Romaine lettuce with chicken breast, chopped tomato, bacon, blue cheese & hard boiled eggs served with your choice of dressing
Spinach & Bacon Salad
$9.95
Fresh spinach, bacon, hard boiled eggs & sweet onions are served with a side of our bacon dressing
Italian Chopped Salad
$10.95
Fresh Italian lunch meats (Ham, Salami, Genoa, Cappicola) sliced extra thin with mozzarella cheese, assorted olives, peppers & tomatoes served with a choice of dressing
Half Pint of Minestrone Soup or Soup of the Day
$2.95
Pint of Minestrone Soup or Soup of the Day
$3.95
Sandwiches & Wraps
Add Fries & Choice of Pasta Salad or Cole Slaw $1.50
Hamburger 1/2 Lb.
$6.50
Cheeseburger 1/2 Lb.
$6.95
Meatball Sandwich
$6.25
Papa Joe's special recipe, served with marinara sauce
Italian Beef Sandwich
$6.95
Our famous thinly sliced roast beef served with natural juice or red sauce. Try it with mozzarella cheese
Grilled Italian Sausage
$6.25
Homemade Italian Sausage grilled & served with marinara sauce
Grilled Italian Cheese on Panini
$7.95
Mozzarella, Asiago and Provolone grilled on panini bread
Panini Italiano
$8.95
Salami, cappicola, ham, mozzarella cheese, grilled and served with lettuce and sliced tomato
Chicken Arrabbiata Sandwich
$9.95
Lettuce, tomato & arrabbiata sauce
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
$9.95
Served with lettuce & tomato
Rib Eye Steak
$11.95
Tender steak served on garlic bread. Includes fries & cole slaw
Caesar Chicken Wrap
$8.95
Grilled chicken breast combined with onions, lettuce, tomato & our famous caesar dressing
Includes bread, butter & cheese. Tossed Salad with Dinners $1.50. Add 2 Meatballs $3.50 or Sausage $2.50. Choose Your Favorite Pasta (With one of our Famous Sauces):
Capellini
Mostaccioli
Spaghetti
Linguini
Fettuccine
Pasta Sauces
Meat or Marinara Sauce
$8.95
Mushroom Sauce
$9.95
Al Verde (Spinach)
$10.25
Spinach, garlic, olive oil
Pasta & Broccoli
$10.25
Broccoli, garlic, canadian bacon, cream sauce and parmesan cheese
Arrabbiata Sauce
$9.95
Spicy tomato sauce
Vodka Sauce
$10.95
Pomodoro
$10.25
Tomato, Garlic, Olive Oil & Spices
Dinners
Dinners include bread & butter. Tossed salad add $1.50
Homemade Lasagna
$11.50
Pasta layered with meat ricotta and mozzarella cheese
Baked Mostaccioli
$10.95
Homemade Manicotti
$9.95
Rolled dough stuffed with ricotta cheese, baked with sauce and mozzarella cheese
Homemade Ravioli
$9.95
Meat or Cheese
Stuffed Shells
$11.50
Shell pasta filled with ricotta and spinach and baked with tomato sauce and finished with mozzarella
Tortellini al Forno
$10.95
Fresh tortellini filled with ricotta cheese & baked with mozzarella cheese
Fettuccini Alfredo
Rich egg noodles w/ a creamy sauce
$10.95
Add Broccoli$11.95
Eggplant Parmigiana
$10.95
Sauteed eggplant, interlaced w/ tomato sauce & cheese baked in the oven
Chicken Dinner
$10.95
Fried, Broiled or BBQ w/ fies & cole slaw
Chicken Tetrazzini
$14.50
Boneless chicken breast sauteed with mushrooms, poured over mostaccioli & topped with a creamy white sauce & mozzarella cheese
Chicken Parmigiana
$13.95
Boneless chicken breast sauteed in wine sauce & baked in the oven with tomato sauce & mozzarella cheese over spaghetti
Papa's Favorite Chicken
$14.50
Boneless chicken breast sauteed in a wine sauce with fresh mushrooms, onions, green peppers & served over a bed of mostaccioli
Chicken Lemone
$13.95
Boneless breast of chicken sauteed with mushrooms in a lemon butter sauce
Chicken Marsala
$13.95
Boneless breast of chicken sauteed with mushrooms, onions in a Marsala wine sauce served over linguini
Chicken Vesuvio w/ Vesuvio Potatoes
$13.95
In a thickened garlic sauce, Papa Joe Style, Garlic & Olive Oil, Traditional
Chicken Picante
$13.95
Boneless chicken breast sauteed in a creamy garlic sauce served w/ a side of pasta
Breaded Shrimp
$11.95
