What's wrong with this menu?
Mays Sandwich Shop
2525 Penn Ave # West
Reading, PA 19609
Uber
MORE PHOTOS
Retail Menu
Featured Item - Italians (Subs & Wraps)
Italian
Cooked & hard salami, capicola ham, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, oil & oregano.
- Small $3.99
- Large $5.99
- Wrap $4.50
Cheese Italian
White American & provolone cheese with lettuce, tomatoes, onions, oil & oregano.
- Small $4.70
- Large $6.99
- Wrap $5.20
Other Cold Subs/Wraps
Ham
Chipped ham, mayo, lettuce, tomatoes & onions.
- Small $3.99
- Large $5.99
- Wrap $4.50
- Add Extra Meat
- $1.00
Turkey
Chipped turkey, mayo, lettuce, tomatoes & onions.
- Small $4.70
- Large $6.99
- Wrap $5.20
- Add Extra Meat
- $1.00
Roast Beef
Chipped roast beef, mayo, lettuce, tomatoes & onions.
- Small $4.70
- Large $6.99
- Wrap $5.20
- Add Extra Meat
- $1.00
Tuna Salad
Homemade tuna salad with lettuce, tomatoes & onions.
- Small $4.70
- Large $6.99
- Wrap $5.20
- Add Extra Meat
- $1.00
Egg Salad
Homemade egg salad with lettuce, tomatoes & onions.
- Small $4.70
- Large $6.99
- Wrap $5.20
- Add Extra Meat
- $1.00
Chicken Salad
Homemade chicken salad with lettuce, tomatoes & onions.
- Small $4.70
- Large $6.99
- Wrap $5.20
- Add Extra Meat
- $1.00
Ham Salad
Homemade ham salad with lettuce, tomatoes & onions.
- Small $4.70
- Large $6.99
- Wrap $5.20
- Add Extra Meat
- $1.00
BLT Sub
Bacon, mayo, lettuce & tomatoes.
- Small $4.70
- Large $6.99
- Wrap $5.20
- Add Extra Meat
- $1.00
Vegetarian
Cucumber, lettuce, tomatoes & onions.
- Small $2.99
- Large $3.99
- Wrap $3.50
- Add Hardboiled Egg Slices
- $0.60
Ham & Cheese
Chipped ham, choice of cheese, mayo, lettuce, tomatoes & onions.
- Small $4.70
- Large $6.99
- Wrap $5.20
- Add Extra Meat
- $1.00
Turkey & Cheese
Chipped turkey, choice of cheese, mayo, lettuce, tomatoes & onions.
- Small $5.40
- Large $7.99
- Wrap $5.90
- Add Extra Meat
- $1.00
Roast Beef & Cheese
Chipped roast beef, choice of cheese, mayo, lettuce, tomatoes & onions.
- Small $5.40
- Large $7.99
- Wrap $5.90
- Add Extra Meat
- $1.00
Tuna Salad & Cheese
Homemade tuna salad with choice of cheese, lettuce, tomatoes & onions.
- Small $5.40
- Large $7.99
- Wrap $5.90
- Add Extra Meat
- $1.00
Egg Salad & Cheese
Homemade egg salad with choice of cheese, lettuce, tomatoes & onions.
- Small $5.40
- Large $7.99
- Wrap $5.90
- Add Extra Meat
- $1.00
Chicken Salad & Cheese
Homemade chicken salad with choice of cheese, lettuce, tomatoes & onions.
- Small $5.40
- Large $7.99
- Small $5.90
- Add Extra Meat
- $1.00
Ham Salad & Cheese
Homemade ham salad with choice of cheese, lettuce, tomatoes & onions.
- Small $5.40
- Large $7.99
- Wrap $5.90
- Add Extra Meat
- $1.00
BLT & Cheese Sub
Bacon, choice of cheese, mayo, lettuce & tomatoes
- Small $5.40
- Large $7.99
- Wrap $5.90
- Add Extra Meat
- $1.00
Vegetarian & Cheese
Choice of cheese with cucumber, lettuce, tomatoes & onions.
- Small $3.70
- Large $4.99
- Small $4.20
- Add Hardboiled Egg Slices
- $0.60
Featured Item - Steaks (Subs & Wraps)
Steak
Chopped beef steak, fried onions, and homemade steak sauce.
