If you're like us, you know exactly which cookies you want. Choose to fill this box with all oatmeal raisin, or go nuts and get eleven banana split, and one rocky road. This is your moment. Seize it with your perfect box of cookies. We reserve the right to swap out flavors if one of your selected flavors is unavailable. Choice of cookie: Banana Split, Birthday Cookie, Chocolate Chip, Chocolate Chip Walnut, Chocolate Peanut Butter, Chocolate Pecan Caramel, Cinnamon Sugar, Gluten Free Chocolate Chip, Mint Chocolate, Oatmeal Chocolate Chip, Oatmeal Raisin, Rocky Road, White Chocolate Macadamia, White Chocolate Raspberry, Seasonal: Lemon Blueberry, Seasonal: Gluten Free Lemon Sugar.
One Dozen Box
$30.00
Build your own box of 12 fresh-baked cookies!
vegetarian
One & A Half Dozen Box
$45.00
Build your own box of 18 fresh-baked cookies!
Two Dozen Box
$60.00
Build your own box of 24 fresh-baked cookies!
Cookie of The Month Club
Enroll in Milk Jar's Cookie of the Month Club and you won't just get fresh-baked cookies delivered to your doorstep each month - you'll become a member of a secret society of cookie lovers. To sweeten the deal, we discount the cookies by 10-15% and send you super-secret Members Only promotions. A Cookie of the Month Club membership also makes an incredible gift for the special people in your life. Who knows, maybe they'll return the favor... How it works: Once a month, we choose our favorite cookies, box them up, and ship them to mailboxes across the country. It's truly as easy as that!
Cookie of The Month Club
vegetarian
Half Dozen for 6 Months$81.00
Dozen for 6 Months$162.00
Half Dozen for 12 Months$153.00
Dozen for 12 Months$306.00
Ice Cream
Now scooping fresh Fosselman's ice cream!
Ice Cream Scoop
$2.50
Grab a delicious serving of fresh ice cream in any of our four seasonally selected flavors french vanilla bean, lavender honey, cereal milk, rocky road.
vegetarian
Ice Cream Scoop with Cookie
$5.00
You shouldn't have to choose between ice cream and cookies, and we will never force that choice upon you.
vegetarian
Ice Cream Sandwich
$7.00
Because nothing is more perfect than fresh Fosselman's ice cream between two warm, fresh milk jar cookies.
vegetarian
Popular Assortments
Leave the tough decisions to us with this prix fixe variety of our most popular cookies. Whether treating yourself or someone else, these assortments are sure to be a crowd-pleaser. And, yes, we'll always include a chocolate chip cookie!