What's wrong with this menu?
Legends
835 First St
New Suffolk, NY 11956
Uber
MORE PHOTOS
Menu
Updated Menu Spring 2023
Starters | Soups
New Suffolk Clam Chowder
spicy | tomato base | clams | crabmeat
dairy-free, gluten-free, peanut-free, tree-nut-free
- Bowl $17.00
Housemade Guacamole
$16.00
avocado | red onion | lime | cilantro | pomegranate seeds | corn tortilla chips
vegan, vegetarian
gluten-free
Burrata and Prosciutto di Parma
$20.00
creamy, luscious burrata | prosciutto |balsamic "pearls" crostini
Allergens
dairy
Savory Shrimp Beignets with Remoulade
$18.00
classic remoulade sauce: aÏoli | mustard | paprika cajun seasonings | a touch of garlic
Allergens
shellfish
Fried Calamari or Mike's Style
- Marinara Sauce $17.00
- Lightly Fried | Garlic | Pepperoncini | Butter $18.00
Steamed Hard Clams
$19.00
garlic white wine broth or marinara
dairy-free, gluten-free
Ale Steamed Mussels with Garlic and Dijon Mustardˆ
$20.00
ale | butter | tarragon | cream | garlic | crostini
New Orleans Style Baked Stuffed Clams
$15.00
chopped clams | chorizo | garlic | Parmigiano-Reggiano | hint of spice
Shrimp and Vegetable Spring Rolls
$15.00
ginger-pineapple dipping sauce
dairy-free
Raw Bar
Clams or Oysters on the Half Shell
cucumber mignonette | cocktail sauce
dairy-free, gluten-free
- MP
Tuna* Poke Bowl**
cubed raw tuna | soy, ginger, sesame oil marinade | red onion | scallion | diced mango | avocado | tomato | macadamia nuts
dairy-free, gluten-free
- MP
Tuna* Napoleon
raw tuna | miso-ginger dressing | seaweed salad | crispy wonton
dairy-free
- MP
Sesame Crusted Tuna* Sashimi
seared | pickled ginger | wasabi | seaweed salad
dairy-free, gluten-free
- MP
Entrée Salads
Rocket Salad with Beets & Goat Cheese**
$16.00
arugula | avocado | walnuts | dried cranberries | honey-shallot balsamic dressing
vegetarian
dairy-free, gluten-free
- Add Chicken
- $9.00
- Add Steak
- $14.00
- Add Shrimp
- $12.00
- Add Salmon
- $14.00
Hawaiian Chicken Salad**
$23.00
grilled chicken | crispy wonton wrapper | romaine | sweet red & yellow peppers | green beans | cucumber | red onion | mango | sesame seeds | carrots | scallion | macadamia nuts | lemon miso dressing
dairy-free
Legends Salad
$10.00
baby lettuce | tomato | red onion | cucumber | carrots; your choice of: house made blue cheese (salad no longer dairy free with the addition of blue cheese) | honey mustard | lemon miso white balsamic
vegetarian
dairy-free, gluten-free
- Add Chicken
- $9.00
- Add Steak
- $14.00
- Add Shrimp
- $12.00
- Add Salmon
- $14.00
Caesar Salad^
$16.00
romaine | house-made croutons | parmesan crostini | caesar dressing
- Add Chicken
- $9.00
- Add Steak
- $14.00
- Add Shrimp
- $12.00
- Add Salmon
- $14.00
Sweet Chili Calamari Salad
$18.00
crispy calamari | house chili sauce | field greens | cucumber | sweet peppers | mandarin orange | vinaigrette
Casual Fare
Mahi Tacos
$16.00
lightly fried mahi | pepper jack cheese | salsa | napa slaw | avocado-lime crema
Petit Quesadillas
cheddar | mozzarella | sweet red and yellow peppers | onion | guacamole | sour cream | salsa; minimum 2, priced individually:
- Beef $14.00
- Chicken $9.00
- Shrimp $12.00
Buffalo Wings
$17.00Chicken Fingers
$12.00Onion Rings
$9.00Plain Pizza
$12.00Pepperoni Pizza
$14.00Mozzarella Sticks
$10.00Mains
Filet Mignon* with Bordelaise Sauce
$54.00
pan juices | red wine | herbs | shallots fingerling potatoes | asparagus
dairy-free, gluten-free
- Add a Canadian Lobster Tail (5-6 Oz.)
- $25.00
Braised Boneless Short Ribs
$39.00
braised in red wine, garlic, fresh herbs and shallots | mashed potatoes | green beans
Grilled Skirt Steak* with Chimichurri Sauce
$39.00
with green beans and fingerling potatoes
dairy-free, gluten-free
Copper Creek Black Angus Grilled NY Strip Steak
$55.00
A beautifully marbled and delicious cut! plain or marinated | asparagus | fingerling potatoes
- Add a Canadian Lobster Tail (5-6 Oz.)
