What's wrong with this menu?
Nancy's Cake Appeal & Other Goodies
4405 N Calumet Ave,Suite B & C
Valparaiso, IN 46383
Uber
MORE PHOTOS
Main Menu
Delivery: $40 within a 10 mile radius. After 10 miles call for quote. ($1.50/mile)
Cakes
Celebration Cake
Any style or size with basic decoration and border at bottom and Buttercream and filling. Two layer cake. Single layers are half price. Round cakes only - All other shapes additional $15
- 6" - Serves 12 $27.00
- 8" - Serves 24 $37.00
- 10" - Serves 38 $55.00
- 12" - Serves 56 $65.00
- 14" - Serves 78 $80.00
- 16" - Serves 100 $115.00
- Fondant 6"
- $15.00
- Fondant 8"
- $25.00
- Fondant 10"
- $25.00
- Fondant 12"
- $35.00
- Fondant 14"
- $45.00
- Fondant 16"
- $60.00
Sheet Cakes
approx 2x2x2 one layer only. Double Sheet cakes with filling additional charge. Themed cakes, fondant decorations or special embellishments are additional for time and material. Quarter (9x13) - Serves 28, Half (11x15) - Serves 35, Full (12x18) - Serves 54, Super Full 2-12x18 - Serves 108
- Quarter (9x13) $35.00
- Quarter (9x13) - Double $65.00
- Half (11x15) $45.00
- Half (11x15) - Double $85.00
- Full (12x18) $55.00
- Full (12x18) - Double $125.00
- Super Full 2-12x18 $145.00
Sugar Sheets
- Sheet with their picture $11.00
- Sheet if we do cake $7.00
- Sheet plain $1.75
Celebration Cakes
3D Cakes & Design
prices are approximate and depend on framing and structure of cake. sizes are approximate. Gingerbread house will vary depending on embellishments. Baby Belly Cakes will vary. Ask for price
- Small 8"x16" $95.00
- Medium 10"x18" $180.00
- Large 14"x10" $300.00
Character and Themed Cakes
dogs, bunnys, luau, boots etc.
- Small $50.00
- Medium $65.00
- Large $90.00
Cupcakes
over 2dz. $0.25 less per cupcake. Basic decorations. Embellishments additional charge
- Mini (per dz) $14.00
- Mini (each) $1.25
- Regular (per dz) $24.00
- Regular (each) $2.20
- Jumbo (per 6) $20.00
- Jumbo (each ) $3.75
Cookies
Peanut butter, chocolate chip, shortbread, sugar, tea cakes, oatmeal and many others. Thumbprint, kolache/kolacky, snicker doodles, etc.
- Small (per dz) $8.99
- Small (half dz) $5.25
- Small (each) $0.80
- Med (per dz) $9.99
- Med (half dz) $5.95
- Med (each ) $0.95
- Lg (per dz ) $10.99
- Lg (half dz ) $6.25
- Lg (each ) $1.29
- Nuts, raisins, dipped or filled additional (per dz)
- $2.75
- Nuts, raisins, dipped or filled additional (half dz)
- $2.00
- Nuts, raisins, dipped or filled additional (each)
- $0.75
Kolaczki
Apricot, prune, raspberry, strawberry, Blueberry, lemon, nut, almond etc.
- (per dz) $12.99
Cookies Flooded /Iced
Iced BC
- Small 1" $9.99
- Med 2" $10.99
- Large 3" $11.99
Flooded
- Small 1" $14.99
- Med 2" $17.99
- Large 3" $20.99
Brownies
Additional charge - Rocky road, explosion (malted balls & nuts), coconut, peanut butter, caramel, etc.
- Regular $2.25
- 8x8 Pan $19.99
- 9x13 Pan $29.99
- Additional Charge
- $3.00
Bundt Cake
Apple, Berry, Pumpkin, Spice, Maple etc.
- Mini (12 per) $30.00
- Mini (each) $2.75
- Medium (12 per ) $45.00
- Medium (each) $3.99
- Large (Regular) $19.99
Pies - Regular 9"
Apple, Peach, Pumpkin, Cherry, Blueberry, Mixed Berry, Strawberry, etc.
- $13.00
- Deep Dish $15.00
Pies - Cream 9"
Banana, Chocolate, French Silk, Coconut, Peanut Butter, Lemon, Oreo, etc.
