What's wrong with this menu?
Lucy's New York Style Pizzeria
560 West Broadway St.
Idaho Falls, ID 83402
Uber
MORE PHOTOS
Main Menu
Salads
Antipasto
$6.50
Chopped romaine, topped with cheese, tomatoes, olives, and a variety of peppers and meat.
House Salad
$4.00
Chopped romaine, cheese, olives, pepperoni, tomatoes, and pepperoncini.
Family Salad
$11.00
Hope your group has an appetite for leafy greens. The king size of the house salad.
Caprese Salad
Not a traditional salad by any means, including flavor. Slices of fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, and basil. Lightly seasoned with salt, pepper, and olive oil.
- Half $4.00
- Full $7.00
Appetizers
Breadsticks
$4.50
Flavored with garlic butter & seasonings. Served with Marinara.
Cheesesticks
$5.50
Enhance your breadsticks with mozzarella, enough said.
Firesticks
$6.50
The hybrid of hot & mild. Basted with buffalo sauce then topped with cheese & jalapenos.
Fried Mutz
$4.50
Our delicious whole milk cheese hand breaded and fried, served with marinara.
Meatball
$4.50
Our 10oz zesty meatball smothered with marinara.
Wings
$12.00
(10) Tasty chicken wings doused with your choice between our signture bullafo, sweet chili, or bbq sauce. Served wtih dressing of your choice.
Pizza
Lucy's has been a favorite and masterpiece since 2009. All of our pizzas have whole milk mozzarella and are cooked at 600 degrees. - These are a few fan favorites and frequent requests, but as always, feel free to add anything you would like to try for just a little extra. Bronx your pie for $2.00.
Meaty
An inspired combination of pepperoni, ham, fresh pulled sausage, bacon, and our zesty meatball. Truly fit for a KING!
- 12" $13.50
- 15" $18.50
- 18" $24.00
- Gluten-free $15.00
Veggie
For those of you who want to keep the farm animals safe, try this delightful combo of vegetables: mushrooms, onions, artichokes, peppers, and black olives.
- 12" $13.50
- 15" $18.50
- 18" $24.00
- Gluten-free $15.00
Margarita
A light pizza with your choice of a sauce made of olive oil & garlic or the traditional red. Topped with fresh basil & tomatoes.
- 12" $11.50
- 15" $15.50
- 18" $20.00
- Gluten-free $14.00
Pacific
Escape to the islands with our fresh pineapple and ham.
- 12" $11.50
- 15" $15.50
- 18" $20.00
- Gluten-free $13.00
Supreme
A perfect blend of pepperoni and four crisp veggies: mushrooms, onions, peppers, and black olives.
- 12" $13.50
- 15" $18.50
- 18" $24.00
- Gluten-free $15.00
Zim
A fantastic combination of pepperoni, ham, peppy sauerkraut, and fresh tomatoes.
- 12" $12.50
- 15" $17.50
- 18" $22.00
- Gluten-free $14.00
Zestpian
A recipe sure to make you want to sing & dance. Ranch & bbq sauce mixed, then suffocated with pepperoni, ham, chicken, pineapple, bacon, and jalapenos.
- 12" $14.50
- 15" $20.50
- 18" $26.00
- Gluten-free $16.00
CCB
A Creamy ranch sauce topped with sliced chicken breast, and real bacon pieces.
- 12" $11.50
- 15" $15.50
- 18" $20.00
- Gluten-Free $13.50
Buffalo Chicken
Enjoy a mixture of our savory chicken and our signature buffalo sauce.
- 12" $10.50
- 15" $14.50
- 18" $18.00
- Gluten-Free $12.50
BBQ
Our seasoned chicken with a smokey BBQ sauce. Cooks recommend adding onions for a little extra zing.
- 12" $10.50
- 15" $14.50
- 18" $19.00
- Gluten-Free $12.50
BLT pizza
Creamy ranch sauce topped with bacon, fresh tomatoes, and crisp lettuce. Drizzled with balsamic glaze.
