What's wrong with this menu?
Paul's Live From New York Pizza
604 F St
Eureka, CA 95501
Uber
MORE PHOTOS
Main Menu
Paul's Live From New York Pizza
Toppings (10" $1 - $2.25, 12" & CA $1.50 - $2.75, 14" $3.50 - $4.75, 18" $2.75 - $4, XL $3.50 - $4.75, Sicilian $3 - $4.25): Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Garlic, Roasted Garlic, Tomato, Pesto, Black Olive, Ham, Pineapple, Salami, Mushroom, Broccoli, Bacon, Provolone, Meatball, Yellow Onion, Red Onion, Sauteed Spinach, Fresh Spinach, Jalapeno, Sun-Dried Tomato, Artichoke Hearts, Basil, Pepperoncini, Garlic Butter, Red Bell Peppers, Green Bell Peppers, Extra-Mozzarella, Cheddar, Bleu Cheese Crumble, Feta, Ricotta, Chicken, Anchovy, Pulled Pork, & Seasonal Items
14" Traditional Cheese Pizza
$19.9918" Traditional Cheese Pizza
$24.99XL Traditional Cheese Pizza
$36.99
For Dine-In Orders Only!
10" Gluten-Free Cauliflower Crust Cheese Pizza
$13.99
$2 less than your favorite 12" gluten-free pizza price
12" Gluten-Free & Dairy-Free Crust Cheese Pizza
$15.99California Crust (12") Cheese Pizza
$17.99
$2 more than your favorite 12" gluten-free pizza price
Paul's Sicilian Crust Cheese Pizza
$29.99
Add $5 to your favorite 18" specialty pizza price
Paul's Double-Crusted Specialty Pizzas
The Brooklyn
Double crusted pie filled with sautéed spinach, garlic, ricotta & mozzarella
- 14" $23.99
- 18" $38.99
- XL $49.99
The Hitman
Double crusted with sauce, pepperoni, salami, bacon, sausage & mozzarella
- 14" $23.99
- 18" $38.99
- XL $49.99
Paul's Specialty Pizzas
The Sunset
Traditional pizza with sun-dried tomato, pineapple & basil
- 10" (Gluten Free) $13.49
- 12" (Gluten Free) $14.99
- 14" $21.99
- 18" $36.99
- XL $47.99
Margherita
Mozzarella base with fresh & roasted garlic, seasoned mozzarella, pizza sauce & basil
- 10" (Gluten Free) $13.49
- 12" (Gluten Free) $14.99
- 14" $21.99
- 18" $36.99
- XL $47.99
The Vegetarian
Traditional pizza with tomato, yellow onion, garlic & broccoli
- 10" (Gluten Free) $13.49
- 12" (Gluten Free) $14.99
- 14" $21.99
- 18" $36.99
- XL $47.99
Olive Special
Traditional pizza with artichoke, black olives, garlic & basil
- 10" (Gluten Free) $13.49
- 12" (Gluten Free) $14.99
- 14" $21.99
- 18" $36.99
- XL $47.99
The Joe Namath
A pesto base, with mozzarella, tomato, garlic, & basil
- 10" (Gluten Free) $13.49
- 12" (Gluten Free) $14.99
- 14" $21.99
- 18" $36.99
- XL $47.99
La Bruschetta
Tomato & garlic base, sharp provolone, mozzarella, sun-dried tomato pesto & basil
- 10" (Gluten Free) $14.49
- 12" (Gluten Free) $15.99
- 14" $22.99
- 18" $37.99
- XL $48.99
Garden of Eden
Fresh spinach, fresh tomato, mozzarella, pizza sauce, ricotta dollops & topped with feta
- 10" (Gluten Free) $14.49
- 12" (Gluten Free) $15.99
- 14" $22.99
- 18" $37.99
- XL $48.99
The Godfather
Ricotta base with a hint of garlic, mozzarella, fresh tomato, sun-dried tomatoes & pesto
- 10" (Gluten Free) $15.49
- 12" (Gluten Free) $16.99
- 14" $23.99
- 18" $38.99
- XL $49.99
The Greek
Pesto & fresh spinach base, mozzarella, olives, sun-dried tomato, red onions and feta
- 10" (Gluten Free) $15.49
- 12" (Gluten Free) $16.99
- 14" $23.99
- 18" $38.99
- XL $49.99
Rumble in d'Bronx
Traditional cheese pizza with pineapple, bacon & jalapeno
- 10" (Gluten Free) $13.49
- 12" (Gluten Free) $14.99
- 14" $21.99
- 18" $36.99
- XL $47.99
Buffalo Chicken
Ranch sauce base, red onion, seasoned chicken, mozzarella, & buffalo sauce!