- $15.00
- Deep Dish $17.00
Cheese Cake
Additional charge for flavored cheese cakes (w/ topping)
- 10" $30.00
- Cheese Cake bites (each) $1.50
- Cheese Cake bites (per dz) $14.99
- Cheese Cake bites (w/ topping) (each) $1.70
- Cheese Cake bites (w/ topping) (per dz) $20.00
- Topping additional
- $8.00
Chocolate Covered Fruits & Snacks
Ask about our gift or package prices
Strawberries, Bananas, Apples, Oranges
depending on season
- (each) $2.25
- (per dz) $23.00
Pretzel Rods, Graham Crackers & Oreos
- (each) $1.75
Popcorn Flavored
- Small $1.75
- Large $2.50
Mini Pretzel
- (per lb.) $7.99
Chocolate Covered Nuts
- (per lb.) $10.99
Dessert Bars & Rolls
Most bars are approx 2x2 and $2.25 each. Bars can be ordered in 8x8 pan for $28 or 9x13 $38
Salted Caramel
$2.75Seven Layer
$2.75Chocolate Carmel Shortbread
- $2.75
- For 8x8 pan $28.00
Nut Roll
Baklava, Raspberry Oatmeal Bars, Apple & Cherry Squares, Cobblers, Cream Puffs, Mini Eclairs, etc.
- (per roll) $28.00
Pumpkin Roll
Baklava, Raspberry Oatmeal Bars, Apple & Cherry Squares, Cobblers, Cream Puffs, Mini Eclairs, etc.
- (per roll) $28.00
Cannoli
Baklava, Raspberry Oatmeal Bars, Apple & Cherry Squares, Cobblers, Cream Puffs, Mini Eclairs, etc.
- Sm (each) $1.79
- Sm (per dz) $19.00
- Lg. (each) $2.49
- Lg. (per dz) $27.00
Candies
Buckeyes
- (each) $0.85
- (per 6) $5.25
- (per 12) $8.99
Turtles
- Half pound $6.99
Cake Pops
decorated characters etc start at $3.50
- (each) $2.50
- (per 12) $27.00
Chocolate Truffles
- (each) $1.25
- (per 6) $7.00
- (per 12) $20.00
Cake Balls
- (each ) $0.79
- (per 6) $5.25
- (per dz) $8.99
Chocolate Covered Caramels
- Half pound $6.99
Wedding & Specialty Cakes
cutting in 1" x 2" slices approx 4" tall. Specializing in Gum paste Flowers, Fondant and other Confection designs. Wedding Cake Prices include Basic round cakes and basic decorations. Other shapes additional charge on request. Squares Cakes and other shapes $10/ layer additional. Size 6" - 12 no. of people, 8" - 24 no. of people, 10" - 38 no. of people, 12" - 56 no. of people, 14" - 78 no. of people, 16" - 100 no. of people.
Round Cakes
Cake flavors included in prices Below: Vanilla, Yellow Butter, Chocolate, Banana, Marble. Other cake flavors are additional. depending on ingredients. Icing Flavors included in prices Below: Buttercream any flavor. Italian Buttercream, French Buttercream, Swiss Buttercream $2 per slice. Filling Flavors any
2 Tier
- (6" & 8") Serves 36 $125.00
- (6" & 10") Serves 50 $150.00
- (8" & 10") Serves 62 $185.00
3 Tier
(6", 8", &10") Serves 74
- (6", 8", & 10") Serves 74 $300.00
- (8", 10", & 12") Serves 118 $350.00
- (10", 12", 14") Serves 172 $516.00
- (12", 14" & 16") Serves 234 $702.00
4 Tier
- (6", 8", 10" & 14") Serves 130 $465.00
5 Tier
- (6", 8", 10", 12" & 14") Serves 208 $735.00
- (6", 8", 10", 12" & 16") Serves 230 $805.00
Fondant
varies for cake size (wedding and Celebration Cakes)
6" to 8" Cake
- (each size) $15.00
10" Cake
- (each ) $20.00
12" to 14" Cake
- (each size) $30.00
16" Cake
$40.00Cake Add on
Fresh Fruit & Additional Items
- (per tier) $10.00
Chocolate Chips
Marshmallows, M & M etc additional
- (per tier) $7.00
Nuts and Dried Fruit
- (per tier) $8.00
Cake Tasting
An appointment is required for a Cake Taste with a fee of $50. If you choose to work with Nancy's Cake Appeal as your Cake Designer, the $50 fee will go towards the deposit of your Wedding Cake. If you choose not to use Nancy's Cake Appeal after the Cake Taste, NCA will keep $25 for the cake, filling, icing and time and return the remainder of $25. If you do not show up for your appointment we will keep your $50 fee. If you need to cancel your Cake Taste, please do so, 1 week prior to your appointment. If it is less than 1 week prior to your tasting you may reschedule within 1 month or forfeit the $50 fee.
Fake Cakes
Fake Cakes
Fake Cakes can be decorated and made to top off a cake if more tries are wanted without all the extra cake. These cakes will look real and match the style of your wedding cake. Just don't eat it!
