Four-course dining experience $75. Customize your meal & choose your culinary journey by selecting one from each of these courses:
Un Antipasto
your small starter appetizer
Un Primo
your small pasta course
Un Secondo
your main course
Un Dolce
your small dessert
Antipasti
Choose one of the following starter appetizers
Insalata Mista
Field greens with fresh vegetables, olive oil, red wine vinegar
Stracciatella alla Romana
Classic Roman egg drop soup of chicken broth, egg, lemon, and pecorino
Polpettine di Farro con Fonduta di Pecorino Laziale
Crispy emmer wheat croquette with Lazio ewe's milk cheese fondue. The earliest evidence of similar preparations dates back to Ancient Rome, where spelt was a staple of both the legionary and popular diets. In the second book of Apicio "De Re Coquinaria" (the oldest surviving cookbook from antiquity), there are recipes for Apothermum and Farcimina, sweet and savory spelt meatballs, respectively
Antipasto Misto
Shaved Prosciutto, cheese, and marinated olives
Fiore di Zucca Ripiena di Ricotta e Salame Cotto Laziale
Fried squash blossom stuffed with ricotta and cooked salami from Lazio
Primi
Choose one of the following pasta courses
Penne con Gamberi, Zucchine e Basilico
Penne pasta with sautéed shrimp, zucchini, white wine, tomato, and basil
Gnocchi di Semolino alla Romana al Sugo di Coda
Roman semolina gnocchi baked with butter, parmigiano, and oxtail ragu
Pizzicotti alla Palestrina "Co' de Soreca" con Cozze, Ceci e Pecorino
Hand-rolled pasta with chickpeas, mussels, and pecorino. The gnocchi "coa de soreca" (literally "mouse-tail gnocchi") are a traditional fresh pasta from the Prenestini Mountains east of Rome. Born out of a humble peasant culture, this pasta takes on an elongated, cylindrical shape reminiscent of a rat's tail and is popular in local restaurants
Tonnarelli Cacio e Pepe
Roman spaghetti with savory pecorino-black pepper cream. This is one of the oldest recipes of Roman cuisine, as farmers and shepherds carried dried spaghetti, cheese, and black pepper in their bags during their travels. A simple on-the-go meal that became a staple of Roman and Italian cuisine
Pappardelle al Sugo d'Anatra (Toscana)
Bartolotta's signature wide-ribbon pasta with red wine-braised duck ragù ($6 supplemental)
Secondi
Choose one of the following main courses
Grigliata Mista di Carne
Mixed grill: beef strip loin, pork ribs, lamb chop, and Italian sausage, served with garlic-rosemary roasted potatoes ($10 supplemental)
Abbacchio in Umido
Braised lamb with white wine and herbs
Passera alla Portodanzese con Salsa al Burro e Alici
Sautéed East Coast flounder with anchovy-butter sauce
Petto d'Anatra alle Prugne, Cumino e Semi di Sesamo
Roasted duck breast with prunes, toasted cumin, and sesame seeds. An "agrodolce" (sweet and sour) recipe dating back to the Roman Empire, when cooking with dry fruits, vinegar, and certain spices was common
Saltimbocca di Pollo
Sautéed chicken breast with sage, prosciutto, and white wine. "Saltimbocca" in Italian means "it jumps in the mouth," or an "explosion of flavors." Although many food writers believe it originated in the northern city of Brescia, saltimbocca is nowadays widely considered a staple Roman dish with overwhelming popularity in the eternal city
Dolci
Choose one of the following desserts
Crostata di Ricotta e Visciole
Ewe's milk ricotta and sour cherry tart. This is an iconic dessert of the Judeo-Roman tradition, originating in the 1700's within the walls of the Roman Ghetto. It was created to circumvent edicts by Pope Pius VI that prohibited Christians from purchasing dairy products from Jews, by concealing the ricotta between layers of shortcrust pastry filled with "visciole"—a tart variety of cherries. In operation for over 250 years, Forno Boccione is one of Rome's favorite spots, an authentic tradition of the Ghetto
Crema di Limone "Costa d'Amalfi"
Chilled lemon custard with toasted meringue
Budino di Caramello
Sea salt-caramel pudding with dark chocolate ganache
Torta di Cioccolato Amaro
Flourless chocolate cake with vanilla bean crème anglaise
Classico Tiramisu' di Ristorante Bartolotta dal 1993
Our signature version of this classic dessert of layered mascarpone mousse, savoiardi cookies, espresso, and cocoa
Nestled in a historic Pabst brewery building in the heart of downtown Wauwatosa, Ristorante Bartolotta is the flagship of The Bartolotta Restaurants. Opened in 1993, Ristorante serves authentic, traditional Italian cuisine in a cozy, intimate setting.
Ristorante Bartolotta, rated four stars by the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel upon opening, continues to garner high praise with both critics and customers as Milwaukee’s best Italian restaurant. The traditional menu features handmade pasta and imported Italian ingredients, with the three-course chef’s menu changing seasonally.
Ristorante Bartolotta is led by Chef Juan Urbieta, who joined The Bartolotta Restaurants in 1998 and is known by many as one of the best Italian chefs in the Midwest.