Hours: Mon-Thu 10:30 am - 9 pm, Fri -Sat 10:30 am - 9 pm, Sunday 12.00 pm - 8:00pm Delivery, Sunday 12.00 pm - 8.00pm, Dine in 12.00 - 7.00pm Order On Line www.toasttab.com/paulspizzashop
Appetizers
All appetizers come with in house Ranch or Marinara Sauce
Cheesey Bread
$9.00
Puffy Panned dough, with extra cheese, Garlic Butter, & Romano Seasoning on top w/ Marinara Sauce Wildly Popular!!
Pizza Bread
$5.00
w/ Marinara Sauce
Provolone Cheese Bread
$3.00
on sub roll, Provolone Cheese & Garlic Butter
French Fries
Small$2.25
Large$2.75
Pepperoni Rolls - The Best!
w/ Romano Seasoning and Marinara Sauce for Dipping (or Ranch)
3 for$5.75
6 for$10.75
Mozzarella Sticks
You know what these are!
4 pc$2.99
6 pc$3.99
Fried Ravioli
A tasty new addition.
8 pc, stuffed with Ricotta Cheese$4.99
8 pc stuffed with Jalapeno Cheese$4.99
Wisconsin Cheese Curds
$3.99
6 Oz, Quantity Varies
Jalapeno Poppers
$3.99
Cheddar Stuffed Jalapenos, Breaded and Fried. Quantity 5 (no dipping sauce)
Hot Wings
These are Special! Try our new flavors!
Traditional Wings - No Batter
Various sauces available; served with Celery and Bleu Cheese or Ranch for dipping
10 Wings$12.00
15 Wings$17.00
25 Wings$26.00
Wing Sauces: Traditional and New
Traditional Buffalo:- Mild, Medium, Hot, Extra hot. New Additions:- Sweet Teriyaki, Sweet Chili (a little spicy), Garlic Parmesan, Ghost Pepper, Gochu-Jang, & Lemon Pepper dry rub
Paul's Signature Wings
Mild Buffalo with Minced Garlic and Romano Seasoning
Additional$1.00
Paul's BBQ Sauce
Made in House
Additional$1.00
Boneless Wings - with Batter
Served with Bleu Cheese, Ranch, Honey Mustard, BBQ Sauce, or any of our wing sauces for dipping
Small$11.00
Large$23.00
Combination Pizzas
You'll Taste The Difference! We start with old-fashioned dough (made here daily), add our unique rich premium pizza sauce and then use whole-milk mozzarella cheese! Add our signature Romano Seasoning for $0.60!
Supreme
Your 5 Favorite Toppings! Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Black Olives, Mushrooms, Onions
10" Small$13.95
12" Medium$16.95
14" Large$20.95
Veggie
Healthy! Black Olives, Green Olives, Mushrooms, Onions, Green Peppers, Tomatoes
10" Small$13.95
12" Medium$16.95
14" Large$20.95
Meat Lover
If you just love meat! Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Canadian Bacon, Hamburger, Real Bacon
10" Small$13.95
12" Medium$16.95
14" Large$20.95
Masterpiece Special
"Everything on it!" Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Canadian Bacon, Hamburger, Black Olives, Green Olives, Mushrooms, Green Peppers, Onions, Extra Cheese
10" Small$15.00
12" Medium$19.00
14" Large$23.00
Calzone
$10.50
Big & Tasty! For one, but you might want to share. Thin pizza dough folded over, stuffed with Ricotta and Provolone cheeses, plus your choice of 3 toppings. Marinara sauce for dipping. Did we say big?