- Small $3.99
- Large $5.99
- Wrap $4.50
Mushroom Steak
Chopped beef steak, fried onions, mushrooms & homemade steak sauce.
- Small $4.99
- Large $6.99
- Wrap $5.50
Chicken Steak
Chopped fajita-style chicken, fried onions & homemade steak sauce.
- Small $4.70
- Large $6.99
- Wrap $5.20
Mushroom Chicken Steak
Chopped fajita-style chicken, fried onions, mushrooms & homemade steak sauce.
- Small $5.70
- Large $7.99
- Wrap $6.20
Cheese Steak
Chopped beef steak, choice of cheese, fried onions & homemade steak sauce.
- Small $4.70
- Large $6.99
- Wrap $5.20
Mushroom Cheese Steak
Chopped beef steak, choice of cheese, fried onions, mushrooms & homemade steak sauce.
- Small $5.70
- Large $7.99
- Wrap $6.20
Chicken Cheese Steak
Chopped fajita-style chicken, choice of cheese, fried onions & homemade steak sauce.
- Small $5.40
- Large $7.99
- Wrap $5.90
Mushroom Chicken Cheese Steak
Chopped fajita-style chicken, choice of cheese, fried onions, mushrooms & homemade steak sauce.
- Small $6.40
- Large $8.99
- Wrap $6.90
Other Hot Subs/Wraps
Meatball
Meatballs & our homemade steak sauce.
- Small $3.99
- Large $5.99
- Wrap $4.50
Sausage
Sausage & our homemade steak sauce.
- Small $3.99
- Large $5.99
- Wrap $4.50
Fish
Breaded & fried fish fillet.
- Small $3.99
- Large $5.99
- Wrap $4.50
Grilled Ham
Chipped ham prepared on our grill. Comes with lettuce, tomatoes, onions & mayo.
- Small $3.99
- Large $5.99
- Wrap $4.50
Twinburger
Grilled beef patties, lettuce, tomatoes, onions & mayo.
- Small $3.99
- Large $5.99
- Wrap $4.50
Gismo
Grilled beef patties, grilled ham, choice of cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, onions & mayo.
- Small $5.70
- Large $8.50
- Wrap $6.20
Fiesta
A Mays original! Capicola ham, provolone cheese, bacon, tomatoes, oregano & our homemade steak sauce all toasted to perfection.
- Small $3.99
- Large $5.99
- Wrap $4.50
Meatball Parm
Meatballs, choice of cheese & our homemade steak sauce.
- Small $4.70
- Large $6.99
- Wrap $5.20
Sausage & Cheese
Sausage, choice of cheese & our homemade steak sauce.
- Small $4.70
- Large $6.99
- Wrap $5.20
Fish & Cheese
Breaded & fried fish fillet with choice of cheese.
- Small $4.70
- Large $6.99
- Wrap $5.20
Grilled Ham & Cheese
Chipped ham prepared on our grill with choice of cheese. Comes with lettuce, tomatoes, onions & mayo.
- Small $4.70
- Large $6.99
- Wrap $5.20
Cheese Twinburger
Grilled beef patties, choice of cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, onions & mayo.
- Small $4.70
- Large $6.99
- Wrap $5.20
Chicken Gismo
Chopped fajita-style chicken, grilled ham, choice of cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, onions & mayo.
- Small $6.40
- Large $9.60
- Wrap $6.90
Chicken Parm
Breaded & fried chicken patties, choice of cheese & our homemade steak sauce.
- Small $5.40
- Large $7.99
- Wrap $5.90
Barbeque
Hamburger BBQ
- Small $5.40
- Large $7.99
- Wrap $5.90
- Bun $3.20
Pork BBQ
- Small $5.40
- Large $7.99
- Wrap $5.90
- Bun $3.20
Turkey BBQ
- Small $5.40
- Large $7.99
- Wrap $5.90
- Bun $3.20
Hamburger BBQ & Cheese
Beef BBQ with choice of cheese.
- Small $6.10
- Large $9.05
- Wrap $6.60
- Bun $3.55
Pork BBQ & Cheese
Pork BBQ with choice of cheese.
- Small $6.10
- Large $9.05
- Wrap $6.60
- Bun $3.55
Turkey BBQ & Cheese
Turkey BBQ with choice of cheese.
