Ease the wait for your pizza with terrific hot appetizers
Chicken Tender Basket
$9.99
Chicken tenders with a side of potato wedges
Add Ranch Dressing For
$0.89
Fried Mozzarella Sticks
$7.99
With Mama Pagoni's marinara
Cheesy Garlic Bread
$6.99
Piping hot & bubbly. Served with marinara
Fresh Breadsticks
$3.99
Garlic kissed. Served with marinara for dipping
Garlic Kissed Bread
$5.99
Made fresh to order. Served with marinara
Cheese Pizza Bread
$6.49
Garlic bread, topped with mozzarella cheese
Cheese Pizza Bread with Sausage
$6.99
Garlic bread, topped with mozzarella cheese & sausage
Cheese Pizza Bread with Pepperoni
$6.99
Garlic bread, topped with mozzarella cheese & pepperoni
Onion Rings
$5.99
Served with zesty sauce
Potato Wedges
$4.99
Traditional Chicken Wings
$12.99
A pound of our plump, juicy chicken wings either hot or BBQ
Boneless Wings
$12.99
All white meat
Cheese Stuffed Breadsticks
$5.99
Garlic kissed, stuffed with cheese & served with Mama Pagoni's marinara
Mama's Dipping Stick Pizza
$14.99
A dozen dipping sticks made with a garlic butter crust, topped with mozzarella & cheddar cheese, served with Mama Pagoni's pizza dipping sauce
Jalapeno & Cheddar Sticks
$6.99
Stuffed Breadsticks with ranch dipping sauce
Mama Pagoni's Sampler
$13.99
Fried mozzarella sticks, chicken tenders & onion rings served with ranch & marinara sauce
Bruschetta
$10.99
Perfectly seasoned ripe plum tomatoes with fresh garlic, extra virgin olive oil, fresh chopped basil leaves & drizzled with balsamic vinegar. Served on toasted sliced French bread
Side of Ranch Sauce
$0.89
Side of Marinara Sauce
$0.89
Side of Garlic Butter Sauce
$0.89
Fresh Salads
All dressings are served on the side. Extra Dressing $0.89 each
Chicken Bacon Salad
$12.99
Crispy or grilled chicken tossed with cheddar cheese, bacon & tomatoes nestled on a crisp bed of lettuce
Garden Salad
$9.99
Broccoli, mushroom, tomatoes, green peppers, red onions & fresh parmesan
Garden Salad with Chicken
$12.99
Broccoli, mushroom, tomatoes, green peppers, red onions & fresh parmesan
Antipasto Salad
$12.99
Salami, pepperoni, provolone, olives & peppers in our house dressing
Chef's Salad
$12.99
Lettuce, tomatoes, green peppers, black olives, salami, ham, turkey & mozzarella
Wisconsin Caesar Salad
$9.99
Romaine lettuce, croutons & fresh parmesan tossed with Caesar dressing
Wisconsin Caesar Salad with Chicken
$12.99
Romaine lettuce, croutons & fresh parmesan tossed with Caesar dressing
Pizza
Pizza Toppings: Sausage, Broccoli, Extra Cheese, Extra Sauce, Ham, Pepperoni, Spinach, Mushrooms, Sliced and Diced Tomatoes, Black Olives, Mild Giardiniera, Salami Ground Beef, Canadian Bacon, Green Peppers, Green Olives, Hot Giardiniera Bacon Crumbles, Meatballs, Onions, Pineapple, Jalapeño Peppers, Bleu Cheese, Italian Beef, Fresh Basil, Fresh Garlic, Shrimp (available at an additional charge)
Thin Crust Pizza
Each Pizza comes with sauce and cheese. You can add any of our delicious toppings
Mozzarella Cheese
Individual 9" (Serves 1)$9.99
Small 12" (Serves 2)$12.99
Medium 14" (Serves 2-3)$15.99
Large 16" (Serves 3-4)$17.99
Family 18" (Serves 4-5)$20.99
Grande (Serves 5-6)$23.99
Additional Topping (Each)
Individual 9" (Serves 1)$0.99
Small 12" (Serves 2)$1.50
Medium 14" (Serves 2-3)$1.75
Large 16" (Serves 3-4)$2.25
Family 18" (Serves 4-5)$2.75
Grande (Serves 5-6)$3.25
Double Crust (Hand Tossed)