Create Your Own Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Proprietors Favourite
10" Small$10.50
12" Medium$12.95
14" Large$14.95
Each Additional MeatTopping
Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Canadian Bacon, Hamburger, Real Bacon, Chicken Breast, Spicy sausage, Sliced Meatballs*, Smoked Sausage*. . . .* Extra Cost
10" Small$1.75
12" Medium$2.00
14" Large$2.25
Each Additional Vegetable Topping
Black Olive, Green Olive, Mushroom, Onion, Tomato, Green Pepper, Red Onion,
Extra Cheese, Extra Sauce, Feta Cheese*, Alfredo*, BBQ*. . . .*Extra Cost
Small$1.75
Medium$2.00
Large$2.25
Flat Spinach or Wheat Crust
Medium size only - add $0.10
Pizza by the Slice - New York Style
each slice is a big as 3 regular slices
Cheese Slice
Add a Drink?
Slice$4.00
Slice and a Drink$5.00
Additional Slice Toppings
Add additional toppings to your slice as we make them fresh. Maximum 3
Per Topping$0.50
Pasta - Comfort Food!
Served with garlic bread slice. Add Chicken to any pasta $2. Add Side Salad:- Dinner, Greek or Caesar for $2.50
Alfredo Pasta
$9.50
Penne Pasta with Alfredo Sauce, Mushrooms, Onions
Spinach Pasta
$7.75
Penne Pasta with Spinach, Mushrooms, Garlic & Tomatoes
Kid's Spaghetti
$6.00
with Marinara Sauce or Butter or Just Plain
Spaghetti w/ Marinara Sauce
$7.50
Spaghetti w/ Meatballs
$10.00
6 hearty meatballs!
Subs - Big and Tasty!
Served with fries (try them with Romano Seasoning)
Meatball Sub
$10.00
Meatballs, Pizza Sauce, Provolone
Pizza Sub
$10.00
Canadian Bacon, Pepperoni, Diced Tomatoes, Provolone, Caesar Dressing. Pizza Sauce instead of Caesar dressing upon request
Fajita Chicken
$10.00
An employee favorite! Shredded Chicken Breast, Provolone, Bell Peppers, Onions, Mushrooms, Tomatoes, Mayo
Try it on a Deli Dough! Add
$0.50
Philly Cheese Steak
$11.99
8 oz. Steak, Swiss and Provolone cheese, mushrooms, onions, green peppers and garlic
Gyro Sub
8 oz. Gyro/Donner meat, red onions, tomatoes, feta and tzatziki sauce
Served on our Deli-Dough$11.99
Dine In Specials, Limited Time Offers
Come on in and See what we have.
Weekday Dine In Specials
Since our buffet is closed, we decided to offer some combo specials for folks that want to Dine in. Come on in and check them out
Pizza Slice Special
$10.00
1 Pizza Slice (Up to 3 toppings), 1 Side Salad, 1 bowl of Soup, 1 Drink.
Small Pizza Special
$13.00
1 small Pizza (up to 3 toppings), 1 Side Salad, 1 Bowl of Soup, 1 Drink.
Family Dine in Special
1 Large Cheese Pizza 1 Order of Cheesy Bread
Family Special$17.00
each Additional Topping$1.25
Gourmet Salads & Soups - Fresh!
Add Chicken to any salad $2, Add Garlic Bread Slice $0.50. Dressings see section below
Greek Salad
Lettuce, grape tomatoes, red onions, cucumbers, celery, feta cheese, black olives, kalamata olives, Greek vinaigrette dressing
Regular$7.50
Small$4.00
Dinner Salad
Lettuce, grape tomatoes, red onions, cucumbers, celery, black olives, choice of dressing
Regular$6.50
Small$4.00
Chinese Chicken Salad
Lettuce, broccoli, sunflower seeds, chinese fried noodles, Asian vinaigrette dressing
Regular$7.50
Small$4.00
Caesar Salad
Lettuce, shredded parmesan, croutons, house-made Caesar dressing
Regular$7.50
Small$4.00
Available Salad Dressing
House Made Ranch, House Made Ceasar, Bleu Cheese, Thousand Island, Greek Vinaigrette, Italian Vinaigrette, Asian Vinaigrette, Balsamic Vinaigrette.......Seems we like Vinaigrette, Ceasar is my personal Favorite
Made-From-Scratch Soup
Made-From-Scratch Soup
$4.00
Chefs Choice Soup of the Day, something different every day with Clam Chowder on Fridays
Specialty Pizzas - Different!
