What's wrong with this menu?
Mitchell's Tavern
734 Sheridan Dr
Tonawanda, NY 14150
Uber
MORE PHOTOS
Main Menu
Prices Subject to Change. Ask Your Server About Our Beer, Liquor & Wine Selection. Place order 716-874-8907
Starters
Mozzarella Sticks
$6.25
Five (5) battered mozzarella cheese sticks, served with a side of marinara
Pizza Logs
$7.00
Four (4) cheese & pepperoni logs, served with a side of marinara
Buffalo Shrimp
$9.75
Eight (8) hand breaded butterfly shrimp tossed in hot sauce, served with celery & bleu cheese
Mitchell's Fries
Crispy fries topped with roast beef & our very own steak sauce
- Small $7.00
- $7.75
Pickle Fries
$7.50
Packing a puckerful punch, our lightly battered pickle fries are served with a zesty Boom Boom sauce
Buffalo Fries
$4.50
French fries tossed in hot sauce, served with celery & bleu cheese
Pretzel Sticks
$5.75
Ten (10) mini pretzel sticks lightly salted and served with honey mustard
Sides
French Fries
Lightly salted with a crisp
- Small $2.75
- $3.50
- Add Gravy
- $0.75
- Add Texas Sauce
- $0.75
Sweet Potato Fries
$4.75
Hand-cut sweet potato fries, served with honey & butter
Cajun Fries
Our crisp fries with a kick of cajun seasoning
- Small $3.25
- $4.00
Onion Rings
$4.25
Thick cut onion rings, lightly breaded
- Add Boom Boom Sauce
- $0.75
- Small
- $2.50
Bag of Chips
$1.75
Ask server for choice selection
Potato Salad
$2.25Coleslaw
$2.25Salads
Dressings: Balsamic, Italian, Honey French, Greek, Ranch, Bleu Cheese, Honey Mustard, Extra Dressing +$0.75
Buffalo Chicken Finger Salad
$9.50
Lettuce with tomatoes, onions, croutons & a pepperoncini topped with breaded chicken fingers tossed in your choice of sauce
Greek Salad
$8.75
Lettuce with feta, tomatoes, onions, black olives & a pepperoncini
- Add Chicken
- $2.00
Grilled Chicken Salad
$9.50
Chicken breast over lettuce topped with tomatoes, onions, croutons & a pepperoncini
House Salad
Lettuce, tomatoes, onions, croutons & a pepperoncini
- Small $5.50
- $6.75
Hand Held Sandwiches
All sandwiches served on a fresh Costanzo roll (unless otherwise noted) with a pickle spear
Roast Beef - Our House Specialty
$9.25
Lean roast beef, slow roasted to perfection, served with our very own gravy on a plain Costanzo roll or Kimmelweck. Also served on white bread with our homemade gravy smothered on top
- Add (5) Wings
- $7.50
Spicy Philly Beef - A Mitchell's Specialty
$9.75
Philly style beef, American cheese, fried onions with Carlos hot sauce for an extra kick
Roast Beef Melt
$10.00
Roast beef served with Swiss, sautéed onions, homemade gravy on rye bread
Carolina BBQ Beef
$9.75
Delicious BBQ sauce with roast beef, topped with coleslaw
Burgers & Chicken
Mitchell's burgers are 1/3 lb. USDA ground beef patties served on a fresh Costanzo roll with a pickle spear. Add Extras: American, Swiss, Feta, Cheddar, Provolone & Crumbly Bleu Cheese, Bacon and/or Sautéed Mushrooms +$0.75
Classic Burger
$7.50
Lettuce, tomato & mayo
- Add Cheese
- $0.75
Habanero Burger
$9.50
Hand-pressed with fresh diced habanero peppers, finished with shredded cheddar, jalapenos, lettuce, tomato & mayo
Black & Blue Burger
$9.00
Crumbly bleu cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato & mayo
Mushroom Swiss Burger
$9.00
Sautéed mushrooms, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato & mayo
Southwestern BBQ Burger
$9.25
Bacon, onion ring, American cheese, BBQ sauce, lettuce, tomato & mayo
Classic Chicken
$7.50
Grilled or fried chicken with lettuce, tomato & mayo
Buffalo Style Chicken
$8.25
Grilled or fried chicken in your choice of mild, medium or hot, topped with lettuce, tomato & bleu cheese
- Specialty Sauce
- $0.75
Southwestern BBQ Chicken
$9.25
Grilled or fried chicken topped with bacon, onion ring, American cheese, BBQ sauce, lettuce, tomato & mayo
Patty Melt
$9.25
