unlimited single serve toppings all extras $1 more!
Our pizzas & handmade to order calzones are well-known in New London, we have been voted top pizza place in New London for the past 21 years! Fresh ingredients, dough and sauces made daily, we take great pride in our pizza! Dough choices are: original thin, thick & pan style
10" Gluten Free$12.00
Or create your own style from our many toppings list!
sausage, pepperoni, mushroom, onion, green pepper
sausage, onion, mushroom, green pepper
tomato, onion, mushroom, green pepper, green & black olives
Or create your own style from our many toppings list! $2 more each topping
sausage, pepperoni, beef, ham, canadian bacon, bacon, chicken, taco meat, mushroom, onion, green pepper, green olive, black olive, tomato, pineapple, jalapeno, saurkraut cheddar Anchovies & Shrimp
Bob's Stuffed Pizza
Choose up to 5 topping to fill this Chicago style pizza pie! Between 2 layers of dough we put your toppings and a pound and a half of cheese, cover it with spicy pizza sauce and fresh tomatoes and bake for 45 minutes!
Handmade to order!! We start with a thin pizza crust, piled high with mozzarella cheese and your choice of toppings (up to 5) and roll and bake until golden brown. For a finisher we cover it with our homemade sauce and more fresh mozzarella!
Mouth Watering Appetizers
Cheesy Garlic bread
Hand-rolled Mozzarella Logs!
6 jumbo logs with our sweet marinara!
Garlic & Parm Fries
Haystack onion rings
Chicken strips W/FF
ff, rings, curds, mozz, strips
Our own homemade recipes! Ask for today's flavor
Best Wings Around!!
We swear they are the best you'll find served with celery & dressing. Medium, Hot, Inferno, BBQ, Teriyaki or Garlic Parmesan
5 Boneless Strips$6.00
Sandwiches & Burgers
All served with a pickle and Choice of: Fries, Haystack Onion rings Pasta Salad or steamed veggies (all chicken sandwiches are available sauteed or deep fried)
Sweet Haystack sauce & Haystack onion rings
lettuce, tomato, mayo
sauteed mushroom, onion, gr. pepper
mozzarella & marinara
tomato, onion, garlic sauce
Chick Bacon Ranch
mozz, bacon, ranch dressing
hot wing sauce, lettuce, tomato, ranch
lettuce & tartar
Italian beef dip
mozzarella & au jus
sauteed mushroom, onion, gr. pepper, & au jus
marinara & mozzarella
hot ham and mozzarella
ham, mozzarella, onion & sauerkraut
1/2 lb certified angus steak burgers!
lettuce, tomato & onion free upon request.
cheddar or mozzarella
Mozz & Shroom burger
pepperoni, pizza sauce & mozzarella
Fresh made Bruschetta
Sweet BBQ sauce & fried onions
Sweet haystack sauce & haystack onion rings
Our pasta dishes are incredible each served with it's own homemade sauce. All pasta dishes come with our fresh garlic bread. Add soup, side salad or steamed veggies for $2
with your choice: homemade Marinara, Meat sauce, or Meatballs
Jolly Roger's Pizza is the place to go for the best pizza in New London. Our top secret recipe pizza sauce, homemade dough and fresh ingredients will quickly make you a fan! We promise that once you have a taste, you will definitely be back again... soon. Customize your pizza with our wide range of available toppings or chose from some of our customers' favorites like our homemade chicken alfredo, and buffalo chicken pizza..or try one of our other specialty pizzas.