A purée of black & green olives served with our Nostalgia flatbread
Nostalgia Olive Spread
$8.00
Fresh mozzarella, sliced tomatoes, extra virgin olive oil & basil
Nostalgia Pasta Side
$7.00
Your choice of any Nostalgia pasta - Alfredo, Pomodoro, Bolognese
Garlic Cheese Bread
Parmesan, mozzarella cheese, garlic & extra virgin olive oil
$5.00
$7.00
Gluten-free available
$2.00
Italian Sausage & Peppers
$9.00
Italian sausage, bell peppers, onions & garlic sautéed in olive oil
Antipasto Italiano
$9.00
Prosciutto on a bed of arugula lightly tossed with lemon, olive oil and asiago cheese.
Homemade Soups & Fresh Salads
We start out with the freshest local produce, tossed to order with our homemade dressings (available in petite, entree and family sizes). Our soups are always made from scratch, daily
Stracciatella Soup
Egg drop, fresh spinach and pasting noodles in a homemade chicken broth
Cup$5.00
Bowl$7.00
Tomato Basil Soup
Savory and succulent, made with fresh tomatoes
Cup$5.00
Bowl$7.00
Soup Of The Day
Cup$5.00
Bowl$7.00
Nostalgia House Salad
House Italian dressing on a bed of fresh field greens, sliced tomatoes, croûtons & Parmesan
Petite$5.00
Entreé$10.00
Family$17.00
Greek Salad
Greek dressing, fresh field greens, feta, red onions, mild peppers, kalamata olives & beets
Petite$5.00
Entreé$10.00
Family$17.00
Michigan Salad
Raspberry vinaigrette with red onions, dried cherries & bleu cheese
Petite$5.00
Entreé$10.00
Family$17.00
Caesar Salad
Caesar dressing, romaine lettuce, croûtons & Parmesan
Petite$5.00
Entreé$10.00
Family$17.00
Chef Mario's Sandwiches
(Available on our lunch menu only) All combo sandwiches are served with a cup of homemade soup
Fresh mozzarella, sliced tomatoes, extra virgin olive oil & basil
Chicken Caesar
$9.00
Char-grilled chicken breast, romaine lettuce, Caesar dressing & Parmesan cheese
Nostalgia Pasta
All pasta entrées are served with a cup of our homemade soup or a petite salad and house-baked bread
Fettuccine Alfredo
$15.00
Fettuccine noodles cooked perfectly with a sauce made from Parmesan cheese, cream & garlic
Pasta Pomodoro
$13.00
Penne noodles tossed in a savory tomato sauce
Pasta Bolognese
$16.00
Fettuccine noodles tossed with our house-made bolognese sauce
Wood Fired Pizza
Our wood-fired pizza is what made us who we are. All pizza's are available in small (4 slices) and large (8 slices) sizes. Feeling creative? Tell us that you would like to build your own pizza!
