What's wrong with this menu?
Red Hook Lobster Pound
34 South Etna Avenue
Montauk, NY 11954
Uber
MORE PHOTOS
more menus
Main Menu
Catering Menu
Main Menu
Lobster Rolls
One quarter pound of Maine claw and knuckle meat piled on a New England split-top bun served with a Brooklyn Brine Pickle.
Maine Lobster Roll
$20.00
Maine Lobster tossed with a touch of homemade mayo piled on to a buttery split-top bun and topped with paprika and scallions.
Connecticut Lobster Roll
$20.00
Served warm with butter and lemon topped with paprika and scallions.
Tuscan Lobster Roll
$20.00
Tossed in a basil vinaigrette.
Bikini Style
$20.00
Any of the above rolls served on a bed of lettuce.
Blt Lobster Roll
$22.00
Lobster + Bacon = Heaven. Chipotle mayo, Applewood smoked bacon, topped with paprika and scallions.
Goodness
Tuna Melt
$15.00
Fresh local Tuna tossed in a homemade sweet pickle mayo with fried onion and melted cheese.
Caesar Salad
Classic Caesar with house-made dressing and croutons.
- $10.00
- With Shrimp $14.00
- With Lobster $20.00
Cobbster Salad
$20.00
Maine Lobster, bacon, bleu cheese, tomatoes, egg, crispy onions with avocado vinaigrette.
- With Shrimp
- $14.00
Lobster Mac & Cheese
$16.00
Maine Lobster and organic pasta swimming in our five-cheese mac sauce.
Peel and Eat Shrimp
Thrown around in a bunch of Old Bay and served with cocktail sauce.
- (12) $12.00
Elote
Roasted and sweet corn in a cup with chipotle mayo, cotija cheese and chili powder.
- $7.00
- With Lobster $15.00
Fried Clam Roll with Fries
$14.00
with citrus aioli.
Fried Clam Basket
$13.00
Fresh clam strips, fried served with our homemade tarter sauce.
Land Lubbers
Red Hook Dawg
$6.00
Bacon is Better! All natural Berkshire pork and bacon hot dawg.
Grilled Cheese
$5.00
Cheddar and Fontina on a top-split bun.
BLT
$9.00
Applewood smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato and chipotle mayo.
Chicken Fingers with Fries
$13.00Soup
New England Clam Chowder
Creamy old-fashioned clam chowder.
- Cup $7.00
- Bowl $17.00
Downeast
Lobster, clams, haddock and mussels in a creamy tomato broth.
- Cup $7.00
- Bowl $17.00
Sides
Homemade Coleslaw
$3.00Homemade Potato Salad
$3.00Watermelon, Feta and Mint Salad
$7.00Mac & Cheese
$7.00French Fries
$6.00Sweet Potato Fries
$8.00Green Salad
$5.00Corn on the Cob
$4.00Mexican Corn on the Cob
$6.00
Steamed corn topped with chipotle mayo, cotija cheese and chili powder.
Elote
Roasted corn in a cup with chipotle mayo, cotija cheese and chili powder. With or without Lobster.
- $7.00
- $15.00
Breakfast
Served Saturdays and Sundays 11am to 1pm holiday weekends 10am - 2pm.
Monteith
$16.00
Lobster, bacon fontina and eggs.
Avocado Toast
Sourdough bread w/ tomato jam & slices of ripe avocado with or without Lobster.
- $12.00
- $18.00
Morning After
$7.00
Bacon, egg and cheese on a grilled, buttered split top bun.
Stoked Parfait
$8.00
Surfer gal granola, Fage Greek yogurt, fresh fruit and catskill honey.
Side of Bacon
$4.50Fresh Fruit
$7.00Hard Boiled Eggs
$0.75Toby's Cold Brew
- Small $5.00
- Large $7.00
Lobster Rolls
Maine Style
Fresh Maine lobster tossed in homemade mayonnaise, dusted with paprika, sprinkled with scallions and served on a warm, grilled split-top bun.
- Full Lobster Rolls $18.00
- Half Lobster Rolls $9.50
Connecticut Style
Fresh Maine lobster poached in warm drawn butter, lemon and served on a warm, grilled split-top bun.
- Full Lobster Rolls $18.00
- Half Lobster Rolls $9.50
Tuscan Style
Fresh Maine lobster tossed with a house made basil vinaigrette and served on a warm, grilled split-top bun.
- Full Lobster Rolls $18.00
- Half Lobster Rolls $9.50
Lobster Blt
Fresh Maine lobster tossed with chipotle mayonnaise, paprika, lettuce, tomato & bacon, served on a grilled split-top bun.
- Full Lobster Rolls $20.00
- Half Lobster Rolls $10.50
Surf Turf & Lobster Roll
Fresh Maine lobster poached in warm drawn butter, roasted prime rib & horseradish mayo served on a grilled split-top bun.
- Full Lobster Rolls $24.00
- Half Lobster Rolls $15.50
Bikini Style
Any lobster roll served sans bread on a bed of greens.
Sides & Salads
Lobster Mac and Cheese
Fresh Maine lobster bathed in a four-cheese sauce and tossed with organic pasta.
