What's wrong with this menu?
Sanibel Cottage
1517 Empire Blvd
Webster, NY 14580
Uber
MORE PHOTOS
Dinner Menu
Appetizers
Gator Bites...yes! Alligator!
$9.95
marinated in beer & secret spices then breaded to make it not only edible but also damn good, fried and served with our honey mustard sauce
Calamari
$9.95
dusted in seasoned flour and lightly fried to perfection. served with marinara sauce on the side
Sicilian Calamari
$11.95
fried then tossed with vinaigrette, 3 types of peppers, kalamata olives & feta—it’s got a kick to it!
Conch Fritters
$7.95
minced conch, onions, peppers, and spices battered then fried served with cocktail sauce
Artichokes Frenchy French
$7.95
battered artichoke hearts, sautéed in olive oil, in a sherry, lemon butter sauce
Wings
$8.95
sweet and sour or we can serve ‘em buffalo style...hot, medium or mild
Tater Skins
$7.95
potato wedges baked with melted cheddar cheese and crispy bacon bits
Soup
Soup Of The Day
ask your server for our delicious homemade soup special
French Onion Soup
$5.95
baked with a homemade crouton and melted provolone
Island Gumbo
chicken, andouille sausage and southern veggies, authentic & perfect
- Cup $5.95
- Bowl $7.95
Cottage Conch Chowder
a secret key west recipe with a whole lotta zip!
- Cup $5.95
- Bowl $7.95
Salads
Causeway Cobb Salad
$8.95
mixed greens topped with grilled turkey breast, hard-boiled egg, bacon, cheddar cheese and tomato with your choice of salad dressing on the side
Caesar
$7.95
served with a fantastic made from scratch authentic caesar dressing
Port Abella Spinach Salad
$8.95
fresh spinach topped with grilled portabella mushrooms, crumbled bleu cheese, hard boiled egg, red onion tossed in a warm bacon dressing
Sanibel Citrus Salad
mixed greens tossed with mandarin oranges, dried cranberries, toasted walnuts and our famous mango vinaigrette dressing
- $7.95
- Add Chicken $4.00
- Add Shrimp $5.00
Raw Bar
clams & oysters
Steamed Clams
- 6 For $6.95
- Dozen For $11.95
Clams Captiva
simple & delicious, baked & topped with three cheese bread crumbs & butter
- 6 For $9.95
Clams Casino
baked & topped with onion, green pepper, bread crumbs & bacon
- 6 For $9.95
Shrimp Cocktail
6 beautiful chilled gulf shrimp, it’s the best deal in town!
- 6 For $3.95
King Crab Legs
1/2 lb
- Market Price
Oysters Rockefeller
the right way, baked with spinach, bacon & a touch of anisette topped with hollandaise
- 6 For $12.95
Entrees
all entrees include choice of one side & side & house salad bread will be served upon request
Sanibel Grouper
$19.95
any way you like it: blackened, broiled or fried. served with our veggie of the day
Chicken French
$15.95
do we really have to explain what it is? served with veggie of the day
Pot Roast
$17.95
slow cooked until its juicy and tender. served with veggie of the day
Sanibel King Crab Leg
one full pound of sweet alaskan king crab legs and veggie of the day
- Market Price
Pirate Pork Chops
$18.95
twin 8 oz. center cut pork chops char grilled & topped with an apple cider glaze. served with veggie of the day