Individual 9" (Serves 1)$1.00
Small 12" (Serves 2)$1.50
Medium 14" (Serves 2-3)$1.75
Large 16" (Serves 3-4)$2.25
Family 18" (Serves 4-5)$2.75
Grande (Serves 5-6)$3.25
Sicilian Style Pizza Rectangular, Pan Baked
Sicilian Style Pizza comes with sauce and cheese. You can add any of our delicious toppings
Mozzarella Cheese
Rectangular, Pan Baked: 1/4 Sheet (9" X12")$16.99
Rectangular, Pan Baked: 1/2 Sheet (12" X18")$22.99
Additional Topping (Each)
Rectangular, Pan Baked: 1/4 Sheet (9" X12")$1.25
Rectangular, Pan Baked: 1/2 Sheet (12" X18")$2.50
Stuffed Pizza
Stuffed Pizza comes with sauce and cheese. You can add any of our delicious toppings
Mozzarella Cheese
Small 12"$17.99
Medium 14"$20.99
Large 16"$23.99
Additional Topping (Each)
Sallm 12"$1.49
Medium 14"$1.99
Large 16"$2.99
Deep Dish Pizza
Deep Dish Pizza comes with sauce and cheese. You can add any of our delicious toppings
Mozzarella Cheese
Individual 6" (Serves 1)$9.99
Small 10" (Serves 2-3)$16.99
Large 12" (Serves 3-4)$20.99
Additional Topping (Each)
Individual 6" (Serves 1)$0.99
Small 10" (Serves 2-3)$1.49
Large 12" (Serves 3-4)$1.99
Chicago Style
Individual 6" (Serves 1)$1.29
Small 10" (Serves 2-3)$1.99
Large 12" (Serves 3-4)$2.99
Calzones
Our hand-rolled, oven-baked calzones are made from scratch with lots of mozzarella, ricotta cheese, pizza sauce, your favorite toppings & lots of love. Served with a side of Mama Pagoni's favorite marinara. Pizza Toppings: Sausage, Broccoli, Extra Cheese, Extra Sauce, Ham, Pepperoni, Spinach, Mushrooms, Sliced and Diced Tomatoes, Black Olives, Mild Giardiniera, Salami Ground Beef, Canadian Bacon, Green Peppers, Green Olives, Hot Giardiniera Bacon Crumbles, Meatballs, Onions, Pineapple, Jalapeño Peppers, Bleu Cheese, Italian Beef, Fresh Basil, Fresh Garlic, Shrimp (available at an additional charge)
Create Your Own Plain Cheese Calzone
Small$12.99
Large$16.99
Additional Toppings (Small)
$0.99
Additional Toppings (Large)
$1.49
The House Calzone
$15.49
Pepperoni, sausage, onion & green pepper
Mama Pagoni's Special Calzone
$15.99
Steak, onion, green pepper & mushroom
Quattro Formaggio Calzone
$15.49
Mozzarella, cheddar, provolone & parmesan cheese
Spinach Calzone
$13.98
With ricotta and mozzarella cheese
Sausage Calzone
$13.98
Sausage and cheese over delicious pizza sauce
Pepperoni Calzone
$13.98
Pepperoni and cheese over delicious pizza sauce
Stromboli
Rolled pizza dough stuffed with mozzarella cheese & served with a side of Mama Pagoni's favorite marinara. Pizza Toppings: Sausage, Broccoli, Extra Cheese, Extra Sauce, Ham, Pepperoni, Spinach, Mushrooms, Sliced and Diced Tomatoes, Black Olives, Mild Giardiniera, Salami Ground Beef, Canadian Bacon, Green Peppers, Green Olives, Hot Giardiniera Bacon Crumbles, Meatballs, Onions, Pineapple, Jalapeño Peppers, Bleu Cheese, Italian Beef, Fresh Basil, Fresh Garlic, Shrimp (available at an additional charge)
Create Your Own Stromboli
$12.99
Plain Cheese Stromboli
Additional Toppings
$0.99
The Traditional Stromboli
$14.49
Pepperoni, sausage, onion & green pepper
Garden Stromboli
$13.99
Spinach, mushrooms, diced tomato, green peppers & broccoli
Syracuse Stuffer Stromboli
$14.99
Steak, onion, green peppers & mushroom
Spinach Stromboli
$13.98
With ricotta and mozzarella cheese
Sausage Stromboli
$13.98
Sausage, mushrooms and cheese over delicious red sauce