- $25.00
Cacciucco – Tuscan Seafood Stew^
$38.00
tuna | shrimp | clams | salmon | mussels | full bodied broth | garlic crostini
dairy-free
- Add a Canadian Lobster Tail (5-6 Oz.)
- $25.00
Pan Seared Norwegian Salmon with Coconut Curry Sauce
$37.00
Norwegian Salmon is known for its succulent texture, rich flavor and beautiful color; delicate coconut curry sauce | jasmine rice | green zucchini | cherry tomatoes | sprinkle of sesame seeds
dairy-free, gluten-free
Pad Thai with Shrimp* **
slightly spicy | rice noodles | vegetables | fresh ginger | sesame | peanuts | egg | cilantro | fish sauce
dairy-free, gluten-free
- $27.00
- No Shrimp $18.00
Seafood Vol-au-Vent
$35.00
shrimp | scallops | rock shrimp | tuna | puff pastry triangles | haricot vert | sherried lobster cream sauce
Ragú alla Bolognese Over Rigatoni
$30.00Parmesan, Panko and Herb Crusted Chicken
$29.00
creamy lemon-sage sauce | brussels sprouts with pancetta | fingerling potatoes
Roasted Za'tar Dusted Cauliflower Steak
$22.00
house-made hummus | blistered cherry tomatoes | shaved asparagus | garlic | sprinkle of sesame seeds | chive oil drizzle; contains sesame seeds
vegetarian, vegan
dairy-free, gluten-free
Asian Vegetable Stir Fry
$18.00
sweet red peppers | red onion | green beans | carrots | lotus root | ginger-sesame infused soy sauce | sesame seeds | jasmine rice; has nuts and seeds
vegetarian, vegan
dairy-free, gluten-free
- Add Chicken
- $9.00
- Add Steak
- $14.00
- Add Shrimp
- $12.00
- Add Salmon
- $14.00
Grilled Bone In Pork Chop with Cognac Demi-Glace
$38.00
with cauliflower au gratin and green beans
Parmesan and Panko Encrusted Swordfish with Herb Aioli
$38.00
with sauteed gnocchi and green beans
Sandwiches
Pan-Fried and Crispy Pork Schnitzel
$18.00
seasoned pork cutlet | panko breadcrumbs | arugula | provolone cheese | garlic-Dijon aÏoli | capers
Fresh Flounder Sandwich (Broiled or Fried)
- MP
Norwegian Salmon BLT
$18.00
seared and roasted salmon | bacon | lettuce | tomato | caper mayo
Grilled Sesame Tuna* Sandwich
grilled red onion | ginger-mustard aioli
- MP
Grilled Chicken, Avocado and Bacon Sandwich
$18.00
grilled chicken | bacon | crumbled bleu cheese white balsamic | lettuce | tomato
Legends Half Pound Burger*
$18.00- Add Cheddar, Swiss, American, Pepperjack, Mozzarella, Provolone
- $2.00
- Add Bleu Cheese
- $3.00
- Add Bacon
- $2.25
Pork Banh Mi
$17.00
roast pork | baguette |cucumber | red onion | cilantro| spicy aioli
vegetarian
Sides
Mixed Veggies
$6.00Green Beans
$8.00Asparagus
$9.00Fingerling Potatoes
$9.00Sautéed Mushrooms
$7.00Broccoli, Garlic and EVOO
$10.00Desserts
Chocolate Lovers Dream
$12.00
chocolate sable cookie | chocolate mousse | chocolate | sauce
Cheesecake Spring Rolls
$11.00
chocolate sauce | caramel sauce
Crema Catalana
$11.00
Similar to crème brûlée but with a Spanish flair laced with fresh lemon zest for an extra bit of olé!
Brownie Sundae with Blackberry Goat Cheese Swirl
$12.00
*This menu consists of, or contains meat, fish, shellfish, or fresh shell eggs that are raw or not cooked to proper temperature to destroy harmful bacteria and/ or virus. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish, or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of food borne illnesses, especially if you have certain medical conditions. **Contains nuts. ^Can be made gluten free upon request
Browse Nearby
General Info
About Us
Welcome! You've visited our historic villages, toured the vineyards and tasted the wine. But your North Fork visit won't be complete until you've visited Legends!
Legends is located down by the water in the charming little town of New Suffolk on the East End. In the ZAGAT SURVEY, Legends was rated "very good to excellent" and was 'legendary' for its 'generous portions' of 'creative' American fare ('sensational daily specials').
Legends serves New American cuisine featuring fresh local seafood, fresh local produce, and premium steaks and chops, all prepared with culinary artistry. Add homemade desserts, local wines and fresh flowers at your table!