What's wrong with this menu?
Michael's New York Style Pizza
127 E Prospect St
Covington, VA 24426
Uber
MORE PHOTOS
Main Menu
Appetizers
Mozzarella Sticks and Sauce
$5.25Battered French Fries
$2.50Bacon Cheese Fries Melt
$6.25
Mozzarella & Cheddar
Onion Rings
$2.50Breaded Mushrooms
$5.25Home Fried Chips
$2.50Fried Pickles
$4.50Chicken Wings
$5.25
Honey Mustard, Ranch or Barbeque Sauce
Boneless Chicken Wings
$7.99
Barbeque Sauce, Buffalo or Honey Mustard
Stuffed Peppers (2)
$2.00Pizza
Extra Toppings - $1.75, Pizza by the Slice - $2.50, Extra Topping for Slice - $0.50, Slice of Special - $3.75
Cheese
- Medium - 6 Slices $10.00
- Large - 8 Slices $11.00
- Sicilian - 12 Slices $13.25
Extra Cheese
- Medium - 6 Slices $11.25
- Large - 8 Slices $12.25
- Sicilian - 12 Slices $14.25
Mushroom
- Medium - 6 Slices $11.25
- Large - 8 Slices $12.25
- Sicilian - 12 Slices $14.25
Sausage
- Medium - 6 Slices $11.25
- Large - 8 Slices $12.25
- Sicilian - 12 Slices $14.25
Chicken
- Medium - 6 Slices $11.25
- Large - 8 Slices $12.25
- Sicilian - 12 Slices $14.25
Pepperoni
- Medium - 6 Slices $11.25
- Large - 8 Slices $12.25
- Sicilian - 12 Slices $14.25
Green Peppers
- Medium - 6 Slices $11.25
- Large - 8 Slices $12.25
- Sicilian - 12 Slices $14.25
Onions
- Medium - 6 Slices $11.25
- Large - 8 Slices $12.25
- Sicilian - 12 Slices $14.25
Broccoli
- Medium - 6 Slices $11.25
- Large - 8 Slices $12.25
- Sicilian - 12 Slices $14.25
Anchovies
- Medium - 6 Slices $11.25
- Large - 8 Slices $12.25
- Sicilian - 12 Slices $14.25
Meatball
- Medium - 6 Slices $11.25
- Large - 8 Slices $12.25
- Sicilian - 12 Slices $14.25
Bacon
- Medium - 6 Slices $11.25
- Large - 8 Slices $12.25
- Sicilian - 12 Slices $14.25
Garlic
- Medium - 6 Slices $11.25
- Large - 8 Slices $12.25
- Sicilian - 12 Slices $14.25
Bonnie's Blond
Mozzarella, ricotta, mushroom, garlic and spinach
- Medium - 6 Slices $12.75
- Large - 8 Slices $13.75
- Sicilian - 12 Slices $15.75
Steak
- Medium - 6 Slices $12.50
- Large - 8 Slices $13.50
- Sicilian - 12 Slices $15.75
Hawaiian
Pineapple and ham
- Medium - 6 Slices $12.25
- Large - 8 Slices $13.75
- Sicilian - 12 Slices $15.75
Veggie
Green peppers, onion, garlic, tomato, mushroom, black olives and spinach
- Medium - 6 Slices $14.75
- Large - 8 Slices $15.75
- Sicilian - 12 Slices $17.75
Michael's Special
Pepperoni, sausage, green peppers, onion, garlic, mushrooms, ham and anchovies
- Medium - 6 Slices $14.75
- Large - 8 Slices $15.75
- Sicilian - 12 Slices $17.75
Baby Isabelle Pizza
$5.00
1 Ingredient, 4 small slices
- Add Extra Topping
- $0.50
Baby Special
$7.00Bread
$1.50Sauce
$1.50Bread & Sauce
$2.50Garlic Bread & Sauce
$3.75Garlic Cheese Bread & Sauce
$4.00Bread Sticks & Sauce
- Small $2.75
- Large $4.25
Salads
Add chicken to any salad - $1.50. All salads served with crackers. Choice of Dressings: Ranch, Bleu Cheese, Thousand Island, French and Italian
Chef Salad
Lettuce, tomato, mushrooms, green peppers, broccoli, cucumber, black olives, ham, salami, turkey, bacon bits and cheese
- Large $5.50
- Small $6.80
Tuna Salad