When you're looking for something different that grabs your taste buds, try these! All come with Romano Seasoning on the crust!
Margarita
Italian Flag Colors! Fresh Roma Tomatoes (marinated in olive oil & garlic), with fresh Basil and Feta Cheese
10" Small$13.25
12" Medium$17.50
14" Large$21.00
Buffalo Chicken
A new favorite! Sliced Chicken Breast marinated in Wing Sauce, Real Bacon, atop Alfredo sauce, with Ranch dressing drizzled on top
10" Small$13.25
12" Medium$17.50
14" Large$21.00
BBQ Chicken
Truly unique! BBQ sauce, Chicken, Red Onions, Real Bacon, with fresh Cilantro. Can be prepared with Smoked Sausage or a mix of both
10" Small$13.25
12" Medium$17.50
14" Large$21.00
Brenda's Special
For the diet conscious! A great-tasting pizza without cheese! Black Olives, Green Olives, Mushrooms, Onions, Green Peppers, Tomatoes and Pineapple, with Romano Seasoning. Suggestion: eat with knife and fork
10" Small$11.50
12" Medium$15.00
14" Large$17.50
Spinach & Artichoke Alfredo
Rich alfredo sauce!. Creamy Alfredo sauce, topped with Artichokes, Spinach and Mushrooms
10" Small$13.25
12" Medium$17.50
14" Large$21.00
Chicago Deep Dish
Wow! It's big, gooey and will make you dream of Chicago, even if you've never been there! Up to 4 toppings. Allow extra time to cook. Deep Dish Pizza - amazing!
No Romani Seasoning$32.00
With Ronamno Seasoning
Without pizza sauce on the top$30.00
Dessert
Sweets for the Sweet!
Cinnamon Bread
$5.50
Ooey gooey goodness!
Paul's Famous Homemade Cheesecake
$5.75
a big slice
Brownie
$1.80
There's no substitute for chocolate!
Famous Cheesecake Batter Dessert Pizza
Topped with Strawberry and Peach or Chocolate Chips w/ Chocolate Sauce
Small$12.00
Medium$16.00
Large$19.00
Blackberry Bacon Dessert Pizza
Something New,
Small$12.00
Medium$16.00
Large$19.00
Raspberry White Chocolate Dessert Pizza
Simply Delicious.
Small$12.00
Medium$16.00
Large$19.00
Beverages
Free Refills on Soft Drinks or Tea
Soft Drinks or Ice Tea
Drink$1.75
Drink with food$1.00
Kids Drink
$1.00
Bottled Water
$2.00
2-Liter Soft Drinks
$3.25
ON LINE ORDERS AVAILABLE AT
WWW.TOASTTAB.COM/PAULSPIZZASHOP
Order Online WWW.TOASTTAB.COM/PAULSPIZZASHOP
Appetizers
Cheesey Bread
$7.50
Panned pizza dough and Mozzarella with Marinara Sauce, wildly popular
Pizza Bread
$3.80
Panned pizza dough with Marinara Sauce
Provolone Cheese Bread
$2.55
On sub roll, Provolone Cheese and Garlic Butter
French Fries
Small$2.25
Large$2.75
Paul's Signature Pepperoni Rolls
The Best! Made In House. With Romano Seasoning and served with Marinara Sauce or House Ranch for dipping
3 Piece$5.50
6 Piece$10.50
Fried Ravioli
$4.99
8 piece with Marinara Sauce or House Ranch Dressing
Fried Jalapeno Ravioli
$4.99
8 Piece with Marinara Sauce or House Ranch Dressing
Mozzarella Sticks
with Marinara Sauce or House Ranch Dressing
4 Piece$2.99
6 Piece$3.99
Mozzarella Wedges
$2.99
3pc order with Marinara Sauce
Hot Wings
Traditional Wings
No Batter. With Celery and Blue Cheese or House Ranch Dressing, plus your choice of Sauce. Mild, Medium, Hot and Xtra Hot Buffalo Style Sauce New Flavors: Garlic Parmesan, Sweet Red Chili, Teriyaki, and a dry rub Lemon Pepper.