Pepperoni Stromboli
$13.98
With pasta sauce and mozzarella cheese
Specialty Pizza
Premium Pagoni's Pizza Creations
The Star Special Pizza
Sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, green pepper, black olive, diced tomato & mozzarella cheese
Thin Crust, Round: Small 12" (Serves 2)$18.99
Thin Crust, Round: Medium 14" (Serves 2-3)$21.99
Thin Crust, Round: Large 16" (Serves 3-4)$25.99
Thin Crust, Round: Family 18" (Serves 4-5)$29.99
Sicilian: 1/4 Sheet (Serves 2-3)$20.99
Sicilian: 1/2 Sheet (Serves 4-5)$29.99
Deep Dish: Small 10" (Serves 2-3)$20.99
Deep Dish: Large 12" (Serves 3-4)$26.99
The "Don" Pizza
Italian beef, Italian sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, onions & mozzarella
Thin Crust, Round: Small 12" (Serves 2)$18.99
Thin Crust, Round: Medium 14" (Serves 2-3)$21.99
Thin Crust, Round: Large 16" (Serves 3-4)$25.99
Thin Crust, Round: Family 18" (Serves 4-5)$29.99
Sicilian: 1/4 Sheet Serves 2-3)$20.99
Sicilian: 1/2 Sheet (Serves 4-5)$29.99
Deep Dish: Small 10" (Serves 2-3)$20.99
Deep Dish: Large 12" (Serves 3-4)$26.99
Mama Pagoni's Kitchen Sink Pizza
Sausage, pepperoni, green peppers, onions, mushrooms & mozzarella
Thin Crust, Round: Small 12" (Serves 2)$18.99
Thin Crust, Round: Medium 14" (Serves 2-3)$21.99
Thin Crust, Round: Large 16" (Serves 3-4)$25.99
Thin Crust, Round: Family 18" (Serves 4-5)$29.99
Sicilian: 1/4 Sheet (Serves 2-3)$20.99
Sicilian: 1/2 Sheet (Serves 4-5)$29.99
Deep Dish: Small 10" (Serves 2-3)$20.99
Deep Dish: Large 12" (Serves 3-4)$26.99
The Ulti-Meat Pizza
Sausage, pepperoni, ham, ground beef, bacon & mozzarella cheese
Thin Crust, Round: Small 12" (Serves 2)$18.99
Thin Crust, Round: Medium 14" (Serves 2-3)$21.99
Thin Crust, Round: Large 16" (Serves 3-4)$25.99
Thin Crust, Round: Family 18" (Serves 4-5)$29.99
Sicilian: 1/4 Sheet (Serves 2-3)$20.99
Sicilian: 1/2 Sheet (Serves 4-5)$29.99
Deep Dish: Small 10" (Serves 2-3)$20.99
Deep Dish: Large 12" (Serves 3-4)$26.99
The Great White Pizza
Grilled chicken, olive oil, fresh garlic, fresh basil, spinach, red onions, diced tomatoes, romano & mozzarella cheese (no red sauce)
Invented here. Pagoni's dessert bombs are filled with creamy fillings, topped with icing or powdered sugar & served warm. Made to order!
Chocolate Bomb
$9.99
Chewy, sweet crust overflowing with hazelnut chocolate, topped with powdered sugar
Apple Bomb
$9.99
Chewy, sweet crust stuffed with hot apple pie filling, topped with icing. It's the bomb!
Cherry Bomb
$9.99
Calzone-style crust filled with cherry pie filling & drizzled with icing
Just for Kids
All Dine-In kids selections include a small fountain drink or glass of white or chocolate milk
Kid's Cutie Pie Tray
$9.99
Kid's sauce & top their own pizza with up to 2 toppings. Dine in only
Kid's 2-Topping Pizza
$8.99
Additional Toppings (Each)
$0.99
Kid's Chicken Strips
$7.99
with potato wedges
Kid's Spaghetti
$7.99
with marinara sauce & a breadstick
Soda
Nothing like a cold soda to go with your pizza. We offer Coke, Diet Coke, and Sprite in 2 Liters and cans
Soda
Cans$1.89
2 Liter$3.99
*Healthy
Dinner Party Buffet
Capacity: Minimum 15, Maximum 30 people, Dine-In Only, Reservation Required. Per Person: $15.95
Garden or Caesar Salad
Endless Soda
Garlic Breadsticks
Cavatappi with Alfredo Sauce
Penne with Marinara Sauce
Endless Different Pizza Creations
Dessert to Top Off a Perfect Meal!
