Baguette bread with slow roasted tomatoes and mozzarella
vegetarian
Poached Pear Salad
$9.00
poached in white wine served with goat cheese
vegetarian
Smoked Trout with Turnip Greens
$9.00
Lightly blanched turnip greens with smoked Norwegian steelhead trout tossed in light sweet chili sauce.
Allergens
fish
Chip Shop Curry
$7.00
vegetarian
Soups
Sweet Potato, Apple & Ginger with Pepper Jack Melt
$14.00
gluten-free
Potato and Onion with Bacon & Brie Melt
$14.00
gluten-free
Famous Grilled Cheese & Tomato Soup
$14.00
vegetarian
Soup of the Day
$5.00
$7.00
Black Bean & Tomato Soup with Lime and Cilantro & Pepperjack Melt
$14.00
Cock-a-leekie Soup with Gouda Grilled Cheese
$14.00
Scottish classic dating from 1598, with leeks, prunes and chicken
Puree of Cauliflower Soup with English Cheddar Grilled Cheese
$14.00
Sandwiches
Served with Kettle Chips
Payne's Club House
bacon, brie, spinach, turkey, tomato, grilled
Half$8.00
Whole$14.00
Rye Reuben
$14.00
roast beef, Swiss cheese, sauerkraut, Thousand Island, rye bread
Pepperoni BBQ Bourriche
$12.00
pepperoni, mozzarella, our sweet barbeque sauce
Apple Walnut & Brie Panini
$14.00
vegetarian
Goat Cheese Club Wrap
$14.00
bacon, turkey, goat cheese, spinach, tomato, in a tomato basil wrap
Beef Burger Royale and Fries
$16.00
grass fed beef, Swiss cheese, caramelized onion, tomato served with French fries and fried egg on top (optional with potato chips $10)
Veggie Burger Royale and fries
$14.00
corn, black bean, red pepper & quinoa burger, tomato, sprouts, coleslaw served with French fries and over easy egg (optional potato chips substitution $10)
vegetarian, vegan
Desserts
Sticky Toffee Pudding
$8.00
Bread Pudding with Caramel
$8.00
Rhubarb Crumble with Granola
$8.00
American Brownie
$8.00
Homemade, warm brownie with vanilla, hot fudge and strawberries.
Christmas Eve: 9am-4pm
Christmas Day: Closed
Dec. 26th:12pm-10pm
New Year's Eve:9am-10pm
New Year's Day: CLOSED
About Us
When Stephen Payne decided to make his home in Grant County, Indiana, after a long journey from England to Los Angeles took him finally on a pilgrimage to the birth place of James Dean, Paynes Custard and Coffee was born. Built to provide a charismatic and eclectic venue for locals to relax and socialize, Payne's has developed into a full-service restaurant that offers an intimate and unique dining experience. Hidden just off Exit 259 on the I69, where the communities of Marion, Gas City, and Upland join, Payne's is a true hidden treasure in Grant County, Indiana that the locals adore and travelers make a point to stop and visit.
Stop by for a wide range of healthy and nutritious breakfasts, your morning coffee, or enjoy your lunch on the terrace with the delicious Soup du Jour, wonderful fresh salads and specialty sandwiches. In the evening Payne's offers an innovative dinner menu that's often changing,all made with the freshest local ingredients and pasture raised meat. Payne's closely supports local art and culture, and often hosts acoustic concerts, as well as art/photography shows throughout the year. We have selected the best Indiana craft beers and boutique wines to complement our meals.