A Italian Classic Flavored Oval Shaped Pasta Dumpling. Cavatelli are Blended with Ricotta Cheese into the Dough before they are formed. One of our Family's Favorites.
Baked Ziti Parmigiana
$13.99
Ziti with Ricotta Topped with Sauce and Melted Mozzarella Cheese. Pasta and Cheese Lovers Delight.
Fettuccini Alfredo
$14.99
A Variety of Special Chesses Blended in Cream, Butter and Parmesan Cheese.
Eggplant Parmigiana
$15.99
Battered Dip Eggplant set the Right Beginning to an All Time Winner.
Sherry's Favorite
Fresh Tomatoes, Spinach, Basil Sautéed in Oil & Fresh Garlic Seasoned with Parmesan Cheese and Served over Penne Pasta.
$14.99
Add Chicken Breast with Melted Parmesan Cheese$16.99
Manicotti
$12.99
Stuffed with Ricotta Cheese and Topped with our Tomato Sauce and a Blend of Cheeses.
Beef
All Beef Dinners Served with a Garden Salad, Vegetable and Choice of Pasta or Potato, plus Papa's Famous Warm Italian Bread.
Prime Rib Steak
$21.99
A Generous 14 oz. Cut of our Slow Roasted Black Angus Prime Rib Seasoned Just Right then Grilled to Perfection.
Steak Mafia
$23.99
The Most Tender Piece of Angus Sirloin smothered in Sautéed Peppers, Onions and Mushrooms, Topped Off with Papa's Homemade Tomato Sauce and Melted Mozzarella Cheese.
Veal & Chicken
Chicken Parmigiana
$15.99
Served with a Side of Pasta; Tender Chicken Breast Topped with Tomato Sauce and Melted Cheese.
Chicken Primavera Alfredo
$16.99
Tender Breast of Chicken and Broccoli in Creamy Alfredo Sauce over Fettuccini.
Chicken Cacciatore
$16.99
Chicken Chunks with Tomato, Mushrooms, Onions and Green Peppers over Linguini.
Veal Parmigiana
$15.99
Breaded Veal Topped with Cheese & Tomato Sauce, Served with a Side Pasta.
Seafood
Served with Salad & Papa's own Homemade Italian Bread.
Clam Sauce Over Linguini
$16.99
Whole Shell Clams Sautéed in Garlic Butter, Wine and Spices. Red or White Sauce.
Seafood Fettuccini
Clams, Seafood Supreme and Shrimp Sautéed in Butter, Wine and Our Special Alfredo Sauce.
Homemade Calzones
Made with Papa Joe's Famous Homemade Pizza Dough and a Blend of 3 Cheeses. A Meal in itself. Served with Papa's Homemade Sauce on the side.
Cheese, Mozzarella & Ricotta
$7.99
Pepperoni
$8.59
Sausage w/Peppers & Onions
$8.99
Spinach & Cheese
$8.59
Chicken & Broccoli
$8.59
Combo
$9.59
Peppers, Onions, Mushrooms, Sausage and Pepperoni.
Black Angus Beef Subs
$4.99
– $7.99
Black Angus Roast Beef
Angus Cheeseburger Sub
$8.99
Black Angus Prime Rib Subs
Philly Steak
$5.99
– $8.99
Sautéed Peppers & Onions with Cheddar Cheese Sauce.
Delmonico Steak
$5.99
– $8.99
Italian Philly
$5.99
– $8.99
Steak, Italian Sausage, Peppers, Onions & Mozzarella Cheese.
Angus Burgers
Hamburger
$7.59
Cheeseburger
$7.99
Italian Burger
$7.59
With Peppers & Onions.
The Papas Bacon Burger
$7.99
With Bacon & Cheddar Cheese Sauce.
The Tuscan Burger
$7.99
With Mushrooms & Fresh Mozzarella.
Uncle Paulie'S Subs & Wraps
All Served on Papa Joe's very own Homemade Italian, Whole Wheat, Parmigiana Bread or Wrap
Traditional Subs
Turkey
Small 6"$3.99
Large 12"$6.99
Boiled Ham
Small 6"$3.99
Large 12"$6.99
Capacola
Small 6"$4.59
Large 12"$7.99
Pepperoni
Small 6"$4.59
Large 12"$7.99
Genoa Salami
Small 6"$4.59
Large 12"$7.99
Classic Subs
Italian Delight
Small 6"$4.99
Large 12"$7.99
Tuna Fish
Small 6"$4.99
Large 12"$7.99
Country Gentlemen
Small 6"$4.99
Large 12"$7.99
Hot Pastrami
Small 6"$4.49
Large 12"$7.99
BLT
Small 6"$4.59
Large 12"$7.99
Original
Bologna, Genoa Salami, Cooked Salami
Small 6"$3.99
Large 12"$6.99
Vegetarian
Small 6"$3.99
Large 12"$6.99
Chicken Deluxe - One Size
Chicken Cordon Bleu
$8.99
Chicken Philly
$7.99
Tender Chicken Breast
$8.59
Hot Oven Grinders
All grinders or wraps, have a choice of: Mozzarella, American, Provolone Extra Trimmings: $ .75: Hot or Sweet Peppers, Black or Green Olives, Pickles. Topped with Tomato Sauce and Melted Mozzarella Cheese. Peppers & Onions Extra: $ .75
Sausage
Small 6"$4.59
Large 12"$7.99
Meatball
Small 6"$4.59
Large 12"$7.99
Eggplant Parmigiana
Small 6"$4.99
Large 12"$7.99
Chicken Parmigiana
Large 12"$7.99
Veal Parmigiana
$7.99
All-You-Can-Eat Mama's Sunday Buffet
$10.99. Every Sunday 4PM to 8PM. Kid's 10 & under $4.99, Kid's 3 and under Eat Free. Homemade Pizza, Pasta, Homemade Meatballs, Salad, Desserts and Much More!