- Small $6.10
- Large $9.05
- Wrap $6.60
- Bun $3.55
Side Orders
French Fries
- Small $1.99
- Large $2.50
Cheese Fries
- Small $2.70
- Large $3.20
Sweet Potato Fries
- Small $2.25
- Large $2.75
- Add Cup of Cheese
- $0.70
Old Bay Fries
- Small $2.25
- Large $2.75
- Add Cup of Cheese
- $0.70
Onion Rings
- Small $2.50
- Large $3.50
Corn Fritters
- Small $2.50
- Large $3.50
Pierogies (3)
$1.99Shrimp Roll
$1.99Pizza Roll
$1.99Fried Mushrooms
$2.50Clam Strips
$2.50Crab Cake (1)
$2.50Mini Corn Dogs (7)
$2.50Cheese Sticks (5)
$3.75- Add Cup of Steak Sauce
- $0.70
Chicken Fingers (3)
$4.25Fried Shrimp
$4.254 Piece Fried Chicken
$4.50Fried Chicken Wings (8)
$5.99
8 wings in your choice of sauce- Plain (No Sauce), Mild Buffalo, Ranch, Hot, BBQ, Butter Garlic.
Chicken Nuggets
- 8-piece $2.30
- 12-piece $2.90
- 20-piece $3.95
Chicken Fries
- 8-piece $2.30
- 12-piece $2.90
- 20-piece $3.95
Bun/Kaiser Roll Items
Hamburger
$2.50
1/4 lb. grilled beef patty on burger bun, made to order.
Cheese Burger
$2.85
1/4 lb. grilled beef patty on burger bun with choice of cheese, made to order.
Bacon Cheese Burger
$3.85
1/4 lb. grilled beef patty on burger bun with choice of cheese and topped with bacon.
Pizza Burger
$2.85
1/4 lb. grilled beef patty on burger bun with steak sauce, provolone cheese & oregano.
Breaded Chicken Patty
$2.85Veal Patty
$2.85Grilled Chicken Patty
$2.85Double Hamburger
$3.50
Two 1/4 lb. grilled beef patty on burger bun, made to order.
Double Cheese Burger
$4.20
Two 1/4 lb. grilled beef patty on burger bun with choice of cheese, made to order.
Mushroom Swiss Burger
$3.85
1/4 lb. grilled beef patty on burger bun topped with mushrooms and swiss cheese.
Fish Sandwich (on Bun)
$2.85
Breaded & fired fish fillet on burger bun, made to order.
Chicken Parm (on Bun)
$3.20
Breaded & fried chicken patty topped with provolone cheese & our homemade steak sauce.
Veal Parm
$3.20
Breaded & fried veal patty topped with provolone cheese & our homemade steak sauce.
Crab Cake Sandwich (on Bun)
$3.50Bread Sandwiches
Bread Sandwich
$2.99
Choose from a variety of meats, cheeses, toppings & condiments to make the sandwich you want!
Toasted Cheese
$2.25
Choice of cheese.
BLT
$3.25
Bacon, lettuce, tomatoes & mayo on toast.
Toasted Ham & Cheese
$3.25
Grilled ham with choice of cheese.
Club Sandwiches
Ham Club
$3.75
Chipped ham, bacon, mayo, lettuce & tomato on choice of toast.
Ham & Turkey Club
$4.75
Chipped ham & turkey, bacon, mayo, lettuce & tomato on choice of toast.
Tuna Salad Club
$3.75
Tuna salad, bacon, lettuce & tomato on choice of toast.
Chicken Salad Club
$3.75
Chicken salad, bacon, lettuce & tomato on choice of toast.
Turkey Club
$3.99
Chipped turkey, bacon, mayo, lettuce & tomato on choice of toast.
Roast Beef Club
$3.99
Chipped roast beef, bacon, mayo, lettuce & tomato on choice of toast.
Egg Salad Club
$3.75
Egg salad, bacon, lettuce & tomato on choice of toast.
Ham Salad Club
$3.75
Ham salad, bacon, lettuce & tomato on choice of toast.
Large Pretzel Sandwiches
Ham Pretzel
$4.25
Chipped ham on a pretzel bun with your choice of toppings.
Italian Pretzel
$4.25
Cooked salami, provolone cheese, capicola ham, hard salami & oregano on a pretzel bun with your choice of toppings.
Turkey Pretzel
$4.75
Chipped turkey on a pretzel bun with your choice of toppings.
Roast Beef Pretzel
$4.75
Chipped roast beef on a pretzel bun with your choice of toppings.