Includes fries
Pizza
Gluten Free Pizza Available. Meat Toppings: Sausage, Pepperoni, Ground Beef, Meatballs. Extra Ingredients: Mushrooms, Green Pepper, Tomato, Onion, Black Olive, Green Olive, Jalapeno, Giardiniera, Pineapple, Spinach, Broccoli. Premium Ingredients: Canadian Bacon, Roast Beef, Shrimp, Grilled Chicken, Anchovies
Thin Crust
Cheese
10"$9.50
12"$12.50
14"$15.50
16"$19.00
Any One Meat Topping
10"$11.50
12"$15.00
14"$18.50
16"$22.50
Extra Ingredients
10"$1.75
12"$2.00
14"$2.25
16"$2.50
Premium Ingredients
10"$3.75
12"$4.00
14"$4.25
16"$4.50
Pan (Deep Dish)
Cheese
10"$15.00
12"$18.00
14"$21.00
Any One Meat Topping
10"$17.00
12"$20.50
14"$24.00
Extra Ingredients
10"$1.75
12"$2.00
14"$2.25
Premium Ingredients
10"$3.75
12"$4.00
14"$4.25
Stuffed Pizza
Cheese
10"$16.00
12"$19.00
14"$22.00
Any One Meat Topping
10"$18.00
12"$21.50
14"$25.00
Extra Ingredients
10"$1.75
12"$2.00
14"$2.25
Premium Ingredients
10"$3.75
12"$4.00
14"$4.25
Desserts
Cheesecake
$3.95
Fresh Made Cannoli
$2.95
Tira-Mi-Su
$3.95
Beverages
Pepsi
Can$1.00
2 Liter$2.95
6 - Pack$5.75
Diet Pepsi
Can$1.00
2 Liter$2.95
6 - Pack$5.75
Mountain Dew
Can$1.00
2 Liter$2.95
6 - Pack$5.75
Sierra Mist
Can$1.00
2 Liter$2.95
6 - Pack$5.75
Bottled Water
$1.00
Salads
Pasta Salad
spring noodles with diced tomatoes, green peppers, in an oil base dressing
Half Pan (serves 10-12)$15.95
Full Pan (serves 20-25)$22.95
X-large (serves 40-50)$38.95
Cucumber, Tomato, Onion Salad
in a vinegar and oil dressing
Half Pan (serves 10-12)$15.95
Full Pan (serves 20-25)$22.95
X-large (serves 40-50)$38.95
Tossed Salad
with olives, onions, tomatoes and a choice of dressing
Half Pan (serves 10-12)$15.95
Full Pan (serves 20-25)$22.95
X-large (serves 40-50)$38.95
Chicken Caesar Salad
romaine lettuce, grilled chicken breast hard boiled eggs, croutons with classic caesar dressing
Half Pan (serves 8-10)$24.95
Full Pan (serves 15-20)$46.95
Entrees
Roast Beef
3 pound minimum. thinly sliced with our own juice
Per Pound$8.95
Italian Sausage And Peppers
Half Pan (serves 8-10)$21.95
Full Pan (serves 15-18)$34.95
X-large Pan (serves 30-35)$65.95
Homemade Meatballs
"grandma recipe" a perfect blend of ground beef, sausage, cheeses and spices in our famous marinara sauce
Half Pan (20 Pieces)$24.95
X-large Pan (40 Pieces)$47.95
Eggplant Parmigiana
sauteed eggplant, interlaced with tomato sauce and cheese, baked in the oven
Half Pan (serves 8-10)$26.95
Full Pan (serves 15-20)$44.95
Stuffed Shells
shell pasta filled with ricotta cheese and spinach, baked with tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese
Half Pan (serves 8-10)$26.95
Full Pan (serves 15-20)$44.95
Mostaccioli Or Spaghetti
meat sauce or marinara
Half Pan (serves 6-8)$18.95
Full Pan (serves 12-15)$29.95
Large Pan (serves 25-30)$44.95
Lasagna
ricotta cheese and meat
Half Pan (serves 12-15)$33.95
Full Pan (serves 25-30)$64.95
Manicotti
cheese filled
Half Pan (serves 8-10)$26.95
Full Pan (serves 15-20)$44.95
Pasta And Broccoli
sauteed broccoli, garlic, canadian bacon with a light cream sauce
Half Pan (serves 8-10)$26.95
Full Pan (serves 15-20)$44.95
Ravioli
meat or cheese stuffed pasta pillows topped with red sauce
Half Pan (15 Pillows)$24.95
Full Pan (30 Pillows)$39.95
Chicken
sicilian style: baked with an array of italian spices and a hint of lemon; fried: always delicious; barbeque: basted in our special sauce; italian baked: lightly breaded and baked to perfection. chicken is sold by the piece $1 per piece. intervals of 4. 24 pieces minimum
Chicken Tetrazzini (house Specialty)
boneless breast of chicken sauteed with mushrooms and onions, served in cream sauce, over mostaccioli and topped with cheese
Half Pan (serves 8-10)$28.95
Full Pan (serves 15-20)$53.95
Papa's Chicken