All-You-Can-Eat Papa Joe's Lunch Buffet
$7.99. Every Wednesday through Friday 11AM to 2PM. Homemade Pizza, Pasta, Homemade Meatballs, Salad and More!
Homemade Pizza
Papa Joe's pizza is made from an old family recipe. We start with Papa's homemade pizza dough, we add our own pizza sauce just like Mama did from the finest whole plumb tomatoes. We only use 100% mozzarella cheese & only the finest toppings.
Cheese Pizza
Choose from one of our homemade crust: Hand Tossed thin. Sicilian thick crust. Chicago Deep Dish Choose from Tomato, Blanca or Pesto Sauce. Toppings: Hamburger - Black Olives - Meatballs - Green Peppers - Hot Peppers - Pineapple Pepperoni - Fresh Tomatoes - Mushrooms - Sweet Sausage - Fresh Garlic - Spinach Italian Sausage - Broccoli - Onion - Ham; Hamburger - Black Olives - Meatballs - Green Peppers - Hot Peppers - Pineapple Pepperoni - Fresh Tomatoes - Mushrooms - Sweet Sausage - Fresh Garlic - Spinach Italian Sausage - Broccoli - Onion - Ham Hamburger - Black Olives - Meatballs - Green Peppers - Hot Peppers - Pineapple Pepperoni - Fresh Tomatoes - Mushrooms - Sweet Sausage - Fresh Garlic - Spinach Italian Sausage - Broccoli - Onion - Ham; Hamburger - Black Olives - Meatballs - Green Peppers - Hot Peppers - Pineapple Pepperoni - Fresh Tomatoes - Mushrooms - Sweet Sausage - Fresh Garlic - Spinach Italian Sausage - Broccoli - Onion - Ham; Premium Toppings (Additional charge may apply) Grilled Chicken - Extra Cheese - Roasted Peppers - Fresh Mozzarella - Genoa Salami Feta Cheese - Anchovies - Bacon - Ricotta - Eggplant - Artichoke
Medium
$10.99
Large
$13.99
Extra Large
$14.99
Party Size
$19.99
(18"x 24")
Ole World Pizza's
Add your choice of toppings
Pizza Marguerite
Made to represent the colors of the Italian flag, chunky tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella & basil.
$12.99
$14.99
$15.99
Pizza Rustica
Chunky tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil with a blend of 3 cheeses.
$12.99–$15.99
$14.99
$15.99
Specialty Pizzas
Tomato Sauce; Mama Joe's very own pizza sauce recipe. Made in our family for over 50 years.
Mama Joe's Special
Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Hamburg, Mushroom, Onion and Green Peppers.
Medium$14.59
Large$16.59
X-Large$17.59
Papa Joe's Special
Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Sweet Sausage, Hamburg, Mushroom, Onion, Green Peppers, Ham & Anchovies.
Medium$15.59
Large$17.59
X-Large$18.59
Pompeii
Hot and Spicy, Hot as a Volcano. Pepperoni, Hot Sausage, Ham, Onions, Garlic, 2 kinds of Hot Peppers and a Special Hot Sauce.
Medium$14.99
Large$16.99
X-Large$17.99
Barbeque Pizza
Pizza made with Barbeque Sauce, Onions and your Choice of One Topping: Beef, Pork or Chicken. Barbeque Combo Priced Accordingly.
Medium$13.99
Large$15.99
X-Large$16.99
Hawaiian
Pineapple, Ham and Green Peppers.
Medium$13.99
Large$15.99
X-Large$17.99
Cheesy Parmigiana
Cheese & Tomato Lover's Delight. 5 kinds of Cheese Topped with Fresh Tomato.
Medium$11.99
Large$14.99
X-Large$15.99
Meat Lover's Pizza
Pepperoni, Ham, Meatball, Italian Sausage and Chicken.
Medium$14.59
Large$16.59
X-Large$17.59
Pizza Florentine
Spinach, Tomato, Bacon and Onion.
Medium$14.59
Large$16.59
X-Large$17.59
Buffalo Chicken
Chicken, Peppers and Onions with Hot Buffalo Wing Sauce.