- Full Tray (Serves 35) $350.00
- Half Tray (Serves 12) $120.00
Mac and Cheese
- Full Tray (Serves 35) $150.00
- Hall Tray (Serves 12) $50.00
Green Salad
Seasonal greens and vegetables tossed with a house made basil vinaigrette.
- Full Tray (Serves 25) $125.00
- Half Tray (Serves 10) $50.00
Roasted Fingerling & Tomato Salad
Green beans, roasted corn and arugula.
- Full Tray (Serves 40) $160.00
- Half Tray (Serves 15) $60.00
Pickled Cucumber & Red Onion Salad
- Full Tray (Serves 40) $160.00
- Half Tray (Serves 15) $60.00
Watermelon, Feta & Mint Salad Tossed with Balsamic
- Full Tray (Serves 40) $150.00
- Half Tray (Serves 15) $50.00
Quinoa, Almond, Cranberry & Feta Salad
- Full Tray (Serves 40) $200.00
- Half Tray (Serves 15) $75.00
Coleslaw / Potato Salad
- Full Tray (Serves 60) $120.00
- Half Tray (Serves 25) $50.00
Party Specials
Unlimited Lobster Roll Bar
Let's get crazy! Unlimited lobster rolls in three styles - Maine, Connceticut and Tuscan - half or full.
- (per Guest per Hour) $50.00
Raw Oyster Bar
Not only does Red Hook Lobster Pound serve the freshest lobster in NYC, we are now serving fresh oysters. All oysters shucked at our mobile raw bar, presented on crushed ice and served with mignoette, cocktail sauce, horseradish and lemon. Minimum 200 piece per order required.
- Oyster a La Carte At Market Price
Seafood Fest with Lobster
Steamed clams, Andouille sausage, potatoes, shrimp, mussels and corn on the cob topped with Maine lobster. Served family-style with coleslaw.
- (per guest) $55.00
Seafood Boil
Steamed clams. Andouille sausage, potatoes. shrimp, mussels and corn on the cob, served family-style with coleslaw.
- (per guest) $30.00
Drop off Catering and Pick up Orders
Perfect for office parties, lunches and small celebrations. We require 24 hours notice to honor drop off catering orders as well as a $200 order minimum and $50 delivery fee. No minimum for pick up orders. Free delivery on your next two orders if you refer us to another customer who orders from us!
Party Box of Lobster Rolls
Choice of Maine and Tuscan Style Rolls.
- Box of 12 Lobster Rolls $216.00
- Box of 24 Lobster Half Rolls $228.00
Lunch Box of Lobster Rolls
Choice of Maine and Tuscan Style Rolls with individual servings of coleslaw and chips.
- Box of 12 Lobster Rolls $276.00
- Box of 24 Lobster Half Rolls $348.00
Tray of Lobster Mac and Cheese
- Full Tray (Serves 35) $315.00
- Half Tray (Serves 12) $120.00
Coleslaw or Potato Salad
- Full Tray (Serves 60) $120.00
- Half Tray (Serves 25) $50.00
Lobster Roll Diy Kits
Do it yourself Lobster Rolls! Available in Maine. Connecticut and Tuscan Styles.
- Package for 4 $68.00
- Package for 8 $136.00
Lobster Meat and Salad
- Maine Style Lobster Salad (per lb) $65.00
- Fresh-Picked Lobster Meat (per lb) $65.00
Party Box of BLT Lobster Rolls
Chipotle mayo, applewood smoked bacon, paprika & scallions.
- Box of 12 Lobster Rolls $240.00
- Box of 24 Lobster Half Rolls $252.00
Lunch Box of BLT Lobster Rolls
BLT Lobster Rolls with individual servings of coleslaw & chips.
- Box of 12 Lobster Rolls $300.00
- Box of 24 Lobster Half Rolls $372.00
Tray of Mac and Cheese
- Full Tray (Serves 35) $150.00
- Half Tray (Serves 12) $50.00
Green or Caesar Salad
- Full Tray (Serves 25) $125.00
- Half Tray (Serves 10) $50.00
- Full Tray with Lobster (Serves 35) $250.00
- Half Tray with Lobster (Serves 12) $100.00
- Full Tray with Shrimp (Serves 35) $175.00
- Half Tray with Shrimp (Serves 12) $70.00
A La Carte Drop off Menu
We can deliver a custom made drop off or pick up menu as well!
Maine Style
Fresh Maine lobster tossed in homemade mayo, with paprika, scallions and served on a grilled split-top bun.
- Full Lobster Rolls $18.00
- Half Lobster Rolls $9.50
Tuscan Style
Fresh Maine lobster tossed with a house made basil vinaigrette and served on a grilled split-top bun.
- Full Lobster Rolls $18.00
- Half Lobster Rolls $9.50
Lobster BLT
Fresh Maine lobster tossed with chipotle mayonnaise, paprika, lettuce, tomato & bacon, served on a grilled split-top bun.
- Full Lobster Rolls $20.00
- Hall Lobster Rolls $10.50
Lobster Mac and Cheese
$14.00Mac and Cheese
$6.00Caesar Salad
- With Lobster $19.00
- With Shrimp $14.00
Green Salad
- With Lobster $14.00
- With Shrimp $9.00
Coleslaw or Potato Salad
$3.00Cape Cod Potato Chips
$2.00
Original or Salt & Vinegar.