Corkage fee is $15 for up to two bottles. Featured Varietals: Ask your server about our current featured wines by the glass and bottle. Offerings change throughout the season
Cocktails
Legendary Bloody Mary
$11.00
Locally famous & made from scratch
Mouse Rock Mai Tai
$11.00
Appleton Estate rum, house made orgeat, Orange Curaçao & lime. Served with a float of Myers Dark rum
Frothy Colada
$12.00
Our take on the tiki classic. Shaken and served up with a dash of Blue Curaçao
Opolo Grand Rouge, Paso Robles 2018 ~ Rich GSM Blend
Glass$12.00
Bottle$44.00
Thatcher Working Holiday, Paso Robles 2018 ~ Well balanced GSM
Glass$11.00
Bottle$40.00
For the Table
Legendary Calamari
$15.00
strips breaded in panko & deep fried
Crab Cakes
$16.00
with mixed greens and fire roasted corn salsa
Ahi Egg Rolls
$15.00
flash fried rare, with Thai chili sauce, wasabi & pickled ginger
BBQ Oysters
$18.00
half dozen broiled in garlic parsley butter
Steamed Clams
$15.00
with mushrooms in a spicy garlic & white wine broth
Nachos
$12.00
black beans, pico de gallo, cheddar and jack cheese and house salsa
Add Chicken Tinga
$6.00
Add Grilled Steak
$10.00
Raw Bar
Ceviche & House Chips
$15.00
with pickled onion & avocado
Oysters
$18.00
half dozen on the shell
Ahi Sashimi
$17.00
with spicy Thai peanut slaw
Jumbo Black Tiger Shrimp Cocktail
$18.00
New England Clam Chowder
Our award winning recipe is made in house and loaded with clams
Cup$6.00
Bowl$11.00
Bread Bowl$13.00
Garden Variety
Cayucos Salad
$12.00
Avocado, tomatoes, carrots, celery, cucumber, red onion & cilantro-lime-mango dressing on a bed of fresh mixed greens
Add Grilled Chicken
$8.00
Add Grilled Salmon
$10.00
Add Grilled Jumbo Shrimp
$12.00
Spicy Halibut Slaw
$21.00
Grilled halibut over a spicy Thai peanut slaw with crisp cabbage, carrots & mango-chili sauce
Sesame Crusted Ahi
$20.00
Seared rare over a bed of field greens topped with mandarin oranges, sliced bell peppers, shaved almonds, crisp wontons and strawberries, served with a soy ginger dressing
Grilled Salmon Caesar
$19.00
Over crisp romaine, tomatoes, croutons & Parmesan cheese
New York Steak Salad
$22.00
Prime NY Steak over field greens tossed with balsamic vinaigrette & blue cheese crumbles, topped with roasted corn salsa and crispy onion strings
BBQ Chicken Salad
$17.00
Crisp chicken breast tossed in our spicy BBQ sauce over a bed of romaine in bleu cheese dressing topped with chopped celery and bleu cheese crumbles
Side Garden or Caesar Salad
$8.00
Chowder & Salad
Cup & Salad$12.00
Bowl & Salad$17.00
Bread Bowl & Salad$18.00
Hand Crafted Fish and Chips
Served with beer battered fries. Substitute sweet potato fries, onion rings or garden salad ~ $1
Alaskan Cod & Chips
$17.00
Halibut & Chips
$21.00
Jumbo Shrimp & Chips
$19.00
Calamari & Chips
$17.00
Classic Burgers
6 oz all chuck patty on a brioche bun with lettuce, tomato, and red onion. Served with beer battered fries. Substitute sweet potato fries, onion rings or garden salad ~ $1. Substitute Grilled Chicken ~ $3 ~ Substitute vegetarian Impossible Burger ~ $4
ABC Burger
$15.00
Avocado, bacon & cheddar
Cowboy Burger
$15.00
Onion ring, bacon, pepper jack & bbq sauce
Cheese Burger
$13.00
All chuck & cheddar
Patty Melt
$14.00
with grilled onions, pepper-jack, and chipotle aioli
Lunch Specials
Available until 5 pm
Schooners' Tacos
A local's favorite, topped with avocado-jalapeño sauce, chipotle aioli, cabbage, Monterey Jack cheese & pico de gallo. Served on warm corn tortillas with rice and black beans
Halibut$21.00
Salmon$20.00
Shrimp$18.00
Ahi$20.00
Chicken$18.00
Guacos
$17.00
Scratch made guacamole on warm corn tortillas with melted Monterey Jack cheese & a zesty cilantro shallot-slaw. Served with rice and black beans
Cayucos BLT
$15.00
With avocado & chipotle aioli on toasted sourdough. Served with beer battered fries
Albacore Tuna Melt
$16.00
Cheddar cheese & tomato on toasted sourdough with our house made tuna salad. Served with beer battered fries
Schooners Specialties
Pan Seared Alaskan Halibut
$30.00
With Yukon Gold mashed potatoes, seasonal veggies and a lemon caper beurre blanc
Soy Ginger Glazed Coho Salmon
$26.00
With sautéed broccoli florets over rice pilaf
Seafood Pasta
$28.00
Shrimp, fish & crab meat with spinach & mushrooms over fettuccine in a creamy marinara
Horseradish Crusted Ahi
$27.00
Served over blue crab wasabi mashed potatoes, with seaweed salad and a teriyaki glaze
Cioppino
$32.00
Crab, shrimp, clams and fish in a spicy tomato broth with grilled garlic bread
Market Garden Pesto Risotto
$23.00
Served with seasonal vegetables and topped with basil and freshly grated Parmesan. Vegan upon request
Fresh Catch
We proudly feature sustainably caught seafood and source locally whenever possible. Ask about today's offerings
MP
Lobster Mac
$28.00
Served with sautéed bell peppers, chopped bacon, bay shrimp and large chunks of lobster
Lobster Tail Dinner
8oz tail broiled in garlic parsley butter, with a potato croquette and sautéed broccoli
MP
NY Strip
$32.00
12 oz cut served with sautéed broccoli and a potato croquette, topped with our house made bourbon peppercorn sauce and crispy onion strings
Surf and Turf
NY Strip Steak with Yukon Gold mashed potatoes and seasonal veggies. Add (4) Jumbo Prawns ~ $18, Add Snow Crab Legs ~ MP, Add Lobster Tail ~ MP
House Favorites
Alaskan Cod & Chips
$17.00
Halibut & Chips
$21.00
Calamari & Chips
$17.00
Jumbo Shrimp & Chips
$19.00
Cowboy Burger
$15.00
Onion ring, bacon, bbq & pepper-jack
ABC Burger
$15.00
Avocado, bacon & cheddar
Cheese Burger
$13.00
Dessert
The Cayookie
$10.00
A homemade ½ pound, chocolate chip cookie Served warm, gooey in a cast iron skillet & topped with vanilla ice cream. Please allow 8-10 minutes to bake
We believe in offering the finest wild caught fish and sustainably raised meat, together with the freshest local produce, to provide our guests with a remarkable experience. Our staff is eager to help you navigate our menu to find that perfect dish – and ready to help you pair it with a glass of local wine. And if you just want to sip a cocktail and watch the dolphins play outside, this is the place.