Papa's has over 24 flavors of ice cream, as well as sherbet, and frozen yogurt. Our milkshakes are made with milk and ice cream, not a mix, and are topped with whipped cream and a cherry. Our Tropi-Kool smoothies are non-dairy, made with real fruit puree. The FroYo is a smoothie made with vanilla yogurt Real fruit puree. Banana Splits & Sundae are "Make Your Own". You get one trip through the toppings bar to get all your bowl will hold for one low price. No scales here.
Waffle Cone or Waffle Bowl
7 Scoop Sampler
Seven small scoops in one big cup. You pick the flavors. Great for a group, or if you just can't decide which flavor you want.
Sundaes & Drinks
Make your own sundaes, or banana splits for one low price. One trip through the toppings bar for all your bowl will hold.
Banana Split / Sundae
Banana splits or Sundaes can be made with your choice of available ice cream flavors, and toppings.
Milkshake & Tropical Milkshakes
Choose from 24+ flavors for your milkshake, including peanut butter, banana, and pineapple. All milkshakes come with whipped cream, topping, and a cherry.
16oz Regular Milkshake$3.49
16oz Tropical Milkshake$4.49
24oz Regular Milkshake$5.09
24oz Tropical Milkshake$6.09
Hershey's smoothies are refreshing and delicious. our flavors include strawberry, mango, peach, very-berry, strawberry-banana, strawberry pineapple, and pineapple-mango. mix any flavors you like.
16oz Tropi-Kool Smoothie$3.29
16oz FroYo Smoothie$4.29
24oz Tropi-Kool Smoothie$4.89
24oz FroYo Smoothie$5.89
Ice Cream Floats
You pick the soda, and the ice cream flavor for a different twist to this classic treat.
Blenjavas are a blended shake made with Hershey's ice creams, and flavored syrups. Flavors include Mint Chocolate Mocha, Mocha Madness, Caramel Macchiato, and Frozen Hot Chocolate.
All Panini Toaster Sandwiches & Subs come with Tea, and Chips, or your choice of one of our homemade sides.
Panini Toaster & Sub Baskets
All of our sandwiches are made fresh to order and come with a tea and your choice of a chips or one of our homemade sides. You can choose from our selection of breads, and cheeses for a delicious lunch, or dinner.
Ham & Cheese, Turkey & Cheese, BLT, Baby Club, even a Tomato sandwich if you like. These are just a few of our menu items. We also have homemade Chicken Salad, Tuna Salad, and Deviled Egg. We use only Dukes Mayonnaise on our sandwiches, and in our sides. All on Panini toasted White, Wheat, or Rye bread. choice of cheeses are American, Swiss, Sharp Cheddar, Provolone, and Pepper Jack.
Build your own sub with our selection of meats and cheeses, on white or wheat, foot long or half size. Get as much or as little as you want on a sub with our many choices of toppings, and sauces.
Chips, Sides & Other Good Stuff To Eat
Selection of various flavors of bag chips, and choice of 3 homemade sides. we have Potato Salad, Macaroni Salad, and Slaw. We have Hot Dogs and Nachos & Cheese. There's also Cookies, Candy bars, and other Munchies to choose from.
Closed for Thanksgiving Holiday. Nov.26th-Nov.30th
Here at Papa's Ice Cream Shop & More we not only serve delicious Hershey's Ice Cream, but we also serve Panini Toaster sandwiches, and subs. All sandwiches are made fresh to order, and homemade sides are also available. Come by for lunch, dinner, or just a snack attack.