- 12" $12.50
- 15" $17.50
- 18" $22.00
- Gluten-Free $14.50
Build your own masterpiece
Choice of Toppings: Extra cheese, bell pepper, black olive, yellow onion, artichoke, green olive, red onion, tomato, pepperoncini, mushroom, jalapeño, pineapple, meatball, bacon, pepperoni, ham, sausage, chicken, salami, anchovy, sauerkraut, spinach, basil, and garlic.
Red sauce & cheese
- 12" $9.50
- 15" $12.50
- 18" $16.00
- Gluten-free $11.00
Bronx bomber
Love thicker crust? Then double it up!
- 12" $2.00
- 15" $2.00
- 18" $2.00
Extra toppings
Pick your favorites from the list to the left.
- 12" $1.00
- 15" $1.50
- 18" $2.00
- Gluten-free $1.00
Sauce
Buffalo, BBQ, Creamy white, Zestpian, or Garlic & Olive oil.
- 12" $0.50
- 15" $0.75
- 18" $1.00
- Gluten-free $0.50
Slices of Heaven
Choose from Pepperoni, Cheese, or our Flavor of the Month! Get your huge New York Style slice of za!
- Pepperoni $3.50
- Cheese $3.50
- Flavor of Month $3.50
Calzones
a REAL pizza pocket! Your calzone starts with a topping of your choice and 2 cheeses, mozzarella & ricotta.
Calzones
- Small $6.50
- Large $11.50
Extra toppings
Choose your favorite from the list to the right.
- Small $0.50
- Large $1.00
Sauce inside
Add red, buffalo, bbq or creamy white sauce.
- Small $0.50
- Large $1.00
Subs
Sausage & peppers
$7.50
Delicious oven baked sausage covered with sautéed peppers, onions, and melted cheese.
Meatball
$7.50
An instant favorite, our 10oz meatball sliced & coated with marinara & melted cheese.
Chicken Parmesan
$7.50
Hand breaded chicken breast smothered in marinara & cheese.
Pepperoni Melt
$5.50
Melted mozzarella covers our classic pepperoni & marinara.
CCB.L.T
$8.50
A browned bun with chicken, bacon, romaine and tomatoes and ranch.
Black Angus
$8.50
Did someone say steak? a 6oz angus steak with sautéed mushrooms, onions & mozzarella.
Kids
Kids 8 & under drink soda for $0.50. Request a coloring peel and markers for 0 pennies!
Milk
$1.00Chocolate Milk
$1.00Juice box
$1.00Desserts
Cannoli's
Tube-shaped shells of fried pastry dough, filled with a sweet creamy filling.
- (3) $3.00
- (6) $6.00
- 1 $1.00
New York cheese cake
$4.50
A slice served with your choice of fruit, dark chocolate, carmel, or enjoy just plain.
Gluten Free Brownie
$4.00
Rich brownie doused with dark chocolate or carmel sauce.
Calzone
$5.50
Choose your flavor: Snickers, Milky Way, Reese's, 3 Musketeers, Twix, Oreo, or Nutella and we combine it with cheesecake to make an oozing pocket of joy!
Dessert Pie
$10.00
Choose your flavor: Snickers, Milky Way, Reese's, 3 Musketeers, Twix, Oreo, or Nutella and we combine it with cheesecake to make a pizza even a Dentist can't say no to!
Browse Nearby
General Info
Payment Types
All Major Cards
Cuisine
Pizza
Italian
Meals
Lunch
Dinner
Hours
Monday:
11:00am - 9:00pm
Tuesday:
11:00am - 9:00pm
Wednesday:
11:00am - 9:00pm
Thursday:
11:00am - 9:00pm
Friday:
11:00am - 10:00pm
Saturday:
11:00am - 10:00pm
Sunday:
Closed
About Us
Here at Lucy’s our dough is prepped fresh daily from only the best ingredients. Our homemade Italian Marinara Sauce simmers on the stove for hours, infused with authentic Italian spices. Come in and taste our authentic new york style crust and sauce. If you enjoy thin-crust NY style pizza you will love our pizza. Always hand-made and hand-tossed!