie
The classic, a chocolate chip cookie with vanilla ice cream
Party Cake Sammie
Snickerdoodle cookie with Vanilla ice cream, dipped in chocolate with rainbow sprinkles!!
The price of our ice cream
We sell ice cream by the weight, not by the scoop. Why? Because it allows you to mix as many flavors in any size cup, it allows you to get exactly what you want and you pay for what it weights, not what looks about right. We have sold ice cream per ounce since we opened in 1995 and we believe it's the best way to sell ice cream for both the customer and the business. Please note, this has been our price per ounce for several years. We have not had an increase in this price since 2016.
Ice cream and Sorbet
Priced by the weight, minus the inedible containers. However, due to Covid, we have stardardized our sizes and we check the weight to ensure it's the amount you have paid. You can still mix as many flavors as you like in any size cup.
(small / 5 oz)$3.75
(Regular /7 ozz)$5.50
(Large /10 oz)$7.50
Milkshakes & Sundaes
Our limited menu is specifically for the flavors listed on this page only. We cannot scoop any of the flavors listed on the other menus. we prefer to make these items when you arrive to avoid melting and thinning. These items are priced per item
Any flavor ice cream available, excluding any mud flavor, blended into a milkshake. Whipped Cream optional. Malt powder available.
(Regular /16 oz)$6.50
(Large /20 oz)$7.75
1 Scoop Sundae
1 Scoop of ice cream with your choice of toppings.
2 scoop sundae
2 Scoops of the same or two different flavors of ice cream, choice of Hot fudge, Caramel , strawberry, or marshmallow topping, whipped cream, nuts or sprinkles and a cherry.
4 Scoop Sundae
2 scoops or 4 flavors. choice of topping
Our house made warm brownie sundae with 2 scoops of ice cream, whipped cream and a cherry. Nuts optional.
The Sebastopol Mimi
Warm apple bread with vanilla ice cream, our homemade caramel sauce and fresh made whipped cream
three flavors, three toppings. Traditional or mix it up; you choose
A milkshake using Mimi's Mud ( or any Mud flavor) a shot of hot fudge and topped with our fresh, house made whipped cream.
(Regular /16 oz)$7.50
An Espresso shake using fresh brewed Illy Cafe and our vanilla ice cream
(Large/ 20 oz)$8.50
An Espresso shake using fresh brewed Illy Cafe and our vanilla ice cream, our house made hot fudge and of course our delicious whipped cream
(regular /16 oz)$7.25
A dairy free shake made with your choice of sorbet and fruit juice.
Ice cream Float
Traditional Root Beer (we use Sprecher's) or any of our Italian Syrup flavors and your choice of ice cream
choose from a large variety of syrup flavors. Made with or without cream, your choice.
your choice of 1 ice cream flavor with a fresh brewed double shot of Illy Cafe poured.
Our ice cream sandwiched between two delicious cookies. Pick them up at our express window or order them at our front order area. Available in a variety of flavors combinations
(4 pack of regualr)$18.00
(4 pack of GF)$20.00
Our version of Cookies and Cream, but even better
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
we make our won eggless Chocolate Chip cookie Dough and put it in our vanilla ice cream
Made with fresh locally grown berries
Our Chocolate Chip
Our most popular flavor for a good reason. Espresso, chocolate chips, crushed cookies and our homemade fudge
Made with pure Madagascar vanilla
Deep Dark Secret
Our dark chocolate ice cream
Chocolate PB Cup
Peanut Butter Ice cream with chocolate covered honeycomb candy
Sorbets (vegan / dairy free)
Lemon Berry Cream
Vegan Caramel Swirl
Waived for orders totaling $40 for 5 miles or less, $60 5-7 miles & $80 for 7-10 Miles. We suggest asking your neighbors to go in on a delivery!
Delivery fee for 5 mile radius delivery
For order less than $40 within 5 miles of Screamin' Mimi's.
Delivery Fee for 5.1 to 7 mile radius
For orders totaling less than $60 delivered within 5-7 mile range
Delivery Fee 7-10 Miles
for order totaling more than $80, this fee will be waived. (Hint:ask you neighbors to go in on a delivery!)
Chocolate Chip cookie Sammies
Delicious chocolate chip cookie sandwiches with your choice of Vanilla or mint chip ice cream
Salted Toffee Oatmeal Sammies GLUTEN FREE
A delicious oatmeal cookie with toffee bit s & salt with vanill a ice cream
Ice cream Pie
Mimi's Mud : our best selling Mimi's Mud ice cream (espresso Ice cream, chocolate chips, Oreo cookies & our homemade fudge) in Oreo crumb crust The Basic: 1/2 vanilla 1/2 Deep Dark Secret with a thin layer of cookie crunch and caramel swirl between. In an oreo crust, drizzled with fudge. Nothing basic there!! The Neopolitan Ice cream Pie 1/3 Strawberry, 1/3 Vanilla and 1/3 Deep Dark Secret with a thin cookie layer. On Graham cracker or Oreo crust. Peanut Butter Cup Pie: Oreo Crust, Peanut Butter ice cream in between layers of Deep Dark secret with Oreo Crust Peppermint Patty Pie: A layer of our Creme d'Menthe (mint chip) ice cream in between layers of Deep Dark Secret. Vanilla Swiss Almond and 1/2 Chocolate chocolate Almond ice cream. Oreo Crust Cookie Break : Oreo or Graham crust filled with Cookie Break ice cream. Topped with whipped vanilla Ice cream or a thin, smooth layer of Fudge. Galaxy Pie 4 days notice required for special order.
Mimi's Mud/ Oreo crust / Fudge$30.00
Peanutbutter & Chcolate$30.00
Vanilla Swiss & chocolate chocolate Almond$30.00
Writting on any cake$3.00
Pints : We always have these flavors
16 ounce containers. Serves 1-4 Most are currently packed as we make the ice cream , resulting in a much lighter pint. Hand packing is available on limited flavors and may be higher than price range quoted.
Mimi's Mud- available hand packed
Espresso ice cream, chocolate chips, Chocolate cookies and our homemade fudge. Hands down our best seller.
Inspired to find ice cream reminiscent of her childhood, Maraline Olson began making her own homemade ice cream and opened Screamin' Mimi's on October 28 1995. Maraline makes ice cream fresh every day, choosing from over 300 recipes.