- 10" (Gluten Free) $14.49
- 12" (Gluten Free) $15.99
- 14" $22.99
- 18" $37.99
- XL $48.99
New Amsterdam
Traditional pizza with mushroom, sausage, yellow onions, & pepperoni
- 10" (Gluten Free) $13.49
- 12" (Gluten Free) $14.99
- 14" $21.99
- 18" $36.99
- XL $47.99
The BBQ Pizza
Traditional cheese pizza with chicken, bacon & red onion, then BBQ sauce on top
- 10`" (Gluten Free) $14.49
- 12" (Gluten Free) $15.99
- 14" $22.99
- 18" $37.99
- XL $48.99
Off-Broadway
Traditional pizza with mushroom, sausage, green bell pepper & yellow onion
- 10" (Gluten Free) $13.49
- 12" (Gluten Free) $14.99
- 14" $21.99
- 18" $36.99
- XL $47.99
The 'Roni Special
Traditional cheese pizza with pepperoni, basil, tomato & garlic
- 10" (Gluten Free) $13.49
- 12" (Gluten Free) $14.99
- 14" $21.99
- 18" $36.99
- XL $47.99
The Wise Guy
Traditional pizza with sausage, green peppers, yellow onions & garlic
- 10" (Gluten Free) $13.49
- 12" (Gluten Free) $14.99
- 14" $21.99
- 18" $36.99
- XL $47.99
The Hawaii 5-0
a traditional ham and pineapple pizza with bacon & BBQ sauce added
- 10" (Gluten Free) $13.49
- 12" (Gluten Free) $14.99
- 14" $21.99
- 18" $36.99
- XL $47.99
The B.L.T.
A ranch based pizza with fresh spinach, bacon, tomato & mozzarella
- 10" (Gluten Free) $13.49
- 12" (Gluten Free) $14.99
- 14" $21.99
- 18" $36.99
- XL $47.99
4 Meat Special
Traditional pizza with pepperoni, sausage, salami & bacon
- 10" (Gluten Free) $14.49
- 12" (Gluten Free) $15.99
- 14" $22.99
- 18" $37.99
- XL $48.99
Tony Soprano
Traditional pizza with mushroom, sausage, red onion & ricotta
- 10" (Gluten Free) $14.49
- 12" (Gluten Free) $15.99
- 14" $22.99
- 18" $37.99
- XL $48.99
The Guido
Traditional pizza with sausage, green peppers, red peppers, red onion & pepperoncini
- 10" (Gluten Free) $13.49
- 12" (Gluten Free) $14.99
- 14" $21.99
- 18" $36.99
- XL $47.99
Chicken Club
A ranch sauce base, mozzarella, tomato, red onion, chicken & bacon
- 10" (Gluten Free) $14.99
- 12" (Gluten Free) $15.99
- 14" $22.99
- 18" $37.99
- XL $48.99
Florentine
Fresh spinach, chicken, roasted garlic, provolone, & garlic butter under mozzarella
- 10" (Gluten Free) $14.49
- 12" (Gluten Free) $15.99
- 14" $22.99
- 18" $37.99
- XL $48.99
Pesto Paradise
A pesto based pizza with fresh spinach, mushroom, bacon, red onion & mozzarella
- 10" (Gluten Free) $14.49
- 12" (Gluten Free) $15.99
- 14" $22.99
- 18" $37.99
- XL $48.99
Manhattan
Pesto base pizza with fresh tomatoes, sundried tomatoes, artichoke hearts & chicken topped with mozzarella
- 10" (Gluten Free) $14.49
- 12" (Gluten Free) $15.99
- 14" $22.99
- 18" $37.99
- XL $48.99
New York Combo
Traditional pizza with pepperoni, mushroom, sausage, salami, green bell pepper, black olives & yellow onion
- 10" (Gluten Free) $15.49
- 12" (Gluten Free) $16.99
- 14" $23.99
- 18" $38.99
- XL $49.99
Pizza Rolls
Additional items are available $1 to $2
Sausage Roll
$12.49
Italian sausage, green bell pepper, yellow onion, red sauce & mozzarella wrapped in pizza dough
Veggie Roll
$12.49
Mushroom, green bell pepper, black olives, yellow onion, red sauce & mozzarella wrapped in pizza dough
Calzones
A pocket of dough stuffed generously with ricotta and mozzarella cheese. Ricotta and mozzarella are baked inside. Marinara on the side! Additional items $1 to $2
Mini-Vinnie Calzone
$10.49Large Calzone
$18.49Salads
Served with a dinner bread
Dinner Salad
Spring mix with red onion, grape tomato, romano & croutons
- Small $7.99
- Large $9.49
Garden Salad
$14.49
