What's wrong with this menu?
Pizzeria Scotty
9022 W Oklahoma Ave
West Allis, WI 53227
Uber
MORE PHOTOS
Main Menu
Pizza
We feature real Wisconsin cheese on our pizzas, which are made with premium ingredients & freshly made dough.
Traditional Thin Crust Cheese Pizza
We roll it thin & cook it crisp. We'll load it up with the toppings of your choice, then pile on real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese.
- Small 10" $11.10
- Small 10" Gluten-Free $13.10
- Medium 12" $13.40
- Large 14" $16.40
- X-Large 16" $19.00
Toppings (each)
Ingredients: Italian Sausage, Canadian Bacon, Pepperoni, Bacon, Ground Beef, Fresh Mushrooms, Onions, Green Peppers, Sliced Tomatoes, Green Olives, Black Olives, Jalapeño Peppers, Pineapple, Anchovies, Extra Cheese, Fajita Chicken (available at an additional charge).
- Small 10" $1.75
- Medium 12" $1.95
- Large 14" $2.15
- X-large 16" $2.35
1/2 Toppings (each)
Ingredients: Italian Sausage, Canadian Bacon, Pepperoni, Bacon, Ground Beef, Fresh Mushrooms, Onions, Green Peppers, Sliced Tomatoes, Green Olives, Black Olives, Jalapeño Peppers, Pineapple, Anchovies, Extra Cheese, Fajita Chicken (available at an additional charge).
- Small 10" $0.87
- Medium 12" $0.97
- Large 14" $1.07
- X-large 16" $1.17
Double Dough Cheese Pizza
This pizza features a hand-rolled edge & is twice as thick as our traditional thin crust pizza.
- Small 10" $12.15
- Medium 12" $14.70
- Large 14" $17.95
- X-large 16" $20.80
Chicago Pan Cheese Pizza
The pizza that made chicago famous! Delicious, thick & perfectly baked crust that features a double portion of cheese.
- Small 10" $13.45
- Medium 12" $16.00
- Large 14" $19.25
- X-large 16" $22.10
Stuffed Cheese Pizza
A 2" thick masterpiece, baked like a pie, with a double portion of cheese & the toppings of your choice stuffed inside.
- Small 10" $14.45
- Medium 12" $17.00
- Large 14" $20.25
- X-large 16" $23.10
Pizza By The Slice
Monday-Sunday 11:00 A.M. - 2:00 P.M.
Cheese Slice
$3.50Pepperoni Slice
$3.50Sausage Slice
$3.50Thin Crust Specialty Pizza
These delectable delights are sure to tantalize your taste buds. Choose the combination of your choice. Pricing below is based on traditional thin crust pizzas. Specialty crusts are available upon request for a small additional charge.
Buffalo Chicken Deluxe
Authentic buffalo wing sauce loaded with chunks of zesty fajita chicken, smothered with mozzarella & mild cheddar, then topped with premium blue cheese crumbles.
- Small 10" $17.20
- Medium 12" $21.20
- Large 14" $23.20
- X-large 16" $26.40
Ultimate 5 Cheese Pizza
Not a meat eater? Try this perfect blend of monterey jack, mild cheddar, mozzarella & imported shredded parmesan cheese topped with premium crumbled blue cheese. Outstanding!!!
- Small 10" $17.20
- Medium 12" $21.20
- Large 14" $23.20
- X-large 16" $26.40
Sausage Supreme
Sausage, Onion, Green Peppers & Mushrooms.
- Small 10" $17.20
- Medium 12" $21.20
- Large 14" $23.20
- X-large 16" $26.40
Vegetarian Deluxe
Mushrooms, Onions, Green Peppers & Sliced Tomatoes.
- Small 10" $17.20
- Medium 12" $21.20
- Large 14" $23.20
- X-large 16" $26.40
Pepperoni Supreme
Pepperoni, Mushrooms, Onions & Green Peppers.