Tuna Salad Pretzel
$4.75
Tuna salad on a pretzel bun with your choice of toppings.
Egg Salad Pretzel
$4.75
Egg salad on a pretzel bun with your choice of toppings.
Chicken Salad Pretzel
$4.75
Chicken salad on a pretzel bun with your choice of toppings.
Ham Salad Pretzel
$4.75
Ham salad on a pretzel bun with your choice of toppings.
Salads
Tossed Salad
$3.50
Broccoli, cauliflower, cucumber, tomatoes & croutons on a bed of iceberg lettuce with your choice of dressing.
Caesar Salad
$3.75
Shredded mozzarella & croutons on a bed of romaine lettuce with Caesar dressing.
Chicken Steak Salad
$4.50
Grilled strips of chicken & croutons on a bed of romaine lettuce with your choice of dressing.
Tuna Salad Plate
$4.50
Tuna salad, tomatoes & croutons on a bed of iceberg lettuce with your choice of dressing.
Chicken Salad Plate
$4.50
Chicken salad, tomatoes & croutons on a bed of iceberg lettuce with your choice of dressing.
Chef Salad
$3.99
Pieces of chopped ham, turkey, and swiss cheese, tomatoes & croutons on a bed of iceberg lettuce with your choice of dressing.
Chicken Caesar Salad
$4.75
Grilled strips of chicken, shredded mozzarella & croutons on a bed of romaine lettuce with Caesar dressing.
Egg Salad Plate
$4.50
Egg salad, tomatoes & croutons on a bed of iceberg lettuce with your choice of dressing.
Ham Salad Plate
$4.50
Ham salad, tomatoes & croutons on a bed of iceberg lettuce with your choice of dressing.
Pizza
French Bread Pizza
$1.999 inch Cheese Pizza
$3.999 inch Pepperoni Pizza
$4.999 inch Onion Pizza
$3.999 inch Mushroom Pizza
$4.999 inch Bacon Pizza
$4.99Hot Dogs
Plain Hot Dog
$1.25
Hot dog on a bun, made to order.
Cheese Hot Dog
$1.60
Hot dog on bun with choice of cheese.
Chili Hot Dog
$1.99
Hot dog on bun with chili sauce.
Coney Island Hot Dog
$3.25
Grilled all-beef hot dog topped with our homemade beef sauce, onions, & yellow mustard all toasted to perfection.
Cheese & Bacon Hot Dog
$2.25
Hot dog on bun with bacon & choice of cheese.
Chili & Cheese Hot Dog
$2.25
Hot dog on bun with chili sauce & choice of cheese.
Sweets
Large Cookie
$0.99
Choice of Chocolate Chip or Oatmeal Raisin.
Cinnamon Roll
$1.99Homemade Cookies
$7.00
Seasonal selection of cookies.
Cho Chos
Julie's Olde-Tyme Cho-Chos are a malted ice cream bar that has been popular in the Reading area for over 60 years!
- Single $1.29
- Bag of 10 $9.50
Platters
Crab Cake Platter
$6.25
Two fried crab cakes with an order of french fries.
Fried Shrimp Platter
$6.25
Fried shrimp with an order of french fries.
4 piece Fried Chicken Platter
$6.25
Four pieces of fried chicken with an order of fries.
Chicken Tenders Platter
$6.25
Three chicken fingers with an order of french fries.
Child Meals
Child's Hot Dog Platter
$2.25
A plain hot dog & child's size french fry.
Child's Cheese Burger Platter
$2.75
A plain cheese burger & a child's size french fry.
Child's Chicken Nugget Platter
$2.75
Six breaded & fried chicken nuggets with a child's size french fry.
Child's Toasted Cheese Platter
$2.75
A toasted cheese sandwich & a child's size french fry.
Child's Mini Corn Dog Platter
$2.75
Four battered & fried mini corn dogs & a child's size french fry.
Child's Chicken Finger Platter
$3.25
Two breaded & fried chicken fingers with a child's size french fry.
Breakfast Items
Breakfast Sandwich
$2.25
Make-your-own breakfast sandwich with a variety of bread and meat choices. All include egg patty and choice of cheese.
Hash Brown
$0.99Browse Nearby
General Info
Payment Types
All Major Cards
Cuisine
American - Traditional
BBQ
Burgers
Deli
Pizza
Sandwiches
Meals
Breakfast
Lunch
Dinner