boneless breast of chicken sauteed with mushrooms, green peppers, onions in a light red sauce and served over mostaccioli
Half Pan (serves 8-10)$28.95
Full Pan (serves 15-20)$53.95
Chicken Lemone
boneless breast of chicken sauteed with mushrooms in a lemon butter sauce
Half Pan (serves 8-10)$33.95
Full Pan (serves 15-20)$64.95
Chicken Marsala
boneless breast of chicken sauteed with mushrooms and onions in a marsala sauce
Half Pan (serves 8-10)$33.95
Full Pan (serves 15-20)$64.95
Boneless Italian Baked Chicken
lightly breaded and baked to perfection
Half Pan (serves 8-10)$33.95
Full Pan (serves 15-20)$64.95
Potatoes
Vesuvio Potatoes
baked in the oven in our vesuvio sauce (light brown)
Half Pan (serves 8-10)$15.95
Full Pan (serves 20-25)$22.95
X-large (serves 40-45)$38.95
Parsley Potatoes
small red potatoes with butter, parsey and spices
Half Pan (serves 8-10)$15.95
Full Pan (serves 20-25)$22.95
X-large (serves 40-45)$38.95
Whipped Potatoes With Gravy Or Garlic Mashed
smooth and creamy
Half Pan (serves 10-12)$15.95
Full Pan (serves 20-25)$22.95
Breads
Italian Dinner Bread
Per Loaf$3.95
French Bread Rolls (4-inch)
Per Loaf$3.95
Assorted Dinner Rolls
Per Dozen$3.95
Sides
Baked Broccoli
broccoli spears baked with fresh garlic and topped with parmesan cheese
Half Pan (serves 10-12)$15.95
Full Pan (serves 20-25)$22.95
X-large (serves 40-50)$38.95
Green Beans Italian
sauteed onions, diced tomatoes and black olives
Half Pan (serves 10-12)$15.95
Full Pan (serves 20-25)$22.95
X-large (serves 40-50)$38.95
Green Beans Almondine
served with sliced toasted almonds
Half Pan (serves 10-12)$15.95
Full Pan (serves 20-25)$22.95
X-large (serves 40-50)$38.95
Candied Baby Carrots
sweet and delicious
Half Pan (serves 10-12)$15.95
Full Pan (serves 20-25)$22.95
X-large (serves 40-50)$38.95
Extras
Sweet Peppers
Pt.$2.25
Qt.$4.50
Hot Giardiniera
Pt.$3.25
Qt.$6.50
Red Sauce
Pt.$2.25
Qt.$4.50
Meat Sauce
Pt.$2.75
Qt.$5.50
Salad Dressings
house, garlic, french, 1000 island
Pt.$2.95
Qt.$5.95
Breakfast Catering
Main
Breakfast Sandwich
choice of sausage or canadian bacon, with egg and cheese on a bagel, croissant, or english muffin
Each$3.85
Breakfast Burrito
sausage, bacon, egg, cheese, and salsa in a burrito
Each$4.15
Continental Breakfast (per Person)
includes danish, muffins, fruit
$4.95
With Breakfast Sandwich$6.95
With Breakfast Burrito$7.25
Fruit Tray
fresh cantaloupe, honeydew, grapes and pineapple
Half Tray (15-20 People)$22.95
Full Tray (35-40 People)$39.95
Breakfast Package
includes: scrambled eggs, toast with jelly and butter. choose: pancakes or french toast, sausage or bacon, cheese blintzes or cookies
Per Person$7.95
Catering Packages
Main
can add a side: potatoes or vegetables for $1 more per person
Catering Packages A
choice of chicken- fried, italian baked, bbq, or sicilian; mostaccioli- choice of red or meat sauce; - can make it baked most. for $0.35 extra per person; bread- french (unless italian is requested); choice of salad- tossed, pasta, or c.t.o; settings- number of guests
Per Person$5.25
Catering Packages B
choice of chicken- fried, italian baked, bbq, or sicilian; choice of meat- beef, sausage and peppers, or meatballs; bread- french (unless italian is requested); choice of salad- tossed, pasta, or c.t.o; settings- number of guests
Per Person$5.95
Catering Packages C
choice of chicken- fried, italian baked, bbq, or sicilian; choice of meat- beef, sausage and peppers, or meatballs; mostaccioli- choice of red or meat sauce; -can make it baked most. for $0.35 extra per person; bread- french (unless italian is requested); choice of salad- tossed, pasta, or c.t.o; settings- number of guests
Papa Joe's Italian Restaurant has been recognized in Daily Southtown and Star newspapers' reader's polls since 1998 in such categories as "Best Italian Cuisine," "Best Catering," and "Favorite Restaurant."