10 Wings$9.50
15 Wings$13.50
25 Wings$22.50
Paul's Signature Wings
$1.00
Mild Sauce, Garlic and Signature Romano Seasoning + $1.00
Paul's House BBQ Wings
$1.00
BBQ Sauce made in house; + $1.00
Boneless Wings
With Batter. Served with blue cheese, House Ranch, Honey Mustard, or House BBQ Sauce for dipping
Small$9.00
Large$21.00
Made From Scratch Soups
Made From Scratch Soups
Rotating collection of soups with Clam Chowder always on Fridays
Bowl (12 Oz.)$3.75
Pizza - Taste the Difference
We offer our pizzas in three different styles: Hand-tossed Dough, New Thin Crust, Gluten-Free Cauliflower Crust (Small Size only). Flat Spinach and Wheat available in Tortilla Crust (Medium Size Only) Toppings: Meat: Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Canadian Bacon, Hamburger, Bacon, Chicken Breast, Sliced Meatball (Additional Cost), Smoked Sausage (Additional Cost). Vegetables: Black Olives, Green Olives, Mushrooms, Onion, Spinach, Tomato, Green Pepper, Red Onion. Interesting: Anchovy, Jalapeno, Banana Peppers, Pineapple, Basil, Garlic, Artichoke (Additional Cost), Spicy Sausage. Cheese / Sauce: Extra Cheese, Extra Sauce, Feta Cheese (Additional Cost), Alfredo Sauce (Additional Cost), BBQ Sauce (Additional Cost). Add our signature Romano Seasoning for $0.60!
Combination Pizzas
Supreme
Your 5 favorite toppings! Pepperoni, Italian sausage, black olives, mushrooms, onions
10" Small$10.65
12" Medium$14.00
14" Large$16.75
Veggie
Healthy! Black olives, green olives, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, tomatoes
10" Small$10.50
12" Medium$13.75
14" Large$16.50
Meat Lover
If you just love meat! Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Canadian Bacon, Hamburger, Bacon
10" Small$11.10
12" Medium$14.40
14" Large$17.25
Masterpiece Special
Everything on it. Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Canadian Bacon, Hamburger, Black Olives, Green Olives, Mushrooms, Green Peppers, onions, extra cheese
10" Small$12.25
12" Medium$16.00
14" Large$18.95
Create Your Own Pizza
Flat Spinach or Wheat Crust - medium only, add $0.10
Cheese Pizza
10" Small$7.75
12" Medium$10.25
14" Large$12.25
Each Additional Topping (10" Small)
$1.00
Each Additional Topping (12" Medium)
$1.20
Each Additional Topping (14" Large)
$1.45
Pepperoni
and most 1 topping pizzas
10" Small$8.75
12" Medium$11.45
14" Large$13.70
Pizza by the Slice
Cheese Slice
$3.50
Add up To 3 Additional Regular Toppings (Each)
$0.50
Featured Items
Calzone
$9.00
Big & Tasty. For one, but enough to share. Thinned folded dough, stuffed with Ricotta and Provolone Cheeses, plus your choice of 3 toppings
Deep Dish
Chicago Style, large and cheesey. Comes with up to 4 toppings, please allow extra time to cook
$24.00
With Romano Seasoning$24.60
Without Pizza Sauce on Top$23.00
Speciality Pizzas
When you are looking for something different that grabs your taste buds, try these! All are offered with our Special Romano Seasoning on the Crust
Margherita
The Colors of the Italian Flag! Fresh Roma Tomatoes marinated in Olive Oil, Garlic, and Fresh Basil, with Feta Cheese