Spring mix with artichoke hearts, black olives, mushrooms, sharp provolone, jalapeños, grape tomato & romano
Antipasto Salad
$16.99
Spring mix with artichoke hearts, black olives, mushrooms, sharp provolone, salami, pepperoni, sun-dried tomatoes, red onions, grape tomato, and romano
Caesar Salad
$13.99
Romaine lettuce tossed with caesar dressing, grape tomato, sharp provolone, croutons & romano
- With Bacon
- $2.99
- With Seasoned Chicken
- $3.99
- With a Breaded Chicken Breast Filet
- $5.49
Buffalo Salad
$16.99
Spring mix tossed with bleu cheese dressing (or your choice), bleu cheese crumbles (or grape tomato), red onion, and four chicken tenders tossed in buffalo sauce
Entrees & Pasta
Includes your choice of a Small Dinner Salad, Garlic Bread, or Dinner Breads
Beef Lasagna
$18.99
Lightly seasoned ground beef, ricotta, marinara, and mozzarella layered between lasagna noodles with parsley & romano
Spinach Lasagna
$18.49
Seasoned & sauteéd spinach, ricotta, marinara, and mozzarella between lasagna noodles with parsley & romano
Chicken Parmigiana
$18.49
Breaded chicken breast fried and toasted with marinara, mozzarella, parsley & romano. Served on spaghetti marinara
Eggplant Parmigiana (Seasonal)
$18.49
Breaded eggplant baked, fried, and toasted with marinara, mozzarella, parsley & romano. Served on spaghetti marinara
Baked Ziti
$17.49
Ziti baked in a creamy marinara sauce with mozzarella, parsley & romano
- Add 2 Meatballs
- $4.00
- Add 3 Meatballs
- $5.00
Traditional or Deep-Fried Ravioli
$17.49
Eight cheese ravioli served in our homemade marinara with parsley & romano
- Add 2 Meatballs
- $4.00
- Add 3 Meatballs
- $5.00
Spaghetti Marinara
$15.49
Spaghetti served in our homemade marinara, parsley & romano
- Add 2 Meatballs
- $4.00
- Add 3 Meatballs
- $5.00
Garlic Bread & Garlic Knots
Garlic Bread (2)
$4.99- With Cheese
- $0.50
Dinner Breads (3)
$2.22Garlic Knots
$5.99
7 Knots
Hot Sandwiches
Served with French fries. Substitute small dinner salad with an upcharge
Meatball Hero
$15.99
Homemade meatballs covered in marinara, mozzarella, parsley & romano
Chicken Parmigiana Hero
$15.99
Breaded chicken breast fried and toasted with marinara, mozzarella, parsley & romano
Italian Sausage, Pepper & Onion Hero
$15.99
Sausage, green bell peppers & yellow onions with marinara, mozzarella, parsley & romano
Chicken Dijon Hero
$13.99
A breaded chicken breast & mozzarella, tomato, red onion & dijon ranch dressing
Appetizers
Mussels Marinara
$14.49
Mussels are back!! Order Hot & Spicy or Just Plain Mild
- Add French Fries for Only
- $3.00
- Add Onion Rings for Only
- $4.00
Deep Fried Ravioli (8)
$8.99
Lightly breaded, deep-fried & served with marinara or your choice of dressing
French Fries
$5.99Sauteéd Broccoli with Garlic
$6.99- Add Provolone Cheese
- $1.00
Wings & Tenders
Chicken Wings (12)
$14.99
Wings available in: Buffalo Sauce, BBQ, Thai, or Plain Served with your choice of dressing
Chicken Tenders (4)
$8.99- Add French Fries for Only
- $4.00
- Add Onion Rings for Only
- $6.00
Browse Nearby
General Info
Cuisine
Italian
Pizza
Meals
Lunch
Dinner
Hours
Monday:
11:30am - 9:00pm
Tuesday:
11:30am - 9:00pm
Wednesday:
11:30am - 9:00pm
Thursday:
11:30am - 9:00pm
Friday:
11:30am - 10:00pm
Saturday:
11:30am - 10:00pm
Sunday:
12:00pm - 9:00pm
About Us
We are committed to using the highest quality and most fresh ingredients in our Home Made Hand Tossed New York Style Thin Crust Pizza, Sandwiches, Salads, Wraps and Italian Dinners cooked in our Brick Oven! Our staff is professional, friendly and is ready to serve you.