What's wrong with this menu?
Matey's Restaurant
110 Franklin St
Michigan City, IN 46360
Uber
MORE PHOTOS
Main Menu
Appetizers
great ways to start your dining experience,
Boneless Chicken Wings
$9.99
naked or served with your choice of sauce: mild, medium, hot, extra hot bbq, honey mustard, teriyaki or garlic butter
Bosco Stix
- $7.99
- Cheese $0.59
Cheddar Cheese Curds
$8.49Chicken Quesadilla
$9.99Chicken Wings
$10.99
naked, mild, medium, hot, extra hot, bbq, honey mustard, teriyaki or garlic butter
Deep Fried Pickles
$7.99Fried Calamari
$8.99Key West Eggrolls
$8.99Matey's Sampler Platter
$11.99
includes chicken wings, onion rings, extremers, deep fried pickles & cheese sticks served with ranch & cusabi
Mozzeralla Sticks
$7.99Nacho's Grande
$10.99Oysters On The Half Shell
$7.99Oysters On The Half Shell
$10.49Oysters Rockefeller
$11.49Peel & Eat Shrimp
$8.49Shrimp & Crab Extremers
$7.99Shrimp Quesadilla
$10.99Steamed Shrimp
- Dozen $11.99
Tangy Whambam Shrimp
$11.99Salads
made from the freshest ingredients just for you dressings: thousand island, ranch, raspberry vinaigrette, jalapeno ranch, french, italian bleu cheese, fat free ranch, oil & vinegar, blue cheese crumbles - $1.59 extra
Garden Greens
$5.99Grilled Chicken Salad
- $9.99
- Make It Blackened $10.49
Seafood Garden Salad
$10.99
made with shrimp & crab
Taco Salad
$9.99
chicken or beef
Tenderloin Steak Salad
$10.99Soups
hot and homemade by our chef paul every day
Almost World Famous Cajun Chowder
- Cup $3.99
- Bowl $4.89
Captain Bill's Homemade Chili
- Cup $3.59
- Bowl $4.59
Fresh Soup Of The Day
- Cup $2.89
- Bowl $3.79
Baskets
served with waffle fries and coleslaw. all for just 10.99
Breaded Clam Strips
$10.99Breaded Shrimp
$10.99Chicken Tenders
$10.99Coconut Shrimp
$10.99Lake Perch
$10.99Entrees
entrees include your choice of soup of the day or fresh salad
Beer Battered Lake Perch
$16.99
with choice of potato & veggies
Crab Cakes Che' Paul
$16.99
with choice of potato & veggies
Sauteed Grouper
$19.99
with choice of potato & veggies
Steak & Cake
$19.99
an 8 oz ribeye, a homemade crab cake, choice of potato & veggie
Only At Matey's!
All You Can Eat Lake Victoria Perch
$12.99
a delicate white fish with fries & slaw. sorry no carry out or splits
No Max Prime Rib
friday & saturday evening only. 10 ounce minimum, you pick the size! with choice of potato and veggies
- Per Ounce $1.59
Sandwich Selections
includes french fries & a pickle. add waffle fries and coleslaw $2.59. add a pile of beer battered onion rings $2.99
Battered Lake Perch
$11.99Bbq Pulled Pork Sandwich
$7.99Bleu Cheese Burger
$8.29Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
$8.79Corn Beef Stack
$8.99Corn Beef Stack
$9.99Grilled Chicken Breast
$7.99Grilled Grouper
$10.99Matey Melt
$8.29Mushroom Swiss Burger
$8.29Ribeye Steak Sandwich
$11.49Roast Beef Melt
$8.99Sauteed Tilapia
$9.79Shrimp Po' Boy
$8.99The Famous - Lb. Matey Burger
with american, cheddar, mozzarella, pepperjack or swiss cheese only $0.30 more
- $7.69
- Add Bacon $0.59
Signature Sandwiches
includes french fries & a pickle. add waffle fries and coleslaw $2.50. add a pile of beer battered onion rings $2.99
The First Mate Prime Rib
$10.99
slow roasted prime rib, shaved very thin, on a kaiser roll, with au jus or our homemade horseradish sauce
Buried Treasure
$8.99
a grilled fresh burger patty loaded with green olives, cheddar cheese and bacon, topped with lettuce, tomato and mayo
Fire Down Below
$8.99
grilled smoked chicken breast covered in pepperjack cheese, sizzling bacon & jalapeno ranch dressing all on a toasted bun
Hammer Head
$9.49
a fresh beef patty with bacon, cheddar & smoky bbq sauce on an "everything" bagel, topped with lettuce, tomato and mayo
Loaded Cannon
$10.99
spicy marinated shaved prime rib on a french roll, smothered in sliced jalapenos, sharp cheddar and pepperjack cheeses
Ship Wreck
$8.99
blackened grilled chicken breast with tangy sauce and bleu cheese dressing, topped with lettuce on french bread
The Commodore
$8.99
slivered beef piled on a grilled french roll, smothered with grilled onions, green peppers, and melted mozzarella cheese
Walk Da Plank
$9.99
deep fried cod filet with zesty jalapeno ranch and topped with pepperjack cheese on a french roll