- Small 10" $17.20
- Medium 12" $21.20
- Large 14" $23.20
- X-large 16" $26.40
Bbq Chicken Deluxe
White meat chicken, bbq sauce, mozzarella, red onions, tomatoes, topped with cheddar / jack cheese.
- Small 10" $17.20
- Medium 12" $21.20
- Large 14" $23.20
- X-large 16" $26.40
Ranch-style Bacon & Chicken Supreme
Premium ranch dressing, loaded with chunks of juicy fajita chicken & primed with real wisconsin mozzarella cheese. All this veiled with a manly portion of real bacon!!
- Small 10" $17.20
- Medium 12" $21.20
- Large 14" $23.20
- X-large 16" $26.40
Our Famous Scotty's "extreme Pizza"
Not for the faint of heart! A robust blend of Italian Sausage, Canadian Bacon, Ground Beef, Pepperoni, Bacon, Fresh Mushrooms, Onions, Green Peppers, Sliced Tomatoes, Black & Green Olives. This creation is sure to overwhelm your hunger with each flavorful bite.
- Small 10" $20.00
- Medium 12" $24.00
- Large 14" $27.10
- X-large 16" $31.20
Appetizers
Deep Fried Garlic Bread Sticks
Strips of fresh dough, deep fried then basted with creamy garlic butter & topped with grated Romano cheese. Served with our home-made marinara sauce.
- Regular / Half Pound $4.10
- Half Tray / Two Pounds $11.30
- Full Tray / Four Pounds $20.80
Mozzarella Sticks
Served with marinara.
- Regular / Six $7.25
- Half Tray / Twenty-four $28.10
- Full Tray / Forty-eight $54.30
Garlic Bread
- plain $2.85
- with melted mozzarella add $2.05
Wings
Deep fried to perfection! Served with ranch, blue cheese, bbq or buffalo sauce.
- Regular / Half Dozen $8.50
- Half Tray / Two Dozen $32.00
- Full Tray / Four Dozen $62.00
Breaded Mushrooms
- Regular / Half Pound $4.40
- Half Tray / Two Pounds $15.35
- Full Tray / Four Pounds $29.30
French Fries
- Regular / Half Pound $2.65
- Half Tray / Two Pounds $9.10
- Full Tray / Four Pounds $16.80
Boneless Wings
Crispy outside with a tender inside.
- Regular / Half Pound $8.50
- Half Tray / Two Pounds $32.00
- Full Tray / Four Pounds $62.00
Chicken
Wings
Deep fried to perfection! Served with ranch, blue cheese, bbq or buffalo sauce.
- Regular / Half Dozen $8.50
- Half Tray / Two Dozen $32.00
- Full Tray / Four Dozen $62.00
Boneless Wings
Crispy outside with a tender inside.
- Regular / Half Pound $8.50
- Half Tray / Two Pounds $32.00
- Full Tray / Four Pounds $62.00
Pasta
A generous portion of pasta with homemade marinara served with cole slaw, french bread & grated romano cheese.
Baked Lasagna
Add meatballs - personal $3.45, half tray $9.85, full tray $18.00.
- Personal $11.75
- Half Tray $44.50
- Full Tray $87.00
Mostaccioli
Add meatballs - personal $3.45, half tray $9.85, full tray $18.00.
- Personal $7.10
- Half Tray $26.00
- Full Tray $46.00
Cheese Ravioli
Add meatballs - personal $3.45, half tray $9.85, full tray $18.00.
- Personal $8.60
- Half Tray $31.00
- Full Tray $56.00
Sandwiches
Milwaukee's finest Italian sandwiches! Our bread is baked fresh daily. Our lean, thin sliced roast beef is simmered in authentic, homemade Chicago-style beef juice. Our meatballs are simply superb. Add on garlic bread $1.30, melted mozzarella $1.95.
