What's wrong with this menu?
Maggoo's Pizza Pasta & More
1816 E High Ave NE
New Philadelphia, OH 44663
Uber
MORE PHOTOS
Main Menu
Appetizers
House Sauces: Southern BBQ, BBQ, Spicy BBQ, Spicy Southern BBQ, Buffalo, Garlic Parmesan, Sweet Chili, Plain, Sweet & Tangy Asian. Extra Sauce $0.50
Garlic Bread
$3.50Bitty Burgers
Italian burgers on our special grilled bun topped with onions & pickle or as you like
- (1) $2.25
- 2 $3.99
- (3) $5.99
Bruschetta*
$6.99
Freshly chopped tomatoes & onions bathed in a sweet basil dressing, covered with parmesan cheese served on garlic bread
Mozzarella Stix
$6.99
8 Cheese Sticks Served with Cal's Sauce
Maggoo Chips
$4.99
Dipping sauce available
Onion Petals
$6.75
Ranch, Jamaican Jerk, BBQ, Ketchup available
*NEW ITEM: Cheesy Bread
Served with Cal's sauce
- 1/2 order $5.99
- Full order $8.99
My Buddy Larry's Meatballs
$5.99
Covered with house sauce and cheese, nuff to share!
Chicken Tenders
$7.99
Choice of dipping sauce
Stuffed Hungarian Peppers*
$7.99
Baked in our own Sauce & topped with cheese
Sausage-n-Peppers
$8.99
Fresh sauteed sweet peppers and onion mild sausage with Cal's sauce and olive oil
Traditional Wings
- 5 $6.00
- 10 $10.00
Boneless Wings
- 5 $6.00
- 10 $10.00
LOADED Maggoo's Chips
$8.99
loaded with cheese, bacon and ranch dressing
Salads
Add grilled chicken to any salad for $2.99. Choice of Homemade dressings: House, Ranch, Sweet N Sour, French, pear
My Buddy Larry's Salad*
Iceberg lettuce, colby cheese, pepperoni, black and green olives tossed in our House dressing. Made fresh to order
- House $3.75
- Large $5.99
- Big Daddy $10.50
Caprese
$8.99
Fresh mozzarella and tomatoes drizzled with our homemade sweet basil dressing
Spinach Salad
$9.99
Fresh spinach, red onions, cucumbers, goat cheese, dried cranberries and walnuts. Served with hot bacon dressing
Our Famous Pizza
Gluten free pizza available add $2. Yaggi's cheese served here! Extra toppings ($0.99): Extra Pepperoni, Extra Colby Cheese, Onions, Sauteed Fresh Mushrooms, Red, Yellow or Green Bell Peppers, Fresh Chopped Garlic, Pineapple, Sausage, Green or Black Olives, Cal's Hot Mix, Crumbled Bacon, Fresh Mozzarella, Anchovies, Meatball, Ham, Mild Pepper Rings
Almost Larry's Pizza*
Pepperoni & cheese
- $8.99
Homemade Calzone
$8.99
Stuffed with any four of your favorite pizza toppings and served with a side of marinara for dipping
Stuffed Hungarian Peppers
$7.99
Baked in our own sauce & topped with cheese
16 x 16 Thick Crust
$17.958x8 Thick Crust
$8.99Sides
Fresh Broccoli
$2.99Homemade Cole Slaw
$2.99White Rice
$2.25French Fries
$2.25Marinated Chicken Breast
$2.99Applsauce
$2.25Side of Spaghetti & Meatball
$3.99Dinners
All pastas served with locally baked Italian bread from Buehler's upon request. Gluten free pasta available add $2
Baked Spaghetti*
$7.99
Baked spaghetti with Cal's spiced ground beef, topped with cheese and pepperoni, and broiled to perfection
- Add Hot Mix
- $0.99
Spaghetti & Meatballs*
$6.99- Add Extra Meatball
- $1.25
Spaghetti Aglio e Olio
$7.99
Spaghetti tossed with garlic, olive oil, parmesan cheese, black pepper and red pepper flakes
Larry's Big Daddy Sampler
$13.99
No substitutions. Small salad, small pizza and small spaghetti with one meatball
Ravioli
$6.99
Cheese or meat
Chicken Parmesan
$8.99
Spaghetti with breaded chicken breast and Cal's seasoning, topped with provolone and sauce
Eggplant Parmesan
$8.99
Served with side of spaghetti
Caprese Pasta*
$8.99
Fresh garlic and olive oil pasta, cherry tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, basil, with a dollop of poggi sauce
Lasagna*
$9.99
Lasagna noodles layered with Cal's spiced ground beef and three cheeses...Delicious!
