ham, sausage, pepperoni with imported romano and the finest grande mozzarella cheeses surrounded by a thin light golden crust all around. no sauce.
our famous tomato sauce - sausage, meatball, ricotta, imported romano and the finest grande mozzarella cheeses surrounded by a thin light golden crust all around.
Stuffed Vegetable Pizza
fresh mushrooms, spinach, broccoli, imported romano and the finest grande mozzarella cheeses surrounded by a thin light crust all around.
pepperoni, sausage, meatball, anchovies, green peppers, onions, garlic, olives, broccoli, spinach, extra cheese.
Each Adtl. Topping Per Slice$0.75
our house made fresh mozzarella, ricotta, chicken cutlet, ham, prosciutto, fresh mushrooms, porcini mushrooms, eggplant, artichoke, capers.
Whole Pie Or Half Pie
Our Famous Signature Pizza Pies
Round Cheese Pizza (8 Slices)
our famous signature pie! light thin crust topped with our famous house tomato sauce, the finest grande mozzarella & romano cheeses.
Fresh Mozzarella With Basil Pizza
our very own house made fresh mozzarella is used for this pie. the crust is topped with a plum tomato sauce made especially for this pie, the fresh mozzarella is placed in between, sprinkled with a generous layer of imported romano cheese, then topped off with a swirl of imported italian extra virgin olive oil and fresh basil.
a cheese lovers favorite! oozing with imported romano and the finest ricotta and grande mozzarella cheeses. no sauce.
Sicilian Pizza (12 Slices)
good old new york style sicilian a cooked onion based sauce, sprinkled with imported italian romano cheese, covered with the finest grande mozzarella and all this on a light and airy deep dish square crust.
Upside Down Pizza (12 Slices)
a first cousin of the new york style sicilian. this is the true sicilian pie and another famous signature pie. a sauce lovers favorite the finest grande mozzarella covers a light and airy deep dish square crust. the mozzarella covered with a cooked onion based sauce, then finished with imported romano cheese and extra virgin olive oil, sauce on top of the cheese, hence upside down pizza.
Marinara Pizza (12 Slices)
a delicious garlic based marinara sauce, sprinkled with imported romano cheese and finished with fresh basil. no mozzarella.
NY Pizza Suprema was established in 1964 in this location by my father Salvatore Riggio, an Italian immigrant. PLAIN SLICES ONLY”, was announced several times a day when customers would ask for toppings on their slice. But even though “NO” was often said to customers, these very same customers came back because that plain slice was so delicious. My father believed in keeping things simple. Pizza here at NY Pizza Suprema is not just another item on a long Diner's style menu... it pretty much is our menu. We take pizza making very seriously here! We use three different sauces for our different pizzas. One for our regular cheese with their toppings, one for our Marinara, Sicilian/Up side down pizza and one for our Fresh Mozzarella with Basil pizza. Also, we make our very own fresh Mozzarella cheese.