Medium$13.99
Large$16.99
X-Large$17.99
Mexican Pizza
Hamburg, Re fried Beans & Cheese Topped with Tomatoes, Lettuce, Onion & More Cheese. Taco Sauce on the side.
Medium$14.99
Large$16.99
X-Large$17.99
Chicago Deep Dish Pizza
Papa Joe's adds this pizza to it's family. Made to order in a deep pan lined with Chicago style homemade dough. Loaded with mozzarella and a variety of other cheese plus the best ingredients we can find; Large Only
Goodfella
$14.99
Wise guys start here work your way up adding your own toppings for a delicious pizza. Start with homemade crust, lots of cheese and chunky tomato sauce.
The Godfather
$16.99
The pizza you can't refuse. Lots of cheese pepperoni, Italian sausage, sweet sausage, mushrooms, hamburg, sautéed peppers and onions with chunky tomato sauce.
Capone
$16.99
The head of the family, respectively delicious. Our famous crust full of cheese, pepperoni, Genoa salami, ham topped with chunky tomato sauce & parmesan cheese.
Philly Connection
$16.99
You will make a good connection with this one. Shaved sirloin steak, sautéed peppers & onions, chunky tomato sauce and again lots of cheese.
Fredo
$16.99
The traitor of this family style pizza. Fajita chicken, blend of cheeses, sautéed peppers & onions and salsa sauce served with sour cream.
Santino
$16.99
This one is sure to be a big hit. Roasted red peppers, garlic, onions, chunky tomato sauce, lots of marinated mushrooms and loaded with cheese.
The Don
$16.99
You will pledge your respect to this one because it's so good. Ricotta cheese, lots of mozzarella, spinach, broccoli and fresh tomato topped with parmesan cheese.
The Corleone
$16.99
The one whose destiny is to establish itself as one you will never forget. Our homemade crust filled with eggplant, sautéed peppers and onions, ham and chunky tomato sauce.
The Original White Pizza - Blanca Sauce
Grandma's very own recipe of 100% pure olive oil, fresh garlic, parsley and secret spices. This makes the tastiest homemade pizza
Pizza Blanca
White Pizza, Pure Olive Oil, Garlic, Secret Spices & Extra Cheese.
Medium$11.99
Large$14.99
X-Large$15.99
Seafood Supreme
Clams, Shrimp and Seafood Supreme.
Medium$14.99
Large$16.99
X-Large$18.99
Pizza Vinaigrette
Blanca Pizza with Fresh Tomato, Broccoli, Onions, Ricotta and Mozzarella Cheese. Vinegar served on the side to add that tantalizing taste you never had before on a pizza. Something new, something different, something great. Try One.
Medium$13.99
Large$15.99
X-Large$17.99
Chicken Pesto
Roasterie Chicken, Fresh Tomato & Pesto Sauce.
Medium$14.59
Large$16.59
X-Large$17.59
Garden of Eden
White Vegetarian Pizza with Broccoli, Onions, Mushrooms, Peppers, Black Olives and Fresh Tomatoes.
Medium$14.59
Large$16.59
X-Large$17.59
Tomato, Bacon, Ranch
Our Cheese Pizza Sprinkled with Crispy Bacon, we then add layer of Tomato, Drizzled with Creamy Ranch.
Medium$14.59
Large$16.59
X-Large$17.59
Tomato, Chicken, Ranch
Cheese Pizza with layers of Chicken and Tomatoes' Drizzled with Creamy Ranch.
Medium$14.59
Large$16.59
X-Large$17.59
Papa Joe'S Family Style Meals
For A Large Family Or Group; Your Choice of Pasta: Spaghetti, Linguini, Ziti or Cavatelli, served with Papa's Famous Tomato Sauce or add $2.00 more for Papa's Meat Sauce.
Family Style Pasta
Family Style Dinners Ala Cart
.Large serves (4)$19.99
Pasta Pleasures
Serves 4-5
Fettuccini Alfredo
$26.99
Linguini & Red Clam Sauce
$26.99
Linguini & White Clam Sauce
$26.99
Ravioli
$26.99
Baked Ziti Parmigiana
$26.99
Manicotti
$26.99
Italian Specialties
Serves 4-5
Chicken Parmigiana & Pasta
$28.99
Veal Parmigiana & Pasta
$28.99
Eggplant Parmigiana & Pasta
$28.99
Family Value Meals
Serves 4-5
Large family pasta dinner/garden salad & bread sticks
$28.99
Any pasta pleasure or Italian specialty
$39.99
More Favorites To Take Home with You
Also please see our service counter for more selections
Loaf of Papa's Homemade Italian & Semolina Bread. Large
Papa Joe's Pizza is made from an old family recipe. We start with Papa's famous Pizza Dough that's made on the premises, fresh every day. Then we add our own Pizza Sauce, made from the finest whole plumb tomatoes and spiced the way Grandma did. We use only 100% Mozzarella Cheese, and for the finishing touch we use only the best pizza toppings we can find.