Burger patty with American cheese, sauteed onions and Thousand Island dressing on Rye Bread
Old School Favorites
Meatloaf
Two slices of homemade meatloaf served with our very own gravy on a Costanzo roll. Also served on white bread with our homemade gravy smothered on top
- Half $8.75
- 2 Slices $9.75
Mitchell's Texas Hot
$3.75
Sahlen's hot dog with onion, mustard & Nick's homemade Texas sauce, same as Dad served over 50 years ago
Fried Bologna
$7.75
An American Classic - bologna covered with fried onions & your choice of cheese on a Costanzo roll
- Upgrade to Steak House
- $1.00
Mitchell's Royal
$9.00
Italian sausage topped with spicy capicola & melted provolone cheese with lettuce, tomato & mayo on a Costanzo roll
Fish Fillet
$8.75
Beer battered cod fillet deep fried, served with lettuce, tomato & tartar sauce on a Costanzo roll
Wraps
Served on your choice of wheat or spinach wrap
Mitchell's Wrap - A Mitchell's Specialty
$9.50
Roast beef, fried onions, sautéed mushrooms, Swiss cheese, horseradish sauce & a touch of gravy
Stinger Wrap
$9.75
Roast beef, chicken fingers tossed in your choice of sauce with bleu cheese, lettuce, tomatoes & onions
Greek Wrap
$9.00
Grilled chicken, black olives, onions, lettuce, tomatoes, feta & Greek dressing
Chicken Ranch Wrap
$9.00
Grilled chicken, bacon, ranch, lettuce tomatoes & onions
Chicken Finger Wrap
$9.00
Chicken fingers tossed in your choice of sauce with bleu cheese, lettuce, tomatoes & onions
Wings & Things
Served plain, mild, medium & hot. Specialty Sauces (+$0.75): Sweet Baby Ray's BBQ, Carlos Hot, Cajun, Jack Daniels BBQ, Deep Eddy's Garlic Parmesan & Honey Mustard
Chicken Fingers
$10.25
Four (4) fingers tossed in your choice of sauce, served with French fries, celery & bleu cheese
Chicken Wings
$15.00
Ten (10) wings in your choice of sauce, served with bleu cheese & celery
Boneless Wings
$10.75
Ten (10) wings in your choice of sauce, served with bleu cheese & celery
Seafood
Served Daily with French fries, potato salad, coleslaw tartar or cocktail sauce & lemon wedge
Fish Fry
$15.00
Beer battered haddock fillet
Shrimp
$14.75
Ten (10) hand breaded butterfly shrimp
Fall / Winter
Award Winning Homemade Chili
Best of show 2012 Ballpark Brew Bash Chili cook-off
- Bowl $4.25
- Add Cheese
- $0.75
- Add Sour Cream
- $0.50
- Add Loaded Chili Cheese Fries
- $2.25
- Add Grilled Cheese
- $3.50
Pork
Pulled Pork Sandwich
$9.25
BBQ homemade pulled pork topped with coleslaw on a Costanzo roll
Pulled Pork Hot Dog
$5.25
Bacon wrapped Sahlen's hot dog with BBQ pulled pork & shredded cheddar cheese on a hot dog bun
BBQ Pork Cheeseburger
$12.75
BBQ pulled pork, burger, American cheese, bacon, onion ring, lettuce, tomato & mayo on fresh Costanzo roll
Pig Skin BBQ
$10.25
BBQ pulled pork, bacon, bologna & shredded cheese on a fresh Costanzo roll
Kids Menu
$6.50; Children 12 & under. All kids meals include French fries & a beverage
Chicken Fingers
$6.50Hot Dog
$6.50Grilled Cheese
$6.50Pizza Logs
$6.50Beverages
Ask Your Server About Our Beer, Liquor & Wine Selection
Soda
$2.75
Free refills with a meal! - Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Ginger Ale, Mountain Dew, Sierra Mist, Lipton Iced Tea, Unsweetened Tea, Lemonade, Loganberry & Eroquois Keg Birch Beer
Bottled Water
$2.75Energy Drinks
Red Bull & Sugar Free Red Bull
Prices Subject To Change
Browse Nearby
General Info
Payment Types
All Major Cards
Cuisine
American - Traditional
Meals
Lunch
Dinner
Late Night
About Us
As one of the Buffalo's last great Tavern's, my staff and I strive to make your experience here a pleasurable one. We are famous for our mouth-watering beef on weck, beer battered haddock and juicy burgers. That doesn't mean you shouldn't try our homemade Texas sauce, delicious wings or sweet potato fries. Our goal is that our guests go home satisfied with the food, atmosphere and service that we provide.