The Best Seafood House on Long Island. Period.' is what food critic Peter Gionatti of Newsday said in his recent three and a half star review of The Plaza Cafe. Service was rated as 'Exceptional' and the ambiance as 'Excellent'. After 22 acclaimed seasons as Southamptons highest rated restaurant, The Plaza Cafe 'is better in every way'. The relaxing bar area now offers an innovative food and drink menu and al fresco dining is also an option. The Plaza Cafe has also added a Food Truck that caters private events as well as lunch on weekends at the restaurant.