Chicken Pasta Alfredo
$8.99Shrimp Pasta Alfredo
$10.99Sweet Chili Chicken
$8.99
Grilled chicken breast smothered in sweet peppers and onions with a sweet chili sauce, served with white rice and broccoli
Caprese Pasta
$8.99
fresh garlic and olive pasta, cherry tomatoes fresh mozzarella and basil, with are pogo sauce
Sandwiches
All served with fries or Maggoo chips
Maggoo's Burger
$8.99
A family favorite made fresh with choice ground beef and seasonings. Served on our grilled Hawaiian bun with lettuce, tomato and onion
- Add Cheese (American, Swiss or Provolone)
- $0.99
My Buddy Larry's Italian Burger*
$8.99
Choice ground beef and Buddy Larry's seasoning topped with sauce, onions and peppers on our grilled Hawaiian bun
- Add Hot Mix
- $0.99
- Add Cheese
- $0.99
Chicken Breast
$8.99
Sweet basil marinated chicken breast served on toasted bun with lettuce, onion and tomato
Meatball Sub*
$8.99
Meatballs doused in our homemade spaghetti sauce topped with colby cheese
- Add Hot Mix
- $0.99
Italian Sausage Sub
$8.99
DiRusso's sausage covered with peppers, onions and mozzarella cheese
- Add Hot Mix
- $0.99
Chicken Parmesan Sandwich
$8.99
Breaded chicken breast topped with sauce and provolone cheese.
Sandwich Extras
Season your fries or chips for an extra $0.25. Choose from our delicious flavors:
Garlic Parmesan
Salt & Vinegar*
Fountain Drinks
Free Refills. Add vanilla or cherry flavoring for $0.30
Coca Cola
$2.50Diet Coke
$2.50Sprite
$2.50Hi-C
$2.50Mr. Pibb
$2.50Mellow Yellow
$2.50Iced Tea 4flavors
$2.75Hot Tea
$2.75Coffee
$2.50Bottled Drinks
Coca-Cola
$2.50Crush Grape
$2.50Crush Orange
$2.50IBC Rootbeer
$2.50Acqua Panna
$2.99
Natural Spring Water
Lemonade
$2.75Desserts
All homemade from scratch made in house
Red Velvet Cake
$5.99
Covered with toasted pecan cream cheese frosting
Key Lime Pie
$5.99
Our very own...Delicious!
Molten Chocolate Lava Cake
$5.99
Made to order! Please allow 15 minutes
Cream Puffs
$5.99
Choux puff filled with chantilly custard and drizzled with the best chocolate around, kissed with powdered sugar
Coconut Cake
$5.99Vanilla Bean Ice Cream
- Scoop $1.99
- Dish $2.99
- Add Hot Fudge
- $1.00
Banana Cake
$5.99Grape Pie
$5.99
Come try some people say the best pie ever, just for a short time
Daily Specials
Scalloped Potatoes with Ham
$8.99
Served with a small house salad
Chicken Carmella
$10.99
Spiral Pasta tossed in Creamy Marsala Alfredo sauce with fresh spinach, Sauteed mushrooms and Marinated Grilled Chicken
Cheesy Bread
$8.99
Plenty to share! Must try!
Scalloped & Ham Potatoes
$8.99
Are scalloped & ham potatoes coved with cheese
Maggoos Party and Catering Prices
Don't see something you're Hungry for? Give us a call, we would be happy to prepare it for you. Feeds 30-35 people
Roster Pan Baked Spaghetti
$85.00Roster Pan of Lasagna
$85.00Maggoo's House Salad Bowl
$65.00Marinated Grilled Chicken Breasts
$130.00Pan of 50 Meat Ball
$60.00House Made Pizza
$8.99Pan of Chicken Carmella
$125.00Pan of Chicken
$130.00Pan of Alfredo Noodles
$75.00
*Maggoo's Favorite
Browse Nearby
General Info
Payment Types
Visa
MasterCard
Discover
Check
Cuisine
American - Traditional
Italian
Pasta
Pizza
Meals
Dinner
Hours
Monday:
Closed
Tuesday:
4:00pm - 8:00pm
Wednesday:
4:00pm - 8:00pm
Thursday:
4:00pm - 9:00pm
Friday:
4:00pm - 9:00pm
Saturday:
4:00pm - 9:00pm
Sunday:
Closed