Mozzarella, green pepper, red pepper, mushrooms & white onions
$9.00
$16.00
Dootz Melone
Mozzarella, pepperoni, Italian sausage, ham & bacon
$9.00
$16.00
Little Guy
Mozzarella, pepperoni, Italian sausage & mild peppers
$9.00
$15.00
Pepperoni Classic
Pepperoni & mozzarella
$8.00
$13.00
Aloha Hawaiian
Mozzarella, bacon, ham & pineapple
$9.00
$15.00
Pizza Saltimboca
Fresh mozzarella, bacon, arugula, fresh lemon & Romano cheese
$9.00
$15.00
Four Seasons
Mozzarella, ham, mushrooms, artichokes, kalamata olives
$9.00
$16.00
Calabrese
Fresh mozzarella, soppressata, red onion & garlic
$9.00
$16.00
The Cheese Classic
Mozzarella cheese
$7.00
$12.00
Nostalgic Desserts
All desserts are made fresh, in-house
Fresh-Filled Cannoli
Available in original, mocha, Oreo and seasonal
Reg$4.00
Try a mini for$2.00
S'more Pizza
Chocolate chips, toasted marshmallows, graham cracker & Hershey's chocolate
Four slices$7.00
Dulce Leché
$7.00
Vanilla white cake with sweet cream filling and torched sugar topping
New York Style Cheesecake
$7.00
Your traditional cheesecake with a graham cracker crust
Nutella Pizza
The chocolate lovers favorite! Made with real Nutella
Four slices$7.00
Beer & Wine
Red Wine
Apothic Red, California
A blend of Zinfandel, Syrah and Cabernet with intense fruit aromas and flavors of rhubarb, black cherry, chocolate and vanilla with a velvety, smooth finish
Montepulciano D'Abruzzo, Italy
a deeply colored wine with pepper and spice notes. It can be described as "rustic" with low acidic balance
Mirassou Pinot Noir, California
has flavors of cherry, strawberry and red currant, which are supported by light vanilla and oak notes. This wine is well balanced with a round, full mouthfeel
Canyon Road Cabernet, California
A medium-bodied wine with rich and flavorful hint of ripe raspberry and a velvety smooth finish
Red Diamond Merlot, Washington
A soft and versatile Merlot with flavors of blackberries, cherries and plums with sweet fruit and a spice and toasty oak finish
Caposaldo Chianti, Italy
Italy's classic red wine. A ruby red wine with fruity aromas, smooth texture and excellent structure
White Wine
Apothic White, California
An blend combining chardonnay, riesling and moscato to create a luscious, vibrant wine. Intense flavors of peach, pineapple, honey and vanilla spice make for a smooth finish
Ruffino Pinot Grigio, Italy
A fragrant, elegant wine with aromas of flowers and pears with a mineral touch, crisp and dry with lasting finish
Chateau Grand Traverse Sweet Harvest Riesling, Traverse City
A sweeter-style white wine displaying flavors of apricot, melon and honey with a sweet finish.
William Hill Chardonnay Central Coast Collection, California
Aromas and flavors of ripe tree fruit, underscored by hints of brown spice, citrus and tropical fruit with a smooth and creamy finish
Beer Selection
local craft & domestic favorites
Snapshot, New Belgium
Snap! You Just captured an unfiltered wheat beer full of refreshment and a smile-inducing flash of tart at the finish
Red, Rochester Mills
This deep red colored ale is full of caramelly sweet malt flavor, yet nicely balanced with a smooth finish
Milkshake Stout, Rochester Mills
This stout is not as bitter as the Sacri-licious Stout. It is brewed with milk sugar(lactose) to impart a fuller body and sweeter palate
Cornerstone IPA, Rochester Mills
This unfiltered amber ale is packed full of hop bitterness, flavor and aroma. IPA is the most bitter beer style and it is enjoyed by people we refer to as "hopheads." We dry hop this beer with a combination of English and American hop varieties for a wonderfully aromatic finish
Fat Tire, New Belgium
Belgian beers use a far broader palette of ingredients (fruits, spices, esoteric yeast strains) with a toasty, biscuit-like malt flavors coasting in equilibrium with hoppy freshness
Omission Lager, Widmer Brothers Brewery
An award winning, refreshing and crisp beer, brewed in the traditional lager style. The aromatic hop profile offers a unique, easy-drinking beer for those looking for a lighter and approachable beer style
gluten-free
Omission Pale Ale, Widmer Brothers Brewery
Bold and hoppy and brewed to showcase the Cascade hop profile. Amber in color and the floral aroma is complimented by it's caramel malt body
We're more than just pizza, though. What makes us unique is our commitment to quality and freshness. That's how it was done back in the day, and that's exactly what's wrong with most of today's restaurants... They've changed their ways. Chef Mario had the unique privilege to study in Rome before opening Pizza Nostalgia, and one of the most important things he brought back was to stay true to your roots. Pizza Nostalgia is much more than just pizza. In addition to that, there are homemade pasta dishes, sandwiches crafted to order with wood-fired bread, delicious soups made daily and we've been told that our fresh-filled cannoli is an absolute must-have. Check out our menu and if you plan on dining in with us, our drink menu features a great beer and wine selection.