Appetizers
1 Dozen Garlic Breadsticks
$12.99
Add Pint of Marinara Sauce
$6.95
Half Sheet Dipping Sticks
$21.99
with four sides of Marinara
Traditional Bone-In Wings
Hot or BBQ
5 Lbs$59.99
Boneless Wings
50 Pieces$54.99
Add Pint of Ranch or Blue Cheese
$6.95
Loaf of Garlic Bread
$9.99
Loaf of French Bread
$5.99
Quart of Marinara
$6.95
Italian Meatballs
In Marinara Sauce
Half Pan (25)$39.99
Full Pan (50)$69.99
Submarine Sandwich
8 four-inch sub tray serves 6-7 people $44.99, 16 four-inch sub tray serves 12-14 people $74.99
Turkey
Italian French bread, Romaine lettuce, sliced turkey, sliced tomatoes and provolone cheese with a side of mayo or Italian dressing
Ham
Italian French bread, Romaine lettuce, sliced ham, sliced tomatoes and provolone cheese with a side of mayo or Italian dressing
Italian
Italian French bread, Romaine lettuce, sliced ham, salami, pepperoni, sliced tomatoes and provolone cheese with a side of house Italian dressing
Pasta Tray
Half Pan serves - 8-10 people, Full Pan serves - 16-20 people
Chicken & Broccoli Cavatappi with Alfredo Sauce
Spiral tube-shaped noodles with grilled chicken and broccoli, cooked in our house made garlic Alfredo sauce. A must-have at any event!
Half$54.99
Full$99.99
Meat Lasagna
Hand-layered made fresh to order. Parmesan marinara sauce slowly cooked with ground beef and ricotta cheese. Topped with mozzarella & Parmesan cheese, baked to a perfect golden brown
Half$54.99
Full$99.99
Spinach Lasagna
Hand-layered made fresh to order. Parmesan marinara sauce slowly cooked with spinach and ricotta cheese. Topped with mozzarella & Parmesan cheese, baked to a perfect golden brown
Half$54.99
Full$99.99
Mona Lisa Pasta
Mostaccioli with sliced Italian sausage or grilled chicken, sautéed mushrooms, onions, green peppers & roasted red peppers resting in our garlic butter Alfredo sauce
Half$59.99
Full$104.99
Baked Mostaccioli with Marinara Sauce
Penne noodles layered in our house made marinara, topped with mozzarella and Parmesan cheese
Half$49.99
Full$89.99
Baked Mostaccioli with Meat Sauce
Penne noodles layered in our meat sauce, topped with mozzarella and Parmesan cheese
Half$54.99
Full$99.99
Salad Tray
Half Pan serves 8-10 people (32 oz of dressing), Full Pan serves 16-20 people (64 oz of dressing)
Garden Salad
Romaine lettuce mixed with spinach, broccoli, fresh sliced mushrooms, diced green peppers, sliced tomatoes and red onions. Topped with shredded Parmesan cheese
Half$34.99
Full$59.99
Chicken Caesar Salad
Rich Romaine lettuce, grilled chicken, seasoned croutons, topped with shredded Parmesan cheese. With a side of creamy Caesar dressing
Half$39.99
Full$69.99
Antipasto Salad
Iceberg lettuce, pepperoni, salami, provolone cheese, black olives, diced green peppers, mild giardiniera mix, black pepper and oregano seasoning. Topped with pepperoncini peppers and shredded Parmesan cheese. With a side of our house Italian dressing
Half$39.99
Full$69.99
Chef Salad
Blend of Romaine and Iceberg lettuce. Sliced turkey, ham and salami. Sliced black olives & tomatoes and diced green peppers. Topped with shredded mozzarella cheese
Half$39.99
Full$69.99
Chicken Bacon Salad
Blend of Romaine and Iceberg lettuce. Grilled chicken, Yorkshire bacon, sliced tomatoes, cheddar & Parmesan cheese