10" Small$12.25
12" Medium$16.00
14" Large$18.95
Buffalo Chicken
A regular favorite. Sliced Chicken Breast Marinated in Wing Sauce, Bacon atop Alfredo Sauce with a House Ranch Drizzle
10" Small$12.25
12" Medium$16.00
14" Large$18.95
BBQ Chicken
Somewhat Unique. House BBQ sauce, Chicken, Red Onion, Bacon and fresh Cilantro. Can be prepared with Smoked Sausage or a mix of both
10" Small$12.25
12" Medium$16.00
14" Large$18.95
Brenda's Special
For the diet conscious. A great tasting pizza without cheese! Black Olives, Green Olives, Mushrooms, Onions, Green Peppers, Tomatoes, and Pineapple. Special Romano Seasoning on the crust. Use a knife & fork, it's easier
10" Small$12.25
12" Medium$16.00
14" Large$18.95
Alfredo Artichoke
Rich Alfredo Sauce. Creamy Alfredo sauce with artichokes, Spinach and Mushrooms
10" Small$12.25
12" Medium$16.00
14" Large$18.95
Pasta Selection
Served with a slice of garlic bread. Add Chicken to any pasta $2. Add one side salad for $2.25
Alfredo Pasta
$8.50
Penne Pasta with Alfredo Sauce, Mushrooms, Onions
Spinach Pasta
$7.00
Penne Pasta with Spinach, Mushrooms, Garlic and Tomatoes
Kids Spaghetti
$4.50
with Marinara Sauce, Butter, or Plain
Spaghetti Traditional
$6.50
with Marinara Sauce
Spaghetti & Meatballs
$8.75
comes with 6 Hearty Meatballs
Fresh Gourmet Salads
Add Chicken to Any Salad $2, Add Garlic Bread Slice $0.50. Dressings: House Caesar, House Ranch, Blue Cheese, Honey Mustard, Thousand Island, Asian Vinaigrette, Balsamic Vinaigrette, Greek Vinaigrette, Italian Vinaigrette
Dinner Salad
Romaine Lettuce, Grape Tomatoes, Red Onions, Cucumbers, Celery, Black Olives, with a Choice of Dressing
$5.50
Small$3.25
Greek Salad
Romaine Lettuce, Grape Tomatoes, Red Onions, Cucumbers, Celery, Feta Cheese, Black Olives, Kalamata Olives with the Greek Vinaigrette Dressing
$5.50
Small$3.25
Caesar Salad
Romaine Lettuce, Shredded Parmesan, Croutons, with our House Caesar Dressing. Dressing mixed in upon request
$5.50
Small$3.25
Chinese Chicken Salad
Romaine Lettuce, Broccoli, Chicken, Sunflower Seeds, Chinese Fried Noodles, with the Asian Vinaigrette Dressing
$5.50
Small$3.25
Subs - Big and Tasty
Served with Fries (try them with Romano Seasoning)
Meatball Sub
$8.50
Meatballs, Pizza Sauce, Provolone, Diced Tomatoes
Pizza Sub
$6.95
Canadian Bacon, Pepperoni, Diced Tomatoes, Provolone and Caesar Dressing, Pizza Sauce in place of Caesar Dressing upon request
Fajita Chicken Sub
$7.25
Employee Favorite, Shredded Chicken Breast, Provolone, Green Peppers, Onions, Mushrooms, Tomatoes, Mayo
Try It on Deli Dough
$0.50
Philly Cheese Steak
$11.99
Philly Beef, Provolone and Swiss Cheese, Mushrooms, Onions, Garlic, Green Peppers, Mayo
Gyro Sub
$11.99
Gyro meat with Tzatziki Sauce, Red Onions, Tomatoes, Feta Cheese, Swiss Cheese on a Deli Dough
Desserts
Brownie
$1.80
There is absolutely no substitute for chocolate!
Homemade Cheesecake
$4.50
A big slice, with caramel or chocolate
Cinnamon Bread
$5.50
Ooey, gooey goodness!
Dessert Pizza
Based with our Famous Cheesecake Batter on pizza dough. Comes in varying styles: Fruit, Chocolate, or Tropical