- 6" $20.00
- 8" $28.00
- 10" $48.00
- 12" $58.00
- 14" $75.00
- 16" $98.00
Basic Flavors
included in cake price
Yellow (vanilla)
Chocolate
Banana
Marble
White
Carrot
Dark Chocolate
Lemon Zinger
Red Velvet
Strawberry
Pistachio
Pink Champagne
Coconut Pineapple
Apple
Black Forest
Cherry
German Chocolate
Chocolate Raspberry
Chocolate Fudge
Double Chocolate
Hazel nut
Maple
Lemonade
Fruit Punch
Orange
Cream Cheese
Basic
included in cake price
Butter Cream
Vanilla, Chocolate, Flavored BC - any flavor coffee, cream cheese etc
Peanut Butter
Cream Cheese
Italian, Swiss etc
Meringue any flavor
Strawberry Meringue
Chocolate Ganache
German Chocolate
Maple
Hazel Nut
Basic
included in cake price
Butter Cream
any flavor
Whipped
Amaretto Cream
Peanut Butter Cream
Lemon Curd
Raspberry
strawberry (any berry)
Mousse
any flavor
Mint Chocolate Chip
Mocha
Bavarian Cream Banana
chocolate etc
Main
After 5 to Infinity. Make your party extra special by celebrating at Nancy's Cake Appeal. You and your friends will have fun decorating yummy treats. Each guest will decorate (parents choice) cupcakes, cookies, or brownies, and the Honoree will decorate a 6" cake. Parents can relax and enjoy the party and let our staff take care of all preparation, and best of all, the cleanup.
Package Cost
Package Cost is $300 (deposit of $50 required to reserve date and room) balance of party must be paid two weeks prior to. Event is 2 hrs. Parents - you may bring food in the party room if you schedule it ahead of time with N.C.A. (A clean up charge may occur).
The cost includes, honoree and 10 quests (extra quests are $35 per guests (maximum of 12)
Cake & Cupcakes choice of (Chocolate, yellow, or white)
2 Icing bags of different colors: not all guests will have the same colors so they can share
Each guest will have paper aprons and hats, and the honoree will have a chef hat with their name on it and apron
Refreshment, Chips and Popcorn!
Cups, napkins, plates and forks
Group picture 4 x 6 once developed
We will also put one on our party wall
Play a Game
if time permits
Decorations include; table cloth & ballons
Pictures can be taken in front of our fantasy walls for selfies or groups!
Additional Items Can be Purchased
Other items may be purchased to decorate: brownies, cookies, jumbo cupcakes, mini cakes etc for additional charge
Candles
Gift Bags
Gifts for guests
Theme Parties
Plates, napkins, decorations, ballons
N.C.A. T-Shirts
Dessert Buffet
Dessert Buffet
minimum of 30 guests. Includes 3 desserts listed below.
- (per person) $4.50
Candy Buffet
Includes 6-7 different candy items and one popcorn (large bowl). Any chocolate covered items would be $1 per person.
- (per person) $4.00
Dessert & Candy Buffet
minimum of 30 guests. Includes 2 Desserts & 5 Candies.
- (per person) $4.50
Customized Candy Buffet
Includes 8-9 candy items in matching color to match your theme. Dessert Items are listed below. Prices for buffet will be quoted separately for items below.
- (per person) $6.00
Bars & Other Desserts
Most bars are $2.50/slice 2x2 approx size (call for quote on larger quantities)
Baklava
Lemon Squares
Raspberry Oatmeal Bars
Apple Squares
Pumpkin Rolls
Chocolate Rolls
Cream Cheese Squares
Cobblers
Peach, Blueberry & Apple
Fruit Cobbler
Chocolate Truffles
Whoopie Pies
Mini Wedding Cakes
Cream Puffs
Petite Four
Cake Push Pops/Cake Pops
Flavored Popcorn
Chocolate Covered Strawberries
Chocolate Pretzel Sticks
Cake Balls
Turtles
Chocolate Covered Nuts
Cheese Cake Bite Size
Browse Nearby
General Info
Cuisine
Bakery
Dessert
Hours
Monday:
-
Tuesday:
10:00am - 6:00pm
Wednesday:
10:00am - 6:00pm
Thursday:
10:00am - 6:00pm
Friday:
10:00am - 6:00pm
Saturday:
10:00am - 5:00pm
Sunday:
10:00am - 3:00pm
About Us
Nancy's Cake Appeal makes custom wedding cakes, custom celebration cakes, cupcakes, desserts and much more. Our bakery case is filled with homemade dessert items every week. We also host birthday parties that teach kids how to decorate cakes & cookies.We also create dessert and candy buffets for all occasions! Come see what we're all about!