Tuna served on lettuce leaves, cottage cheese, pineapple, tomato and peaches
- Small $5.45
- Large $6.60
Gyro Salad
Gyro meat (beef and lamb), lettuce, tomato, onion, black olives, cucumber dressing and feta cheese
- Small $5.55
- Large $6.80
Small Side Salad
$3.20
Lettuce, cucumber, tomato, onion, bacon bits, mushrooms and cheese
Wraps
Available in Wheat by Request
Chicken Caesar Wrap
$5.50
Chicken, parmesan cheese, lettuce, tomato and Caesar dressing
Tuna Wrap
$5.00
Tuna, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayo
Turkey Wrap
$5.50
Turkey, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayo
Club Wrap
$6.00
Ham, turkey, bacon, provolone cheese, onion, lettuce, tomato and mayo
Dinners
For small dinner - subtract $1.50. All dinners served with side salad and bread, except chicken tenders, catfish
Lasagna
$8.25Manicotti
$8.25
Includes 2 manicottis
Raviol
$8.25
Includes 4 raviolis
Spaghetti
$6.80- With Meatballs
- $1.75
- With Meat Sauce
- $1.75
Chicken Parmesan
$9.25
Breaded chicken and mozzarella over spaghetti
Chicken Tenders
$6.25
With French fries
Catfish
$8.25
Cole slaw, hushpuppies and onion rings
World Famous Turnovers
All Turnovers Served With Sauce
Extra Large One Topping
$10.00- Extra Topping
- $1.50
Extra Large Special
$14.95- Extra Topping
- $1.50
Cheese
- Small $4.60
- Large $6.10
- Extra Topping
- $0.50
- Ricotta
- $0.75
Extra Cheese
- Small $5.00
- Large $6.50
- Extra Topping
- $0.50
- Ricotta
- $0.75
Mushroom
- Small $5.00
- Large $6.50
- Extra Topping
- $0.50
- Ricotta
- $0.75
Chicken
- Small $5.00
- Large $6.50
- Extra Topping
- $0.50
- Ricotta
- $0.75
Sausage
- Small $5.00
- Large $6.50
- Extra Topping
- $0.50
- Ricotta
- $0.75
Bacon
- Small $5.00
- Large $6.50
- Extra Topping
- $0.50
- Ricotta
- $0.75
Pepperoni
- Small $5.00
- Large $6.50
- Extra Topping
- $0.50
- Ricotta
- $0.75
Green Peppers
- Small $5.00
- Large $6.50
- Extra Topping
- $0.50
- Ricotta
- $0.75
Onion
- Small $5.00
- Large $6.50
- Extra Topping
- $0.50
- Ricotta
- $0.75
Broccoli
- Small $5.00
- Large $6.50
- Extra Topping
- $0.50
- Ricotta
- $0.75
Meatball
- Small $5.00
- Large $6.50
- Extra Topping
- $0.50
- Ricotta
- $0.75
Ham
- Small $5.00
- Large $6.50
- Extra Topping
- $0.50
- Ricotta
- $0.75
Steak
- Small $5.50
- Large $7.00
- Extra Topping
- $0.50
- Ricotta
- $0.75
Hawaiian
- Small $5.25
- Large $6.75
- Extra Topping
- $0.50
- Ricotta
- $0.75
Bonnie's Blond
Mozzarella, ricotta, mushroom, garlic and spinach
- Small $5.75
- Large $7.25
- Extra Topping
- $0.50
- Ricotta
- $0.75
Veggie
Green peppers, onion, garlic, tomato, mushroom, black olives and spinach
- Small $6.55
- Large $8.00
- Extra Topping
- $0.50
- Ricotta
- $0.75
Michael's Special
Pepperoni, mushrooms, ham, sausage, green peppers, onions, garlic and anchovies
- Small $6.80
- Large $8.25
- Extra Topping
- $0.50
- Ricotta
- $0.75
Beverages
Fountain Drinks
$1.79
(Includes 1 Free Refill) Coke, Diet Coke, Fanta Orange, Sprite and Extra Pibb
Can Drinks
$1.00
Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Diet Sprite, Extra Pibb, Root Beer, Orange and Grape