The "Big Cheese"
$7.80
The boss of all Italian sandwiches. One-third of a pound of delicious, thin sliced Italian beef served on French bread smothered with melted mozzarella.
Italian Beef
$6.60
Sliced thin & piled high.
Meatball Sandwich
$6.15
Three 2 oz. meatballs served with marinara.
Pizza Bread
- $6.10
- Each Additional Topping $1.10
Garlic Bread
$2.85
Sweet or hot peppers on any sandwich.
Salads
Dressing choices: ranch, blue cheese, creamy caesar or italian.
Caesar Salad
Add fajita chicken - regular $3.50, half tray $10.25, full tray $18.50.
- Regular $3.50
- Half Tray $10.25
- Full Tray $18.50
Garden Salad
Add fajita chicken - regular $3.50, half tray $10.25, full tray $18.50.
- Regular $3.50
- Half Tray $10.25
- Full Tray $18.50
Side Orders
Beef Juice
$0.90Marinara Sauce
$0.90Pizza Sauce
$0.90Hot Peppers
$0.90Sweet Peppers
$0.90
Sautéed green peppers.
Meatballs (3)
$3.45Anchovies
$1.95Cole Slaw
$1.20French Bread
- 6" Loaf $1.20
Ranch or Blue Cheese Dressing
$0.90Buffalo or Bbq Sauce
$0.90Pepperoncini
$0.90Hot Giardiniera
$0.90Beverages
We serve quality Pepsi products.
Pepsi
- By The Can $1.25
- 2-Liter $3.25
- 6-Pack Can $7.15
Diet Pepsi
- By The Can $1.25
- 2-Liter $3.25
- 6-Pack Can $7.15
Mountain Dew
- By The Can $1.25
- 2-liter Bottle $3.25
- 6-Pack Can $7.15
Bottled Water
- By The Bottle $1.25
- 6 Pack $7.15
Weekday Pasta Specials
Served with French bread, cole slaw & grated romano cheese.
Monday & Tuesday - Mostaccioli Dinner
$6.10Wednesday - Cheese Ravioli
$7.60Thursday - Baked Lasagna
$10.75Early Bird Special
Every Monday-Thursday between (4pm -7pm) purchase any 16" x-large pizza at regular price & get $11.99 off any second pizza valued at $11.99 or more.
Browse Nearby
General Info
Payment Types
All Major Cards
Cuisine
Pizza
American - Traditional
Italian
Sandwiches
Meals
Lunch
Dinner
Hours
Monday:
11:00am - 10:00pm
Tuesday:
11:00am - 10:00pm
Wednesday:
11:00am - 10:00pm
Thursday:
11:00am - 10:00pm
Friday:
11:00am - 11:00pm
Saturday:
11:00am - 11:00pm
Sunday:
11:00am - 10:00pm
About Us
Pizzeria Scotty is the culmination of my restaurant career dating back nearly 40 years. In 1968, at the age of 15, I got my first restaurant job working as a busboy at Arlington Park Racetrack in suburban Chicago. From that point on, I hoped that someday my name would be on the sign over the front door of my own business. With few exceptions, I have spent my entire life in the hospitality business.
During the summer of 1972, in the waning years of the Vietnam era, I was drafted into military service. I chose to serve in the U.S. Marine Corps. Having the ambition to excel, I was twice meritoriously promoted and within 17 months achieved the rank of non-commissioned officer.
Upon my honorable discharge in 1974, until the present, I have worked in the restaurant and hospitality business as a busboy, dishwasher, cook, bartender, manager and general manager. In August of 1985, I moved to Wisconsin to open and manage a new pizzeria located at 9809 W. Oklahoma Avenue in Milwaukee, exactly where Pizzeria Scotty is located today. Since early 1995, I have been the sole owner of that pizzeria. For the first 22 years I did business under a different name, through a licensing agreement with a family-owned pizza group out of Chicago. With a desire to finally put