Coke and Extra Pibb 2 Liter
$2.99Bottled Water, Lemonade, Tea & Coffee
$1.00Desserts
New York Cheese Cake
$3.50
Chocolate syrup, cherry or strawberry topping
Chocolate Mousse Cheesecake
$3.50Cannoli
$3.50
Italian pastry shell filled with mixture of ricotta cheese, sugar and chocolate chips
Homemade Ice Cream
$3.50Homemade Brownie
$1.25Sandwiches
Chips and pickles served with subs when dining inside. Fried onions or banana peppers - no charge. Extra Topping - $.050, Extra meat - $0.75, Turkey and tuna subs served cold unless requested hot
Hoagie
Ham, salami, lettuce, onion, tomato, provolone cheese, oil and vinegar dressing
- Small $3.65
- Large $4.40
Meatball
Mozzarella cheese and sauce
- Small $3.65
- Large $4.40
Steak
Sauce
- Small $3.65
- Large $4.40
Ham & Cheese
Provolone cheese, ham, lettuce, tomato, oil and vinegar dressing
- Small $3.65
- Large $4.40
Cheese Steak
American cheese and sauce
- Small $3.85
- Large $4.60
Pizza Steak
Mozzarella cheese and sauce
- Small $3.85
- Large $4.60
Mushroom Steak
Mushroom and sauce
- Small $3.85
- Large $4.60
Pepper Steak
Green peppers and sauce
- Small $3.85
- Large $4.60
Elroy's Special
Steak, American cheese, mushrooms, pepperoni, banana peppers, green peppers and sauce. Onions by request
- Small $4.05
- Large $5.00
Michael's Gyro
Gyro meat (beef and lamb), lettuce, tomato, onion and cucumber dressing
- Small $4.05
- Large $5.00
Veggie Sandwich
Provolone cheese, green peppers, onion, garlic, tomato, mushroom, black olives and spinach
- Small $4.05
- Large $5.00
Tuna
Lettuce, tomato and mayo
- Small $3.75
- Large $4.75
Roasted Turkey
Baked daily with lettuce, tomato and mayo
- Small $4.30
- Large $5.25
Chicken
Lettuce, tomato and mayo
- Small $3.80
- Large $5.00
Chicken Parmesan
$5.50
Parmesan cheese, mozzarella cheese and sauce
Buffalo Burger
$5.25
Add your own toppings
Chicken Cheese Steak
Chicken steak and American cheese
- Small $4.30
- Large $5.25
Fish
Tarter sauce, lettuce and tomato
- Small $4.30
- Large $5.25
Broccoli & Chicken Cheddar Melt
Chicken steak, broccoli, garlic, cheddar cheese and mayo
- Small $4.50
- Large $5.50
Sloppy Jim
Ground beef in a spicy sauce
- Small $4.30
- Large $5.20
Michael's Club
Turkey, bacon, ham, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, mayo & onion
- Small $4.75
- Large $6.00
Michael's Cheese Quesadilla
$5.50
Mozzarella cheese melted on a grilled flour tortilla
Michael's Special Quesadilla
$6.75
Mozzarella cheese melted over your choice of grilled ingredients on a flour tortilla
Browse Nearby
General Info
Payment Types
All Major Cards
Cuisine
Pizza
Sandwiches
Hours
Monday:
-
Tuesday:
11:00am - 10:00pm
Wednesday:
11:00am - 10:00pm
Thursday:
11:00am - 10:00pm
Friday:
11:00am - 11:00pm
Saturday:
11:00am - 11:00pm
Sunday:
-
About Us
we serve only authentic New York style pizza, it is always served on our own homemade bread. Also, all sandwiches served come on this homemade bread, including our signature cheesesteak that tastes just like the authentic Philadelphia style cheesesteak. It's the best of both worlds!